HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

golemotron

1,963 karma · joined July 20, 2014

submissionscomments
golemotron··on Cloudflare tells U.S. govt that foreign site blocking efforts are trade barriers
There are many arguments but the most straightforward one is that a country may decide that preserving particular industries is in their security interest. That can be extended to culture as well.

Japan closed itself off from the world for centuries during the Edo period. One could say that they suffered economically due to that, but on the other hand, they ended up creating one of the more unique cultures in the world, developing in ways very different from others. It's an interesting kind of diversity.

golemotron··on Cloudflare tells U.S. govt that foreign site blocking efforts are trade barriers
This comes from the dated perspective that free trade is universally good. Nations create their own trade rules and they ought to be able to enforce them. I consider that far preferable than attempts to exert extraterritorial control over services from other countries.

If, say, Uruguay doesn't like content on Facebook, they are free to block it. In their opinion, they are protecting their citizens and that's ok. It should not produce legal action that could result in least common denominator style global content censorship.

In an ideal world, there would be no country level blocking but invariably laws will differ.

golemotron··on Why don't you use dependent types?
The juice isn't worth the squeeze.
golemotron··on You did this with an AI and you do not understand what you're doing here
Why do people want to signal their low status?
golemotron··on Generative AI as Seniority-Biased Technological Change
Isn't every advanced technology is seniority-biased?
golemotron··on Programming Deflation
..and regulation. The same with supersonic.
golemotron··on The Culture novels as a dystopia
All utopias are dystopias because they deny reality. With enough perception and wisdom you can find the good in an imperfect universe.
golemotron··on Second study finds Uber used opaque algorithm to dramatically boost profits
More businesses than the authors can imagine work this way. They really ought to sit down and have a coffee with some salespeople.
golemotron··on Large language models often know when they are being evaluated
If you know enough cognitive science, you have a choice. You either say that they "know" or that humans don't.

It's like the critique "it's only matching patterns." Wait until you realize how the brain works.

golemotron··on Corporation for Public Broadcasting Statement Regarding Executive Order
The idea that Congress can set up agencies that are outside the control of the Executive needs to be revisited. It leads to rogue, unaccountable bureaucracy.
golemotron··on The Ethics of Spreading Life in the Cosmos
Nothing to worry about. Anti-Natalism is self-extinguishing.
golemotron··on US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrighted
No, I just think that the space can be cleared up with legislation.

It's a weird world where works created with a prompt are not creative enough for protection but pictures taken by randomly pointing smartphone cameras (which use significant amounts of AI internally, btw) are copyrightable.

golemotron··on US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrighted
No truer words have been said.
golemotron··on US appeals court rules AI generated art cannot be copyrighted
This is clearly a case where we need new legislation. The US Copyright Act needed to be amended to cover photography. Prior to that photos were not copyrightable. It seems like we are on the same trajectory now.

The real problem is that Congress is institutionally incapable of making simple amendments to law. Everything gets delegated to agency rule making regardless of whether anyone likes the outcome.

golemotron··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
We only get to complain about these things because ride service is ubiquitous and easy now. With taxis, it wasn't.
golemotron··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
What was the plan for fixing taxi service?
golemotron··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
Uber is not a great case for your argument. They made the world safer and enabled transportation for people who would otherwise not have it. No one, literally no one, who has spent any time in taxis wants to go back to them. I can't tell you the number of times I've had to call several companies to get a taxi to the airport have none arrive. Uber broke the ice and showed what was possible. There was literally no other way to get past the regulatory capture. Yes, they broke the law, but they are net positive by a large margin.
golemotron··on Wishing for a more orderly disruption may misunderstand government reform
Isn't ending the filibuster a one-way trip also?

I can imagine doing it temporarily, but once the precedent has been set, it's over, isn't it?

golemotron··on Starlink Direct to Cell
Thiel and Masters make the case eloquently in Zero to One.
golemotron··on Netflix Europe offices raided in tax fraud probe
The problem is deeper than that. When a physical space is raided, its scope is obvious. Digital spaces don't have that characteristic. There can always be hidden indexes.
golemotron··on Netflix Europe offices raided in tax fraud probe
The real issue is that technology has rendered office raiding useless. People are welcome to explore alternatives.
golemotron··on Netflix Europe offices raided in tax fraud probe
The alternative, giving them a password that gives them read/write access to sensitive systems, would be insane. Subpoena for particular data.
golemotron··on Can SpaceX land a rocket with 1/2 cm accuracy?
The fact that someone tried is significant. We've had 50+ years of not trying.
golemotron··on How to succeed in MrBeast production (Leaked PDF)
Nietzsche called it 'Ressentiment'
golemotron··on Reflection 70B, the top open-source model
That's a very 'Star Trek' view of human nature. History shows that whenever we solve problems we create new ones. When material scarcity is solved, we'll move to other forms of scarcity. In fact, it is already happening. Massive connectivity has made status more scarce. You could be the best guitarist in your town but today you compare yourself to all of the guitarists that you see on Instagram rather than the local ones.
golemotron··on Julian Assange has reached a plea deal with the U.S., allowing him to go free
It might be turnabout. The settlers of Aus were exiles from England.
golemotron··on Microsoft to delay release of Recall AI feature on security concerns
I can't believe that no one there didn't anticipate the blowback. It could just have been a way for Satya to put the feature in front of their business customers. They'd likely want that feature even if consumers reject it.
golemotron··on Microsoft's official Minesweeper app has ads, pay-to-win, and is hundreds of MBs
Ask the stock holders.
golemotron··on Can a bridge be unethical?
Pulling the lever isn't designing the lever. Sometimes reality designs the lever and you have no choice but to make a choice.
golemotron··on Can a bridge be unethical?
The Trolley Problem is not constrained to human design. The author pretends that it is. Their reaction to the issue with self-driving cars illustrates this.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →