HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gortok

4,285 karma · joined February 4, 2013

submissionscomments
gortok··on Ask HN: Funding – Should we wait for this fund to invest in us?
You're not going to get one.

You reach out every few months with updates, especially if those updates include the KPIs they're looking for to invest. If you don't know what those KPIs are, then your initial conversation with them was too hand-wavy.

If you have traction and you continue to gain traction, follow up every few months with a "This is where we are" email, if you'd like. But if you're waiting for them to do something before you make whatever move you were going to make after they made their decision, you're going to be waiting for a long time.

gortok··on Code execution through email: How I used Claude to hack itself
In the comments here there are basically two schools of thought illustrated:

1. This is how MCP and LLMs work. This is how non-deterministic systems turn out. You wanted agentic AI. This is a natural outcome. What’s the problem?

2. We can design these systems to be useful and secure, but it will always be a game of whack-a-mole just like it is now, so what’s the problem?

What I’d like to see more of is a third school of thought:

3. How can anyone be so laissez-faire about folks using systems that are designed to be insecure? We should shut this down now, and let our sense guide our progress, instead of promises of VC-funded exits and promises of billions.

gortok··on Supabase MCP can leak your entire SQL database
If "a lot" of MCP servers let agents input whatever they want; then at what point do you consider the standard itself faulty?
gortok··on Supabase MCP can leak your entire SQL database
I am baffled by the irrational exuberance of the MCP model.

Before we even get into the technical underpinnings and issues, there's a logical problem that should have stopped seasoned technologists dead in their tracks from going further, and that is:

> What are the probable issues we will encounter once we release this model into the wild, and how what is the worst that can probably happen.

The answer to that thought-experiment should have foretold this very problem, and that would have been the end of this feature.

This is not a nuanced problem, and it does not take more than an intro-level knowledge of security flaws to see. Allowing an actor (I am sighing as I say this, but "Whether human or not") to input whatever they would like is a recipe for disaster and has been since the advent of interconnected computers.

The reason why this particularly real and not-easy-to-solve vulnerability made it this far (and permeates every MCP as far as I can tell) is because there is a butt-load (technical term) of money from VCs and other types of investors available to founders if they slap the term "AI" on something, and because the easy surface level stuff is already being thought of, why not revolutionize software development by making it as easy as typing a few words into a prompt?

Programmers are expensive! Typing is not! Let's make programmers nothing more than typists!

And because of the pursuit of funding or of a get-rich-quick mentality, we're not only moving faster and with reckless abandon, we've also abandoned all good sense.

Of course, for some of us, this is going to turn out to be a nice payday. For others, the ones that have to deal with the data breaches and real-world effects of unleashing AI on everything, it's going to suck, and it's going to keep sucking. Rational thought and money do not mix, and this is another example of that problem at work.

gortok··on Adding a feature because ChatGPT incorrectly thinks it exists
No one is “requiring perfection”, but hallucination is a major issue and is in the opposite direction of the “goal” of AGI.

If “don’t hallucinate” is too much to ask then ethics flew out the window long ago.

gortok··on Adding a feature because ChatGPT incorrectly thinks it exists
Is it your argument that the folks that make generative AI applications have nothing to improve from this example?
gortok··on Adding a feature because ChatGPT incorrectly thinks it exists
I think folks have taken the wrong lesson from this.

It’s not that they added a new feature because there was demand.

They added a new feature because technology hallucinated a feature that didn’t exist.

The savior of tech, generative AI, was telling folks a feature existed that didn’t exist.

That’s what the headline is, and in a sane world the folks that run ChatGPT would be falling over themselves to be sure it didn’t happen again, because next time it might not be so benign as it was this time.

gortok··on Tesla reports 14% decline in deliveries, marking second year-over-year drop
That’s the bug, that the rear view camera stayed on when I shifted into drive until I manually closed it. I could reproduce that bug reliably, leaving me to believe it’s just not a big deal to the manufacturer to fix.

Also, just because you’re unable to crash the infotainment system doesn’t mean no one is, or that it’s hard to crash.

gortok··on Writing Code Was Never the Bottleneck
I agree.

In the Venn diagram of the programming culture of the companies that embrace vibe coding and the companies whose developers like to rewrite applications when a new framework comes out is almost a perfect circle, however.

gortok··on Writing Code Was Never the Bottleneck
Developers have always loved the new and shiny. Heck, getting developers not to rewrite an application in their new favorite framework is a tough sell.

LLM “vibe coding” is another continuation of this “new hotness”, and while the more seasoned developers may have learned to avoid it, that’s not the majority view.

CEOs and C-suites have always been disconnected from the first order effects of their cost-cutting edicts, and vibe coding is no different in that regard. They see the ten dollars an hour they spend on LLMs as a bargain if they can hire a $30 an hour junior programmer instead of a $150 an hour senior programmer.

They will continue to pursue cost-cutting, and the advent of vibe coding matches exactly what they care about: software produced for a fraction of the cost.

Our problem — or the problem of the professionals - is that we have not been successful in translating the inherent problems with the CEOs approach to a change in how the C-suite operates. We have not successfully pursuaded them that higher quality software = more sales, or lower liability, or lower cost maintenance, and that partially because we as an industry have eschewed those for “move fast and break things”. Vibe coding is “Move Fast and Break Things” writ large.

gortok··on Tesla reports 14% decline in deliveries, marking second year-over-year drop
I use their adaptive cruise control; and unless they intentionally nerfed it compared to their FSD, I have to be really careful using it in the DC area, as it will randomly brake in certain places.

With the latest Tesla Updates I can tell it thinks there's a grade or curve issue that is causing it to brake; but before the latest update it would just randomly brake in certain places (coming down from 70 to 40 very quickly) and that is just dangerous in the DC area.

gortok··on Tesla reports 14% decline in deliveries, marking second year-over-year drop
Let me start with the App.

The Tesla App allows me to lock, unlock the car, pop and close the trunk, check the cameras, schedule it to warm itself up, input destinations, see its real-time location, and see charging issues.

The app isn't clunky to use. It's wonderful, and it's really well made.

The car's infotainment system is vertically integrated; all of the features are available in one common interface and work well with one another. The car will automatically turn down the fans when I'm on a call, as just one example.

The cameras turn on and show me the blind spots when I'm changing lanes (my only complaint there is that the side-view mirrors do not physically allow me to position them as recommended by NHTSA).

The integrated maps also include charging station availability; and the maps automatically update (I don't need to buy an SD Card from a manufacturer with the updated maps). The software team is able to push updates to my car; so if there are bugs with their bluetooth, it gets fixed without me having to go to the dealership and hoping they care enough about their technology stack to fix it.

If there are bugs, they get fixed; and since they're not dealing with different third-party modules, they own the entire stack that is in the car.

My only complaints are that I can't use Waze on my Tesla, which shows where cops are, and sometimes their navigation routes are wonky and aren't practical (like driving through the middle of DC to avoid going around the beltway), but otherwise the technical experience of owning and operating a tesla an using their infotainment system is lightyears ahead of any other car I've driven.

Contra that with the Volkswagen I just rented where its Carplay crashed and crashed the whole infotainment system; or the bug where its rearview camera stayed on until I manually closed it when I shifted into drive;

gortok··on Tesla reports 14% decline in deliveries, marking second year-over-year drop
The "Hype" (not sure why we're using scare-quotes here; as if somehow EVs are the only thing that aren't subject to the Gartner Hype Cycle) surrounding EVs include some of the following:

- Range is vastly overstated, especially in adverse weather conditions (like cold, snow, or even heat) As an example, in spring, when conditions are perfect (70 degree weather, not too sunny, not too cloudy), my Tesla Model Y LR that is supposed to get 330 miles from a 100% charge gets ... 250. That's not even close to accurate. In winter or in adverse weather conditions it can drop down to as much as 180. That's close to a 50% drop.

- Taking an EV on a long trip is not a simple prospect; and even now in 2025 Tesla still hasn't made it convenient to put in a destination and get there. Somehow the tesla navigation assumes (and up until this latest software update you had to do it yourself) that somehow when you get to where you're going a charger will be within x% of you, for whatever percentage of "x" is when you arrive at your destination. Until the latest update, we had to trick the Tesla by making our destination a round trip affair, to get it to give us a super-charger that would hopefully be close to where we're going, so it wasn't a matter of getting to our destination and manually figuring out where the nearest supercharger is. (We use it for Hockey, so we are frequently driving up the East Coast from the DC Area).

- To keep on the Super Charger issues, it is common to arrive and find undocumented issues with Superchargers (their latest updates also seem to have tried to deal with that problem, though it's not 100% fixed), or entire Supercharger stations literally being out of service but not documented on their side.

- Outside of First party charging; the thirdparty charging, like through Chargepoint et. al. is even worse. As an owner of a Tesla, it's more likely that any third-party charger I try to use will have a problem where my car doesn't actually charge. It's super annoying and at a recent visit to Hershey Park PA, I didn't find out until I came back two hours later that no charging had occurred. I don't blame Tesla for this (though it'd be nice to have a push notification warning me after 5 minutes that nothing is charging), but this is a larger EV Problem. - Overall, taking an EV somewhere still means planning your trip carefully to ensure your destination has charging, how you're getting there has charging, and a back-up plan in case that charging doesn't work.

- Like recently, my spouse took our Tesla to Massuchusetts to pick up our daughter from Soccer camp; and to where we were going there was literally a route that was backed up for 4 hours, and another route that had no superchargers for about 100 miles. So we could either deal with the fact that she was in traffic for four extra hours, or we could deal with the fact that no first-party chargers were in the other route and hope the third-party chargers were up to snuff.

- Wear and tear on the car tires. I got 30,000 miles out of my tires and the tire technician said that was pretty good. They regularly deal with Teslas and other EVs that eat through tires much more quickly than the tires are rated for (and these are Tesla approved tires) due to the weight of the vehicle and the braking dynamics.

- Supply chain for repairs. There's lots of collision centers in the Washington DC area. There are lots of vehicles hanging out, waiting for parts. By far the most vehicles that stay out there the longest (both from my conversations with folks that work at the collision centers and my own eyeballs, I pass two every day) say that EVs, especially Teslas, have a much longer lead time than non-EV vehicles for parts, and that there are not as many OEMs for those parts. So that means if you get in a wreck with a Tesla, you can be waiting weeks or months when someone else might only wait a week or two for a part. As the supply chains improve for EVs that will get better, but that's still a concern for now, and a reason why you can't go "all EV" if you do any serious driving (like we do).

- Charging is not yet as easy as finding a Gas station and taking five minutes to pump gas. It's 15-30 minutes at a Supercharger depending on what you're charging to. Luckily most of the super chargers I used have good amenities close by, but some don't. Some are random mall parking lots with nothing nearby.

These are things the hype cycle doesn't tell you about and you don't realize until you've actually owned an EV and tried to make it your day-to-day vehicle. It's wonderful for short commutes to work; but there are real drawbacks, especially using it for long distance trips or trips that include winter weather.

gortok··on Tesla reports 14% decline in deliveries, marking second year-over-year drop
I'm sure Teslas automated features work well in California, where their engineers are based. They do not, however, work as well in the varying climates found on the East Coast. This is funny as a "works on my machine" approach to testing, but tragic since real lives are at stake.
gortok··on Tesla reports 14% decline in deliveries, marking second year-over-year drop
As someone who dislikes Musk's seemingly oblivious approach to "Move fast and break things" in government when real lives are at stake and expertise is not easy to come by, I really want this drop to be attributable to that. I really, really do.

I own a Tesla (2023 Model Y Long Range 7-seat), and I do enjoy my Model Y; I have some complaints, but overall I'm happy with the safety features of the vehicle. I do not and will not enable the FSD or Auto-steer; but otherwise I am happy with it, and want other car manufacturers to take note of the vertical technological integration possible when they put their minds to it.

However, in pursuit of a better bottom line, Tesla has made some affordance changes to their post 2023 models; and even their camera vision in the 2023 model is a poor substitute for ultra-sonic sensors for parking.

Combine that with their gutting of the Tesla Supercharger team; and the subsequent decline in quality of their supercharger experience, and then combine that with the macro-economic issues that are surrounding EV range and EV experiences in real world conditions; and you have a decline that can be attributed to the non-Musk effects as well.

I don't doubt his political machinations have contributed to Tesla's decline. If I could sell my Tesla, I would; (I am way underwater due to its steep drop in resale value), but I think a substantial percentage of this drop can be attributable to the hype of the EV not living up to the reality of owning an EV.

gortok··on How Frogger 2’s source code was recovered from a destroyed tape [video]
How about ascii art of a male penis every time you opened your IDE?

The point isn’t what you (MyPasswordSucks) would find objectionable, the point is what the median would find objectionable in a professional setting. Luckily we’ve gotten away from the locker room behavior being the median and now the median is approaching good-manners behavior. This is one of the situations where the Overton window shifting makes us better as a species instead of worse.

gortok··on Tell HN: Help restore the tax deduction for software dev in the US (Section 174)
The SSBA (Small Software Business Alliance) was set up by Michele Hansen -- co-founder of Geocodio, http://geocod.io (and the SSBA is now run by another person) for this reason -- to raise awareness in Washington DC of the issue with the Section 174 Capitalization changes and the efforts to repeal it.

https://ssballiance.org/

She has also spoken about it on podcasts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=oF-xsDd1A4o

gortok··on The time bomb in the tax code that's fueling mass tech layoffs
The IRS releases guidance on tax code, and one of the issues with section 174 taking effect in 2022 (and the IRS believing it would be repealed before it went into effect) was that the guidance was released in 2023 under notice 2023-63

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-23-63.pdf

To answer your question, the following are software development activities that are capitalizable (and instead of quoting the notice itself, I’m quoting from a better written blog post by accountants:

https://www.cohnreznick.com/insights/additional-guidance-irs...

> Section 4.03(1) of the Notice clarifies that labor costs – including those for contract employees and independent contractors – related to those who perform, supervise, or directly support SRE activities are considered Section 174 expenditures. All elements of compensation are to be included with the exception of severance, which is excludable and deducted by taxpayers in the period paid or incurred. SRE-related labor costs expenses included in the Notice expenses related to pension costs and stock-based compensation.

Section 4.03(1)(e) provides guidance pertaining to certain costs related to operation and management (i.e., rent, utilities, etc.) activities. Specifically, in addition to items such as rent, utilities, and insurance, expenditures such as taxes (i.e., property), repairs and maintenance, and security are now considered SREs subject to Section 174.

So what software development activities don’t count as “Specified Research Expenditures” (SRE)”?

> Training of employees in the use of the software

>Maintenance activities after the software is placed into service that do not constitute upgrades or enhancements (i.e., corrective maintenance to debug, diagnose, and fix programming errors)

> Data conversion activities (except activities to develop computer software that facilitates access to existing data or data conversion)

> Installation and other activities related to placing the software into service

> Marketing and promotional activities

> Distribution activities

> Customer support

If you’re a startup and you have a software developer doing the above activities as well as SRE work, then in order to expense the SRE parts of their job you either have to estimate (and be able to defend) the estimations, or your employee needs to track their time for each type of activity they do.

gortok··on The time bomb in the tax code that's fueling mass tech layoffs
> A startup isn't likely to be making a profit yet, under either accounting rule. Is there a benefit to reporting a larger loss?

As an example, A two person software startup; both drawing a salary, each making $100,000 per year. Each doing things related to software development.

Startup brings in 200,000K in revenue.

Under pre Section 174 changes, the profit is zero. Both salaries are expensible in the year they were incurred.

Post Section 174, the profit is now $160,000 each year. Now they pay taxes on $160,000, even though they literally have no money left over because revenues equaled expenditures.

At 25% tax rate, that’s $40,000 in taxes, for a business that made literally no money.

That’s why this is so devastating to small software businesses; unless you’re highly profitable and have cash reserves, this change hits hard.

gortok··on Figma Slides Is a Beautiful Disaster
Post a link to one? Would love to see how they turn out.
gortok··on At Amazon, some coders say their jobs have begun to resemble warehouse work
> Companies seem to be persuaded that, like assembly lines of old, A.I. can increase productivity. A recent paper by researchers at Microsoft and three universities found that programmers’ use of an A.I. coding assistant called Copilot, which proposes snippets of code that they can accept or reject, increased a key measure of output more than 25 percent.

> The engineers said that the company had raised output goals and had become less forgiving about deadlines.

There are two issues this article brings to mind:

1. Feels like we are back when lines of code was a measure of productivity.

2. We’ve heard this tune before, and the problem we have now is that you don’t understand what you didn’t write. Software development is in large part about understanding the system from the highest level to its smallest details, and this takes away a key part of how our world works, in favor of a “cattle not pets” view of code.

Now, if you don’t expect your programmers to have an understanding of the system they built, and you treat code as disposable, then you’ll center around a world where folks aren’t trained to learn a system, and I don’t see that as a world that is compatible with increased reliance on A.I.

gortok··on Watching AI drive Microsoft employees insane
At least currently, to qualify for copyright, there must be a human author. https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-appeals-court-rejects-co...

I have no idea how this will ultimately shake out legally, but it would be absolutely wild for Microsoft to not have thought about this potential legal issue.

gortok··on FBI arrests judge accused of helping man evade immigration authorities
This over-simplifies our federal system to the point of uselessness.

The Federal Government is responsible for immigration. It's their job to set policies and adjudicate immigration issues.

Local and State Law Enforcement are not responsible for -- and indeed it is outside of their powers to enforce immigration laws.

Supreme Court precedent is that states cannot be compelled by Congress to enforce Immigration law (see: Printz v. United States).

So, what you have in this situation are the fact that States and the Federal Government have opposing interests: The States need to be able to enforce their laws without their people feeling like they can't tell the police when there's a crime, and the current federal policy is to deport all undocumented immigrants, no matter why they're here or whether they are allowed to be here while their status is adjudicated.

gortok··on Pope Francis has died
Indeed; and when the Second Vatican Council decided Mass should be said in the vernacular, the obligation of the Church was to follow. Instead, the conservatives of the church ('conservative' here means those that emphasize adhering to tradition and are adverse to change) created a rift by eschewing this change and even heightening the importance of the Latin Mass, creating the impression that a mass spoken in the local language was somehow less of a mass.

If you’re Catholic, suggesting that a mass spoken in one language over another is somehow "less" takes away from the most important idea of the Mass: reenacting Christ’s Last supper commandment and the institution of the Holy Eucharist for what amounts to word games.

This divisive description of the mass increased over the decades, to the point that it threatened to cause a schism. As such it was the Holy Father’s duty to resolve the issue.

gortok··on Getting forked by Microsoft
Define “substantial”?

What percentage of copying is “substantial”?

That’s the problem with concisely written licenses, the legal world thrives on definitions and terms of art, and when you leave something open to interpretation you invite the probability that a nefarious (or even sufficiently amoral actor like a large corporation) actor will point to the language you use and interpret it differently.

To win any argument in a court of law you must now spend time and money to win the argument. Something an open source maintainer likely doesn’t have, and since the license doesn’t specify damages, there’s no way to even write in a penalty for failure to adhere such that a court of law would consider it under contract law, and then you have to prove damages.

At least in Virginia, each party pays their own lawyers fees, even if they win. You can only collect lawyers fees when statutes allow you to, or there has been sufficient bad faith from the other side that the court uses its own power to sanction.

Oh, and let’s say you win and somehow you are able to prove damages. Now you have to spend money to collect on the judgment. That’s money you’re not getting back.

The point here is that we’ve written software licenses as contracts that assume good faith and do not punish bad actors, when we would need to treat corporations as if they are bad actors and write licenses accordingly.

gortok··on U.S. citizen in Arizona detained by immigration officials for 10 days
I would like to know how far from the “norm” ICE has deviated since January 19, 2025.

It’s possible this is something that happens, and just wasn’t widely reported before now, but is because of the ethnophobic nature of our current administration.

It’s also possible this is far outside of the norm and deserves more attention than it’s getting just on the face of its irregularity.

I cannot find a non-AI generated (in my admittedly quick search) list of statistics of how many US citizens have been detained by ICE (and I do not trust that AI generated answers are accurate), so I am left with feelings, and my feelings indicate this would have been a news story no matter how rarely or often it happens, and therefore is worthy of discussion and reflection as to whether our border policies accurately reflect what we say our values are.

gortok··on Pope Francis has died
It’s important to note that The Two Popes was a drama, and not a true factual story.

It fictionalizes and sensationalizes some details; and that’s ok because its purpose is to make you feel exactly the way you feel about it.

Pope Francis was a wonderful steward of Christianity and espoused the virtues that anyone would want to see in their religious leaders: humility, grace, an openness to listen and a strong voice against even prelates in his own church that are xenophobic or nationalistic. He wanted us to welcome all and to live as the bible said Jesus did.

The fear I have is that each swing of the pendulum goes in two directions. He was far more “liberal” than the conservative Catholic prelates of the USCCB, and I fear his actions — including rightfully limiting the Latin mass, will force the church to swing in the other direction and give in to the illiberal forces that divide us.

gortok··on Kennedy promises to find environmental causes of autism
For the sake of argument, let’s say Trump won on the issue of the economy and “fixing it” to work for the work class who has largely been ignored politically by congress.

That is a one issue voter, and at least the folks I’ve seen around here focus on the economics, so it’s relevant for our interests to focus on that.

This. This is the problem with the one issue vote. Trump is, being charitable, not very good at running a business, let alone a country, and so his choices to run the various federal agencies that make up the government will invariably be bad. We’ve already seen the effects of this “management philosophy”, and will continue to see the effects in the form of actual harm to the folks that live in the United States (and harm to folks around the world, but one thing at a time).

The myopia of the voter, whether it’s here on HN or elsewhere, causes this harm. I don’t know how to fix this issue, because a one issue voter is notoriously difficult to reason with, but it’s what we are facing, whether that issue is the economy, abortion, or trans-fearmongering.

gortok··on CVE program faces swift end after DHS fails to renew contract [updated]
I would hope the folks that frequent HN would not be so insular as to only read what happens on HN and not read any other news source.

If you’ve somehow missed Trump’s systematic dismantling of academic freedom or his disappearing of folks he doesn’t like, then we have a far bigger problem than the limits of what is discussed on HN.

gortok··on Harvard's response to federal government letter demanding changes
By “divisive” you mean dividing heads from bodies, right?
← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →