HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gortok

4,285 karma · joined February 4, 2013

submissionscomments
gortok··on Show HN: A difficult game to test your logic
As someone who is colorblind (Deuteranopia), the first level asks to swap the green and brown frog. With the hues used, I can’t tell the difference between the two frogs.
gortok··on The polar vortex is hitting the brakes
That already seems to be happening. Business leaders with capital are actively trying to replace workers with AI or offshoring; so what would be the extra damage from codifying that we want folks to put their money here?
gortok··on The polar vortex is hitting the brakes
The damage is real even if the dollar amount of the cuts is overhyped.
gortok··on AI-Generated Voice Evidence Poses Dangers in Court
Today. I get an interstitial every time I log in that tries to get me to enable their VoiceID system (here's a screenshot): https://georgestocker.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/schwabv...
gortok··on AI-Generated Voice Evidence Poses Dangers in Court
What shocks (and irritates!) me is that Charles Schwab keeps wanting me to set up voice ID. Why would I want to set up a voice ID for something that is now trivially spoofed?
gortok··on Mark Cuban offers to fund former 18F employees
login.gov is one of the few government services that as a private sector techie I'm in awe of. They really knocked it out of the park with login.gov, and I can only assume it was politics that had the IRS use ID.me instead of login.gov.
gortok··on A Comment on Mozilla's Policy Changes
While waterfax highlights a problematic section of Mozilla's change:

> UPDATE: We’ve seen a little confusion about the language regarding licenses, so we want to clear that up. We need a license to allow us to make some of the basic functionality of Firefox possible. Without it, we couldn’t use information typed into Firefox, for example. It does NOT give us ownership of your data or a right to use it for anything other than what is described in the Privacy Notice. (Emphasis mine)

And they mention that we need to see the context behind this change -- but what they don't to -- is point out that the update clarification makes the whole situation even more problematic than it was previously.

The private notice indicates they use data to:

1. To provide and improve search functionality 2. To serve relevant content and advertising on Firefox New Tab 3. To provide Mozilla accounts 4. To provide AI Chatbots 5. To provide Review Checker, including serving sponsored content 6. To provide and enable add-ons (addons.mozilla.org) 7. To maintain and improve features, performance and stability 8. To improve security 9. To understand usage of Firefox 10. To market our services 11. To pseudonymize, de-identify, aggregate or anonymize data 12. To communicate with you 13. To comply with applicable laws, and identify and prevent harmful, unauthorized or illegal activity

1,2,4,5,10 are problematic. We don't want those things. Mozilla wants those things. The problem isn't the lack of context behind the changes, the problem is Mozilla wants to be able to use our 'input' data for whatever they want, and I don't want them to.

They said they're the privacy focused browser; and they're not. That's a lie. I moved from Chrome to Firefox precisely because I couldn't trust Google. Now I can't trust Firefox.

gortok··on Introducing a terms of use and updated privacy notice for Firefox
If you don't want this to happen, then a company would need to:

1. Have the capital to build and maintain a browser 2. By selling copies of that browser 3. In sufficient funds to keep the business going and make the owners a profit.

Let's say you can do it with a small team -- if you're forking something like firefox, and pay for the salary of 21 people -- full time, 8 developers, a PM, a manager, Customer support (3 people), 3 sales folks, and 3 testers, and one owner.

If the average salary is $175,000, and the fully loaded cost of each employee (including office space, equipment, benefits) is $250,000, then just to break even -- and not even account for inflation or costs rising -- and not even accounting for capital expenditures, the product would have to sell 105,000 copies at $50 a pop.

If you sold it for $30 a year, that's now 175,000 copies, every year. Realistically, to account for taxes and the fact that Developer salaries are no longer expensible (thanks Trump!), you'd have to sell around twice that number of copies, so around 350,000 copies of this browser, a year. Every year. Just to break even.

When's the last time 350,000 people said, "I want to buy a web browser?". When's the last time 350,000 people bought a web browser?

We've made our own bed in this one, the second folks saw that Internet Explorer was free; and that killed the original Mozilla browser -- that -- by the way -- I happily paid for.

If you want an internet where you're not the product, then that's an internet where the business models have to change, and the customer desire to pay for the software they use has to go up.

And that still -- still -- does not alleviate the problem of capital needing to get started, which is only exacerbated by the Section 174 changes in the TCJA of 2017.

gortok··on DOGE staffers quit, citing Musk
The reason why they're called DOGE staffers is because Trump renamed the US Digital Service to the US DOGE Service. That's why they're DOGE Staffers. They were there before January 20th, when it was still the US Digital Service.
gortok··on Texas banned abortion, then sepsis rates soared
By 'life-altering', do you mean: Fewer women dying of sepsis?
gortok··on "Ensuring Accountability for All Agencies" – Executive Order
Executive Orders were meant to give instructions to the executive branch on how to “faithfully execute the law”. They turned into — through several presidents, a way to bind the executive branch to a particular way of interpreting the law —- or in some cases —- making law out of whole cloth.

Trump is continuing this trend, and while we should all be concerned as to where he takes it, congress and the judiciary share the blame for not reigning in prior presidents.

gortok··on The young, inexperienced engineers aiding DOGE
> Who controls the US Capitol Police? I remind you that they obeyed Trump during the January 6th insurrection.

[Citation Needed]. Seriously. Heck, even a cursory read of the Wikipedia article would tell you they are controlled by the Legislative branch.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Capitol_Police

> The United States Capitol Police (USCP) is a federal law enforcement agency in the United States with nationwide jurisdiction charged with protecting the United States Congress within the District of Columbia and throughout the United States and its territories. It answers to the Capitol Police Board and is the only full-service federal law enforcement agency appointed by the legislative branch of the federal government of the United States.

Misinformation is infectious.

gortok··on TCAS Avoided Collision with Army Helicopter over Potomac River [video]
They do have authority over certain airspaces and this is one of them. They can tell the military not to fly over certain airspace.
gortok··on Snyk security researcher deploys malicious NPM packages targeting cursor.com
The only part of the article I disagree with is this line:

> But in general, it’s a good idea not to install NPM packages blindly. If you know what to look for, there are definite signals that these packages are dodgy. All of these packages have just two files: package.json and index.js (or main.js). This is one of several flags that you can use to determine if a package is legit or not.

This works -- maybe OK for top-level packages. But for transitive dependencies it's nearly impossible to vet every transitive dependency.

If you're pulling in a package that has 400 dependencies, how the heck would you even competently check 10% of that surface area? https://gist.github.com/anvaka/8e8fa57c7ee1350e3491#top-1000...

gortok··on The Origins of Wokeness
The humorous part to me is when folks talk badly about 'antifa' they either forget or gloss over what the 'fa' means in antifa.
gortok··on Pushing the whole company into the past on purpose
With this comment you seem to be putting the Overton window farther right than I’ve seen it in recent memory —- outside of very rural areas.
gortok··on After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code
> it is freaking hard to commit to 3-5 years of virtually no salary to maybe get to the same outcome you would have had with a funded business.

I agree and I disagree.

It is hard to bootstrap a product. It's even harder to bootstrap a product that folks want to buy. It's even harder to do that when the prevailing wisdom on this (and other tech sites) is to go the VC-funded route.

The VC funded route -- for the vast, vast, vast majority of software businesses ends up being the exact same as the bootstrapped route -- except that you lose one avenue when you find out your business isn't "hyper-growth" or isn't going to be a huge as you claimed in your pitchdeck to the VCs. You lose the ability to pare back and to be what is described as a "lifestyle business". On failure, the business gets sold or stripped for parts, unless the founder can somehow get the VCs to agree to let them 'buy it back' or write-off their investment and give it back.

Bootstrapping means taking that risk on yourself; but it also means control over your options, and that is one fundamental strength to bootstrapping you don't get with VC funded startups.

Absolutely, it's no salary or the aptly named ramen profitability for a long time if your marketing is not aligned with the folks that will buy your software, or if your software really is just selling a solution to a problem no one actually cares about.

The 'hard part' isn't the engineering. It isn't the technology. The hard part is the marketing -- the connecting the hopefully expensive problem you solve to the right folks who want to buy that solution.

To your second part, I wholly agree that selling $10/month licenses is not a viable way forward if you want to be anything more than a solopreneuer.

But to do that, you need to hone your positioning so that you get in front of the folks with money who need to solve the problem your solution solves.

In your case, it looks like you run a web-auditing tool (according to your bio) called caido.io; and it looks like you're targetting basically everyone who needs to audit a website.

In the thought that "there are more fish in the ocean so why not fish there", that is a seemingly sound idea.

But you don't really want to spend your time trying to fish in the ocean if you have a barrel you could fish in and get the same result... dinner. (I did not come up with this metaphor, that was Jonathan Stark -- who writes a lot about positioning in this context).

The question you have to ask yourself is, are you positioning your product so that the CISOs or the large cyber-security firms would want to buy it? And if you did, do you think they'd trust your product at a mere $25 per month?

Anyway, the point to all this is that the problem is learning how to position the thing you build and get it in front of the right folks, and that's a marketing problem, not a technology problem, and that's something that we as engineers have ignored for far too long collectively.

I wish you the best of luck with your product -- we need more small software businesses in this world!

gortok··on After 3 Years, I Failed. Here's All My Startup's Code
> While we gained some traction with some startups, we ultimately weren't able to build a hyper-growth business.

>"We then decided to pivot into a vertical B2B SaaS AI product because we felt we could use the breakthroughs in Gen AI to solve previously unsolvable problems, but after going through user interviews and the sales cycle for many different ideas, we haven't been able to find enough traction to make us believe that we were on the right track to build a huge business."

How many wonderful niche products would be around if their owners had tried for a small business instead of a 'huge business' with 'hyper growth'?

gortok··on The Porsche Macan EV is being recalled because its headlights are too bright
The default 'height' of the Tesla Model Y headlights make it appear to be bright lights by default. I live in the DC metro area, and buses (who are typically folks that drive a lot) would constantly flash me to let me know they thought my brights were on.

You can go into the car's settings and lower the headlights, but because of where it is by default, it presents a dangerous situation for other cars. How many non-tech folks would know to even search for this option?

https://service.tesla.com/docs/Model3/ServiceManual/en-us/GU...

gortok··on Trump wins presidency for second time
Gruez. You pay payroll and estimated taxes quarterly. As long as you hit 90% of your actual tax burden, there are no penalties. You file income tax yearly and that sets you up for both your remaining burden that you didn't pay in estimated taxes, and your future estimated taxes. The trick is when you go to file by March 15th, you may or may not have accounted for all of the vagaries of tax changes -- and in fact the IRS pushes out guidance throughout the year that will affect the filing process.

For companies that were expensing 100% of developer salaries (which was a lot of them -- capitalization is very cash intensive), having to now eat 80% of that salary as profit and only being able to deduct 20% is devastating.

1171(!) small software companies have come together to try to get congress to repeal their changes to Section 174. They haven't been successful yet, but here's hoping that by further education of folks like yourself, they will be. https://ssballiance.org/

gortok··on Trump wins presidency for second time
> Seems like a stretch. "Software Development Job Postings on Indeed in the United States"[1] was up into the beginning of 2022. The tax changes were known in advance for years. If the tax code changes were a significant factor, why did companies hire a bunch of people in 2021, knowing that when 2022 rolled around there would be massive taxes?

Gruez... Income Taxes are paid the year after they're incurred. Tax Year 2022 is filed and paid in 2023. The effects wouldn't start being felt until March 2023 at the earliest.

Also, literally everyone involved in tax policy thought it would be repealed. Heck, the IRS had to scramble to release guidance because they thought it was going to be repealed. The IRS didn't release detailed guidance on Section 174 until September 2023 -- six months after tax filings were due (a number of businesses asked for an extension to file but still had to pay the taxes as if they had filed on time). https://www.cohnreznick.com/insights/additional-guidance-irs...

The Section 174 capitalization for software development was included in the TCJA as a way to 'pay' for the tax cuts, but no one seriously believed it would stay in the law. The problem is congress is very dysfunctional, so once it was signed into law you'd need a congress to get it out. It's no surprise the congress in 2023 was more dysfunctional than the one in 2017.

Also, in 2021 interest rates were historically low, and as I stated initially the dual loss of the ZIRP environment and the massive change to how software developer policies worked together to kill software development jobs.

gortok··on Trump wins presidency for second time
It was a combination of factors: zero interest rate policies changed to fight inflation and the Tax Cut Jobs act of 2017 changes (section 174) requiring capitalization of everything softwsre development related except bug fixes went into effect for tax year 2022.

If software developer salaries cannot be expensed and it’s now 5 times more expensive to borrow money to expand, jobs will be lost.

Oh, and the TCJA was championed and signed into law by then President Trump.

gortok··on Microsoft is introducing hidden APIs to VS Code only enabled for Copilot?
> Visual studio is open source.

No it’s not. Visual Studio is a proprietary product and the latest version is Visual Studio 2022.

Visual Studio Code is open source, and it is about as close to Visual Studio as Lightning is to Lightning Bug.

gortok··on Automattic–WP Engine Term Sheet
The terms seem oppressive in nature and not designed to actually be agreed to.

If I wanted to say “I made them an offer” but wanted to be sure they wouldn’t take me up on the offer, this is the sort of term sheet I’d use.

gortok··on DoNotPay has to pay $193K for falsely touting untested AI lawyer, FTC says
> it used to be pretty positively received on HN

Doesn’t that call into question the decision making of folks on HN rather than being a positive view of the product?

gortok··on Eliminating Memory Safety Vulnerabilities at the Source
There is a correlation between new code and memory vulnerabilities (a possible explanation is given in the blog post, that vulnerabilities have a half-life that decays rapidly), but why does the blog post indicate causation between the two factors?

There is more than one possible and reasonable explanation for this correlation:

1. New code often relates to new features, and folks focus on new features for vulnerabilities. 2. Older code has been through more real life usage, which can exercise those edge cases where memory vulnerabilities reside.

I’m just not comfortable saying new code causes memory vulnerabilities and that vulnerabilities have a half-life that decays rapidly. That may —- may be true in sheer number count, but doesn’t seem to be true in impact, thinking back to the high-impact vulnerabilities in OSS like the heartbleed bug, and the cache-invalidation bugs for CPUs.

gortok··on Alexa is in millions of households and Amazon is losing billions
I ordered automated cat feeders and had bought the “honey guaridan [sic]” which is a Chinese knockoff when I thought I was buying “HoneyGuardian” brand automated cat feeders.

This is blatant behavior on the part of sellers and Amazon turns a blind-eye to it.

I didn’t learn my lesson either.

I ordered seat covers, and what came was a misspelled Chinese knockoff brand instead of the name brand I thought I was ordering.

I can’t trust purchases made on Amazon and I have an eye for detail. They got me twice. I don’t know how non-detail oriented folks keep from it happening.

gortok··on 77% of employees report AI has increased workloads and hampered productivity
This is also not the study, but a summary of the study.

At this point I’ll email their POC and see if they’ll release the actual study itself.

gortok··on 77% of employees report AI has increased workloads and hampered productivity
This is not a study. This is an executive summary of a study.

This sort of stuff rankles me. Without the numbers, questions, and methodology there’s no way to ascertain what errors the folks who created the study committed, if any.

gortok··on How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic startups?
You can save minutes of talking to folks through Months of work and tens of thousands of people-hours building something people don't want or need.

You can save months of research by spending years of work and hundreds of thousands of people-hours building something that doesn't work.

← PreviousPage 6 of 10Next →