HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gortok

4,285 karma · joined February 4, 2013

submissionscomments
gortok··on CrowdStrike Update: Windows Bluescreen and Boot Loops
downvoted, because in your response you conflate two issues:

1. The problem with using Microsoft 2. The lack of institutional knowledge of securing BSD and MacOS and running either of those at the scale Microsoft systems are being run at.

The vast majority of corporate computer endpoints are running windows. The vast majority of corporate line-of-business systems are running Windows Server (or alternatively Microsoft 365).

That means a whole lot of people have knowledge on how to administer windows machines and servers. That means the cost of knowledge to adminster those systems is going down as more people know how to do it.

Contra that with MacOS Server administration, endpoint administration, or BSD Administration. Far fewer people know how to do that. Far fewer examples of documentation and fixing issues administrators have are on the internet, waiting to help the hapless system administrator who has a problem.

It's not just about better vs. worse from your perspective; it's about the cost of change and the cost of acquiring the knowledge necessary to run these corporate systems at scale -- not to mention the cost of converting any applications running on these Windows machines to run on BSD or MacOS -- both from an endpoint perspective and a corporate IT system perspective.

It's really not even feasible to suggest alternatives to any of the corporations using Microsoft that are impacted by this outage.

If you want to create an alternative to Microsoft's Corporate IT Administration you're gonna need to do a lot more than point to MacOS or BSD being "better".

gortok··on Ask HN: Who's been hired through Hacker News?
Industry term for when Apple launches a product that does substantially what yours does, or incorporates your product features into their product.

https://www.howtogeek.com/297651/what-does-it-mean-when-a-co...

gortok··on Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for official acts
Congress hasn't declared war after WWII. I suppose that's why you used the euphemism "congressional authorization"; instead of what was intended by the folks that wrote the constitution -- a declaration of war.
gortok··on Supreme Court rules ex-presidents have immunity for official acts
That hasn't stopped any president in the last 60 years from using the Armed Forces to conduct a war -- or "police action" -- if you prefer.
gortok··on Study finds 268% higher failure rates for Agile software projects
The study isn't shared, so we can't see the methodology to determine its accuracy. We see the results of the survey; but that's not a study, and the survey itself isn't shared with us.

I don't dispute that agile has its issues -- and I'd be surprised if 'agile' failure rates weren't an issue. We can empirically see the result of 25 years of 'agile', and it's not somewhere we should aspire to be.

The issues comes down to this:

1. Is adopting an 'agile' methodology sufficient to ensure (insert goal here)? 2. Has the software industry adopted a method of operating that creates a statistical quality control; and adopted practices that investigate and remediate special causes and common causes of variation in quality?

To spoil it: for #1 the answer is 'no', and for #2 the answer is a resounding 'no'.

There are practices that are ingredients to the world described in #2, but we as an industry have not yet adopted a systematic way of thinking and resolving problems in the software development process.

I think we'd be better off adopting Deming's method of management and his System of Profound Knowledge and be far better off than adopting the agile fad of the week; even as I admit I still have open questions on how to apply his work to Software. (See "The New Economics" 3rd Edition, and "Out of the Crisis", both written by Deming).

gortok··on Ask HN: How can we open-source a 7 year old SaaS codebase and build a community?
After having looked over your product's website (ozma.io), it feels like the issue may be more ensuring you're being seen by your target customer and solving a problem they have that entices them to use your product.

Your product's website is very 'feature' oriented, and not very 'Pain/Dream/Fix' formatted. https://sharpen.page/jtbd/copywriting/pain-dream-fix-and-jtb...

gortok··on Ask HN: How can we open-source a 7 year old SaaS codebase and build a community?
if I were you I'd seek to sell it instead of open-source it. "pivoting to adding value with LLMs on top" is very expensive from a COGS standpoint; and will complicate your business economics, not simplify them.

You don't seem to have a problem where open-source is the answer; the problem you seem to have is you built a business and a business model you weren't intending to build; and you don't solve that by open-sourcing. You can solve that a myriad of ways, but none of them are readily solved by open-sourcing your product.

gortok··on Jan Leike Resigns from OpenAI
it requires calculation of frequency of how often words appear next to each other given other surrounding words. If you want to call that 'understanding', you can, but it's not semantic understanding.

If it were, these LLMs wouldn't hallucinate so much.

Semantic understanding is still a ways off, and requires much more intelligence than we can give machines at this moment. Right now the machines are really good at frequency analysis, and in our fervor we mistake that for intelligence.

gortok··on Only 90s Web Developers Remember This (2014)
Was hoping someone would come here and say this, although we're getting to the point where if we don't write it down we won't remember it, and mandela ourselves out of how things actually were.
gortok··on A decade-old Steam bug
In some paragraphs you put “a hat on a hat”. That is, you pile on the snark on top of an already meme-y paragraph and it feels like “too much” of something that works better subtly.

As others have stated, get to the point sooner.

gortok··on Throwing away 10 months of work after 2 months on the job
Ah, I see your argument; SPAs are a preferred way to 'suck folks in' to a page and just have them stay there since they can't navigate in and out to the specific piece of content they want with URLs.

That about sums up everything wrong with our industry. Engagement over usefulness.

gortok··on Throwing away 10 months of work after 2 months on the job
This is a joke, right?
gortok··on Homebrew's analytics have moved to the EU and away from Google
Maybe they get a discount/free hosting by mentioning it?
gortok··on Ferengi Rules of Acquisition
Cardassians? Germany post WW1

The marquis? French resistance Against? The Germans.

Romulans? Romans.

Remans? Guess who?

Vulcans? Greek.

Klingons? Russians/Japanese depending on the Star Trek series.

Federation? Evolved America.

Ferengi? Present day capitalism.

Borg? Eventual conclusion of overreliance on technology.

All of the archetypes and races from Star Trek are taken from germs in our own history.

gortok··on Ferengi Rules of Acquisition
It was a TV show back when they wrote 26 episodes a year, and were producing a show a week. Heck, the entire Star Trek universe is taking pieces of ideas that you see for seconds and turning them into whole backstories.
gortok··on Marten: a Crystal web framework
Not to be confused with the C# document database built on Postgres.

https://martendb.io/

gortok··on Ask HN: Contractors, what is your hourly rate?
I don't charge by the hour.

I charge fixed prices only for project work.

For advisory retainers, I charge a flat rate per month.

All upfront (or 50% up front and 50% in X number of days).

Billing by the hour misaligns incentives.

(Obligatory link to Hourly Billing is Nuts: https://jonathanstark.com/hbin )

gortok··on SPAs Were a Mistake
> . You aren't mixing state across server and client. Single Source of Truth is a thing for a good reason. If you have a stateful backend, and your front end naturally has the state of whatever the user has input, you now have to work to keep those two in sync.

Why would I want to keep any state on the client? What in the history of the web (the whole idea being its someone elses computer) would make it a good idea to take away the one major selling point of the web? That no matter what, someone else has the state I need, and I never have to worry about losing that if something happens to my connection. It either went through or it didn't.

gortok··on Apple deleted films from my AppleTV and now forces to watch them through Disney+
Are you using the Apple TV app? It tries to “take over”.
gortok··on Ask HN: What’s the most outrageous belief you’re confident is true?
The Fermi paradox says otherwise.
gortok··on Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyright [fixed]
That’s not true. You can change the license if the license allows you to. It’s copyright you can’t change unless the author assigns the copyright to you.
gortok··on .NET Foundation under fire as resigning board member questions its role
The PR that removed the Contribution model was only merged for 2 hours before it was reverted: https://github.com/dotnet-foundation/projects/issues/122
gortok··on .NET Foundation under fire as resigning board member questions its role
This is incorrect.

> Assignment and Contribution Models. The .NET Foundation uses either an assignment model or a contribution model for on-boarding new projects. Under the assignment model, a project transfers ownership of the copyright to the .NET Foundation. Under the contribution model, a project retains ownership of the copyright, but grants the .NET Foundation a broad license to the project’s code and other intellectual property. The project also confirms that the project’s submissions to .NET Foundation are its own original work (there are also instructions for any third party materials that might be included).

They accept both models (Contribution and Assignment).

https://dotnetfoundation.org/projects/submit

gortok··on Normal people are beginning to acknowledge loss of free speech on the internet
Some points that are relevant:

Tech has a lot of consolidation behind it both infrastructure-wise and end-user watering-hole-wise.

The fewer providers, the fewer people that make the rules, the more likely it is you have to play by their rules.

If you're upset that there are more free-speech 'restrictions' on the internet and you're cheering every time there's another tech acquisition, you're boiling the pot you're sitting in.

gortok··on Google bookmarks won't be supported past September 31, 2021
The title has a typo; September has 30 days.
gortok··on Software estimation is hard – do it anyway
It’s just “a spike” or “spike”.
gortok··on No one gives a shit what programming language you use
depends on what I'm doing.

I love using Perl for simple automations I have; especially when those automations involve text manipulation.

I focus on C# and .NET professionally; although I've done production work in C, Python, TypeScript, JavaScript, and Perl.

But, the language and stack I pick for a given task is entirely dependent upon the reasons I list in the post. I'll happily dump C# or .NET if the situation calls for it.

gortok··on No one gives a shit what programming language you use
spot on. (compare it to other posts; this is not a trend in my writing; it's a specific (almost one-time) use of language to drive home the point)
gortok··on Ask HN: How do old (30plus) software engineers remain excited about the field?
Do you mean a software developer that’s 30+ years old or a software developer who has been in the industry for 30+ years?
gortok··on Thanks HN: Lessons learned after Google nearly killed my site
I tried to send the blog post link to another person on Twitter and got a notice that the tweet couldn’t be sent because the site was potentially harmful: https://twitter.com/gortok/status/1368309384619626506?s=21
← PreviousPage 7 of 10Next →