HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gortok

4,285 karma · joined February 4, 2013

submissionscomments
gortok··on Astonishing Performance of .NET 5
Coming from a different perspective: Once you've been using Entity Framework for a while (I assume the OP is referring to EF, since there tends to be a 'Use what microsoft ships' culture in the .NET community), is that the APIs available to a "Code First" approach vs. a "Model First" approach are different. If you use Code First and Code Migrations, you don't have access (without getting out of Code First entirely!) to creating Views; and in EF 6 at least, creating indexes was a chore as well. I believe this has been fixed in EF Core; but regardless the mainpoint still stands: The APIs are different and what is natively available is different. At some point doing "Code First", you'll still need to write raw SQL, and that's unexpected if you are planning on doing your work in C# only.

Regarding Dependency Injection: It's very much suited towards enterprise web applications; and its failure mode is trying to get DI to work seamlessly in a non-web application sense (C# is a general language; and .NET supports console, GUI, and web applications) and once you get out of the we application thread-per-request pipeline, you find yourself hitting rough patches.

gortok··on NestedText, a nice alternative to JSON, YAML, TOML
The parent commenter explained it in a somewhat obtuse way.

I don’t doubt they meant to be clear, but reading it they were not and raised more questions than were answered.

As an example:

Wouldnt attributes be better served as details about the current element?

Wouldn’t elements be better served as “I am a child of the parent”?

Why would I use an attribute as a “non-repeating child” when semantically that doesn’t make sense when looking at the document? The attribute is inside the element’s definition, and seems to me attributes should be used to further describe the element being presented itself, and not be structural or describe itself as a child in any way.

gortok··on Saying thanks: testing a new Reactions feature
Also one of the answers on that question was deleted by an employee (! — itself an unusual event) for satirically opposing the change. More information here.

https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/398507/16587

Overall, the biggest complaint against this is:

1. Not enough people vote on questions or answers.

We know this because of the metrics of people who visit a page vs. those that vote vs. those that comment.

I used to know these metrics since I was a Stack Overflow community elected moderator, but no longer have access to them since I resigned in October of last year: https://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/390427/16587

Anyway, the goal of this change is to reduce the number of 'thanks' comments left (and to hopefully make people feel like Stack Overflow is more than 'just' a Q&A site, that it has, itself, a personality that is welcoming); but the problem is that it doesn't address -- and indeed may even exacerbate the issue with not enough people voting.

Voting is what helps ensure bad questions are tended to, good questions are rewarded, and good answers are rewarded (and as a positive reinforcement mechanism for people to post more answers).

If people aren't voting, the Q&A model breaks down rather quickly. Which is Bad™.

The hypothesis against is if people have reactions, why would they need to vote?

Naturally, the people in the community who depend on votes to help their work (the curators) are pretty pissed off that at best this will distract from tackling the issue, and at worst will actively disrupt trying to fix the issue.

There has been a tendency over the past year or so especially for Stack Overflow (The company) to not listen to its curators (it's been going on for much longer than that, but came to a head a year ago); and this is another instance in a long series of instances where at best Stack Overflow (the company) is tone deaf to the issues its community faces.

gortok··on Ex-NSA hacker drops zero-day for Zoom
It's especially relevant to me and my family; as the room-moms in my children's classrooms want to use Zoom to set up playdates so the kids from the classroom can interact, since they really miss each other (and don't get to see each other otherwise).

None of this is contrived; and all of it is serious when you're the parent of a school age child.

gortok··on Please stop recommending Gitflow
> Well, I suppose this one is correct if you consider dropping even the tiniest part of gitflow as completely abandoning gitflow;

Thank you for that feedback.

It's important to note that my blog post rails against Git-flow as described by that blog post, not necessarily as practiced by teams. If teams drop the problematic parts of Gitflow, of course they'd be able to use Continuous delivery!

But the point of Git-flow is very much to not practice Continuous delivery (the textbook example; again if someone practices what they call CD but it isn't what the textbook says "Continuous Delivery" is, I can't help that.

> See gitflow as a starting point, not as a silver bullet. There are no silver bullets.

Now you're getting to the crux of my issue with the original (has since been updated) blog post. The Gitflow the OP described is problematic for all the reasons I laid out in my post (And more that I didn't list, that others have captured in the comments). It necessarily stands to reason that if you don't take gitflow at face-value, you'll be better off -- but that's not what I'm arguing against. I'm arguing against practicing Gitflow as laid out by the OP.

gortok··on Please stop recommending Gitflow
Thank you for that feedback!

I purposefully didn't provide any solutions in that blog post because the entire point of the blog post is for a team to figure out what works for them, in their context, culture, and constraints.

There are lots of different workflows:

> Feature branches

> Merge to Master

> GitHub Flow

> GitLab Flow

> GitFlow

I've also seen weird mutations where each developer reuses a branch and just does new pull requests from that an nukes the remote each time. it's problematic, but some teams swear by it (they also don't do any pairing or code reviews by pulling down branches).

This isn't the first time I've heard this bit of feedback, so I think i may put together a blog post on the different styles and their uses (and limitations). But again, it's up to you and your team to figure out what works in your culture, context, and with your constraints.

gortok··on Why We Terminated Our Partnership with Microsoft
Having used all three, I was rather impressed by Octopus Deploy’s ease of use and deployment. You can set up Jenkins to do whatever you want but it’s a pain. You can also set up TeamCity to deploy, but again it’s a pain. Octopus Deploy is not a CI server, it’s a CD product. That’s Important. It specializes in deployment/delivery, and because of that it does better than Jenkins and TeamCity out of the box for deployments.
gortok··on Launch HN: Vouch (YC S19) – Business Insurance for Startups
I'm not really certain what void this is filling. As a solo-entrepreneur, it took me less than an hour all told to get Hiscox insurance. What is the competitive advantage to this? Why would I choose this over the alternative?
gortok··on The M&A Process Is Broken
So we’ll fix it by putting the non-compete in our favor and making you waive your right to a jury trial.

> Each Party hereby irrevocably waives all rights to trial by jury in any action or proceeding arising out of or relating to the provisions of this Term Sheet.

gortok··on Why is Stack Overflow trying to start audio?
As a community elected moderator (https://stackoverflow.com/users/16587 ) I can tell you with certainty that moderators have no control over ads; only the development (and maybe the community team). In this case we would do the same thing the OP did, in addition we would reach out in Stack Overflow chat to the community team do inform them of the situation.
gortok··on Chase did a bad thing, so we did a good thing
One red flag for me is that for Chase, your Credit Card number is your account number. So we're going to give third parties our credit card number... That's safe.
gortok··on [Backed Up] Freelancer.com stole from me and ruined my life
Besides Toptal (which focuses on the 'elite programming' aspect to the detriment of all else), is there a vetted platform for businesses to look for consulting agencies to do projects for them (anything 10K and up), and for independent consultants/consulting agencies to look for work? There are state run vendor boards like https://eva.virginia.gov; but I haven't seen anything comparable in the private sector.
gortok··on Ask HN: One-person SaaS apps that are profitable?
Specific software for a specific use case for college departments.
gortok··on Ask HN: One-person SaaS apps that are profitable?
I am not at liberty to say who it is but I know a one person SaaS (well, now a 4 person SaaS) that does several million a year in revenue. They found a niche and wrote software for that niche. It is the tiniest of niches but is underserved.
gortok··on Utah Bans Police from Searching Digital Data Without a Warrant, Closes Loophole
If we suddenly have a rash of police under enforcing, is that really a problem? Body cameras aren’t there to ensure police enforce the law, they’re there because power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
gortok··on My Salary Progression in Tech
Agreed (author here).

It's a really taboo subject to talk about to begin with; and there are really two extremes that you'll hear:

1. It's a meritocracy and anyone can do this! (It isn't, and they can't)

2. Yea, this will work for you but not in general. (You're probably right on this one, as my salary and my progression are very personal things).

To thread the needle, I'm trying to point out that I acknowledge #2, and explicitly reject #1 as empirically false; and I hope that by sharing my salary, I bring light to the fact that #1 is false, and that if more people who are similarly advantaged as I am talk about it, we can make #2 no longer be the case.

gortok··on My Salary Progression in Tech
It was a startup; so being VP of Software didn't feel that impressive, but thank you. I built the mobile app, firmware, the deployment pipeline for the site, etc. Since [Jewelbots was open source](https://github.com/jewelbots), everything we did was on Github. Although if you want to see the firmware, you have to dive in deeper on the Arduino side to see it (Jewelbots firmware repo itself is not in the open; though I have no special insight as to why that is).
gortok··on My Salary Progression in Tech
At least in the non SV tech companies, stock and bonuses don’t matter as much. In large companies that is different, of course; but most developers don’t work for large tech companies.
gortok··on My Salary Progression in Tech
CACI required a secret for my job; but those salaries were in line with non cleared positions, at least for that company.
gortok··on My First Year as a Solo Developer
So was this all product work or consulting + product work?
gortok··on My First Year as a Solo Developer
How did you survive if you didn’t make any money last year?
gortok··on Use DuckDuckGo to improve your privacy online (2018)
Missing features I wish DuckDuckGo had (and reasons why I manually type google.com even though I have DDG set as my default browser: - sports searches. If I search for “Washington Capitals”, I want to know when they’re playing next and what channel it’s on, as well as the results of their past game. This goes for any time I search for a sports team. - searches for dictionary terms should one-box the definition (for instance, today I looked up mortified with “mortified definition”). I should see the one-box of what I’m looking for. - one-boxing in general: stack overflow answers, definitions, calculations (feet to meters, grams to pounds, etc), sports, time zones, cities, monuments, etc.

The search results from DDG just feel “off” compared to google search. I want to like DDG and I keep attempting to use it; but it’s failing at making relevant information immediately available at my fingertips.

gortok··on Ask HN: What should an ideal developer interview process look like?
I only see two possibilities:

1. Require developers to code on demand during an interview (personally, I have a hard time with this; the pressure of an interview is not a normal working situation).

2. Allow someone to do it on their own time, under no time pressure. (I advocate paying them for their time at a fair market rate).

Do you see another way of a senior developer demonstrating their abilities without hitting either of the two above?

gortok··on Cluster and app management services in Docker Cloud are shutting down on May 21
I might; but that’d have to mean seeing some traction from that money first. They haven’t proven that they’re able to run the sort of business they’re trying to run.
gortok··on Cluster and app management services in Docker Cloud are shutting down on May 21
I’m concerned as well. We use Docker and Docker Compose heavily for our development and both on Docker for Windows and Docker for Mac developers have to restart their daemon several times a day. The binaries aren’t open so it’s tough to see and fix the issue; but because we aren’t Docker Enterprise Engine customers, there is no path to support. It would be helpful if there were a way to pay for Docker and receive support without having to go the enterprise route. I can see paying $200 a month for the team for support.
gortok··on Funding Open Source: How Webpack Reached $400k+/year
I've seen those docs. I tried implementing webpack to replace our gulp bundler (which was initially an ASP.NET Core Bundler) for an ASP.NET Core project.

Unanswered questions that I left the project with (I time-boxed myself to 4 hours; as that was the initial length of time it took me to get gulp up and running in totality):

- Why do I need a require for my CSS? I literally want to replace the css with its minified form. Maybe even bundle it together (I'd settle for the former).

- How the heck is web-pack doing all this; and why is the package called 'extract-css-loader'? I don't want to extract CSS; I want to minify it.

- If I want a source folder and a dist/ folder for my CSS; how would I get Webpack to update the URLs in the .html files?

- Am I crazy for still doing this through HTML? Is there a 'better way' ?

gortok··on Funding Open Source: How Webpack Reached $400k+/year
I had a similar issue very recently with webpack.

I was attempting to use its bundling capabilities to bundle css and js files for a web application. Believe it or not, the very simple end-user use case of bundling css is not a part of the core library, nor is it well demonstrated or explained in the docs. After a few hours, I simply gave up and continued to use gulp.

We don’t treat user time as precious because our audience is developers; yet startup developers are the people who can ill-afford to lose an afternoon to try to figure out something as demonstrably simple as bundling CSS.

gortok··on Game Engine Black Book Postmortem
Why not buy the paperback edition?

He put years into making this book, you want to read it ("love"), but you won't buy it because he wants to protect his labor of love? (Not interested in arguments why DRM is ineffectual as it has no bearing on this).

Buy the paperback. I just did. If you would really and truly "love" to read it, then buy it.

But really, is the DRM just an excuse? A reason not to part with $32 dollars? A way to virtue signal that you are appreciative of his work without actually showing that appreciation in the only way that matters?

(I didn't mean for this argument to become a larger criticism of how people act to new products and services in general; but I guess that's what it has become).

gortok··on Amazon Launchpad for Startups
Some notes:

1. Amazon Launchpad will ask for a few sample units to test. What they actually mean is that they sell these units. So, don't send Amazon units until you're ready to part with them and put them in your customer's hands.

Here's Vendor Express (their vendor management system) on that topic:

> We'll sometimes request a minimum sample of free units of your product so that we can evaluate the demand from our customers before placing an initial purchase order. After your product sells, we may start issuing purchase orders.

So, if you're a Kickstarter or Indie-go-go project and you want to sell your product on Amazon as well, you'll likely be going through Launchpad. This can get... uncomfortable for you if you send them test units before your Kickstarter backers get theirs.

2. Amazon's ToS for Vendor Express specifically states that they can rescind/change their Purchase Order at any moment before the product physically arrives at their fulfillment center. I've heard stories of startups having their P.O. reduced by half and having to eat that cost. When you're a young startup, capital is everything.

Other resources for understanding more about manufacturing costs: https://www.quora.com/How-do-I-go-about-budgeting-manufactur... http://www.andrewjdupree.com/blog/2016/8/3/how-long-does-it-...

gortok··on How Startup Options and Ownership Work
The article goes over stock options; but it doesn't address an alternate form of equity; issuing early employees restricted stock awards (instead of options).

From the receiver's point of view, Stock Options are a bad deal 99 times out of 100, let's review the cases in which owners of options get screwed:

- Company gets acquired, new terms are put into place.

- Company gets acquired, company isn't good fit.

- Company gets massive amounts of funding (those Unicorns), and due to the increasing funding at each round, those with options are left with a hefty tax bill and only 90 days to exercise if they leave

- If you have stock options and are an employee of a early stage startup, chances are you don't have the liquidity to exercise it. You're also not being paid market value (since you have stock options) If you did have the capital, you could have just invested in the seed round for a much better discount and return.

- If a company goes out of business

- if A company stays private and doesn't offer an internal market

There are only a very few cases where employees with options are taken care of:

- Company sells and ensures there are triggers in the options - Company extends exercise period

- Company goes public and employees are able to exercise their options with the tax bill that goes along with that and still make money on their shares

We have a romanticized view of options because Google, Microsoft, Apple, Twitter, Facebook, and a handful of other companies have hit the bigtime; but that's the huge exception, not the rule, and yet we allow companies to treat options as equal to salary, and they're not.

I know companies face reporting requirements if they have more than 50 shareholders; but the earliest employees should be compensated in a way that respects their sacrifice and risk; and options don't do that. At best, options are a placebo.

← PreviousPage 8 of 10Next →