HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gotostatement

419 karma · joined April 18, 2020

submissionscomments
gotostatement··on Show HN: Sell.app – A simple way to sell digital goods
hmmm, I feel like that is "user-hostile", might not be a great idea for a nascent service. I think that if you're starting a new service you would want to pump it up, make every user feel awesome so they keep using it. you can incentivize upgrade with a carrot without punishing free with a stick. i.e. maybe a "premium" badge only, not the "free" badge. I dont anticipate anyone will be happy that their cheapness is being advertised
gotostatement··on Show HN: Sell.app – A simple way to sell digital goods
whats the purpose of showing "Free store" - why would a customer care about that, and why would a seller be okay with that?
gotostatement··on Launch HN: Payflow (YC S21) – Allow workers to access their wages instantly
> It might seem attractive initially, but within a few months the status quo will have reset and those employees who were living paycheck to paycheck will still be living paycheck to paycheck, just now it will be day by day waiting for their accrued amount to increase.

Except now they have money available to them in realtime, continuously according to the work they've put in, without having to wait for discrete points in time where their bank account refills.

> This unexpected expenses thing sounds like poor justification to me.

The fact that people use it shows people want it. The paternalism towards people who don't have enough money is really staggering. This line of argumentation reeks of "Poor people cant manage their finances - they dont know whats good to them"

> And charging the company Vs the employee is no different. If you didn't charge the company they could instead increase the wages of their staff by the equivalent amount. You are just taking money out of the potential pot that goes to the staff. Staff costs is just a single line on our summary p&l which includes salaries and benefits.

Salaries have other pressures maintaining them besides available funds for salary, like minimum wage and market rates. As we have known for years based on the utter failure of "trickle-down economics", salaries paid and available funds often have little to do with one-another.

gotostatement··on Launch HN: Payflow (YC S21) – Allow workers to access their wages instantly
>And the proposed solution doesn't fix that. Most of those people don't have a problem with unexpected expense once a year. They don't budget and are short on cash every month. So now imagine Bob needs money halfway through the month. He takes out 50% of his pay. He uses is for immediate needs and than has to live at 50% of his pay for the next 1.5 month.

This is extremely paternalistic and shows how little you automatically think of someone who isn't paid a lot of money. You think that people who don't have money, their problem must be budgeting ("stop eating all that avocado toast!!"), so you need to slowly ration out their money "for their own good." Complete ideological BS.

gotostatement··on How many real numbers exist? New proof moves closer to an answer
I guess you could rephrase OP's argument in a sound way as: a set is countable if there's a way to order it such that between every two numbers there are finitely many numbers
gotostatement··on Risk Assessment of GitHub Copilot
its worth noting that, in the article, the author explains that the moon phase function produced by copilot was actually incorrect
gotostatement··on The scientists hired by big oil who predicted the climate crisis long ago
the responses to this comment are the guy in the comic responding to "we should improve society somewhat" with "yet you participate in society. curious"
gotostatement··on Change.org workers form a union
I'm not saying necessarily it was unfair, I'm saying that unionizing can only make it more fair - there's no downside to unionizing.
gotostatement··on Change.org workers form a union
okay.. then unionizing and negotiating will reach a fair agreement. I dont understand how this is remotely an argument against unionizing.
gotostatement··on GitHub Copilot as open source code laundering?
Upvoted. I think the only good use case for this is spitting out 10-line, annoying, commonly used API boilerplate for commonly used APIs
gotostatement··on This Chemical Does Not Exist
its what plants crave!
gotostatement··on Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on municipal broadband
I think you'll struggle with a network effect issue. people aren't already on it - and already have plenty of places to discuss politics - so people won't come on the site and so people won't really care about the points they get on it
gotostatement··on Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on municipal broadband
my point is that since people don't care it might be hard to get people to use the site. And you might have trouble getting enough people to use it in the first place to get these discussions going - why wouldn't they just do it on reddit or twitter where everyone already is?
gotostatement··on Ohio Republicans close to imposing near-total ban on municipal broadband
the problem with this is that I think few people care enough to enter their preferences, let alone to come back and check. not to mention that most people don't really expect politicians to follow through on their promises, and anyone who does will probably figure out how they want to vote via other methods. the only way I see this idea actually becoming useful is if it starts being displayed somewhere people already go, like in a google results page
gotostatement··on Biggest health insurer plans to deny ER bills if it doubts you had an emergency
None of what you're saying has anything to do with the issue. The situation is that UHC is posting record profits but they are trying to implement a cost-cutting policy that will punish patients who make the "mistake" of not retroactively knowing their symptoms did not represent an emergency. All your points are about unscrupulous doctors but this policy punishes the patients, not the doctors.
gotostatement··on Biggest health insurer plans to deny ER bills if it doubts you had an emergency
this has been going on since before COVID https://www.fiercehealthcare.com/payer/big-name-payers-earne...

In particular see the chart that shows 2018 and 2019 profits

gotostatement··on Biggest health insurer plans to deny ER bills if it doubts you had an emergency
Be that as it may, this is not a decision made due to financial pressure on the insurance companies.

"UHC’s parent company UnitedHealth Group posted a 35 percent year-over-year jump in operating profits in the first quarter of 2021. Despite earning $6.7 billion in a single quarter, UHC enrollees are being asked to pay more for their coverage."

gotostatement··on Biggest health insurer plans to deny ER bills if it doubts you had an emergency
the insurance companies have posted record profits. They're not having money trouble

"UHC’s parent company UnitedHealth Group posted a 35 percent year-over-year jump in operating profits in the first quarter of 2021"

gotostatement··on Biggest health insurer plans to deny ER bills if it doubts you had an emergency
The company claims this is cost-cutting: "Unnecessary use of the emergency room costs nearly $32 billion annually, driving up healthcare costs for everyone. We are taking steps to make care more affordable"

But: "UHC’s parent company UnitedHealth Group posted a 35 percent year-over-year jump in operating profits in the first quarter of 2021. Despite earning $6.7 billion in a single quarter, UHC enrollees are being asked to pay more for their coverage."

The greediest, most depraved people in the country are responsible for keeping us healthy.

gotostatement··on Google removes its head of diversity after 2007 blog post surfaces
it makes me sick to see everyone thinking that this is proof of cancel culture - LOOK THE DIVERSITY GUY WAS HOISTED BY HIS OWN DIVERSITY PETARD!

NO. The people calling for this are not progressives - look them up - Simon Wiesenthal Center and Stop Antisemitism are conservative zionist organizations who equate anti-zionism with anti-semitism. As far as I can tell Kamau Bobb's post was anti-zionist, NOT anti-semitic at all. If you read the passages you will see.

This is a cancellation by the original proponents of cancellation: conservatives supporting an entrenched power structure.

gotostatement··on Court rules climate change “duty of care” to future generations exists
interesting thanks for writing this out
gotostatement··on Court rules climate change “duty of care” to future generations exists
it seems like its a pragmatic question, almost an engineering question about how the legal system can work, and Im hopelessly out of my depth there
gotostatement··on Court rules climate change “duty of care” to future generations exists
wouldn't a philosophical/legal framework like "reckless endangerment" apply here? there's a line at which harm to future generations becomes reckless
gotostatement··on New Snap Spectacles Feature Augmented Reality Display
lol only on hacker news would this statement be controversial
gotostatement··on New Snap Spectacles Feature Augmented Reality Display
sounds dangerous to wear AR glasses while driving
gotostatement··on Machine Learning Is a Marvelously Executed Scam
exactly. Im not saying ML should be used in more places. I'm saying that there's almost never a real need for it, despite how hyped it can be and how cool the math/algorithms are in theory
gotostatement··on Machine Learning Is a Marvelously Executed Scam
for me its not that ML is uniquely inherently bad, its more that I was really excited about its applications but realized that, in practice, it's usually pretty simple algorithms, and the more complicated applications dont have much direct application to socially positive stuff. prove me wrong!
gotostatement··on Machine Learning Is a Marvelously Executed Scam
I'm not saying every application is bad. It's just that most of the positive applications seem to mostly be data aggregation and cleaning problems, not hard ML problems. Most of the time it's really a simple algorithm with a lot of good data that you need, there's not much interesting work to do besides plugging things together
gotostatement··on Machine Learning Is a Marvelously Executed Scam
I came out of college super excited about machine learning because the math was so interesting and there was a sense of boundless utility and applicability. I came to realize that, at least in industry, the utility is mostly ad targeting and other stuff that doesn't really matter, and other than that ML is mostly overpowered for the task. There is not much socially positive application of machine learning, mostly socially neutral or negative. Some positive, sure, like there's some in medicine, but my understanding is the hardness there is not algorithmic.
gotostatement··on Nextdoor will alert users if it thinks they’re about to post something racist
The point in saying "race is a socially constructed category" is to counter the ideology that says that "race is a meaningful categorization of people" and, in particular, "it says meaningful things about people's nature and abilities." While ethnicity does pass along, the traits that it carries with it are so scattered and superficial that it's not meaningful in most contexts to categorize people as such, genetically speaking (though of course they can become unified by how they are treated in society).

Analogy: having brown hair is a genetic trait. But it wouldn't make sense if we categorized people as "brown-hairs" because it's just not a meaningful category that says anything much about anything except the color of their hair.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →