HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gottorf

2,754 karma · joined June 30, 2023

submissionscomments
gottorf··on Peopleless economy? Not technically impossible
More people will suffer and die over the next 50-100 years from efforts to counteract climate change than from climate change itself.
gottorf··on The computer science degree isn’t dead
> Alarming doesn’t begin to describe it. This is an existential crises for our industry.

In my (admittedly vibes-based) opinion, this is just a result of there being a huge supply of CS grads in this country due to it being popularized as a path to a stable, high-paying job. Those degrees are now more often than ever held by people who aren't necessarily passionate about, or good at, the field.

The signal-to-noise ratio in hiring, therefore, is worse than ever. AI exacerbates the problem, of course. But I don't think this is an existential crisis; I think the market will sort itself out, as those less-qualified entrants leave.

gottorf··on A Farmer Donated Land to Turn into a Park. The City Is Building a Data Center
> the Supreme Court case where they found standing

> nobody had actually asked for one and the person didn't even make wedding web sites

> There was no actual case

303 Creative v. Elenis started out because the web designer sought injunctive relief from a Colorado state law that would have made her unable to refuse to make a website for a same-sex wedding. She had received a request to make a wedding website (for a heterosexual couple), and preemptively wanted to preserve her right to refuse in light of the Colorado law and to put up a public-facing notice stating as much. The case was appealed all the way up to the Supreme Court by the designer herself.

It doesn't read to me that any standing was "invented" here. Notably, the dissent in this 6-3 decision does not discuss standing at all; and in fact, the Tenth Circuit that decided against the designer (prior to the SC appeal) did find that she had standing.

It sounds like you have your own personal gripes with this decision, which is fair, but an attack on the grounds that there was no standing is misguided.

gottorf··on A walking tour of surveillance infrastructure in Seattle (2020)
> conservatives eat up the dehumanization of it all

One could argue that's really dehumanizing is the callous disregard the system displays for the victims of such repeat violent offenders.

gottorf··on The UK government's Low Value Purchase System is a waste of time
> pressure the representatives

In the GP's case, it sounds like they were on a road show, and they do not live in Illinois at all. Of course, that doesn't prevent them from contacting a IL state representative for redress, but it is an edge case of sorts.

gottorf··on Uber’s COO says it’s getting harder to justify money spent on tokenmaxxing
Considering the IRS mileage rate is 72.5 cents per mile, sounds like there's no way any kind of vehicle is going to get operating costs that low!
gottorf··on Everyone Against Us (2023)
> For one, when someone should not be remanded on bail because they are a danger to society, judges will often set the bail at eleventy zillion dollars, knowing that they won't be able to post bail

Why can't they just deny bail in such cases? Is it local laws that forbid them from doing so? In which case, it seems that the ability to set a ridiculously high bail is a net benefit to society.

gottorf··on Microsoft pulls plug on plans for 244-acre data center in Caledonia (2025)
> The assumption that all these people are stupid sheep probably won't be a productive way to approach this public policy question

I agree, and I do not assume that these people are stupid sheep. However, having said that:

> Data centers absolutely are loud

Compared to undeveloped land, sure. Compared to other uses of industrially-zoned land? Most likely not. I've been to a lot of datacenters. They're not very loud from the outside.

> They consume large quantities of water

I honestly do not understand why they don't just build closed-loop systems, or geothermal where they have a closed loop with the ground acting as the heat sink. Open-loop systems where they consume water just to evaporate sounds stupid to me. But I don't know how common that is.

Politicians showing off in front of the camera with a dirty jug of water, of course, is just grandstanding and has no real relation to datacenters other than they made construction happen.

> huge, absolutely staggering amounts of energy, which typically has the effect of raising rates for everybody else

This isn't just true of datacenters. They're building an aluminum plant near me that will consume on the order of 100+ MW, which is comparable to a fairly large DC. Any other large industrial plant would consume a lot of electricity, but nobody's blaming them for utility capital investment needs.

gottorf··on A successful Japanese trial of a ramjet engine designed for Mach‑5 aircraft
> Dubai to SFO is also a possible route

Is there really that much premium traffic between Dubai and the Bay Area?

gottorf··on Microsoft pulls plug on plans for 244-acre data center in Caledonia (2025)
> The ratio of jobs and taxes to local resources tied up has to be one of the worst possible trade-offs of any industrial use that you can envision

Why? There aren't much "local resources tied up" since it's land that isn't that valuable for the most part. DCs, once built, don't emit fumes or loud noises, or make traffic worse like other industrial land use might. They just sit there quietly and generate tax revenue for the locality.

Sure, there aren't many ongoing jobs at an operating DC. But I can't see why it's one of the worst possible industrial uses, from the point of view of the residents around one.

> data centers are proving to be profoundly unpopular

From what I can tell, this is just from a combination of AI being unpopular plus opportunistic fearmongering on the part of politicians.

gottorf··on Microsoft pulls plug on plans for 244-acre data center in Caledonia (2025)
They're called hyperscalers for a reason.
gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
> Most Hispanic families and cultures are overwhelmingly socially conservative leaning.

The idea that Hispanics and other ethnic minorities would vote Democratic was so popular that people wrote a whole book about it[0], until the idea was finally put to bed with Trump's electoral gain among every nonwhite group between 2016 and 2024.

Until then, the broad demographic makeup of the illegal crossings during Biden's years would absolutely have been assumed to lean Democratic.

> In addition, non-citizens cannot vote in federal elections.

Noncitizens count for Congressional apportionment, and as GP said, there is the implicit understanding that at least some of those noncitizens will become citizens in the future and vote for the party that facilitated their arrival into this country.

[0]: The Emerging Democratic Majority, 2002.

gottorf··on Why Japanese companies do so many different things
It's a very meaningful statement when people claim that thing X's purpose is Y which is good, and therefore thing X is good, even though the actual outcome Z is not Y and in fact may be diametrically opposed to Y. Happens quite often.

I don't know if it really applies to the current thread, but I just wanted to point out that POSIWID is certainly not a vapid, empty concept.

gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
The "birthright" citizenship clause of the 14th amendment was intended to clarify the citizenship status of the recently freed black slaves. That intent is clear by contemporary written material.

Now, you could absolutely argue that whatever the intent of the amendment was, it still protects the present-day state of Chinese mothers having zero ties to this country popping over for a few months and giving birth to a fully-fledged American citizen, because the law says what it says. That's a much better argument than saying that the Civil War was fought for the right of transient visitors or illegal immigrants to this country to birth citizens, because that's just absurd.

gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
> Plenty of studies have made very clear that immigrants contribute more to the community and the nation, and have lower rates of crime, than people born in the country.

You should distinguish between the American model of immigration, which has long been the beneficiary of positive selection effects until recently, against the European model (which seems to be more relevant to the GP), which unfortunately seems to have been designed for the exact opposite.

It's trivially easy to find research from Europe that consistently shows immigrants and descendants of immigrants as having higher rates of criminality than the native population. Even a pro-refugee source has to admit that immigrants in Denmark commit crimes at a level 2-3x higher[0].

And taking a step back, your statement on immigrants contributing more than the native population is absurd on its face. Why are immigrants immigrating to begin with? To seek a better life. Who made a better life possible on the other side of the fence? The native population. The degree to which immigrants, especially to the US, outperform the native population, you're just looking at the aforementioned selection effects; you're comparing the cream of the crop of one group to the median of another.

[0]: https://refugeeswelcome.dk/en/information/focus/crime-among-...

gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
Do you think the Biden-admin immigration shenanigans (2M illegal crossings a year, "temporary" protected status, CBP One, etc.) weren't predominantly aimed at a group of people who were deemed to be more likely to vote Democratic?
gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
> Without immigration, the US would have negative population growth, which is economically probably a disaster.

Nobody knows what the population growth rate would be without immigration. The two are interlinked; ceteris is not paribus.

> We already have shortages in farming, construction and health care labor, which are often populated by immigrants. So overall, we’d have more unfilled positions, which would result in higher prices, etc.

Letting the price of labor in those industries find natural market equilibrium is fine. For agriculture especially, labor is a pretty small part of a product's final cost, anyway.

> Native born Americans just don’t seem to want those jobs.

The price of labor aside, have you ever worked a job where you're surrounded by an ethnic clique? I don't blame anyone for not wanting that.

gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
That America was founded as an economic zone open to all seems more ahistoric. The phrase "ourselves and our Posterity" appears in the first sentence of the Constitution. And you cannot deny that the founders were in fact white Christians[0].

Look, I'm a visibly nonwhite immigrant. I am proud to be a naturalized American and have renounced all legal ties to the country of my birth. I think dual citizenship is at best weird, and I honestly don't understand how one squares that against the oath of allegiance. I believe the onus is upon the immigrant to assimilate, and that America is a rare place where that is in fact possible. I have no desire to recreate the country of my birth in America, especially not in a segregated ethnic enclave.

I would like to live in a colorblind America and, though it may sound implausible to you, I believe the American right has the better claim to that future than the left. I do not empathize more with potential immigrants from my ethnic background than I do with my fellow Americans, and I quite dislike it when those from the left automatically assume the former, because it means they are treating me as being fundamentally different than any other American. And I think this mindset is table stakes for any immigrant to any nation.

Much of the West has seen levels of immigration over the past few decades beyond the capacity of the native population to absorb in a way that results in assimilation. It has increasingly been from cultures that are substantially different, further hampering that effort. It's disconcerting to see that any efforts to pump the brakes even a little bit immediately results in accusations of racism or fascism.

[0]: I don't want to split hairs over 18th-century Deism. All of that was contained within the Christian cultural framework, anyway.

gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
To be fair, not many parts of the US higher education system can be accurately described as free markets or capitalism.
gottorf··on Green card seekers must leave U.S. to apply, Trump administration says
> They may have incurred unlawful presence

> The cruelty is indeed the point

What's the difference between this and just outright saying that enforcing the law is cruelty? After all, nobody enjoys being punished, even if it's for breaking the law.

I don't want people to be unlawfully present in my country. Enough people desired that same outcome that, through the democratic process, we have laws controlling immigration. There has to be consequences for breaking that law. It absolutely cannot be the case that anyone can break the law and then have it not matter on the grounds that to make it matter would be cruel. What even is the point of the rule of law?

gottorf··on Greg Brockman interview [video]
> Western countries have been utterly strangled by nonprofits

To expand, there are two major problems with nonprofits in Western nations these days:

1. Governments use them as a way to do things that they themselves are not allowed to do ("it's private charities that do this!", ignoring the fact that the charities get >90% of their revenue from government grants)

2. Like you mentioned, the government grants to nonprofit back to politicians' campaign funds pipeline. Utterly egregious.

> Obama even expanded the rules in the US to allow the government to unconstitutionally fund religious groups to accomplish functions that belong in government

I wasn't aware of this being a big concern; more the other way around, like in my point 1.

gottorf··on Microsoft starts canceling Claude Code licenses
American software engineers are paid commensurately more than equivalent roles in countries with strong worker rights. There is no free lunch.

Besides, it's probably counterproductive in the long run to think of strong worker rights as being opposed to the employer wanting higher productivity out of the worker.

gottorf··on The FBI Wants 'Near Real-Time' Access to US License Plate Readers
> Maybe having just one euro/asian-style dense city with bike lanes in the US wouldn't be such a bad thing to try out?

What do you call Manhattan? It would count among the ~10 most dense cities proper in the world.

gottorf··on Utah lawmakers form united front in push to ban prediction markets
> This is real close to just “poor people deserve to be poor”

No, I'm saying that there are reasons why some people stay poor. My further implication is that it isn't for the most part because society is keeping them down.

> Your investment math also seems pretty far off. Those numbers appear to assume a 15% return from the S&P 500, a number I’ve never heard a financial advisor recommend.

It was based on an initial $100 investment followed by a monthly $200 investment into the S&P 500 (as an alternative destination for the $2500/year claimed by that study that some high spenders put that much into the lottery) applied over the actual past 10 years of performance[0].

Prudent financial advisors would of course tell you not to count on 15% CAGR forever, but my example was based on real results that anyone could have obtained by consistently buying boring index funds instead of lottery tickets! There's no trickery here.

> that means there are a lot of poor non-ticket-buying households in order for the numbers to work out. Why are those people poor?

In discussions about the poor, we all should distinguish between those who happen to be poor at any given moment, and those who are poor their whole lives, or even over generations. My comments about the character traits of the poor only apply to the latter.

[0]: https://testfol.io/

gottorf··on Enough with the AI FOMO, go slow-mo, says Domo CDO
Would you trust your private files to a Claude-generated Dropbox/syncthing clone?
gottorf··on Actually, democracy dies in H.R.
> clever and lazy at the very top? I don't get it.

Being clever and lazy forces you to determine what should not be done, as opposed to just doing everything because you can because you're clever and industrious.

As you climb higher and higher in decision-making, it becomes clear that the things you say no to at some point becomes more important than the things you say yes to.

gottorf··on Utah lawmakers form united front in push to ban prediction markets
> it’s really hard to climb out of poverty. It’s a function of opportunity, culture, society, and a lot more stuff

I agree with you, but perhaps from the other direction. I think American society in particular gives an amazing amount of opportunity for people to climb out of poverty, or at least we used to, before we started "replacing what works with what sounded good". But we still do, for the most part.

Most of the cultural and social factors that prevent someone from lifting themselves up are self-imposed by those individual cultures and societies, and as of late, it's become verboten to call them out on it. There exist subgroups in this country where you'd indeed have to be a truly remarkable individual to claw yourself out of it into wealth. However, it doesn't have to be that way; that's a choice society made, on what grounds exactly I'm not sure, but the choice was made nevertheless.

gottorf··on Utah lawmakers form united front in push to ban prediction markets
Are we disagreeing about the definition of "poor people"? I'm not sure why someone would find it so hard to believe that the poor, especially the long-term poor, have character traits that are not conducive to lifting themselves out of poverty.

On that same vein, there is no particular evidence needed to convince someone that people who share the characteristics with me of not being very tall or particularly athletic have a terribly poor chance of making it in the NBA.

But here is one study[0] which found, interestingly, that although a higher time preference (that is, preferring the present over the future) is correlated as expected with wealth, it is not significantly correlated with current income. Put another way: in the modern world where opportunities are varied, anyone, even people with poor impulse control and high time preference, could earn high incomes, but you only become wealthy (i.e. escape poverty) over time through putting aside some of that income to save and invest.

Back to the American setting, "heavy hitters" of the lottery spend about $2500/yr[1]. If you instead put $200/mo into the S&P 500 over ten years, you'd be sitting on over $55k. Time under the curve matters greatly. The same personality traits that make someone prefer buying scratchers instead of investing for their future are the ones that keep them poor. I would have thought this to be self-evident.

[0]: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7392281/

[1]: https://elmwealth.com/lottery-fallacy/

gottorf··on Utah lawmakers form united front in push to ban prediction markets
It's more that poor people have worse impulse control and higher time preference[0], which contribute to the behavioral outcome of spending money on lottery tickets despite the EV being negative.

[0]: If we're splitting hairs, we should specify that having poor impulse control and higher time preference are the base causational factors that make it more likely for someone to be poor, buy lottery tickets, engage in criminality, etc. etc.

gottorf··on Utah lawmakers form united front in push to ban prediction markets
Funny, someone cheated a temperature-related bet a few weeks ago: https://www.npr.org/2026/04/23/nx-s1-5797876/polymarket-pari...
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →