HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gottorf

2,754 karma · joined June 30, 2023

submissionscomments
gottorf··on Utah lawmakers form united front in push to ban prediction markets
> Gambling is considered bad, and banned in many states, but many of those states run a lottery. This is just a straight up theft from the poor who are least well equipped to understand they are playing a rigged game, and not rigged in their favor

I think gambling is almost a natural instinct in humans, and a state-run lottery may be a relief valve for that itch to be scratched in a controlled manner.

gottorf··on Utah lawmakers form united front in push to ban prediction markets
> I'm still not sure if banning this activity counts as freedom. I believe that grown consenting adults do have a free will and should have the ability to destroy their lives if they so choose

America is the land of the free, but I think there have been and will continue to be reasonable disagreements on the question of, free to do what? It's evident that "freedom" isn't a pure, unrestricted thing in the anarchist sense. We all agree that through the democratic process, laws can be made to declare some things not free to be done.

And to the degree that various taxpayer-funded social programs exist, the cost of grown consenting adults destroying their own lives are directly borne by the rest of us.

> but outright banning prediction markets and casinos is definitely not the right one

In general, I think a gradual "ban" in the form of taxation is often times better, especially for things that society is trying to discourage out of its sinful or destructive nature; think cigarettes.

gottorf··on I want to live like Costco people
> Costco is for bulk staples and commodities for me

> Milk, eggs, flour, flowers, microfiber towels, batteries, salt and pepper

If you can walk out of Costco month after month with just those essentials, and never pick up any of the nice-looking and reasonably-priced goodies there, I think it's safe to say that you have the level of discipline required to be financially successful and not have to care about whether you're getting the best price per unit of whatever it is you're buying. :-)

gottorf··on I want to live like Costco people
No, you are not out of touch. Functionally everyone can afford a Costco membership and buy staples in bulk at a higher upfront but lower unit costs. The GP's comment about a family of four walking miles to a Little League game because they couldn't afford the bus fare is an extreme outlier.

There's a large overlap between people who cannot "afford" to shop at Costco and people who spend hundreds of dollars a month on scratch-offs. Whether or not someone shops at Costco is mostly a function of preferences and behavioral choices, not dollars.

gottorf··on Singapore introduces caning for boys who bully others at school
Applying physical force to counter in the moment someone that tries to rob you is not vigilante justice. That would be more like if you had your phone robbed, and a few days later you went with your buddies to beat him up and get your phone back.

The former is just maintenance of basic civic standards.

gottorf··on Singapore introduces caning for boys who bully others at school
Putting your different points together:

> piles of research showing that severity of punishment is not an effective deterrent

> not think of consequences

> Deterrence means a lot less when you don't have to worry about recidivism because the person is dead

Sounds like (in general, not talking about minors) when you execute the people who for whatever reason cannot think far enough ahead for punishment to be an effective deterrent, you eventually will be left with people who are able to do that, who will comprise a less criminal society.

gottorf··on Singapore introduces caning for boys who bully others at school
> Every advanced economy in the world except for the United States has a well developed social safety net

The United States has a very well-developed social safety net, despite what Reddit likes to claim. It spends a ton of money making sure the poor are fed, housed, and clothed. There exist literal generations of people who have lived on the public dole.

gottorf··on The Disappearance of the Public Bench
> arresting people for the crime of not having money

Such people are not arrested for not having money, but instead for being a pox upon the public by virtue of their behavior.

gottorf··on It's OK to abandon your side-project (2024)
https://www.handwrytten.com/

I guess it depends on your definition of "handwritten"; they're actually robotically written, so no actual human hands are involved.

gottorf··on It's OK to abandon your side-project (2024)
I'm aware of at least one business that does this already.
gottorf··on George Orwell Predicted the Rise of "AI Slop" in Nineteen Eighty-Four
It's a fun quote. On the other hand, while no one should accuse Rand of being a good writer of fiction, I don't find what's depicted in Atlas Shrugged all that fantastical.
gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> the expectations of employers of having a college degree for even basic stuff

This is mostly an unintentional side-effect of civil rights law, stemming from Griggs v. Duke Power Co.

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> as non-profits, the revenues and expenditures of higher ed have to balance; they can't take out surplus revenue as profit.

Just pointing out that nonprofits do not have to balance revenues and expenditures at all. This is not a mere technical detail. Profit cannot inure to owners with nonprofits as it can with for-profits, but this does not prevent the organization from building up a surplus over time, nor does it prevent them from paying employees very handsomely. Otherwise it wouldn't be possible to have almost one hundred universities with endowments over a billion dollars.

> my argument that the rhetoric and public discussion of massive tuition increases is not supported by the data when using actual tuition paid rather than nameplate/MSRP prices

That's fair, but I suppose there's more to it than that. Any number of datasets point to the cost of admin rising far above the cost of faculty or maintenance; and a lot of them actually show on an inflation-adjusted basis that schools are spending less now on instruction than they did a decade or two ago. So perhaps there's enough truth to the idea that you're getting substantially less education per dollar than you used to.

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> Under simplifying assumptions, including competitive labor markets, no direct schooling costs, and constant proportional returns, this specification yields an interpretable estimate of the average percentage increase in earnings associated with an additional year of schooling.

So, an individual student will be expected to have higher earnings with more schooling. But as a matter of public policy that involves taxpayer funding of higher education, I cannot accurately base those decisions on a methodology that assumes a cost of zero ("no direct schooling costs").

Your source also identifies that higher marginal returns are found in lower-income, lower-educated countries, which makes sense. How much marginal return (for the taxpayer dollar) can we expect in a high-income country with a service-based economy and a third of the population already having a bachelor's degree?

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
My comment was on the price of higher ed, not its cost, which is what your ed.gov source shows.

CPI component calculations done by the BLS shows "College tuition and fees", including adjustments for scholarships and grants, had a 63% increase from 2009 (to match the CB data baseline) to now, which outpaces overall inflation of 56% over the same timeframe. I'm not sure what methodology CB uses to show falling inflation-adjusted prices.

Granted, it's not a massive difference in those percentages[0], but because college is a large single-ticket item, that difference is probably felt more acutely.

> Room and board has gone up, but that is broadly true in college towns generally, and is not in the control of the Universities

In many places the local university is the largest landowner in town, and is tax-exempt to boot. They might hold some of the blame in those costs.

[0]: As an aside, it's incredible that everyone half of their purchasing power in ~15 years, and a quarter in just the past 5 years alone.

gottorf··on New Orleans's Car-Crash Conspiracy
We must be talking at odds here. I'm neither claiming that being ethical is a sufficient condition to getting rich, nor that the ethics of the poor people described in the article played a significant part in their being and remaining poor. The article seems replete with unethical behavior at every level of wealth.

> the American shift from “a hard day’s work for fair pay” to what I’m calling the lottery economy

My point is that people with high time preference and low impulse control, who naturally will tend to be poorer than people without those traits, will also naturally be more drawn to the "lottery economy", whether or not bad actors exist who will take advantage of that. Just look at who buys literal lottery tickets!

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> I don't think linking to a conservative think tank a particularly compelling counterargument

Do you only ingest ideas from places that you're already inclined to believe? How do you get challenges to your beliefs?

> is inequality high and getting higher? Then the tax system should be more progressive.

> Some amount of inequality is healthy.

What amount of inequality is just right, then? On one hand you suggest that we should redistribute to lower inequality, but on the other you seem to see some kind of beneficial role, or at least a neutral role, of inequality in a society.

> The top 10% owning 80% of all wealth in the US is not.

Countries as diverse as Sweden, the Philippines, and Nigeria all have worse inequality in wealth than the US[0]. On the other end, countries like Iceland, Myanmar, and Turkmenistan have similarly low wealth inequality. I might posit that wealth inequality doesn't even make the top 10 of what makes a health society that's nice to live in.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_by_we...

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
Have you observed a lot of critical thinking and good communication from recent college grads?
gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> Europe is evidently constitutionally incapable of taking advantage of what is a genuinely one-in-an-imperial-lifetime chance to drain intellectual capital from the United States

Perhaps you're already implying this, but for Europe to drain intellectual capital from the US, it would have to offer a hell of a lot more than cheap college for foreign students.

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
I don't know if "regulation" is the right word. In the end, what happened was that the foremost power in the world, the US federal government, having observed that college grads earn more than non-college grads, flipped cause and effect on its head and decided that everyone must go to college for better life outcomes. A tremendous amount of time, money, and resources went into making that happen.

Against this backdrop, there was no world in which the price of higher education wasn't going to go dramatically up.

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> which would you choose? The ones you're more-inclined to choose are the better ones

Funny how despite all that, more people choose to come to the US from those "mature" societies than the other way around.

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> The primary goal for attending college, as stated by both students and parents, is for preparation for entrance into the workforce and adult life.

Let's observe revealed preferences, not stated ones.

> One can go to the engineering or computer science building in almost any U.S. or Canadian university and observe a student population that doesn't party on a regular basis.

This is a small fraction of the total college population.

Most people in college are only there because it's the default next step after high school. In fact, a lot of people in graduate school are only there because it's the default next step after a bachelor's degree.

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
I think the notion that's being challenged is that a college degree is an automatic way out of "dad who’s out the door at 5am and home at 7pm", no matter what the degree is for and who is getting the degree; or that being credentialed and unemployed is better than that.
gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
"Everyone" is hyperbole, of course. But it's already too high a number.
gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> Higher education improves society as a whole. It should be paid for from general taxation, and available to all

> A couple of generations ago these were uncontroversial statements

I don't believe those strong assertions you're making were uncontroversial at any time, and are likely objectively less true now than they were in the past.

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> Strange how I never see this line deployed against the mortgage interest deduction or health care for wealthy retirees

For what it's worth, I see arguments like this all the time. Might just be the corner of the information ecosystem you hang out in.

> Subsidizing college education, at least, has a reliably positive ROI.

Maybe it did in the past, where the greatest marginal gains were. Does it still hold true now? Over a third of the US has a bachelor's degree. Is there a reliably positive ROI to society in taking that third to, say, half?

gottorf··on The looming college-enrollment death spiral
> Maybe college never should have been for everyone? That was the norm for the vast majority of the existence of higher education.

This is the only real answer.

gottorf··on When AI Trading Works, You Won't Hear About It
When any kind of trading "works", meaning it generates alpha above and beyond the market, you won't hear about it. Why would anybody give away their secret sauce?
gottorf··on In Denmark, the spread of solar panels has become a divisive issue
> But they did get a big warning shot in 1989 and 2011, and ignored those lessons for cost reasons.

Cost is always a valid reason!

> A couple hundred people died.

Looks like about a thousand people in the US die of hypothermia every year, on average. So this happens frequently in states that aren't in its own interconnection, too.

gottorf··on New Orleans's Car-Crash Conspiracy
I'm talking about traits like high time preference and poor impulse control.

Ethics make people live in poverty? That would be news to a lot of people.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →