HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gouggoug

2,324 karma · joined February 1, 2012

SRE
submissionscomments
gouggoug··on Seedbox Lite: A lightweight torrent streaming app with instant playback
The original statement is not just "we do not facilitate copyright infringement". It has a whole lot of other words.

If your original comment is solely about this revised 6 words statement, then, yes, you are correct, the claim is objectively untrue.

I'm no mind reader though, I assumed you were talking about the whole thing ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.

gouggoug··on Seedbox Lite: A lightweight torrent streaming app with instant playback
TL;DR: I am nitpicking on the use of "objectively untrue" and the implication this disclaimer serves no purpose.

> The creators knew that when they wrote that disclaimer and we all know that reading the disclaimer.

This is the idea I'm pushing back against.

Yes, you are very likely correct in your assessment that the creators know that their software will be used illegally.

No, you are incorrect, in saying this is 1- "objectively untrue" and 2- implying the statement might _not_ have some protective qualities.

To take a purposefully exaggerated analogy: you can believe all day long someone committed murder, it still doesn't make it true. You can argue all day long the authors aren't being truthful, it still doesn't make it true.

> Yet the disclaimer is still placed there like it has some reason for existing beyond allowing everyone to pretend something that is happening isn’t happening

I'd agree with this, and, add that, at the same time, (assuming the USA here) it's probably placed there for legal reasons (whether it factually matters legally or not is a question for an actual lawyer, which, objectively, I am not).

> I’m just remarking on the silliness of the disclaimer.

It feels a bit silly, yes, and at the same time... needed?

gouggoug··on Seedbox Lite: A lightweight torrent streaming app with instant playback
I think it's fair to say that the software itself could/does facilitate illegal uses cases. But with that line of argumentation, then all software facilitates illegal use-cases just by existing.

The statement "We do not endorse, promote, or facilitate copyright infringement, illegal streaming, or piracy in any form", might be poorly written with regards to the fact that just by existing this torrent streaming program _does_ facilitate piracy, but I don't think this was your original argument.

gouggoug··on Seedbox Lite: A lightweight torrent streaming app with instant playback
Torrented material is not necessarily copyrighted material.

It's not unlawful to use bittorent.

gouggoug··on Seedbox Lite: A lightweight torrent streaming app with instant playback
> "Who cares if the words are objectively untrue? We have plausible deniability now that we said them!"

But they are not "objectively untrue". You can argue all day long that you don't believe the author are being truthful, it doesn't make it true.

edit: that being said, in juxtaposition with a copyrighted Marvel image, I could see it being used in court against the author to prove they were all along catering to piracy.

edit2: clearly, I'm not a lawyer

gouggoug··on How I use my terminal
It's also interesting to see that the author themselves are clearly fighting against their own instinct to use uppercase: the first 2 items in the "here's what happens in that video:" list use uppercase.
gouggoug··on All BART trains were stopped due to ‘computer networking problem’
> There was a loud explosion earlier this morning, which may or may not be related, but there aren't any power outages.

Loud explosions happen all the time in SF. Particularly in the Lower Nob Hill / Tenderloin area.

I lived an Lower Nob Hill for many years and heard countless explosions, most often in the middle of the night (2am-4am) or early hours (6am). Often times these explosions M80s-M1000s being dropped and detonated.

Someone was arrested back in 2019 and the explosions reduced dramatically.

This article[0] goes into detail about it.

[0]: https://maxleanne.medium.com/tracking-san-franciscos-mythica...

gouggoug··on We identified a North Korean hacker who tried to get a job
Not to mention the silliness of this statement: "This core crypto principle is more relevant than ever in the digital age"

I wonder what crypto-currency looked like before the digital age...

Edit: added -currency suffix to crypto :p

gouggoug··on Go 1.24's go tool is one of the best additions to the ecosystem in years
I came to the comment section for this comment.

Dark background, too many colors, inconsistent spacing, inconsistent font-size and/or family, some links appear fully pink with pink underline, some links aren't pink and only have the underline, inline <code> is blue, but large code blocks are the same color as regular text – on black background, etc.

I had to stop reading unfortunately.

gouggoug··on Little Snitch: Network Monitor and Application Firewall for macOS
Did you happen to stop at the gas station that same day? What does “that very transaction caused a fraud alert” mean? It’s not unusual for multiple transactions to be marked as fraud, even legitimate ones, when a credit card is stolen.
gouggoug··on How public key cryptography works, using only simple math
This article explains, poorly, _what_ public key cryptography is but not _how_ public key cryptography really works, at all.

Saying that Natasha and Boris both choose a prime number and then "create a safe" with it, is the same as telling someone that to make cake Alice and Bob went to the store and bought flour and eggs.

If you want a real, good and visual explanation of _how_ it works, with simple maths, go watch Computerphile's video[0] about Diffie-Hellman.

[0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NmM9HA2MQGI

gouggoug··on Bitwarden SDK relicensed from proprietary to GPLv3
> It asks you for a URL but you can put anything in.

Well, that’s kind of the problem isn’t it?

Yes, you can put bogus URLs, but it’s far from a great user experience

gouggoug··on 1 bug, $50k in bounties, and a Zendesk backdoor
Indeed - I misspoke.
gouggoug··on 1 bug, $50k in bounties, a Zendesk backdoor
That title is also completely misleading because the author did not in fact get paid.

50k corresponds to the money they made with unrelated bug bounties.

I wish they would fix the title so that it properly calls out zendesk refused to pay for a serious bug.

gouggoug··on 1 bug, $50k in bounties, a Zendesk backdoor
> Side note: I'm not too surprised, as I had one of the worst experiences ever interviewing with Zendesk a few years back. I have never come away from an interview hating a company, except for Zendesk.

Same thing happened to me years ago. Interviewed with them and it was the worst “screening” experience I ever had. After getting a rejection email, I thanked them for their time and said I had feedback about the interview should they want to hear it. They said yes, please.

Sent my feedback, never heard from them again.

gouggoug··on Bplustree.app
If you missed it, this seems directly related to this very interesting submission[0] 3 days ago

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41489832

gouggoug··on Writing a book in the age of open source
As a big advocate of Asciidoc myself, I have to say this sounds backwards to me too.

I can't imagine someone calling themselves a developer finding writing asciidoc difficult. It isn't any harder than markdown. It only has a slightly different syntax[0], and more features.

I've also faced a lot of resistance from people when asking them to migrate from markdown. My, unfavorable, opinion is that it's simply the usual reluctance to change and unwillingness to learn something new, deal with the short term pain of learning, despite longer term advantages.

[0]: https://docs.asciidoctor.org/asciidoc/latest/asciidoc-vs-mar...

gouggoug··on Bypassing airport security via SQL injection
> This isn't a matter of technical chops, this is a matter of someone who is good at navigating bureaucracy convincing the powers that be that they should have a special hook into the system.

I would love to know how one can get what I'd imagine is at least a 6 figures contract with the government? How does this work?

I imagine the author of FlyCASS must be making a good amount of money off their product.

gouggoug··on Okay, I Like WezTerm
Totally agree. Though, usually these programmers know how to properly ask a question, make a bug report and/or feature request.

They wouldn't, for example, just barge in an oss project with arguably low value statements like "Python 2 is retiring in thirty months. Calibre needs to convert to Python 3."

gouggoug··on Okay, I Like WezTerm
> he answers questions from newbies and enhancement requests are far more polite and charitable. His ire seems to be reserved for fellow programmers.

Some programmers (like myself) have little patience for people they consider should know better and are wasting their time. These same programmers are far more charitable to newbies because they know newbies are still learning.

> Remember that this is the guy who said he would personally maintain python 2 because he didn't want to rewrite calibre for python 3 [0].

I read his "I am perfectly capable of maintaining python 2 myself." as "I am perfectly capable of maintaining [calibre running on] python2 myself", which is completely different.

I'm sure some people might also find his answer quite terse and dismissive ("No, it doesn't."), but I read it as a simple statement of facts, using the same tone as the original bug report, which itself is quite terse and imperative "Python 2 is retiring in thirty months. Calibre needs to convert to Python 3."

gouggoug··on How we migrated onto K8s in less than 12 months
Talking about helm - I personally have come to profoundly loathe it. It was amazing when it came out and filled a much needed gap.

However it is loaded with so many footguns that I spend my time redoing and debugging others engineers work.

I’m hoping this new tool called « timoni » picks up steam. It fixes pretty every qualm I have with helm.

So if like me you’re looking for a better solution, go check timoni.

gouggoug··on "We ran out of columns"
I worked many years with an open source eCommerce platform called Magento[0] which, at the time, used something called the "Entity Attribute Value" (or EAV) system[1].

One particularity of the EAV system is that you end up having tables with hundreds (and growing) of columns. It made Magento itself extremely hard to work with and optimize. I hope they moved away from this model since.

To be fair, this was before nosql databases were a thing.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magento

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entity%E2%80%93attribute%E2%80...

gouggoug··on Reverse Engineering for Everyone
Props to the author for writing this – that being said, I felt the same way.

Very long, windy and hard to parse sentences.

For example, Part 2

> There are two basic techniques that you can employ when analyzing malware. The first being static analysis and the other being dynamic analysis.

> Static analysis uses software tools to examine the executable without running the actual decompiled instructions in Assembly. We will not focus on this type of analysis here as we are going to focus on actual disassembled binaries instead however in future courses we will.

> Dynamic analysis uses disassemblers and debuggers to analyze malware binaries while actually running them. The most popular tool in the market today is called IDA which is a multi-platform, multi-processor disassembler and debugger. There are other disassembler/debugger tools as well on the market today such as Hopper Disassembler, OllyDbg and many more.

> A disassembler will convert an executable binary written in Assembly, C, C++, etc into Assembly Language instructions that you can debug and manipulate.

> Reverse engineering is much more than just malware analysis. At the end of our series, our capstone tutorial will utilize IDA as we will create a real-world scenario where you will be tasked by the CEO of ABC Biochemicals to secretly try to ethically hack his companies software that controls a bullet-proof door in a very sensitive Bio-Chemical lab in order to test how well the software works against real threats. The project will be very basic however it will ultimately showcase the power of Assembly Language and how one can use it to reverse engineer and ultimately provide solutions on how to better design the code to make it safer.

> In our next lesson we will discuss various types of malware.

could be written:

> There are two basic techniques that you can employ when analyzing malware: static analysis and dynamic analysis.

> Static analysis examines the executable without running it. We will not focus on this type of analysis here, however in future courses we will.

> Dynamic analysis uses disassemblers and debuggers to analyze malware binaries while running them.

> A disassembler converts an executable binary into Assembly Language instructions that you can debug and manipulate. There are many disassembler/debugger tools available such as Hopper, OllyDbg, IDA and many more. The most popular being IDA, a multi-platform, multi-processor disassembler and debugger.

> Reverse engineering is much more than just malware analysis.

> At the end of our series, we will use IDA in a fictional scenario where you will be tasked by the CEO of ABC Biochemicals – a very sensitive Bio-Chemical lab – to ethically hack his company’s bullet-proof door control-system.

> The project, while basic, will showcase the power of Assembly Language and how one can use it to reverse engineer black-box binaries and ultimately find solutions to make the code safer.

> In our next lesson we will discuss various types of malware.

gouggoug··on Ask HN: Thoughts on shadow banning and other dick moves by Silicon Valley?
I suspect your shadowban is related to how new your account was, its de-facto low reputation and its even lower reputation due heavily downvoted comments you made: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=turdistheword
gouggoug··on CrowdStrike offers a $10 apology gift card to say sorry for outage
Distributing $10 gift cards is so obviously wrong I can't even comprehend how it was approved.

I wonder how much money in total they represent, and if CrowdStrike would have come out better saying "We've immediately allocated $X amount of funds to making sure this issue won't happen again" instead of dividing in x * $10 uber eats insults.

gouggoug··on You can opt out of airport face scans
> I suggest to go and talk with the people who make the laws rather than make on-the-spot scandal with the agents.

Opting-out isn't "making a scandal".

You can both opt-out and "talk with the people who make the laws", one doesn't preclude the other.

> If the law is like that, it's because we have a "majority" (unless democracy is cheated) who voted for such things

That is an idealistic view not grounded in reality at all.

gouggoug··on You can opt out of airport face scans
The right for privacy and not being constantly filmed, monitored and recorded. That principle.
gouggoug··on Debugging an evil Go runtime bug: From heat guns to kernel compiler flags (2017)
Guess I misinterpreted your comment ¯\_(ツ)_/¯, relax.
gouggoug··on Debugging an evil Go runtime bug: From heat guns to kernel compiler flags (2017)
Merely arguing about your _definition_ of 10x engineer and 1x engineer.

Your original comment at the top of the thread implies the engineer who wrote the blog post is a 1x engineer because they spent so much time finding and fixing this bug.

gouggoug··on Debugging an evil Go runtime bug: From heat guns to kernel compiler flags (2017)
> means that a 1x developer will take around 10 hours to get to the same place

A "workaround" isn't an adequate substitute for actual the understanding and fixing of the root cause of a bug.

What you think is a 10x developer is, in fact, a short-term 10x developer, medium-term 1x developer, long-term -10x developer. Their work while seemingly great at first is just accrued debt with an incredibly high interest rate. But they're rarely the ones fixing it.

Now, like everything, a balance needs to be struck between spending hours fixing a bug _the right way_, or, finding a temporary workaround. The real 10x developer is incredibly good at finding this balance.

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →