HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

greatgib

6,555 karma · joined July 31, 2015

submissionscomments
greatgib··on I never authorized an integration that scans my secrets
It is already enough to prove the existence of a password or that another password is not disclosed for example.
greatgib··on Claude reveals ECDSA curve origins
What proof is it that it is really the origin of the curves? That looks credible like most hallucinated output of LLM but it might easily be a coincidence similar to a collision attack, no?

Especially finding the solution that is based on using a random number generator.

It's like people seeing proof that the future was written in Harry Potter books by reading the first letter of the top of the page of a weird set of pages.

greatgib··on Danish Supreme Court Finds That AI CSAM Is CSAM
I agree because I think it is a slippery slop, is that the same reasoning can soon easily be applied to other more disputable cases.

Look at the recent news that Anthropic will ban users that insult their models. How can it make any logic sense?

But it could easily become "punishable by law" also:

- Abusing (non sexually) a fictitious person that is a LLM.

- Insulting a LLM in a chat box, based on a fact that it speaks and appear to behave like a human. The LLM can pretend and simulate that it is offended if you forget that it is just bytes behind.

And in the end, how to consider the following case:

- You have a government call center for a public service, you are aggressive and insult the agent -> it is potentially a legal crime

- Now the agent of this public service that you are talking to is in fact an AI, clearly stated as so, an you insult it very aggressively. -> No human being is hurt so should it be an legal offense?

greatgib··on Firefox Enterprise
I think that I had good instinct by posting the following a few days ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50063676

Honestly it is probably not bad for Mozilla to start such a business, but I have the feeling that it is not in the spirit of "open source"/"freedom for users" Mozilla that we used to have before an Uber exec became in charge.

Now it is like any other startup, and it is possible that in a few years you have features that you will only find in the "entreprise" edition, and that the entreprise edition is distributed in binary only because of "security reason" to protect "entreprise" features.

What is funny is that everyone forgot, but at some point in time, there was the CCK for Netscape and then Mozilla Firefox, allowing to create a standalone installation of the browser that was customized to your preferences as a company or organisation or anything. Your choice of default settings, search engine, background color, plugins, ...

https://wiki.mozilla.org/CCK

And people were worried the same as what we can expect today that it might give tools to companies to "restrict" their users: https://lwn.net/Articles/182904/

greatgib··on AWS Lambda Web Functions
I often hear this argument that it is good for bursty load, but for real, there are a lot of inconvenient limitations. For exemple, you don't really control the number of concurrent instances or the scaling except if you pay for very expensive provisioning.

So you might have to wait for 10s or more to have a new lambda instance spawning up and replying to your requests. And you might have to have your function finish in 15 minutes, deals with the strange concurrency and scaling rules lambda is based on.

greatgib··on The state of systemd: 2026 edition

   He explained that the rate of issues being opened was accelerating, and if it kept up the project would face a large number of unresolved open issues. ""We're currently at 3,000 [open issues]. This is already too much to have a handle on. So I don't know. This is not great"."
Here you can see the crux of the complaints against systemd. it is a giant ball of mud, and working ok in the highway cases but completely fucking up your computer in the other cases.

And you can easily guess that these 3k issues are just the tip of the iceberg.

greatgib··on Mozilla Welcomes Raffi Krikorian as Chief Technology Officer
Did anyone notice that Mozilla recently nominated a new CTO of Mozilla that is totally for from having any connection with the Freedom and Open Source world? That explains a lot of things...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raffi_Krikorian

Raffi Krikorian (Armenian: Րաֆֆի Գրիգորեան; born July 1978) is an Armenian-American technology executive, and the CTO of Mozilla.[1] He was the CTO of Emerson Collective.[2], CTO of the Democratic National Committee,[3] Head of Uber's Advanced Technologies Center,[4][5][6][7] and the former VP of Platform Engineering at Twitter where he was in charge of infrastructure for all of Twitter[8] up to August 2014.[9] He is credited with leading the charge to improve the reliability of Twitter [10][11] as well as the move from Ruby to the JVM.[12] He currently also serves on the board of directors of the Tumo Center for Creative Technologies in Yerevan, Armenia and of Medic Mobile Inc. (Medic).

greatgib··on Let's Encrypt: 64-Day Certificate Lifetimes By Default Coming Feb 2027
"Let's encrypt" was the excuse to impose "https" as mandatory and web browser and so. So let's say you have a home device, https is also mandatory to not have to go through countless warning hops.

But they said: it is ok now, because you can get a certificate for free with let's encrypt. So suppose, you have a local device not connected to internet or your own private network server/services, with 3 month validity, it was short but you were able to generate the certificate in some way, manually, and deploy it manually also.

You could also easily manual renew and deploy the certificates.

Now, with a very short period, especially the 7 days that is their end goal, your devices needs to be constantly connected to internet, constantly receiving "things" from LE that are automatically downloaded and "installed". And it becomes impossible, to manually manage the certificate renewal, so you are force to let automatic scripts/agent do that work. And most probably also let the script/agent auto-update itself because of "breaking changes" like it happened with certbot.

And all of that being, with a short lifetime, you are now constantly at will of Let's Encrypt, and in the end the US state and government where all of this is located. You depend of the https for a lot of things, now at the US gov will you can be cut off, eventually be monitored or be targeted, in a very short timeframe of "days" instead of months.

You can also more easily have your certificates impersonated in a hard to catch way as certificates will be constantly renewed.

And even in a non evil plot, if anything happens to let's encrypt, down time or anything, you could have your service broken with dead certificate in a so short time that you would not even have the time to look for a solution. Today you have at least months to figure out.

greatgib··on Automattic has a new board after failed attempt to put CEO on leave
Funny to see all the comedy and useless energy spent having a board, when this board is a Rubber-stamp board with no real decision power as one person has the majority of the control votes.
greatgib··on Let's Encrypt: 64-Day Certificate Lifetimes By Default Coming Feb 2027
Be ready because their plan is to reduce the lifetime to 7d as soon as possible for their evil masterplan to strip us off reasonable control about our websites.

Now that they have a dominant position they do Google style and Google influenced move.

You are at their will fit whatever retarded dictatorial decision they want.

greatgib··on New gTLD Application for .lan
But why is it that nowadays, it's enough for a vulture corporation to have enough money to be able to privatize a part of the "web" that is in common usage (in the sense of common good) since so long?

It should be logical even without thinking that the request have to be rejected.

greatgib··on The era of software quality, or the era of ostriches?
> GNOME is primarily written using unsafe programming languages where simple mistakes in our code lead to devastating consequences for our users, and we make these mistakes all the time. No matter how much we try, GNOME developers will fail write secure code when using unsafe languages like C, C++, or Vala: it’s just too hard for even experienced developers to do properly.

Once I saw that I knew that this article was a ridiculous stack of bullshit. Gnome might have some bugs and shortcomings but now millions desktops are using Gnome based window manager for decade and the world didn't collapse yet.

And let's not forget the ridiculous assumption that you can't handle a software quality without using AI...

greatgib··on Our approach to EU text provenance rules
My personal opinion is that they cheated evaluations to be able to release this pretending that it has no meaningful impact.

Otherwise, I don't see any logical explanation that some of their benchmark results would be higher when watermarked. Except if benchmark results are so unstable that they are an useless metric.

greatgib··on Treachery in the Rodin Museum 3D scan verdict
That is problem I have personally experienced in France that the administrative justice is bat shit and often being biased and not respecting citizen laws.

I had cases where the official body lied, and the lies where exposed but still it is like they didn't care. Real example:

- opposite side: the memorandum of the accusation was complete enough as you can see they have 90 pages.

- me: what, no, lies, my memorandum is 15 pages as you can obviously see counting the pages.

- decision: rules against me because my 90 pages memorandum shows that the analysis was complete enough.

Another case:

- me: election should be cancelled because not respecting the at least 30% parity law

- opposing party: argument without ground because 1 woman over 6 mans, 1/5 = 40% so please reject the request.

- me: but no, 1/5 = 20% not 40%.

- decision: rejected because more than 30% proved by opposition.

And the worse of all in some decisions "ok, they didn't respect the law, didn't respect the due process, but if they did would have it changed that much the result? Not sure so let's reject the request as without ground..."

But if you over speed the limit, then you will get a ticket in all cases. So it is like not the same justice for everyone.

And something that can explain a little bit why administrative justice is so aweful in France is that judges in this instances are not professional judges but former gouvernement workers that are assigned there. So in the end it is like asking gouv workers to rule against other gouv workers decisions. Totally biased.

greatgib··on Treachery in the Rodin Museum 3D scan verdict
If you know french bureaucracy, it is very simple in the end. It is a public worker that is nominated as the head of the museum. The mindset is almost never to do their job well or benefit the common good. But to be important and showing your importance by abusing your power if necessary to show that you have some.

Somehow he thinks that the sculpture is his own as he is the custodian, and so that he has all rights. And pictures or 3d scans in the end belongs to him also, like if the virtual thing was a physical item locked in the museum.

If he is forced to release publicly the 3d scan, especially against his goodwill, it is like being striped of his power and authority so he couldn't allow that. It becomes a personal matter.

The only thing that could have worked is to befriend him or create a cultural organisation and have lobbied to him in the first place that he would learned a lot of reputation/marketing points by releasing it. Imagine a dedicated website and grand champagne event with the incompetent minister of culture where they push the button...

greatgib··on Anthropic tried to persuade Pope that AI could be conscious being
And let's not forget that it is almost their only job to say or write believable bullshit for all occasions, all day long since leaving the theological school.
greatgib··on cp: -r or -R?
I never noticed but indeed in France the official name is "Pokémon" and not "Pokemon". So that the pronunciation in French is correct.

Is it the case in another country to have a localized name for that?

greatgib··on Updates to Full Disk Access in macOS
Don't be naive, them telling you this in advance and straw man arguments like:

   For communication apps, this can also compromise the privacy of the people users are communicating with.
Let me think that they try to sugarcoat a coming change that has the purpose of transforming your computer as an ipad where you have no access to most of it except what is approved by apple.

For the "greater good" as usual.

Just look how deceptive is the Apple post "full disk access" is not even a thing. You have access to your user files and that is all. You need sudo to have more rights.

A normal copilot/Claude/facebook like app shouldn't ask you for such a right except exceptionally for a very good reason.

So when they speak about backup apps, that are the one that could need sudo to backup the whole system, is to tell you that soon only notarized apple approved and app store delivered apps will be allowed to do that, but certainly not you willingly. Maybe not in version 1 but in version 2 for sure.

Then, like for iOS, they could have proprietary apps like Netflix, Facebook and co storing data on your device that you will not have access to.

greatgib··on Someone Still Has to Buy Your Product
The science fiction theory is that in the end, work is mostly done by AI/Machines and so people can have access to food, products, whatever they need for almost free or at least there is no need to work anymore and everyone can enjoy a beautiful life.

But in reality, a few trillionaire like Musk will capture most of the value/income that they can from the society advancement dividends and a bigger and bigger percentage of the population will become poor, exploited, and depending on the charity of the happy few.

greatgib··on Sober: We Ported Roblox to Linux
Very nice, but sadly almost useless by being closed source.

If you are the kind of person using Linux, you might be sensitive to run "closed source" binaries from random sources, especially for shaddy stuffs like trying to run a game in an unofficial way.

But I was so annoyed by my kid not being able to use Linux if they wanted to play that game, that I could have easily paid for a working solution.

greatgib··on The forgotten battle of East Lansing
The point is that the students are not workers themselves. It is not them that could be "forced" to be on strike. So their reason is because they don't accept that "others" might be forced to be on strike...
greatgib··on The forgotten battle of East Lansing
Curious because when I read this piece, I have the feeling that the student actions are typical left-wing movement things.

Like workers doing the hard work and fighting for their rights to not be exploited. Not to be put in jail for asking better life conditions.

Students on the other side that are lazy brats that fight the workers instead of the system for unclear philosophical "moral" goals...

greatgib··on Ideas on modernizing the open-source desktop

   > People get angry when they have worked hard to get their desktop environment just as they like it and something changes to disrupt that. "And I get that. As I said before, I don't want to change everything." But the world is changing, "and we need to grow our way gently into some new things."
Here is the core of the problem with this kind of "UX designer" persons. You see the need of the user doesn't matter, the world change so a user that is perfectly happy has to adapt to a change he didn't ask for because otherwise the "UX designer" has no life purpose.

Sadly I think that I saw that too many time the useless and hated change just because things had to change. Like android theme instead if fixing bugs...

greatgib··on Returning Soldier Effect
I think that there is a statistic reason hidden somewhere deep but would be on long scale.

Before modern science, you needed a man and a woman to make a baby. Maybe it is for monogamous societies or would apply also to polygamy but there should be just a common average of the number of child a father will procreate. Especially taking care of the fact that he needs to be able to take care of them.

Removing outliers, must men will not do more than 1 to 4 kids for example.

So somehow if you have a too high ratio of women, birthrate will decrease, and same too many men not enough mother do birthrate would decrease also.

So there should be a natural regulation at big scale to keep the population stable or growing.

And probably, the individuals contributing to birth with the good ratio would be the one reproducing themselves so helping correcting anomalies in the long run.

There are probably also environnemental and genetic factors that are at play to determine baby gender, not only perfect randomness, that are still unknown to us.

I think a lot of people are wondering, if I have 2 kids, 2 boys, what are the odds to have a girl the third time? Is it really 1/2 or in a more cases it will be a boy again?

greatgib··on Partnering with Accenture on Embedded Evaluation
> Embedded evaluation is new, and many of the details about how it will operate are still being worked out.

Let's translate: nothing new under the sun. Marketing green washing operation. A bullshit consulting company will do bullshit job as usual but we pay them so can decide what will be in this report and at the same time use their name for name dropping.

greatgib··on OpenAI models secretly generate instructions to ignore constraints
They obviously carefully avoid to give the whole context and original prompt instructions they gave to the model. Or model simulating the user part.

I would easily guess that if you got it you will understand that this behavior is not natural but induced by the researcher.

And to be noted in addition that they are standard prompt injections that were rejected anyway as such.

greatgib··on Online Z3 Guide
If anyone wondering, because it took me a few hops to find out:

Z3 is a high-performance theorem prover being developed at Microsoft Research.

greatgib··on Automattic execs signed reciprocal severance deals in Mullenweg absence
Funny to think about "golden parachute" in their context of the airplane being on fire with the pilot being dead drunk.
greatgib··on Leak: EU Commission to pitch social media restrictions for under-15s
Really exhausting this tyranny of the commission elected by no one that is totally morally corrupt and the power tool of a few lobbies to advance their agenda like censoring and so.

It is because of them that the trust in Europe is at an all time low and that nationalist political movements are gaining so much traction in European countries.

They don't respect the citizen will but then pretend to not understand when far right is winning election all over Europe.

greatgib··on AirBaltic files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy as Iran war costs bite
Same, they were a nice not too expensive company. Sad if they don't make it.

What is curious is for a kind of local carrier, their company is registered in new york.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →