HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

greenshackle

234 karma · joined August 13, 2015

submissionscomments
greenshackle··on The Canadian Housing Boom Fueled by China’s Billionaires
> bicycle

> Canada

That's great, except for the 7 or so months out of the year when it's not.

If flukus prefers dense areas that's his deal... arguing about preferences is dumb.

greenshackle··on There isn’t anything magical about it: Why more millennials are avoiding sex
Why are hookup apps making sex less stimulating? Because they cause people to have more sex. I can't see any other reason.

So what you're saying is, young people are having less sex, because they're having more sex?

(take this as tongue-in-cheek, I don't think you're really making that argument)

greenshackle··on Bad news and good news for tinnitus sufferers
How does that contradict the quote?

Maybe your doc sends you home with no help precisely because it is poorly understood and so they don't know how to help you?

greenshackle··on How to Read a Book [pdf]
Adler doesn't say you should read every book deeply though. He defines four levels of reading, from reading the table of content, to deep reading and synthesis of multiple works in the same domain.

Elon's technique makes sense, but you can't just do that. The most impressive people seem to be T-shaped: they have very deep understanding of their specialty, but they also a familiarity with a wide breadth of fields.

I skim a bunch of technical software books that are not immediately useful to me. My goal is not to remember every detail, it's just to get an idea of what's out there, and where to find more information if I need it.

greenshackle··on How to Read a Book [pdf]
It's not about efficiency, it's about effectiveness.

Sequential reading may be more efficient, but it's infinitely less effective if you never pick up the book to read the next chapter.

It's a workaround for the 'I started this useful, interesting book, read 50% of it, then never touched it again, for no good reason' bug. You solve the problem by nerd-sniping yourself with an exercise.

If you don't experience this bug perhaps it's not good advice for you.

My 'technique', if I want to read a particular book, is to carry it, and no other book, in my backpack. I'll inevitably read it in my down times.

greenshackle··on Tips from the Pragmatic Programmer (2000)
"I never make exceptions. An exception disproves the rule."
greenshackle··on LastPass autofill exploit
Does it need to have Windows client? I'm guessing yes. If not there is [SFLVault](http://sflvault.org/)
greenshackle··on Show HN: Riko – A Python stream processing engine modeled after Yahoo! Pipes
Python 3.5 introduced the async/await syntax, I don't do C# but at a glance it's the same.

I've been working on a similar project and I've also found the push model easier.

greenshackle··on Show HN: Riko – A Python stream processing engine modeled after Yahoo! Pipes
I just started writing a functional stream processing library in Python for some of the same reasons.

We use somewhat different concepts. I tend to think of streams as infinite, so it didn't occur to me to include something like a reverse pipe operator.

I'm a bit surprised, why is filter an operator rather than a processor? I would think filters usually apply per-item, not to a whole stream?

I havn't worked on it very much but I'm heading towards push-based, using 0MQ for distribution/parallel processing, and using asyncio, mostly because it plays nicely with 0MQ.

greenshackle··on Why I’m Suing the US Government
Yes, and VLC should have to pay movie publishers since they let users add subtitles over the video stream.

That makes a lot of sense. /s

greenshackle··on Ask HN: Laptop that doesn't suck
You're missing the point, of course hammering the GPU creates a lot of heat, but you would expect a high end system that came pre-packaged with the GPU to be able cope with the heat. If the system is overheating, clearly it is not coping very well.

Packaging hardware into a system without sufficient cooling to actually use it at capacity is just bad design.

greenshackle··on A Single Div
So did I...
greenshackle··on So Many Research Scientists, So Few Openings as Professors
To oversimplify by a lot, Civil/Environmental = urban/industrial (e.g. industrial/municipal wastewater treatment, air pollution), Environmental = agricultural/resources (e.g. soil management, biofuels, soil decontamination for mining/oil).

That's roughly how it was divided at my college, anyway.

greenshackle··on Make the Web Work for Everyone
They mean in the USA, it's based on a misintepretation of the graph below the quoted phrase, or on poor wording on their part.

The graph says there are as many vision-impaired American internet users as there Canadian internet users - not the entire population - around 20-25 millions (the graph is hard to read). I'm sceptical of that number because it suggests ~10% of the USA is vision impaired, seems too high.

Anyway the only reason I care is that I'm Canadian ;)

greenshackle··on Unpleasant Design
I don't think speaking of 'treating people as actual humans' is productive. It's a rhetorical device to paint people who disagree with your policy proposals as evil. It will get people who already agree with you to give you a pat on the back but it won't convince anyone who doesn't already agree. I say that as someone who probably mostly agrees with your position on this issue

Maybe you think your policy proposals flow directly from 'treating people as actual humans', but they don't. There are lot of (obviously true, from your perspective) assumptions there that will not be shared by people who disagree with you.

greenshackle··on Make the Web Work for Everyone
"it was found that there are more hard of hearing users in the United States than the population Spain and more users who are blind and low-vision than the population of Canada."

Really? There's more than 35 millions internet users with vision impairment? The previous section says there are 8 million people with vision impairment in the USA.

greenshackle··on Economic Reality
I don't find it too surprising that fewer hours worked results in a higher productivity per hour.

EDIT: But I am surprised by the higher productivity per worker, compared to UK.

greenshackle··on Would a Work-Free World Be So Bad?
You're not wrong, but then again, the typical American doesn't live in a typical city (where typical = median).

The average American city/town has a population of 20,000, yet 80% of the population lives in a metropolitan area.

(http://www.newgeography.com/content/00242-america-more-small...)

If that's counterintuive, imagine the extreme case of a country with 100 cities of 10,000 residents, and one city of 10 million residents. The median city has 10,000 residents, yet 10 out of 11 millions live in the big city.

If you are interested in the experiences of people as opposed to statistics about cities, the sort of city a typical American lives in is more interesting than a typical city.

greenshackle··on Living, in Limbo
I suspect when people are asked what they regret and they say, I wish I had spent more time with my family, what they really mean is, I wish I had more time to spend with my family.

Humans are not actually very good at remembering their past selves. Memories are reconstructed on the fly, we 'remember' by projecting our present selves into past situations.

greenshackle··on Software has diseconomies of scale, not economies of scale
Maybe I was unclear, what I meant is that usually you need to tinker with the internals at some point. Which is fine, but it does mean you need more than basic knowledge to use the tool productively. (And if the software is proprietary and poorly documented, you're SOL).

The lie is that this tool is so easy, you just have to read this 30 minute tutorial and you'll be able to write powerflu software and you don't even need to learn the internal mechanics of it.

I havn't used Kubernetes, it's possible it's so good that you don't need the learn the messy details, I'm just sceptical of that claim in general.

greenshackle··on Software has diseconomies of scale, not economies of scale
Powerful abstractions make the promise that you'll only have to learn the abstraction to write powerful software, so "even people with only basic knowledge will be able to do X using abstraction Y".

The promise is almost always false. All abstractions are leaky, and if you do serious development with them inevitably bugs will bubble up from below and you'll have to dive into the messy internals.

For example, ZeroMQ makes distributed messaging relatively painless. Someone with very little knowlegde of the network stack can write simple programs with it easily. But for any serious enterprise application with high reliability requirements you'll eventually run into problems that require deep knowledge of the network stack.

>Talk to me about Docker and Swarm and the like hosting technology platforms and frameworks that make it trivially straightforward to program distributed systems reliably, and really hard to program them wrong, and we might have the utopia you speak of.

Yes, that.

greenshackle··on Software has diseconomies of scale, not economies of scale
More than two scales in fact, I can think of three: scale of firm, scale of distribution, scale of product.

In most industries scale of firm goes hand-in-hand with scale of distribution. Software breaks the paradigm, so we have to be careful to say which scale we're talking about.

Obviously, with distribution, software has insane economies of scale, since we can copy-paste our products nearly for free. That's why we can have small firms with a large distribution, unlike most industries.

With scale of firm, we face some of the same diseconomies as other industries. Communication and coordination problems grow superlinearly with firm size.

Effort and resources needed also grow superlinearly with product scale. That's also true of other engineering disciplines though. Making a tower twice as high is more than twice as hard. Part of it is the complexity inherent in the product, and part of it is that a more complex design needs a bigger team, so you run into the firm diseconomies of scale mentionned above.

greenshackle··on Stop Bashing G.M.O. Foods, More Than 100 Nobel Laureates Say
An aside: Organic farmers use Bt too. As a spray. Bt proteins are a naturally occuring substance, after all.

They argue the spray is not as bad as the GM crops due to the timing of exposure. I really don't know enough about insect biology to say if that makes sense.

Glyphosate is certainly not a sustainable weed control solution but it's no worse than the herbicides that it replaced.

I wonder if the biggest negative impact of biotech firms is not the chemicals but on IP and patents, hindering the positive development of GMOs, and to what extent proprietary software IP and patent rulings paved the way for them.

greenshackle··on Stop Bashing G.M.O. Foods, More Than 100 Nobel Laureates Say
Off the top of my head: Bt proteins, copper. There are many more, you can easily google and find a long list.

And yes, that's the same Bt that's in Bt crops, by the way (proteins from Bt bacteria). Organic farmers use it in a spray. It's a natural substance, and they argue the spray causes less resistance than the GM varieties. I really don't have the domain knowledge to say whether they're right.

Not all organic farmers are the same, and over time the meaning of 'organic' has been diluted. Smaller, more idealistic organic farmers mostly don't use pesticides, but there are large commercial organic growers out there who meet the bare minimum for certification and will use whatever pesticides are allowed.

greenshackle··on Woman wins $10k judgment against Microsoft for forced Windows 10 upgrade
Yeah I'm not saying the payouts are great. But let's say, pessimistically, that the lawyers took 80%; if they had done it pro bono, you'd get 5 coupons instead of 1. Better, but not by much.

A small payout could be due to greedy class action lawyers, but it could be due to the corporate lawyers successfully arguing damages down to nearly nothing (compared to the size of the class). The second one sounds more likely to me.

In the cases I've heard about, the corporate team had orders of magnitude more resources than the class action lawyers (think 3 lawyers working part time on the case vs. the corporation having an expert prepare for 2 years to appear once in court. I am not making this up.)

I'm biased though, the few class action lawyers I know are good guys, it's possible most aren't. I havn't looked at the field in general, and IANAL, so take that with generous salt.

greenshackle··on Simple Ways of Reducing the Cognitive Load in Code
The guidelines for a framework I use is to put views and models in separate folders. Which means code for any model is spread out between at least two folders. Finding code is annoying.
greenshackle··on Woman wins $10k judgment against Microsoft for forced Windows 10 upgrade
Yes, you can reverse it on Windows. I should know, Windows 10 activated 'natural' scrolling on my touchpad when I upgraded. I'm really not sure why.
greenshackle··on How Bayes’ Rule Emerged Triumphant from Two Centuries of Controversy
I disagree. There's a large grey area between 'completely unknown' and 'scientific certainty'. I prefer guessing and doing computations with my guesses than throwing my hands up in the air and calling it unknowable.

When presented with new evidence it's better to write a number down for your degree in belief in X, ask how much you should change that belief based on the new data, and update your probability estimate, than to just go with your feelings. You're not doing actual bayesian computations, that's totally untractable for anything that's not a very well defined problem, but doing 'pseudo-bayesian' updating is better than not.

I think of it as the fermi approximation of probabilities. You won't get accurate numbers that way but you'll get better numbers than if you just invent the answer.

EDIT to add: most of the time you should then throw out the number. Just like a fermi estimate, you get a ballpark sense for the answer, not a precise answer.

In the superforecasting experiment by Tetlock the best forecasters did this. They were writing down probability estimates and methodically updating them based on new data (news articles, data, etc.). They were forecasting geopolitical events, not dice rolls, and it worked (better than the alternative, obviously no one can forecast geopolitical events with high certainty).

greenshackle··on Show HN: Anime.js – Polyvalent JavaScript Animation Engine
No, it means he is french. I am french and understood immediately.

It's a valid but rarely used word in english. It means flexible, or 'with many functions/uses', or 'good at many things'.

greenshackle··on Woman wins $10k judgment against Microsoft for forced Windows 10 upgrade
I know class action lawyers who work incredibly hard to defend the 'small people' and don't make that much. They take David vs Goliath cases. They went after a tobacco company, for example.

The lawsuits take a lot of work, they only get paid if they win, and they don't always win.

I'm sure there are class action lawyers who are in it for the money, but most lawyers who are in it for the money would go into corporate law, not class action.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →