HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

greygoo222

213 karma · joined August 26, 2025

submissionscomments
greygoo222··on Tech boss uses AI and ChatGPT to create cancer vaccine for his dying dog
ChatGPT did not make the treatment. ChatGPT summarized literature explaining how to make similar treatments, and then specialized tools were used to make the treatment. It is perfectly reasonable that ChatGPT can summarize literature and not make compliant 100 page legal documents.

The principle behind personalized mRNA vaccines is simple enough, and it's perfectly plausible that someone with money and lab access can create an effective treatment not offered through conventional means. It would be plausible even for a human patient right now, with mRNA vaccines still hung up in clinical trials. For a dog? Of course.

greygoo222··on The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure
The LLM did not design the drug. The LLM summarized some papers on how to design similar drugs, and then a dozen specialized tools were used in an established pipeline to design the drug. You people need to read the article and read the background before writing nonsense based on your assumptions.

Here's a previous comment of mine talking about personalized mRNA vaccines with useful citations: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47210284

greygoo222··on The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure
It's not a radical medical breakthrough, it's applying a technique already documented in the literature and years into human clinical trials. The LLM is just doing literature summary and planning. The most notable AI innovations here are in protein folding and binder prediction.
greygoo222··on The bureaucracy blocking the chance at a cure
The LLM didn't oneshot the mRNA treatment, it merely suggested the idea. Most of the steps in the process were done with specialized tools. And no novel treatments were invented wholesale, it's more applying a documented process with existing open-source tools that's just too personalized and expensive to be offered by any vet.

I find this story perfectly plausible.

greygoo222··on Obsession with growth is destroying nature, 150 countries warn
Pollution is not in the "top 5 leading causes of death" unless you count all deaths caused by diseases that are exacerbated by pollution as caused by pollution.
greygoo222··on Obsession with growth is destroying nature, 150 countries warn
As someone who is sensitive to noise, rural areas bother me far more than urban ones. Traffic is low-frequency and only rarely annoying, but the few times I have lived in rural areas or gone camping, I have been woken up repeatedly by the horrific screeching of birds. Louder, shriller, less predictable than any city noise.

There are birds in cities too, and they are annoying, but they are thankfully drowned out by the cars.

greygoo222··on Obsession with growth is destroying nature, 150 countries warn
Your problem is that you were happy as a child and unhappy as an adult. That's a personal problem, and has little to do with rural or urban living. As other commenters have pointed out, you can most likely afford to buy a farm if you really want that lifestyle. I suspect you don't, because it sucks major ass to have to do manual labor all day, to eat almost entirely the same things and see the same people for decades on end, and to choke off your access to most of the joy and beauty in the world.
greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
What is monstrous is the confusion of the natural with the just.
greygoo222··on The optimal age to freeze eggs is 19
If you had kids earlier, you wouldn't get more time with the specific person you love that is your son, you'd get more time with a different son. No doubt you'd love your counterfactual son too. But you shouldn't feel bad for having done any wrong by your real kid. This is the only timeline he could exist in.

Bit of a thorny philosophical argument, maybe, but reasonable in this case.

greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
It's not gymnastics, you just have no background on this topic.

Species are not moral subjects. Individuals are.

Killing an individual animal that could live a worthwhile life for longer is an individually bad act. Insofar as this happens in the process of species going extinct, that's bad. But it's also the default state of nature. Does replacing a forest with a city cause net harm to non-human animals? That's not clear. It might even be net good.

Does that mean we should destroy wilderness on purpose to prevent wild animal suffering? Not yet, we don't have the technology to mitigate knock-on effects, and it should be done a way that does not harm individuals. But I can't get behind viewing biome destruction as some kind of atrocity against the animals within them, at least not as a whole. (Some species have better lives than others).

greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
I'm not angry, just disdainful. Some abstract philosophical positions are unworthy of respect.
greygoo222··on The optimal age to freeze eggs is 19
That's exactly why I look forward to it!
greygoo222··on The optimal age to freeze eggs is 19
"Regrowing teeth" started human trials last June. Development takes time.

And there is no single cure to cancer.

greygoo222··on The optimal age to freeze eggs is 19
There's no way it's a worthwhile investment to invest thousands of dollars and take on significant risk and discomfort just for a tool to "resist expectations." You should invest that in a therapist. Or moving to a different state.
greygoo222··on The optimal age to freeze eggs is 19
Calling 19 "childhood" is crazy. Most teens have an understanding of what they want their life to look like.
greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
That's not what I'm suggesting. I'm suggesting your attitude towards it might be.
greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
There probably are reasonable methods of estimation that would say suffering associated with factory farms currently outweighs suffering occurring in the wild, though I don't know if I agree. However, factory farms are both relatively recent and temporary. It's hard to defend the position that humanity vanishing tomorrow would reduce net suffering in the long run. If nothing else, another industrial species will eventually replace us, and there's little reason to believe they'll be any better.

Of course, I personally have higher hopes for intelligent life than merely not causing massive suffering. That brings me to another tangent: Are you vegan?

I am. You might be, but I'm estimating you probably aren't. You can go vegan, it's easier than you think, and if you don't think you can commit, being 90% vegan is 90% as good as being 100% vegan. All thought experiments aside, you can be a part of making a better world, right now.

You can also make donations: https://funds.effectivealtruism.org/funds/animal-welfare

greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
As a card-carrying optimist, I am strongly in favor of universal right to die. Maybe you should wait for the people in this thread to report their opinions before making assumptions?

I don't want most "complainers" to kill themselves, nor would I recommend them to, but I support their right to. And if they showed me convincing evidence their life contains too much suffering to be worthwhile, I would agree with their decision.

greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
I mean this sincerely, not as an insult: consider that the problem is with your mind or personal life, not with the world, and you should look for a way to address that if you haven't already.
greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
The person you're responding to is explicitly saying they would be fine with suicide.
greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
Unlikely. See some expert analysis here: https://forecastingresearch.org/xpt
greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
Causing harm to biomes is not the same thing as causing net harm to animals inside biomes. The base rate of harm done to animals inside biomes is immense and horrific.
greygoo222··on New farm bill would condemn pigs to a lifetime in gestation crates
Biomes are not moral subjects and don't deserve consideration. (Pigs are).
greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
First I want to say I appreciate that you're willing to acknowledge when you're wrong or confused. As I said, you've convinced me the LLM fucked up here. I still believe LLMs are useful for learning, as long as you know the right questions to ask.

To my understanding, "tumor architecture" is used in the same manner as "tissue architecture", it just refers to the physical structure of the tissue, nothing more specific.

I recommend The Biology of Cancer - Robert A. Weinberg. It's on Anna's Archive.

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
Jake Seliger died ten weeks before his daughter was born. For many people, a chance at buying some time is worth a lot.

Trials are also by no means exclusively performed on terminal patients.

greygoo222··on TikTok will not introduce end-to-end encryption, saying it makes users less safe
Why? Plenty of children benefit from talking to other people. Some children need careful monitoring, and some children shouldn't be allowed to use DMs, but it's not universal and should be up to the parents.
greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
Funnily enough, now that I've gone back and reread the LLM's explanations, I've decided that point 1, the one you were least critical of, is garbage whereas points 2 and 3 are fine.

1. Mice usually clear drugs faster, not slower, than humans, so either point 1 is wrong or I'm missing something, and either way it's a bad explanation.

2. This point is fine. The use of the phrase "tumor architecture" in this context is common, for example this random paper https://www.cell.com/cancer-cell/fulltext/S1535-6108(12)0008... and several papers cited by the Nature review. I don't get your problem with the phrase "highly pressurized cores" is, or what you're calling a non-sequitur.

Maybe you're arguing that it's an oversimplification to imply that xenografts are just not dense or pressurized enough, and it would be better to emphasize that tumor microenvironments affect drug delivery and aren't accurately modeled, which... sure, I suppose, though it seems like a nitpick.

3. Come on, you can't possibly think this is a valid criticism, and not just a thing you made up to have something to say.

> I continue to assert that the LLM's badly-plagiarising some papers, lecture notes and/or textbooks, blended with bad pop-sci analogies to the point of incoherence.

Then please, strive to do better!

I mean that in earnest, not just as an insult. You hate reading bullshit? Me too. If you're not familiar with the term "tumor architecture", it takes five seconds to put it into Google Scholar before you start insisting it's made up. Reducing the amount of bullshit on this site is everyone's duty.

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
Examples aside, 5 years isn't long enough for a treatment to move from early mice trials to clinical use. The average time from application to FDA approval is about 10 years.

The breakthroughs happening now will benefit average patients later. It's frustrating, but it's not because we've run out of innovations.

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
Short answer, no.

Long answer, it's a variable you need to consider when doing data analysis, and it depends on what exactly you're talking about, but it's absolutely not true for improvements in cancer survival general. One alternative method is to look at per-capita death rates, for example:

Reduction in US and UK childhood cancer death since 2000 https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cancer-death-rates-in-chi...

Reduction in several countries' age-standardized breast cancer death since 2000 (Why did it increase in South Africa? I'm not sure, maybe socioeconomic factors) https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/breast-cancer-death-rate-...

Reduction in global age-standardized cancer death rate since 2000 (Scroll down to second graph. Since the population is getting older, age-standardization makes a fairer comparison) https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/cancer-death-rates

2000 is an arbitrary year I picked for clear visual changes without needing to haggle over statistics. If you want to feel optimistic, switch the childhood cancer death graph to 1960-now.

This method has different possible failure points. It could be that less people are getting cancer, or that people who would get cancer are dying of other causes, or reporting of cause of death has changed, though this is very unlikely for some figures, such as leukemia death rates for children in the US. Statistics is hard. Overall though, the evidence is very good that cancer survival has improved a lot due to better treatments since 2000.

If you have a more specific claim you're dubious about, I'd be willing to look into it for you. I'm very enthusiastic about this topic.

greygoo222··on New iron nanomaterial wipes out cancer cells without harming healthy tissue
I just got nerdsniped for an hour writing up a comment about how cool they are.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →