HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

greygoo222

213 karma · joined August 26, 2025

submissionscomments
greygoo222··on How AI gave me my voice back – an artist's review of Suno Studio
I absolutely love Suno music. Most of the music I listen to nowadays is Suno generated. There are so many creative people out there making things that never would've existed without it.
greygoo222··on Criticisms of “The Body Keeps the Score”
It's completely sensible for most people to believe they are above average drivers, and all be correct. This is because there isn't a single objective measurement for "good at driving."

Imagine that 50% of people are cautious drivers, and 50% are fast drivers. The cautious drivers think being cautious is more important than being fast, so they all believe they are above average. The fast drivers, vice versa. Everyone thinks they're above average, and they are by their own standards, no delusion required.

greygoo222··on Criticisms of “The Body Keeps the Score”
Raising counter-examples shouldn't mean throwing shit at the wall to see what sticks, and the author's point could easily have been made without repeating an extraordinary claim he fails to provide evidence for. If The Body Keeps the Score had arguments as poorly sourced as "this textbook said that PTSD co-occurs with inflammation, so Western diets could cause inflammation which could cause PTSD", the author of the Substack would rightfully criticize it as unsubstantiated bullshit. His own article should be held to the same standards.
greygoo222··on Criticisms of “The Body Keeps the Score”
What is the definition of trauma, and what is the evidence that most people don't overcome it on their own?
greygoo222··on Criticisms of “The Body Keeps the Score”
> It's simply important to recognize that trauma means you're probably not going to get better on your own, and you should find help.

There is no evidence for this, and it is exactly the harmful mindset being criticized. Developing PTSD from traumatic events is the exception, not the rule. The majority of people do get better on their own.

greygoo222··on Criticisms of “The Body Keeps the Score”
The Body Keeps the Score is bullshit, but this Substack is even more bullshit. The author criticizes Bessel van der Kolk for failing to prove causation, and then writes this gibberish:

"In the textbook Evolutionary Psychology, the authors explain that a particular hunter gatherer population isn’t as susceptible to PTSD despite being exposed to similarly tragic events. They argue that part of the physiological changes that come along with PTSD are increased inflammation in the body. Thus, the inflammatory nature of a standard western diet may make some people more susceptible to PTSD."

"A 2020 study on Turkana warriors in Kenya found them to be much less likely to develop PTSD-related symptoms compared to US combat vets despite also experiencing gruesome acts in a war zone."

Where is the proof that diet causes PTSD?

greygoo222··on Gifted children are special needs children
This sounds like a No True Scotsman. What's the evidence that "real" Montessori does work well for children of all academic levels, when placed in the same class?
greygoo222··on Gifted children are special needs children
Childhood intelligence is not exactly the same thing as the skills that allow you to immigrate, but it is highly, highly correlated. You can't just say "merit isn't a singular quality", you have to prove that the effect you see is due to wealth differences rather than merit differences.
greygoo222··on America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy
China's fertility rate, even assuming it does not improve, won't cause problems for several decades. https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/can-anything-knock-china-off-i...
greygoo222··on America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy
> One of the single largest determiners of schooling success is the number of books at home.

This "effect" is the textbook example of correlation != causation. By which I mean, it was literally in my AP Psych textbook in high school.

greygoo222··on America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy
If you read the article, you'll know that the affluent kids never saw a decrease in performance begin with. The top 10% performed just as well as always.
greygoo222··on Gifted children are special needs children
I went to a Montessori kindergarten and I still got sent to a psychologist for acting out because I wasn't challenged enough. What I needed was a more rigorous curriculum and peers that were on the same level.
greygoo222··on Gifted children are special needs children
Affluent Black or Asian immigrants are typically high-skilled immigrants, a program that, by definition, screens for merit. Merit is heritable.
greygoo222··on Gifted children are special needs children
I preferred to read instead of doing "normal children things" in kindergarten. I acted out so much my teacher forced me to see a psychologist. When I was placed in an appropriately challenging environment, I did much better.
greygoo222··on Mamdani says he would phase out NYC gifted program for early grades
Please make sure your kid gets the enrichment he needs! Many people here would be happy to recommend resources.
greygoo222··on Mamdani says he would phase out NYC gifted program for early grades
Why does it matter if it's innate talent or not? The point is to identify which kids will benefit from accelerated education.
greygoo222··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
Symptoms and side effects can vary a lot between people, you could've gotten unlucky.

> Who is more negatively affected by this behavior: your employer or you?

I like my job. I think I am making the world a better place, and I would choose to do this even if I was wealthy enough to never work. When I am unable to do my job because my ego does not align with my id, it makes me angry and disappointed.

> I do not think there is anything pathological about being a jack-of-all trades type or not committing to some hobby.

Nor do I. I do, however, think there is something pathological about sitting on the floor for three hours doing nothing because you're procrastinating on deciding what book to read next, or debugging a 3D printer, or replying to an invitation (or because you need to shower, or cook, ...). This behavior is not enjoyable at all.

It sounds like you primarily experience ADHD as getting in the way of things you have to do, rather than things you want to do. I'm sure that sucks in its own way, but the grass looks greener from over here.

> Which I believe is direct evidence of how our symptoms affect others and not inherently oneself.

I inherently care about other people, and when I let them down, it makes me sad. Perhaps you prefer to define all instances of your friends having desires and expectations around your relationship as oppression, that when I am upset I missed an important event it is because I am being brainwashed by society. But I think this is a small, selfish way of viewing the world. Many traits can get in the way of being a good friend (surely you know someone who is prone to anger, or envy, or insecurity), and if you are a good friend, you try to mitigate them.

> I would say that I made a deal with the Devil just to feel some sense of respite.

Next time you see the Devil, do me a favor and ask him if he has any other opportunities.

greygoo222··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
Treated for others' benefit? Your opinion has to be in the extreme minority here, at least for ADHD. ADHD is hell. Can't sleep and eat properly, can't focus on your work and hobbies, can't maintain your relationships, constantly losing shit... everyone I know is incredibly grateful to be on medication.
greygoo222··on Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods
You can live your life how you want. What the rest of us eat isn't your business.
greygoo222··on Walmart U.S. moves to eliminate synthetic dyes across all private brand foods
Titanium dioxide is naturally occurring.
greygoo222··on Energy Dept. adds 'climate change' and 'emissions' to banned words list
Using the term "birthing person" in a particular document != banning the term "mother"

How is this even relevant?

greygoo222··on MAID in Canada
People stated they supported the policy after reading a full description of the policy. If you don't trust the paper (whose researchers are anti-euthanasia), the Canadian government found the same results. https://researchco.ca/2023/05/05/maid-canada-2023/

Nobody ever correctly answers questions about legislation, to put it glibly. Any piece of legislation newer than 10 years and more complex than a sentence is not going to pass such a test with the general public. 19.2% knew that terminal illness is not required? I would be shocked if 19.2% could correctly answer a few basic questions about the definition of "terminal illness."

greygoo222··on Reading for pleasure plummets by 40% in the US
Do you think reading in Starbucks doesn't count as reading?
greygoo222··on MAID in Canada
Hippocrates didn't actually write the Hippocratic Oath, which, if this matters to you, also forbids abortion.
greygoo222··on MAID in Canada
73% of Canadians support MAID https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38910003/ 71% of Americans believe doctors should be "allowed by law to end the patient’s life by some painless means if the patient and his or her family request it" https://news.gallup.com/poll/648215/americans-favor-legal-eu...

These policies are supported by a strong majority of people.

← PreviousPage 5 of 5