HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

griffzhowl

1,116 karma · joined April 22, 2020

submissionscomments
griffzhowl··on Essex police pause facial recognition camera use after study finds racial bias
But it doesn't seem like these physical factors would have reversed the effect between 2020 and now. Unless you can think of some?
griffzhowl··on The Feynman Lectures on Physics (1961-1964)
If you're into atomic physics and getting a feel for the intricate structure of the basic processes, the best find I had recently is this MIT course by Wolfgang Ketterle. The first lecture is an informal overview, and he gives vivid and detailed descriptions of the phenomena they can create and control now, like why we see different kinds of thing happening at very low temperatures: the atoms are moving past each other so slowly that it gives their wavefunctions time to overlap and interact, using intersecting lasers to create arrays of dimples in the electromagnetic field to draw in and hold single atoms, this kind of thing. It gives a more tangible insight into the quantum aspects of matter that can otherwise seem inscrutable

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Agu68RGaoWM&list=PLUl4u3cNGP...

He also got the Nobel prize in the 90s for making a Bose-Einstein condensate iirc.

griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
Yeah, soon after I posted this it became clear it's nonsense, a few people in the thread have referred to studies that trees underneath the landslide have been carbon dated to 9400BP, while the book this article's based on claims 5500BP for an "impact"

I mainly posted this because I was beguiled by the images of the disk. I hadn't seen it before, so even these shoddy images were impressive, with the circular form, radially arranged characters and lines looking both ancient and technical. Would you recommend a source for some proper information on it? I'm curious about what it says. Googling I keep coming up with rehashings of this meteor story from websites with "Atlantis" in their names and suchlike.

griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
Very perspicacious remark that it's more likely than five or four... are you an astronautical engineer by any chance?

But I'm wondering about such shallow angles - wouldn't it bounce off the atmosphere or somesuch? Perhaps it's just about possible somehow: just imagine firing a kilometre of rock from a mountain at a six degree angle with enough velocity to get it into orbit, but in reverse.

griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
The plot thickens: a commenter here posted this link, which indicates Ötzi might have been roped in to this story in quite an imaginative way:

"Despite this new evidence, curiously in 2008 the impact hypothesis was revived by some pseudoscientists in connection to supposed observations of a meteorite by the Sumerians or to explain the death of the Iceman as a human sacrifice to prevent a nuclear winter after the impact."

http://historyofgeology.fieldofscience.com/2011/04/landslide...

Unfortunately the sciforums link to discussion of the pseudoscientists is dead

griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
Yeah, it was quite a compelling story, and it's at least a genuinely beautiful and intriguing tablet. The author Hempsell does have some talent though, in seemingly getting a reputable university to publish his book... I'm thinking he was quite canny in finding this attractive untranslated tablet with little else written about it, and then employing enough knowledge about a combination of different subjects (ancient Sumerian, asteroid orbits, Alpine geology) that no single reviewer was able or motivated to properly evaluate all the arguments. Or he just had a friend at the press.
griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
That's cool isn't it? Even to the Akkadians, Sumerian was an ancient language (prehistoric!), that became sacred.

Aren't there also bilingual texts that are used for learning it? Or maybe I'm thinking of different versions of stories, in Sumerian and later Akkadian or Babylonian.

I'm curious how the modern pronunciation is arrived at. Is that a lot of convention and guess work or is it reasonably secure through knowing (approximately) Akkadian pronunciation via other Semitic languages?

griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
Yeah, the meteor story is rubbish. Strange Bristol Uni published this. They're an actual, legitimate, good university.
griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
Yeah, my bad for sharing. I mainly did it for the pictures because it looks spectacular, and just read through the story quickly, looked like book published by Bristol University? But as per references from other comments here, the landslide was ~9400 BP, so a bit earlier than the 5500 BP date proposed in TFA
griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
Thanks for the landslide info! Good to have the proper knowledge. Shame there's no reliable stuff about the tablet. Maybe it hasn't been translated by a sane, competent professional
griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
If you're looking for a source on the landslide, another commenter here posted this, that seems more reliable than wikipedia. Searching for Kofel's impact, rather than landslide, brings up nonsense because there's only pseudo-evidence for that.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01695...

It dates the landslide to about 9400 years ago (BP), so this article about the star map putting it at 5500 years ago seems to be a colourful fabrication (my bad). The author of the meteor theory apparently even tries to connect it to Sodom and Gomorrah being hit by the passing heat! Lol

Finding reliable info on this "planisphere" tablet isn't easy. As far as I can tell it was untranslated and kept a low profile until this impact story

griffzhowl··on Sumerian Star Map Recorded the Impact of an Asteroid (2024)
Ah, oh well. Was an interesting story. But I mainly shared this to remind myself of this incredible star map, or whatever it really is... Seems not easy to find bona fide information on it, maybe because it's untranslated/decoded except for this Kofels' story, which indeed appears to be out of the bounds of likelihood by 4000 years.
griffzhowl··on Waymo robotaxi hits a child near an elementary school in Santa Monica
So you're confidently stating it's not the normal behaviour... Can you tell me what the average speed is for human drivers outside elementary schools at drop-off times?
griffzhowl··on How AI assistance impacts the formation of coding skills
Well, this is exactly the problem. This tactic works until you get to a problem that nobody has solved before, even if it's just a relatively minor one that no one has solved because no one has tried to because it's so specific. If you haven't built up the skills and knowledge to solve problems, then you're stuck.
griffzhowl··on Does Anthropic believe its AI is conscious, or just want Claude to think so?
> in a physical sense free will does not exist

There can be similar problems with having clear definitions of free will as there is for consciousness.

For example, if I define free will as the capacity to formulate and evaluate various plans, and select one to implement, it seems compatible with physics.

griffzhowl··on How wolves became dogs
The wiki article doesn't say domestication occurred roughly 14k years ago, it says at least 14k years ago, because that's the earliest definitive evidence of a domesticated dog. Here are the next two sentences from the wiki article:

"The remains of the Bonn–Oberkassel dog, buried alongside humans between 14,000 and 15,000 years ago, are the earliest to be conclusively identified as a domesticated dog.[9][7] Genetic studies show that dogs likely diverged from wolves between 27,000 and 40,000 years ago."

griffzhowl··on Why didn't AI “join the workforce” in 2025?
True, maybe full formalisation is too strict and the evaluation should be fuzzier
griffzhowl··on Why didn't AI “join the workforce” in 2025?
True, they use the word "reasoning". Part of my point was just to focus on the more concrete concept: the capacity to produce and evaluate arguments.
griffzhowl··on Why didn't AI “join the workforce” in 2025?
Whether the Holy Grail is unreachable or not is the question. Of course, the problem in full generality is hard, but that doesn't mean it can't be approached in various partial ways, either by restricting the inputs as you suggest or by coming up with some kind of evaluation procedures that are less strict than formal verifiability. I don't have any detailed proposals tbh
griffzhowl··on Why didn't AI “join the workforce” in 2025?
> the current algorithms are clearly a dead end for thinking machines.

These discussions often get derailed into debates about what "thinking" means. If we define thinking as the capacity to produce and evaluate arguments, as the cognitive scientists Sperber and Mercier do, then we can see LLMs are certainly producing arguments, but they're weak at the evaluation.

In some cases, arguments can be formalised, and then evaluating them is a solved problem, as in the examples of using the Lean proofchecker in combination with LLMs to write mathematical proofs.

That suggests a way forward will come from formalising natural language arguments. So LLMs by themselves might be a dead end but in combination with formalisation they could be very powerful. That might not be "thinking" in the sense of the full suite of human abilities that we group with that word but it seems an important component of it.

griffzhowl··on Total monthly number of StackOverflow questions over time
A decline in number of questions asked can also be because most people's questions are already answered in the database.

How would you query this for post views over time?

griffzhowl··on [dead]
> A government right now is using its power to selectively defund and wipe out big chunks of scientific research and communications that ultimately exist to protect your future.

This is the significant point. The govt is defunding yet another scientific research institute. To me it seems more productive to get more specific and more substantive from there: How much of the research presently carried out at NCAR will continue? Are there alternative institutes or sources of funding that might save some of it? What are the likely tangible implications? Is the whole place even closing down or just some of it?

Going in the other direction, less specific, more amorphous abstraction about whether or not this is a free speech issue risks derailing the conversation into semantics.

There are interesting questions about wider meaning of free speech than what's protected by the first amendment, but getting moralistic because someone doesn't consider this a free speech issue, while you both agree that it's government defunding a research institute, and that it's bad, seems unnecessarily fractious

griffzhowl··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
Yes, it can easily just mean that he has some kind of inside information about progress that he doesn't want to divulge, but this is still far from "crypto is broken, guize"

Still, if that's true, it's an example of the very thing Scott's talking about: there are advances in the field that aren't being made public.

griffzhowl··on More on whether useful quantum computing is “imminent”
Aaronson says:

> This is the clearest warning that I can offer in public right now about the urgency of migrating to post-quantum cryptosystems...

That has a clear implication that he knows something that he doesn't want to say publically

griffzhowl··on Inca Stone Masonry
> We know that the Inca didn't build Sacsayhuaman because they said that they didn't.

Where are you getting this from? The Spanish chroniclers report Inca tradition that the 15th century leader Pachacuti initiated the building. The wiki article has a few long excerpts from Pedro Cieza de Leon's Cronicas del Peru, including details of how many labourers were involved and some of the methods for quarrying, transporting stone, and construction:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sacsayhuam%C3%A1n

griffzhowl··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
That's funny, I thought Worcestershire sauce was based on some Asian fish sauce because it has the colonial ingredients like tamarind etc. I had a look on wiki and seems it's not known where the recipe comes from but it dates from the 19th century
griffzhowl··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
Amazing, thanks for pointing it out. In the meantime, there's been some rejigging of the classification so it's this related genus where they've found the melanosomes

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huadanosaurus

griffzhowl··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
There might even be a directish connection, one way or the other, between garum and SE Asian fish sauce, since Roman coins have been found in Vietnam.

Can't find the better source on that specifically now but this is a nice article about the Roman trade with India and mentions the coins found in Vietnam and even Korea about half way down

https://www.thecollector.com/why-was-the-roman-indian-ocean-...

On the other hand, it's not implausible that maritime societies come up with their own fish sauce independently

griffzhowl··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
They only started adding feathers after they found evidence of them being feathered, though.

Plus there's zero direct evidence for their colours so there's no option but to use guesswork in these cases.

And a lot of dinosaur reconstructions may be more for edutainment value rather than reflecting a scholarly best-guess. There's no uniform methodology across all these disciplines.

griffzhowl··on Classical statues were not painted horribly
Yes, the suggestion that they're trolling goes too far.

However, I did a tiny bit of investigating, and according to this write-up it does seem like Brinkmann presents his work as resembling the originals

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/true-colors-1788...

But they still don't add anything without direct evidence - where there's evidence in later statues for more subtle colouring, they include that.

← PreviousPage 2 of 17Next →