HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grobbyy

292 karma · joined November 12, 2022

submissionscomments
grobbyy··on Apple Macintosh System Software 7.1 source (m68k and basic PPC)
Deadware should be open source under the law.
grobbyy··on After 10 years, Yelp gave my app 4 days
A good lesson, but a more nuanced one is to do sure diligence. There are companies I would never build my business around (Google, Oracle, etc.) for a variety of reasons. There are ones I know I can trust (at least until they change). There are many where I need a contract.

Change is also a constant, and there are plenty of good companies give bad, and a few in reverse. So due diligence is an ongoing process.

That dramatically raises the price of SaaS, so I use it much less than mainstream industry practice, but much more than zero.

grobbyy··on MIT: The Missing Semester of Your CS Education
IT is easier than CS, but it's a huge amount of knowledge. It just takes the to learn. Enormous accounts of time. Even more practice to be fluent and fluid.

CS has deep theory. IT doesn't.

grobbyy··on Fake job interviews are securities fraud
Explain it like I'm five: I'm a shareholder. I get defrauded. There's a shareholder suit. Where does the money come from?

It feels like we'd be suing ourselves. Wells Fargo defrauded us and if we win, we'll get money back from an entity we own

The might be a little bit of a shuffle with money going from people who bought one year to those who bought another, but for buy and hold, that's pretty moot. It seems like the lawyers are making money at my own expense?

What an I missing?

grobbyy··on AWS Code Commit Ceased Onboarding New Customers
Amazon has a uniquely large spread, in that case.

I use S3, EC2, Route 53, and RDS. That's more or less it. I advise others to do likewise. Not the same set, mind you, but the same mindset.

grobbyy··on AWS Code Commit Ceased Onboarding New Customers
Having been on both sides, it often makes a lot of sense. A lot of companies have surprises requirements in contacts, such as HIPPA or military/classified or whatnot. The cost of adding a new vendor can be astronomical compared to the cost of dealing with CodeCommit.

In truth, though, Amazon should have bought gitlab instead.

grobbyy··on What are the threats to the AI boom?
We have no idea the growth curve here. People make predictions like this, or on the other side, of singularity, but it's all just speculation.

A good approach is to plan on all things, from plateau to linear growth to polynomial to exponential to singularity, as within the realm of possibility.

Or to have the humility to acknowledge that we may be wrong.

grobbyy··on What are the threats to the AI boom?
To expand on your point:

My lesson from the dot com boom is that's it's very hard to pick the winners. For every Amazon, there were a thousand pets.com. Investing in DEC, Sun, Yahoo, and friends would not have paid off.

That's a broader lesson too. I have an okay -- far from perfect but decent -- track record knowing which national economies will grow, but investing in index funds for those economies rarely yields good returns. I have a tiny portion of my portfolio in various developing markets, and the GDP can rise tenfold with no investment gains.

Many very real revolutions have bubbles. Bubbles are the period when people over-invest.

grobbyy··on Perfectionism – one of the biggest productivity killers in the eng industry
Yeah, no. Most software is cludged together with little design and grows organically. Overall, putting on the time to do it right -- if possible -- parts give dividends.

Software done right from 30+ years ago is still in broad use. There is huge value in that

Doing things right involves prototypes, iterations, and experiments, so high velocity is good. However, if a prototype ships, you often get on trouble.

grobbyy··on Girls in Tech closes its doors after 17 years
Gender and physical contact.

I am at close to zero rush within group (creepiness, leading on, sexual harassment, etc.). Same type of casual physical contact across gender groups, and it's a trip to HR or a cancellation.

A lot of language takes on different making across cultures, and there are literally textbooks about how white casual language is perceived as disrespectful in many African American cultures. The reverse is casual African American behavior incorrectly perceived as aggressive in white culture.

I like looking at this in international studies since there is not the baseline baggage of racism or sexism, and Meyer is a good study.

grobbyy··on Girls in Tech closes its doors after 17 years
At the risk of posting a reflexive comment, what should we be doing here? It seems like everything has unintended consequences (not on a cost-benefit basis):

- Minority affinity groups pull people from majority groups and decrease integration.

- Anti-discrimination/sexism/etc. movements often add social barriers to interactions (e.g. things I do within my identity group would be misperceived if done across)

- Affirmative action makes minorities feel like they don't deserve to be there (and often leads to resentment and other consequences)

Progress in the past few decades has been limited, so it seems like we're taking the wrong approach, but I'm don't have a better approach to propose.

Green fields, blue sky, what should we be doing to resolve the historical issues we have around sex, race, socioeconomic status, etc.?

I think looking to countries which made better progress might be helpful....

grobbyy··on FUTO Keyboard
This is very, very confused. It comes off as dishonest, but isn't; it's just the case that the developer doesn't get it. It seems well-meaning, but badly done.

Developer: I am, in all honesty, glad for the experimentation. However, you should understand that critical issues include the ability to remix. I cannot use your code in my project. Ergo, it is not open, free, libre, or similar.

You're better off underselling and overdelivering. The term should also convey what this does. I like "source-auditable" or similar. "Source-first" says nothing.

You should also think about longevity. How do I know the license won't change next week?

grobbyy··on FUTO Keyboard
My gut reaction to the license was exactly OP's -- it felt shady and sleazy.

Then my logic kicked in and I came to the same conclusion you did -- it's not open source, but source-available means people can audit that it's honest. That's a huge win over closed-source, especially for something privacy-focused.

I think the gut feeling comes from a long history of projects using source-available licenses in shady ways. The brain pattern-matches.

That would be good to address upfront. Simply stating "not open source, but source-auditable" might help address this.

Another good thing would be to post the price upfront. Right now, it requires an email to get to which is an antipattern.

These issues are cosmetic (but important).

This looks like a really good project.

grobbyy··on Measure Schools on Student Growth
I'm abstract, you're correct, and a typical setup for an educational experiment is a calibrated pre / post test to see what changed over the course of interacting with an activity. Both tests are effectively identical and measure the same thing.

However, state tests are annual. You don't want to measure the same thing. If you don't measure the same thing, you can't compare.

There are technically non-adaptive test designs which might work, but it's not what we're using, and they're a lot more complex than adaptive.

grobbyy··on Nvidia is now worth $102M per employee
I'd go down to about $2M, which is where MIT was at a quarter century ago, when it was it's prime.

Being answerable to funding sources, tuition, etc. is a good thing. Having money to soon off from is not.

grobbyy··on Nvidia is now worth $102M per employee
Yes. Do you realize how insane this is? A colleague of mine used to have a chart of staff per faculty member at MIT versus time. That figure has gone up around 20-fold on that chart.

It's almost all bloat and overhead made possible by being over capitalized.

grobbyy··on Nvidia is now worth $102M per employee
I think about it the other way. Businesses with high $/revenue per employee, high margin, etc. tend to be fundamentally better managed and more robust.

I'm not claiming that applies to Nvidia either way specifically, but it's a good sign in the generic:

1. They're efficient.

2. They've avoided the curse of overhiring (hi, Google!)

3. They can stay afloat even if business drops a lot.

grobbyy··on Nvidia is now worth $102M per employee
Believe it or not, elite universities are reaching similar heights. MIT is at roughly $20M endowment per faculty member.

All caveats apply. 20≠100, employees might include staff and grad students, etc.

Still, I would never advise anyone to donate to any institution like this.

grobbyy··on YouTube videos are skipping to the end for users with adblockers
> Now tell me how not doing anything to discourage people from blocking YouTube ads supports Google's long term interests

Google maintains a monopoly and their brand. Profits are entire the of percent lower by the few power users who use all blockers. Big-O profits remain similar.

That contrasts with real competition, brand loss, or monopoly loss. That can lead to astronomically lower profits.

grobbyy··on Measure Schools on Student Growth
I can elaborate a little bit but not a lot since that would be essay-length. I can simplify and explain roughly.

The short story is that most states assessments are designed almost as binary measures, to see if students are above or below a cutoff threshold set by Common Core State Standards. They're designed to measure schools, and in particular, to flag failing schools where kids aren't meeting standards.

They're very good at that, actually.

However, that's almost meaningless as a measure for kids well above or below standards, or unaligned to standards.

"Growth" is almost meaningless here. If I know one number is less than three and another less than four, I can't subtract them.

It's more mathematically fancy, but that's the jist. It gets even worse since measures constructs are highly multidimensional and different dimensions are measured each year. It's like subtracting apples from oranges.

It also encourages the wrong behavior. For kids behind, I'll get the best "growth" by discussing on grade level material and leaving gaps for what kids failed to learn before. I'll also do well to ignore my students who are ahead. Indeed, students who did week last year will inevitably hurt my "growth."

As a footnote, I would not call this a strong claim. Talk to a psychometrician and you'll see it's common knowledge.

If adaptive tests move beyond those few states, the problem goes away.

grobbyy··on Measure Schools on Student Growth
Problem is most states assessments can't measure growth and "growth measures" are numerically nonsense.

Growth measures do exist, but they require adaptive tests.

grobbyy··on YouTube videos are skipping to the end for users with adblockers
I think Yahoo or HP would be the most likely candidates.

HP is at about a fifth of it's peak market cap, largely as a result of a similar play.

I'd short Google, but there's an old saying that markets can be irrational far longer than an individual wallet can sustain a short....

grobbyy··on YouTube videos are skipping to the end for users with adblockers
This is a strawman.

No one is suggesting Google should encourage anything. Openly user-hostile actions devalue brand and trust. That's doubly-true for power users who are thought leaders.

If Walmart has store security shoot suspected shoplifters and unionizers with a 9mm, discontinuing that policy would not be encouraging unions or shoplifting.

grobbyy··on YouTube videos are skipping to the end for users with adblockers
Google has entered into a phase where short term profits outweigh long term growth.

If you're a startup, don't do this. Maximizing the growth exponent does a lot more than tweaks on per-user revenue. Intentionally annoying users is bad business.

When companies do this, it's also good to look at PE ratios, since it suggests they don't anticipate growth.

grobbyy··on Micron Ships Crucial-Branded LPCAMM2 Memory Modules: 64GB of LPDDR5X for $330
64gb is an impressive amount to fit on an LP. Come to think of it, I should back up my ZX Spectrum magnetic tapes to LPs for archival storage.
grobbyy··on TimeGPT: Production Ready Time Series Foundation Model for Forecasting
Closed-source. I'm not sure why this is interesting. ML API companies hoping to hit it rich are a dime a dozen.

With the exception of a few like OpenAI, I can't imagine much success over open source models.

If it can genuinely predict stocks, start a hedge fund.

grobbyy··on StackOverflow is banning accounts that delete answers in protest against OpenAI
This is where GDPR and friends should come in. If they won't do it the friendly way, they should do it the hard way.

Lawyers are a little more expensive than handling a click, especially at scale.

grobbyy··on YouTube's Legal Team sent me a letter [video]
It's more complex. If my app causes someone else to violate ToS, it's very much on realm of the types of things which lead to expensive litigations as I've seen in related domains.

It's dumb, but that's the legal system.

grobbyy··on YouTube's Legal Team sent me a letter [video]
I agree. However, YouTube's legal argument would be tortious interference. As much as that's a stupid concept, it might be enforced.

That might be a good reason not to have a legal entity in the US but a jurisdiction with more sensible laws.

grobbyy··on U.S. to require automatic emergency braking on new vehicles in 5 years
I would encourage you to look more closely. Safest mainstream car is Chevy Bolt which (1) isn't bought by douchebags to show off (2) does 0-60 on 6.6 seconds, on par with muscle cars, exactly as I described.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →