HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grobbyy

292 karma · joined November 12, 2022

submissionscomments
grobbyy··on U.S. to require automatic emergency braking on new vehicles in 5 years
In the situation described, I already charged lanes to avoid the toddler / deer / stopped car.

The question is what I do about the incoming car I didn't notice.

A) change back and hit the toddler

B) do nothing, and have a fatal head-on collision

C) hit the brakes, and have a non-fatal head-on collision

D) speed up a little bit, so I can get back into my lane before the other car gets here

grobbyy··on Google surpasses $2T market cap
If I had infinite dollars and an infinite lifespan, I would. As is, my wallet isn't likely to be able to keep to with an irrational market, and my risk tolerance curve is very conservative.

Unless I hit jackpot, mo shorts for me (in general, not just Google)!

grobbyy··on U.S. to require automatic emergency braking on new vehicles in 5 years
Never been in the path of a speeding police car or ambulance rushing to an emergency from behind you and wanted to get out of the way at the next intersection, just 100m ahead?

Statistics didn't support you. Look at deaths per mile for vehicles. The worst ones are lumbering hulks which can't do avoidance maneuvers.

grobbyy··on U.S. to require automatic emergency braking on new vehicles in 5 years
I think there are soft mechanisms which could enforce speed limits which would need both needs.

Even an obnoxious beeper like for seatbelts.

I prefer the seatbelt beeper to having seatbelts which won't unfasten until the car has come to a complete stop, or cars which don't start without seatbelts. Not everything needs to be enforced with force.

grobbyy··on U.S. to require automatic emergency braking on new vehicles in 5 years
You're passing a broken-down vehicle, a deer that hoped into the road, a toddler, or otherwise go into the opposite lane. There is an incoming car, and you need to merge back before a head-on collision, without hitting whatever you're passing.

Floor it and merge.

I can name many other scenarios, but generally, emergency maneuvers are helped by good control over the car, including braking, turning, and acceleration.

There are nice charts showing accidents per million miles driven by car, and the best ones I've seen are anyone, but not testosterone-promoting agile. Crash ratings are misleading since many of the safest cars in a crash also crash a lot more often and have higher fatalities overall since bigger cars are less likely to be able to avoid an accident.

grobbyy··on U.S. to require automatic emergency braking on new vehicles in 5 years
No. It's not. Pushing down car ownership might be good, but not based on wealth. Priority should go to elderly, people with disabilities, people with kids, etc.

Even so, the goal shouldn't be fewer cars but less miles driven.

The kind of antagonistic approach you prescribe rarely leads to good policy.

grobbyy··on U.S. to require automatic emergency braking on new vehicles in 5 years
Because it would make roads less safe.

It's very common to need to *accelerate* in emergency situations.

Something like smart cruise control which drives the speed limit would be appreciated. A hard cap would not.

grobbyy··on FCC fines largest wireless carriers for sharing location data
I have mixed feelings about opt in. A single accidental click on a web site and GDPR has failed to protect the user. Dark patterns allow that to be gamed. And it complicates legitimate uses.

I'd like auditable data. I should have an easy way to discover everyone with my data (including things like IP logs), see how it's used (at the level of source), and have it destroyed.

grobbyy··on Google surpasses $2T market cap
I never said yearly. I said total profits. If you want to be technical about it, sum of discounted future profits.

People in this thread are also confusing revenue, gross income, and net income.

People in this thread are also giving other companies, but those may be overvalued as well. Companies have a finite (if long) lifespan. If market cap is more than total discounted future income, it's overvalued. If it's less, it's undervalued. It's just a question of when the market corrects.

grobbyy··on Google surpasses $2T market cap
What's interesting to me are:

- market cap

- random layoffs

- overstaffing

- falling competence

A lot of frictions build in there. I'm curious how it will play out.

I tend to translate market cap for big companies into dollars per person. 8 billion people in the world, so Google expects $250 profit per human being in average to be accurately valued.

That feels high, but what do I know?

grobbyy··on Amazon Workdocs End of Life
I genuinely wanted to. It was just too bad to be useable.
grobbyy··on Redis re-implemented with SQLite
I can tell you my use case. I have a lot of systems which I'd like to use on a single computer AND at scale.

That's sometimes even just for development work.

A lot of these use a common API to a more complex distributed store, as well as to something simple like files on disk, in memory, or SQLite.

I'm most cases, it's one user at a time, so performance doesn't matter, but simplicity does.

It can also be for the project which has a 1 percent chance of going viral.

Etc. But I find relatively few cases between truly small scale and large scale.

grobbyy··on Summers: Inflation Reached 18% in 2022 Using the Government's Previous Formula
I think the argument is that inflation is complicated by globalism.
grobbyy··on Show HN: My $1k self-install, off-grid solar backup build for renters
My experience is that power banks and UPSes fail more often than my power.

I keep a couple charged, but with nothing plugged in. I sometimes plug things in before a major storm, planned outage, or after an unplanned one.

grobbyy··on Show HN: I made a new sensor out of 3D printer filament for my PhD
This has inspired about a hundred ideas in my head. Thank you!

(They're all ways which on paper seem like I might be able to do things better, but if the sort where 95% don't pan out in practice. Everything from machine learning algorithms to identify shapes to fancy encoding with spectra of what reflects along the path to other ways to engineer changes in the path)

grobbyy··on Elon Musk's reputation is falling – and it's taking Tesla with it
I don't think Elon is either the devil or a saint. He just happens to be over of the few people at his level without a filter.

Everyone has weird and extreme views somewhere on some topic. Most just won't express them.

grobbyy··on 'Amazon "search through reviews" is blindly just running an AI model now'
Because they're language models and not truth models. Buying stuff, incorrect information can be harmful.
grobbyy··on Physical cash is dying–and you don't need to be a conspiracist to worry
Take out $10k every few years....
grobbyy··on Physical cash is dying–and you don't need to be a conspiracist to worry
Last I looked, checks had privacy regulations. Most other payment methods don't really. I'm also my bank's customer. For most payment companies, I'm the product.
grobbyy··on Physical cash is dying–and you don't need to be a conspiracist to worry
Because it's basically no resources. If they're not doing it now, they'll be doing it in a few years, and if not banned, selling the data.

It's literally adding a 50 cent camera to a cash register.

grobbyy··on Physical cash is dying–and you don't need to be a conspiracist to worry
You fell for a simple fallecy. The line isn't that cash is used in a major crime. It's that someone in power wants someone in prison.

1. You might not be involved in a major crime but you might be a suspect. Lots of innocent suspects get convicted.

2. You might be a whistleblower. Lots of whistleblowers get framed.

Etc.

"If I've done nothing wrong I have nothing to hide" didn't work out well for Soviet Russia or Nazi Germany.

A lot of the reason many of us want privacy preserved is to prevent a similar path here. Totalitarian governments don't always pop up overnight on a revolution; they often creep up on you.

The creeping process is also often:

1. We'll track X with major checks on privacy; it will only be used for terrorism and child abuse investigations and held in a secure vault

2. We're just doing a better job of sharing / using data we already collect

Neither off those is objectionable, but together, you end up in a distopia.

grobbyy··on Contra Wirecutter on the IKEA air purifier (2022)
My experience is Wirecutter recommended process products most of the time, and isn't very clueful in how it evaluates them. It's that's Sharper Image vibe.

Best air filter would use standard home furnace filters. Those are cheap and good enough. Most of the money should be on the fan. High efficieny, high load, low noise fans are expensive.

grobbyy··on T-Mobile introduce fines from Jan 1 for "Code of Conduct" violations
FAANG wasn't about size but about things like salary, benefits, and looking good on a resume.

Microsoft is doing better now, but it's employment conditions aren't the same as FAANG (and no where near the luxuries of when it was coined).

grobbyy··on Ask HN: What prevents Google from having the leading LLM?
It's a huge Google disadvantage. Everyone reliant on NVidia has an ecosystem. Google has internal systems which are expensive to maintain and generally worse than best-of-breed systems.

Google can't leverage the progress everyone else makes.

Google might even reach above average, but they'll still be behind market leaders. AMD and Intel are playing on this space too and it's hard for Google to beat all of them. Everyone else can just use the current winner.

grobbyy··on Judge: Amazon "cannot claim shock" that bathroom spycams were used as advertised
I like having a Wild West, but it should be clearly advertised as such. AliExpress and eBay are clearly Wild West platforms and I appreciate them.

Getting scammed on Amazon is different. Amazon should be fully liable since very sophisticated customers can be confused by commingling, marketplace settlers, algorithmic recommendations, etc. all designed to look legitimate to the unwary while being completely unsafe.

I stopped buying food and medical products on Amazon because... scams.

grobbyy··on Beating GPT-4 with a 13B model
It's possible to say that in two sentences, without a clickbait title.
grobbyy··on Beating GPT-4 with a 13B model
I hate the clickbait title combined with the obvious result....

I have read papers like this which were good, and mostly consisted of fine-tuning, combined with a few tricks to achieve high performance in large but specific domains.

This was a waste of my life. I want the minutes of reading this and of writing this comment back.

grobbyy··on Blender 4.0 release notes
It's not a historical curiosity. The decisions needed to make an architecture viable on the long term happen early on and need to be sustained as code is being developed.

A lot of that comes down to days structures used, system modules, abstractions, If that's done right, it's possible to make a good UX later.

That's very hard in modern software processes which emphasize short term spirits.

grobbyy··on Azure dropping database support for MariaDB. Users advised to migrate to MySQL
I generally pick AWS, but Azure is a close second and we use it for specific things too. Aside from GPT access, Microsoft gets compliance right. Working with medical, military, or some types of educational, Azure is a better choice.

I like that things I did over a decade ago on AWS still work. I don't like that Google throws me on the curb every few months. Azure is in between, but closer to AWS. 95% of the cost is maintenance, so AWS > Azure >> Google.

grobbyy··on DOJ finally posted that “embarrassing” court doc Google wanted to hide
Perhaps. I don't think this reflects anything unethical on the part of Google, but it does represent that market dynamics aren't working.

The point of antitrust isn't so much to punish bad people as to make for efficient markets.

Under mainstream economic theory, Google ought to be regulated. That's good for everyone, Google employees and most Google investors included (by numbers and not dollars; most Google investors hold diverse portfolios).

If the industry and economy as a whole grow, at the expense of Google, both my overall investments and my job options improve.

Corporations aren't human beings with moral rights, and laws are there to keep them beneficial and efficient, but to preserve some abstract corporate freedom.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →