359 karma · joined August 26, 2015
- Paraphrasing n=7 words (and quite a few more) within a sentence can easily be fair use.
- As n gets big, the bloom filter has to also.
If/when attribution is solved for LLMs (and not fake attribution like from Bing or Perplexity) then creators can be compensated when their works are used in AI outputs. If compensation is high enough this can greatly incentivize creativity, perhaps to the point of realizing "free culture" visions from the late 90s.
However, the suit goes far beyond claiming that such copying violates their copyright: "Unauthorized copying of Times Works without payment to train LLMs is a substitutive use that is not justified by any transformative purpose."
This is a strong claim that just downloading articles into training data is what violates the copyright. That GTP outputs verbatim copies is a red herring. Hopefully the judge(s) will notice and direct focus on the interesting, high-stakes, and murky legal issues raised when we ask: What about a model can (or can't) be "transformative"?
> Nothing at all. It distracts me from my family, friends, work, and myself.
> I have no interesting insights or original thoughts about it, and if I did,
> absolutely no one would care. So why read it?
Do you vote or participate in politics in any way or do events in the news directly affect your life? One reason it's rational to read the news: If you don't read the news, then you're at risk of lacking important contextual knowledge about society and social norms. It's pragmatic to keep track of these conversations to avoid embarrassment and to not behave in ways that might offend others. I find it useful to be aware of contentious issues on which I might have a side or a stake.
So I'll still get my colonoscopy, thanks