HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grues-dinner

1,956 karma · joined July 24, 2024

submissionscomments
grues-dinner··on Microsoft only lets you opt out of AI photo scanning 3x a year
If the key remains on the users device but under the control of the app, does that count as out of control of the app?

Maybe you'd have to force the user to export the key to an external file (and forget the path) or encrypt it with some mechanism that the app isn't in control of.

grues-dinner··on People regret buying Amazon smart displays after being bombarded with ads
Nice deal for Amazon because they get to double-dip as the same device served ads for some time for the first owner and then they still get the ad-free uplift eventually.

Maybe one day they'll turn it into an yearly thing to avoid ads.

grues-dinner··on Indonesia says 22 plants in industrial zone contaminated by caesium 137
It's also used as a gamma source for metallurgical testing. Which is what the sources that caused the recent Thai and Russian incidents were used for.
grues-dinner··on Why a maker of spark plugs and wiper blades has Wall Street worried
To be fair, economists can only guess in this situation. If you want them to be confident why they were wrong today about what happened yesterday, you must wait for tomorrow.
grues-dinner··on I tracked Amazon's Prime Day prices. We've been played
No I mean it's better that they give you the option to come back later than not allowing it and you wasting one in (failed) pursuit of the "good deal", but overall they've engineered a few million in a distributed free loan by doing that. It's a smart move and works out well for everyone (but not as good for the customer as just selling the one at the average price, of course).

There's a reason so many companies like to make it easy for you to top up some kind of prepayment account or otherwise hold benefits for you. Not only is it a free float, but it keeps bringing customers back.

grues-dinner··on I tracked Amazon's Prime Day prices. We've been played
Multiplied by all customers, it could be quite a bit. It's may be better than having to take both items home and wasting one, but I bet the accountants are quite happy about their little free money fund.

It's also quite a "safe" loan to have because not only is it free to hold, you're probably never going to need to repay it all at once.

grues-dinner··on I tracked Amazon's Prime Day prices. We've been played
So an interest-free loan to the store, plus a penalty if you don't make a return visit.

Then again, is food is inflating faster than the interest rates, then you could still come out ahead!

grues-dinner··on The product of the railways is the timetable
Indeed, it's possible. It's probably a mutual thing, and the existing rail-centrism of London would certainly have helped fuel the financialisation of the UK economy. You couldn't build Canary Wharf if no one could get to it.

London always had the better railway lines anyway, privatisation or not. In particular, radial London commuter lines mostly escaped the Beeching cuts. Post-industrial financialisation in London was the crown jewel of the 90s economic strategy. So it feels (feels/reals alert) unlikely that it was specifically the railways being private that led to the boom, but injecting private investment right then could well have been some grease on the wheels.

Of course every private cash injection comes with the long term squeeze as the initial YoY becomes hard to sustain over decades.

grues-dinner··on The product of the railways is the timetable
I agree privatisation did indeed cause a massive revamp of train usage, and I feel like the nostalgia is sometimes rose-tinted and misplaced because 80s BR by all accounts was pretty bad even in the context of the UK in the 80s.

On the other hand, from about the 90s onwards there was a huge increase in London employment relative to the rest of the country, and also a huge (5x or more over that time) house price increase in London. This pushed a lot of people into the commuter belt. and As you basically cannot drive into London from there, those miles can only be provided by rail.

It would be interesting to know how much of the effect is in the South east, and how much is showing labour migration into a rail-centric region after industrial sectors outside the South-east were dynamited in the 80s.

And privatisation does usually have a cycle: influx of cheap capital in a boom phase, followed by a slow ratching squeeze as you struggle to exceed that great initial growth every year thereafter.

grues-dinner··on X-ray scans reveal the hidden risks of cheap batteries
In theory for something like a CE marked power adapter, a manufacturer should be prepared to be challenged on why they feel able to certify it. For example, they could present their testing certificates from some testing lab and show that they haven't changed anything that would materially affect the results.

I suspect that some manufacturers do not get challenged on that nearly as often as they should when they sell into channels like Temu and no-name importers. And so they can skate away with just not doing the certs, so they don't need to do the design work to meet them, and so they don't do it. If anyone asks, you just just don't sell to them.

Whereas if they sell, say, 500k units to Costco, they will be required to produce that paperwork because Costco is taking on the liability in the market and they can't just vamoose when something explodes.

It doesn't always work: things that have been "correctly" CE-marked sometimes do turn out to be unsafe and get recalled, but I suspect the real problems are things where the CE mark is fake and no one is stamping on heads in the way that UL does if you take their name in vain. Once it is known that testing and certification is statistically optional as long as you sell to the right channels, someone will do it unless they are stopped.

grues-dinner··on LLMs are mortally terrified of exceptions
The protagonists are libertarians with teenage harems, who fake an election and team up with with a sex pest. That's extremely reductive to the point of parody, but that will likely be the media coverage of it then moment someone reads the women and politics in the book.

If you completely excise anything too distasteful for a current-day blockbuster, but want a film about a space mining colony uprising you might as well just adapt the game Red Faction instead: have the brave heros blasting away with abandon at corpo guards, mad genetic experimenters and mercenaries and the media coverage can talk about how it's a genius deconstruction of Elon Musk's Martian dream or whatever.

grues-dinner··on The government ate my name
These days they're more likely to a splitting groups up on purpose to encourage juicy "known seat" upgrades.

A 20 euro-plus per seat each-way tax on people with insecure partners.

grues-dinner··on A small number of samples can poison LLMs of any size
There's already AI poisoning spam. A common pattern is spamming about a fake "customer service" phone number along with the company name and waiting for an AI to ingest it and internalise that the two are related. Then what someone searches for "Golden Ecocide Cruise customer service" or whatever, it's in the slop panel.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2025/08/15/google-...

grues-dinner··on X-ray scans reveal the hidden risks of cheap batteries
> It's just a self declaration.

Without registering every minute product variation with a testing certificate, how else would you handle this though? As much as I think regulators should be swinging the axe more than they do, from an engineering perspective it's impossible to actually do unless everything is locked down ISO 9001-style, especially for electronics and doubly so when software is in the mix.

Lying on a self-declaration should always be taken very seriously, but I feel like it often isn't. For example, if Amazon is found to have fake-CE marked good for sale after it's been reported to them, the penalties should make even their eyes water and have their responsible people shuffling nervously.

There's a limited amount you can do for Temu direct-shipped deathtraps (I suppose if you went to an tech-brained extreme, you could use the x-rays of packages at the border that they already do and have something like AI-based statistical recognition of known-bad products). But there's also not nothing you can do if you really cared. For example, you could imagine a registry of every single tested-bad product, photos of it, where it came from, known aliases, sightings in the wild and so on.

> And back then there was also this weird "China Export" logo

I am pretty sure that is a myth. It's just a sloppy, not-quite-to-spec logo. There is no China Export scheme. Maybe it was a sneaky deliberate way to avoid being hit with a "fake CE mark" charge but instead argue it's "no CE mark", but in either case it's not a legal product if the product needed a CE mark in the first place.

Not hammering down on that hard and fast is what allows that kind of thing. Recall the products you see with that and the retailers and importers would quickly get the message. Test products preemptively and publish the results. Allow it to fester and you get problems and people actually die.

grues-dinner··on X-ray scans reveal the hidden risks of cheap batteries
> If the manufacturers are not held accountable

How does a customer of a retailer hold a manufacturer accountable when they have no relationship with said manufacturer?

> But most of the time, retailers are just selling products they think customers will want to buy.

I don't think retailers are nearly as helpless or unwitting as that. Amazon definitely know they have unsafe products on the shelves no matter how dumb they may play.

> The retailers are the front line for returns as that's the point of contact for the customer

They're also the front line for consumer safety reporting, by law. All companies (not only retailers, actually) have a statutory duty to report unsafe consumer goods, even in the US, and not only for CPC/GCC certified goods. When a customer reports an unsafe product to their retailer, the retailer should forward this information, along with batch codes, origins, sourcing information etc (which the customer obviously will not know). This is the early-warning system that leads to things like recalls, withdrawals and so on, before something causes widespread harm.

grues-dinner··on X-ray scans reveal the hidden risks of cheap batteries
Because retailers take the legal responsibility for what they sell to the public. In the same way statutory returns go to the retailer, not the manufacturer (unless the manufacturer has volunteered an extra warranty to use on top). They can take it up with the manufacturers if they want.

The customer doesn't enter into a contract with the manufacturer when they buy an item from a retailer. They do so with the retailer.

Which is not to say the agencies shouldn't also ban the product from the market. But that doesn't absolve the retailer of their duties.

grues-dinner··on X-ray scans reveal the hidden risks of cheap batteries
Kind of crazy that retailers of these things don't get absolutely hammered into the ground by national testing agencies.

It's called a CE mark or equivalent, there is already a system, penalties and tests.

grues-dinner··on Doctorow: American tech cartels use apps to break the law
> By design Android/iOS does not enable users to deny internet access to specific apps.

It does seem like the number one permission you might wish to choose not to grant, doesn't it?

In a privacy-first design there could also be an API for an encrypted channel that the user has access to, rather than allowing the device to send mysterious black-box data from your device on your behalf in the background whenever it wants. Though I suppose it would just turn into base64 "plaintext" payloads quickly and become normalised rather than a neon sign of fuckery afoot.

grues-dinner··on Synology reverses policy banning third-party HDDs
> Can you believe that? They’ll buy anything we tell them to.

Sounds very much like "doing a Ratner": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerald_Ratner

grues-dinner··on Everything Is Becoming a Bank
> Well, that's hyperbolic

It's also a bit misleading because if you included every company that holds onto pre-paid customer money as the denominator, Starbucks may be be way lower down.

My energy company at some point managed to get four-figures of my money in their bank account as "credit" before I could get it back.

Games companies where you buy "tokens" for in game use also must be sitting on huge reserves. And any business that sells you "packages" up front, from hairdressers to IVF (probably individually quite small, though).

In China, almost every restaurant and shop has a membership program where you get discounts for topping up certain amounts. When you have 500 in the account and your meal is 145.63, there's often a small interest-free loan to the business sitting there.

grues-dinner··on Everything Is Becoming a Bank
I have opened several cards over time. I assume they also correlate with the payment card ID (and maybe facial recognition these days).

I also hope my use of random names and emails for captive portal logins is annoying someone somewhere. Tip for anyone looking: its rare you need to give a real email, because if you need to get on the WiFi, they can't really assume you can receive an email until you do.

At least, when I do see ads, they seem very untargeted generic to me so hopefully the algorithms are struggling to lock on!

grues-dinner··on Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first half of 2025
Reducing companies to a stock price has always seemed similar to me. Especially when they so often jump about by big percentages in a day.

There's 10,000 people and 200 facilities in 32 countries and suddenly that's all worth 10% more, no, 6% less, wait, it's holding in a reverse double-sigma split backflip indication, it'll be up when the markets open. Head explode.gif.

grues-dinner··on Removing these 50 objects from orbit would cut danger from space junk in half
Best I can do is this very old card I found for a Mr von Braun, I think it is. It's in a very, um, spiky font.
grues-dinner··on Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first half of 2025
> how in your face it is due to the hype cycle,

I'm really struggling with this one. I think AI (generative and not) is surely fascinating. I should by rights be all up in it. I could definitely get it, I don't think I'm stupid in terms of technology. Regardless of the damage the laser-focus on one thing might (or might not) be doing to rest of industry (and the effect on society, which to be honest, I am conflicted on if we can blame the technology). And yet so much of it is all so...tedious and fake somehow, and just even keeping up with headlines is exhausting let along engaging with every LinkedIn "next huge thing that if you don't do you should find a bridge to live under soon".

It's like that guy who tells you constantly how rich and cool he is. Bro, if you're that cool, let your cool speak for itself. But I'm not sure I want to lend you a grand for your new car.

grues-dinner··on Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first half of 2025
It just goes to show how little information there really is about what will happen here. Literally no one knows. It's uncharted territory, but it's filled with map-sellers.

Another good example is railways in the US. That was an huge, huge boom, around a fifth of GDP. No one knew what the railway-based economy of the 1900s would look like but it was surely going to be spectacular. All that money! The speed! The cargo! All those people! Railways absolutely were a commerce multiplier, and made stacks of revenue very quickly and got investment from around the world to build build build. But, eventually, the (over)building was done, there were bankruptcies and consolidations and it ultimately did not become the dominant industry. And yet, it's still a big industry that enables a lot of other economic activity. Trains are still expensive to operate, but moving goods is pretty cheap. Obviously there's a natural physical monopoly at play there that AI doesn't have so again, who knows.

Which leads to another thought the AI investors, both commercial and national, maybe should eventually have: is there an automobile or airliner to their railway?

grues-dinner··on Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first half of 2025
It's a spectrum of possibilities upon which, as yet, no one is sure where it will land. Invested proponents say it will eat the world. Sceptics say it's all a crock of shit. Anyone who says they know the answer, doesn't.

The two positions there aren't really different, they're mostly that the profitability of AI can be eroded from several sides. One: the cost to run (power and hardware) being high and bring unable to recover it from revenue. Or two, commoditisation and efficiencies (which can also be operational convenience rather than only about power) driving down costs and therefore also revenue, and being unable to compensate by selling more AI more cheaply. Three: AI didn't actually help as many people make money as hoped and thus they don't want to pay, also depressing revenue.

In the middle is the three-axis happy AI place where costs are not too high, but also AI is too hard to have someone else do it cheaper, and it's useful enough to be paid for.

My guess is AI ending up roughly as impactful overall as cloud computing. A big industry, makes a lot of money, touches and enables very many businesses but hasn't replaced the entire economy, profitable especially if you can stake out a moat, with low-margin battlegrounds for the price-sensitive.

grues-dinner··on Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first half of 2025
I'm not saying they won't (the "if" is an important word in the sentence), it's just that datacentre growth is not the same as AI growth. It's related, but it is, by definition, temporary as datacentres are soon completed.

There's obviously evidence people use LLMs. That's not necessarily the same as people paying a noticeable fraction of all their money to use them in perpetuity. And even if "normal" people do start taking out $50 subscriptions as a matter of course, commoditisation could push that price down as could "dumping" of cheap models from overseas. A breakthrough in being able to run "good enough" models very cheaply, or even locally, would also make expensive cloud AI subscriptions a hard sell. And expensive subscriptions are the only way this pans out.

It hasn't yet been shown that AI is a gas that will fill all the available capacity, and keep it filled. If bread were 10 times cheaper, would you buy 10x as much? That has more or less happened to food availability in the West over the last 200 years and OpenBread and BunVidia don't dominate the economy.

None of that is sure to happen, and maybe the AI hype train is right and huge expensive LLMs specifically drive a gigantic productivity boom¹ and are worth, say, 0.2*GDP forever. But if it isn't, and it turns out $5 a month gets you all people actually need, it's going to be untidy.

¹: in which case, why is GDP not growing from the AI we already have?

grues-dinner··on Without data centers, GDP growth was 0.1% in the first half of 2025
Building the datacentres may be massively "productive" in GDP terms (servers! GPU! Power plants! Electrical inspection!), but when they're completed, that activity will cease. Datacentres don't employ many people directly and mostly consume only electricity.

So if the action of datacentre building shows up as essentially the only GDP growth, but what later happens in the datacentres fails to take its place or exceed it, there will be a dip.

Whether LLMs grinding away can prop up all GDP growth from now on remains to be seen. People use them when they're free, but people also collected AOL discs for tree decorations because they were free.

grues-dinner··on Everything Is Becoming a Bank
I often think of them as a tax on people who don't want to carefully tailor their shopping to line up with shifting "deals" across supermarket chains and over time and those who don't have enough storage-times-consumption to benefit from buy-n-get-one-free on kilo packs of margarine.

I don't think they are identical as such, because my impression is that points would not routinely exceed 5% of your overall shopping unless you got lucky or shopped very carefully, but these days "savings" from avoiding the punishment price regularly accounts for 5-10 pounds out of 100 pounds of shopping. Though maybe more people use the cards now to avoid it so it does average out.

grues-dinner··on Eliminating contrails from flying could be cheap
Fair enough, it was pedantic. But the distinction is exactly where conspiracists come unstuck.
← PreviousPage 2 of 22Next →