HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grues-dinner

1,956 karma · joined July 24, 2024

submissionscomments
grues-dinner··on Standard Thermal: Energy Storage 500x Cheaper Than Batteries
7000 * 25t / 2.5t/m^3 = 70,000m^3 of water. So about 1% of the water storage of Dinorwig, which runs dry in about 6 hours of use.

Now, I know reservoirs are ecologically pretty iffy, expensive and obviously geographically sensitive, so you can't slap them around everywhere. But all these mechanical schemes have big "look what they need to mimic a fraction of our power" vibes!

I could imagine that steel-on-steel block movements could actually be quite efficient and effective in limited scenarios, but logistically it just seems like a lot of squeeze for not a lot of juice considering how much power is required to be stored for utility-scale projects. I would like to say that that they're just delusional people truly hoping it'll work, but I think there's a core of hard-nosed scammers who smell money for a shiny PPT and a plausible-to-non-engineers Wile E. Coyote/Troll Physics contraption with big numbers in the brochure: 7000 blocks! 25 tonnes per block! Megajoules! Efficiencies! Scale! Repurposed coal mining infrastructure! They even have AI in the spiel now: https://www.energyvault.com/solutions/software

Or maybe it'll work and I'll look stupid in 30 years when there are huge fields of hundreds of kilometre-deep boreholes with 100 kilotonne masses moving up and down in them. But somehow it seems quite unlikely on a practical level considering the cost of boring gigantic holes that you'd have to do to make it scale. Onsies-twosie installations in a few mines here and there may work for lucky outlying towns, but they aren't civilisational scale solutions.

grues-dinner··on Standard Thermal: Energy Storage 500x Cheaper Than Batteries
It's the same scam selling ideas that sound good to people who don't understand what a "joule" as Pavegen and the other systems that generate energy from footfall or passing cars. Mechanical energy is pretty "low grade" as energy goes.

It 100% works, but it's a system that has very specific applications and doesn't scale up well. And the best systems use a magical property of some fairly heavy materials called "being liquid" to simplify the logistics of getting millions of tonnes of weight to the lifting mechanism.

grues-dinner··on Is 4chan the perfect Pirate Bay poster child to justify wider UK site-blocking?
> No one likes hearing hypocrisy from politicians

Cambridge Analytica showed politicians in real time that on a population scale, hypocrisy doesn't make any difference. In fact people will bend themselves around to square the circle.

Politicians finally knowing for a demonstrable, data-backed, evidence-based fact that they can do basically whatever they want and keep their support as long as they just say they right things is what has brought us from 2016 to now.

grues-dinner··on Is 4chan the perfect Pirate Bay poster child to justify wider UK site-blocking?
He says he's against the OSA but he's also funded by religious right nutters who think it's a great first step. So if/when he gets into power, don't expect anything better to replace it. Not that I would expect him to uphold a single promise: as I understand it, Reform doesn't even commit to a formal manifesto, anyway.
grues-dinner··on 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC
The UK has been effectively a two party system anyway within living memory (Labour and Tories). Only rarely (e.g. 2010) does the token third party, the Lib Dems) get to be in coalition, and I think no one else has won anything since 1910.

In a monkey's paw moment for everyone who dislikes only having effectively two parties to choose from, this may soon be changing as Reform is poised to overtake the Tories.

grues-dinner··on How to Draw a Space Invader
> Inspired by Jared Tarbell

Such a huge part of my early dabbling with computers. A jewel of the early internet, along with the later http://complexification.net, though sadly most of the examples don't run any more due to both Flash (Levitated) and Java (Complexification) dying off.

At least for Complexification, you can copy-paste the Processing .pde source to https://hello.processing.org/editor/#editor and see it run.

grues-dinner··on Porn censorship is going to destroy the internet
I mean, if you will peddle that cornography...
grues-dinner··on Ballot Hand Counts Lead to Inaccuracy
Hand counts and paper in the UK too. It's just not a problem you need to solve with machines, and while UK politics is deeply stupid, flawed and unserious in many ways, at least this endless, endless bullshit and screeching over chads and machines and hacking and conspiracies and all the other nonsense the cousins get up to is not part of it.

Results don't take long to count, even though there are about 30 million ballots. Polls close at 10pm, the first constituency declares some time between 11 and midnight usually, it's 90% done by about 6am[1], and the last will be some time on the second day if there are multiple recounts. Due to the FPTP system, it doesn't really even matter about the rest once the post is already reached - which is its own problem, but it's not like machine-based recount drama doesn't drag on for ages too.

[1]: https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-...

grues-dinner··on X-ray scans reveal Buddhist prayers inside tiny Tibetan scrolls
It's hard to say where rules lawyering ends and hermeneutics begins, but as I am aware it's presumably somewhere before installing an EUV etching machine on a Tibetan mountaintop, I am joking.

That said electric (and wind and water-powered) prayer wheels do actually exist, so there is some prior art.

grues-dinner··on X-ray scans reveal Buddhist prayers inside tiny Tibetan scrolls
The original idle clicker. With modern materials, vacuum pumps, and magnetic bearings for the mechanics and lithography for the writing, we can pump those numbers up!

All silent in the monastery except for the ultrasonic whine of thousands of prayer turbines.

Prayer ring gyros, encoding the prayers into ultra-fast laser pulses going round millions of turns of optic fibre may be a competing technology.

grues-dinner··on Anna's Archive: An Update from the Team
The Internet has been redesigned. It's just not been redesigned with your interests in mind and at least some of the "attacks" are features to the right people.
grues-dinner··on AI is predominantly replacing outsourced, offshore workers
Alternatively, when your outsourcing agency finds they have accidentally assigned you an actually good engineer, term used loosely, that you're not paying for (they know this happens when the engineer gets up to speed with your codebase at all), "your guy" is replaced with another guy who inherits the name, the email address and the SSH key.

And if the agency doesn't do that, the good engineer will figure out he's being underpaid as slop-for-hire cannon fodder and move on his own accord.

grues-dinner··on AI is predominantly replacing outsourced, offshore workers
These are probably the same people who are "surprised" when 100 offshore agency dredgings don't magically do the app 10x faster than 10 expensive onshore workers.

To be fair, the PowerPoint they were shown at that AI Synergies retreat probably was very slick.

grues-dinner··on FFmpeg moves to Forgejo
Cloud-native KTDs (Kids These Days) will never know the joy of lovingly naming all the machines in the building by theme and caring for them like a kennel of slightly sickly pets.

"Cassiopeia is down" - emotional event, especially if she never comes up again. AWS instance 54653-345r3453-34234, meh. Sure, we got more nines, but at what cost?!

grues-dinner··on The Photographic Periodic Table of the Elements (2017)
So much better than the AI slop cutting cubes and sphere of elements that has been all over LinkedIn recently.
grues-dinner··on Sharp Hubble Images Confirm 3I/Atlas as Comet
I don't think any probe can do anything but stand there as the object zooms past.

But if it gets so close to Mars, presumably Mars probes already in orbit can get a closer look?

grues-dinner··on AI is different
When was the last the techno-industrialist elite class said "what we have is enough"?

In this scenario, the marginal cost of taking everything else over is almost zero. Just tell the AI you want it taken over and it handles it. You'd take it over just for risk mitigation, even if you don't "need" it. Better to control it since it's free to do so.

Allowing a competing human economy is resources left on the table. And control of resources is the only lever of power left when labour is basically free.

> Maybe some ecological argument

There's a political angle too. 7 (or however many it will be) billion humans free to do their own thing is a risky free variable.

grues-dinner··on Sunny days are warm: why LinkedIn rewards mediocrity
Or worse, it's a biobot using the little palette of cringey prebaked replies you can post: "very insightful, thanks for posting", "interesting thought", etc.
grues-dinner··on Occult books digitized and put online by Amsterdam’s Ritman Library
Take it up with Longbeard: https://www.longbeard.com/, they seem to be serious about it!
grues-dinner··on AI is different
Because with presumably tiny marginal costs of production, the AI owners can flood and/or buy out your human-powered economy.

You'd need a very united front and powerful incentives to prevent, say, anyone buying AI-farmed wheat when it's half the cost of human-farmed (say). If you don't prevent that, Team AI can trade wheat (and everything else) for human economy money and then dominate there.

grues-dinner··on AI is different
The problem is the "productive activity" is rather hard to define if there's so much "AI" (be it classical ML, LLM, ANI, AGI, ASI, whatever) around that nearly everything can be produced by nearly no one.

The destruction of the labour theory of value has been a goal of "tech" for a while, but if they achieve it, what's the plan then?

Assuming humans stay in control of the AIs because otherwise all bets are off, in a case where a few fabulously wealthy (or at least "onwing/controlling", since the idea of wealth starts to become fuzzy) industrialists control the productive capacity for everything from farming to rocketry and there's no space for normal people to participate in production any more, how do you even denominate the value being "produced"? Who is it even for? What do they need to give in return? What can they give in return?

grues-dinner··on Occult books digitized and put online by Amsterdam’s Ritman Library
Honestly, if Charles Stross decides that reality is catching up with the fiction again and the Laundry Files goes the way Rule 34 universe, I'll have to feed myself to the corner hounds.
grues-dinner··on Occult books digitized and put online by Amsterdam’s Ritman Library
Now to pit it in debate against Magisterium, the Catholic AI: https://www.magisterium.com/
grues-dinner··on With waters at 32C, Mediterranean tropicalization shifts into high gear
The point is not that "we're not fucked" (we probably are pretty fucked). Just that Tsar Bomba yield, like basically any amount of energy directly generated by human endeavour, is a pretty irrelevant unit of energy when talking about the climate because they are on a completely different scale.
grues-dinner··on With waters at 32C, Mediterranean tropicalization shifts into high gear
50 megatons is more on the order of 270 trillion kilojoules, not kilowatt-hours (factor of 3600 difference).
grues-dinner··on With waters at 32C, Mediterranean tropicalization shifts into high gear
1 Tsar Bomba (50 MT = 2e17J) is about 1/28,000,000 of the total solar power delivered to Earth annually, so about 1.4 seconds of top-of-atmosphere solar power (~1.5 million PWh / year).

On the other hand, it roughly equals 1/2000 to 1/3000 of annual global energy consumption (~175 PWh / year) so about 4 hours of human energy.

The energy of those 8000 Tsar Bombas in the Mediterranean then is the same as all of human energy, electrical and fossil and otherwise, going to heating up that sea for a little over 2 years straight, or focussing all sunlight over the disc of the Earth on it for 3 hours.

(All these figures depend on who you ask as all the figures are a little bit fuzzy).

It also shows that any key to climate change revolves around adjusting the modulation of insolation and/or retention - the actual energy used by humans is, for the forseeable future, completely irrelevant except on local scales like warm water outflows into rivers and seas.

grues-dinner··on Have you ever noticed that people dressed better in the past?
Someone, whether employed or married, being at home every day to faff about boiling and ironing and starching may not explain why people wanted to do that, but it helps explain why it was possible.

Much as I actually do quite like wearing a nice shirt to work, ironing the damn thing plus pressing trousers and running about having suits dry cleaned in the window the laundry is open and I'm not at work is a hassle and if I'm not prepared to do it if I don't actually have to, I'm certainly not going to make my (also full time working) spouse do it for me.

grues-dinner··on It is time to 'Correct the Map'
Maybe they should put Roosevelt's massive 50-inch globe back in the Oval Office.

Assuming there's a place for more Big Balls in federal government?

grues-dinner··on It is time to 'Correct the Map'
While we're at it, why not move the default centre line so that it bisects one of these circles: https://www.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/vastwz/the_smalles...

And you can definitely do that because a large proportion of maps sold in Asia do actually have Asia more or less in the middle.

grues-dinner··on Progress towards universal Copy/Paste shortcuts on Linux
Oh thank God it's not just me. At least have a confirmation popup for that! Ctrl+Shift+C, Enter isn't exactly onerous for Teams power users.
← PreviousPage 7 of 22Next →