HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grugq

1,005 karma · joined June 15, 2013

submissionscomments
grugq··on Ask HN: What's the best book you read in 2021?
Try Patrick Rothfuss. Fair warning though, he hasn’t ever written the last part of the trilogy.

The Blacktongue Thief is also good.

grugq··on Ask HN: What's the best book you read in 2021?
Fiction:

  - the blacktongue thief ; if you love rothfuss, then you’ll love this. 
  - between two fires ; same author. Really great book about the Black Death but also demons. 
  - hench ; a normie uses Zersetzung against the alter egos of superheroes. It’s great
  - five decembers ; great read, and a clever take on the traditional noir genre
Non fiction:

  - against the grain
  - pre industrial societies
  - the other face of battle
I’m still chewing through “war from the ground up” and it’s very good, but for me at least, conceptually dense.
grugq··on Ask HN: What's the best book you read in 2021?
Currently reading it.

I recommend “Against the Grain” and also “Pre Industrial Societies.” They give a really good perspective on human life and the structures we create. One of my favourite quotes is: the hallmarks of a state: appropriation, inequality and hierarchy.

Grains are the only agricultural product that can grow an early state, because it can be easily taxed, it’s fungible so you can pay with it, and people can’t run off with their field and canals to somewhere else.

It’s kind of a wonderful point that without the taxman there would be no civilisation.

grugq··on Accepted and ghosted: interviewing for a leadership position at Stripe
FWIW dang was extremely helpful when I had an issue. He worked with me to resolve it, rather than take arbitrary executive action. I don’t credit any accusation of dang playing favourites to YC founders. Basically, there is no level of assistance higher than what I received, therefore there is no way someone is getting preferential treatment. There’s simply no more that could’ve been done.

Note: I wasn’t completely happy with the outcome at the time, but I respected the decision. I hindsight I agree with it too.

grugq··on To remember everything you learn, surrender to this algorithm (2008)
There once was a pianist from Nantucket …
grugq··on Pegasus spyware seller: Blame our customers not us for hacking
It is an on prem system. The customer pays per agent deployed. They buy a license for some number (N) of agents. NSO doesn’t know where those N agents are, but it knows that there are N of them.
grugq··on Pegasus spyware seller: Blame our customers not us for hacking
The FBI uses private contractors for highly specialised tasks, and they perform a law enforcement role also.
grugq··on Pegasus spyware seller: Blame our customers not us for hacking
Licensing.
grugq··on Leak uncovers global abuse of cyber-surveillance weapon
Bezos nudes weren’t stolen by a hack, but by physical access to his mistress’s device. Her brother. At least, that’s what I recall.

The forensic investigation showed that bezos’ device was clean. From what I saw.

grugq··on Mimicking a device is becoming almost impossible
There’s a paper that addresses this fundamental problem:

https://www.freehaven.net/anonbib/cache/oakland2013-parrot.p...

  @inproceedings{oakland2013-parrot,
  title = {The Parrot is Dead: Observing Unobservable Network Communications}, 
  author = {Amir Houmansadr and Chad Brubaker and Vitaly Shmatikov}, 
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2013 IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy}, 
  year = {2013}, 
  month = {May}, 
  www_pdf_url = {http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~amir/papers/parrot.pdf}, 
  www_tags = {selected}, 
  www_section = {Communications Censorship}, 
}
grugq··on Ask HN: What huge mistake did you make early in your career?
Not early, but: talking to the press without any media training.
grugq··on Tricks of Trench Warfare (2020)
There is a lot involved, but the basic idea is that your rifle and sight need to be calibrated to match from where you’re shooting to where you’re shooting. The journey to the sniper hides was long, arduous, grueling, and not exactly guaranteed to be hassle free. You might be stumbling over miles of dirt with stray wires, holes, dead bodies, broken equipment, rubble, and so on, at night, in pitch black. Then wandering through narrow trenches packed with people going both ways, again with dead bodies, stray wires, holes, and broken kit. There is a non zero chance that the scope you sighted in yesterday could get tapped or knocked, and it will be out of alignment by the time your arrive at your hide.

The use of debris was a simple way to sight in. You tell your spotter that you’re gonna shoot that tin can just by the sandbag over there. They tell you where you’re hitting so you can adjust your sights. Naive snipers would fall for this trick, but later on experience taught to use puddles instead.

grugq··on Tricks of Trench Warfare (2020)
There was two years of war before the British had figured out how to do trench raiding effectively. By late 1916 they had the “storm trooper” tactics completely figured out, something the Germans wouldn’t manage until 1918. The Germans on the other hand, developed very good defense in depth tactics.

A trench system is made of three lines of trenches in parallel, covering a mile or more in depth. The front line trench is the combat trench, where the fighting is supposed to take place. Then there is the support trench, which houses units for work parties and counterattacks and so on. Then the reserve trench which houses more work parties and has units resting from front line duty. Units would spent a week or two in the trenches, then rotate into the rear for a while to rest and receive replacements.

As the war progressed everyone basically learned that the front line trench was rubbish. It would be destroyed, overrun, shot up, etc. There was no point in holding it with a lot of troops because they’d get wiped out before they could do much of anything. The Germans switched to a front line that was just fortified shell holes with machine guns. This was very safe against artillery because there was no trench to target. It was effective against infantry attacks because the machine guns could wreak havoc on men with rifles. The support and reserve trenches would be real trenches.

This system of fortified shell holes with supporting strong points from the support trench was “defense in depth.” The opposition could “overrun” the front line, but they’d still have pockets of machine gun nests on their flanks and behind them. Eliminating every single machine gun nest was extremely slow and so… that is how defense was achieved. Not with a single strong trench, but with a system that could absorb an attack, slow it down, and reduce it with machine guns.

[anecdote: during an offensive one officer solved the “eliminate all the machine gun nests” problem by taking a German prisoner and making him stand up on a stump in no mans land pointing out every nest. The officer would prod him with his pistol and demand more information, until all the machine guns were located and neutralized. Only then was the poor German allowed to get off the elevated and exposed position.]

The offensive solution to this system was with artillery box barrages, storm trooper infiltration, and tanks (to some degree). The real solution was to spend years besieging Germany and bleeding her dry so that by late 1918 there was no manpower, materiel or morale to fight. Attrition wins.

Infiltration tactics were basically sending small units of men, say a section (8 men) or platoon (40 men) through the fortified shell hole system at night. That way when the attack began, the men were miles inside enemy territory already and could ambush the strong points, etc. This was what the British began doing by late 1916. Germany gets credit for inventing it almost two years later because, they had a really cool name (storm troopers!) and the enemy always has cooler better stuff than you do. And the British didn’t like a system that gave all the initiative to young officers, particularly the officers later in the war who came from civilian life to fight only for the duration, can’t have those types ruining things for the career officers from good families, etc. etc,

The trench raid was the primary way of defeating the trench system. It begins with a creeping barrage and the box barrage. The artillery fires on the front line trenches until the time when the infantry assault elements are supposed to arrive. Then it lifts and moves to targets further back. It stays on those until the time when the infantry is supposed to arrive then, and then lifts and moves forward again. Creeping barrage. The box baggage was where the artillery fences the area being assaulted with fire along the flanks. This produces a sort of box, where artillery is firing along two sides and one creeping barrage at the back. The idea is that the area within the box will be dealt with by the infantry assault units while the artillery prevents reinforcements and counterattacks.

It is a brittle system because there is so little information flow between the front line assault units and the artillery. If the times scheduled for the advances don’t match with reality the infantry can fall behind the protective screen. When this happens, I.e. the creeping barrage walks too far forward for the infantry to keep up, then the enemy can come up from their dugouts and man their defensive positions. This is, obviously, very bad for the Poor Bloody Infantry.

Anyway, the short answer is that trenches were attacked all the time and clearing trenches was an important activity. There were night raids as well, which is a whole other thing. That’s where the hand to hand fighting comes into it. That’s an entire other subject, including how the armies had to invent modern hand to hand combat training.

These days if you’re in the military you’re taught basically two technica, one to incapacitate and one to kill. Then everything else you learn is a way to setup either of those two techniques. Guy standing up? Ok, get him on the ground and crush his throat. Guy has a knife? Get him on the ground, safely, and crush his throat. Guy has a bayonet? Get him on… and so on. The French system was based on crushing the throat. With thumbs. Very… brutal. I’m not sure how much it was used, but that is what was taught,

grugq··on Tricks of Trench Warfare (2020)
The Finnish war gave us the term “Molotov cocktail.” When the Russians began bombing Helsinki they claimed that the bombers were dropping food to the Finnish people. The Finns made a joke that bombs were Molotov’s bread baskets, or picnic baskets, etc. Molotov was the Soviet Foreign Minister.

When the Finns started using glass bottles with gasoline and a burning rag as anti tank weapons, they made the joke that these were Molotov cocktails to go with the Molotov bread baskets.

It’s strange how Soviet propaganda (“we’re dropping food!”) lives on in English by way of a Finnish joke from 80 years ago.

grugq··on SolarWind, enough with the password already
Thanks
grugq··on SolarWind, enough with the password already
My problem is not with SolarWind but with the analysis that keeps raising the password as the one and only problem. “If only they had good password hygiene then the company would’ve been totally safe against the Russian intelligence services!”

That is just not how things work.

To go further. The password was on GitHub from 2017 to November 2019. The first test build to see if they could backdoor things was in October 2019. If the password was the problem, why wasn’t SolarWind hacked in 2017 or 18?

The only explanation is that it wasn’t an operation that existed back then. It wasn’t a target for the SVR at that point in time, or they weren’t able to service it with their operational capacity. But regardless, the critical factor here is that the RIS started this operation, not that the password was bad or available on GitHub. (Or whatever the issue is with the password.)

Let’s discuss whether the operational concept (CONOP) of hacking a civilian target to get into the supply chain and hit other targets is acceptable in cyber espionage. It seems to be acceptable because that is a methodology that everyone uses.

My point has not been that you just can’t win against Ho Chi Minh, or that SolarWind was particularly negligent (or not, their security posture was abysmal but also irrelevant)... my point is that we should focus on what actually matters — the CONOP. Because if the US sanctions Russia for this operation then the US is locking itself and it’s allies into a position when this CONOP is off the table. If that is what everyone agrees with, fine. But it’s the real discussion to have. Not what sort of security SolarWind did or (realistically) did not have.

grugq··on SolarWind, enough with the password already
I call them the SVR, an agency formed from the FCD of the KGB. The first chief directorate was responsible for international espionage. The internal security responsibilities, along with everything else, was made into the FSB. There are some cross overs which reflect official Russian policy, such as the use of FSB officers to conduct espionage in the near abroad (such as Estonia) because the state believes they’re oblasts not sovereign nations.

That said, KGB is KGB. They call themselves Chekists, we call them KGB.

grugq··on Hackers extorted $1.14M from UCSF
Additional literature on the topic[0]. The finding is that any payment at all is sufficient for the operation to continue. This makes sense for ransomware was well since the marginal cost of hacking additional targets is effectively zero.

The major ransomware operations are targeted and the hackers do research the victims. They use spear phishing, so they need to know their victim. Unless the ban is universal and consistent so that hackers can modify their behaviour before they hack a target, there is no point in doing it. The US treasury announcement about not paying ransoms is just such a pointless terrible idea.

[0] https://rusi.org/publication/occasional-papers/closing-gap-a...

grugq··on Hackers extorted $1.14M from UCSF
Costs are zero. The ransomware platform runs as a server somewhere, and whether they get one ransom payment or 1000 their costs are the same. The gangs that do the hacking operate on commission, they attempt to phish multiple targets (hundreds, more?) at a time. Again, the cost of one payment is sufficient to justify the entire endeavour.

As long as even one victim will pay, then there is no incentive to stop hacking.

This dynamic is covered in the literature on K&R. https://rusi.org/publication/occasional-papers/closing-gap-a...

grugq··on CrimeOps: The Operational Art of Cyber Crime
yup. I've been here for years. Only comment when it is relevant, so maybe once every couple years.
grugq··on CrimeOps: The Operational Art of Cyber Crime
hi.
grugq··on CrimeOps: The Operational Art of Cyber Crime
Author here, and yes, that is correct.
grugq··on CrimeOps: The Operational Art of Cyber Crime
Thank you, I appreciate it.

It is very unlikely that FIN7 are aware of their successful exploitation of the golden triangle. They almost certainly just pursued what worked best for them, creating a lean mean cybercriming machine along the way. (And isn’t that the real treasure?)

Financially motivated crimes are essentially businesses, and so sometimes it can be useful to use business frameworks to understand the criminal enterprise. Fortunately FIN7 happen to be a particularly well documented, making such analysis possible.

I don’t really know what to say re: your meta comment. I wrote some posts for them under contract. I had complete editorial control. I have no idea if it is easier than in other fields. None of the other posts (not posted yet) are about “scary” topics, so I’m not sure if the observation is correct.

grugq··on CrimeOps: The Operational Art of Cyber Crime
I’d call it dual use, but I’m not actually aware of a benign use case for JIRA! ;)
grugq··on Protester shot in chest by live police round during Hong Kong protests
This is not supported by the evidence. They wear street clothes. Look at any pictures or videos, you'll see that they're wearing normal clothes of all colors.
grugq··on Protester shot in chest by live police round during Hong Kong protests
This should be put in some context.

Today is the anniversary of China as a communist country. The Hong Kong marchers were all wearing black today as a sign of mourning. That is why the kids are dressed in black (so please, no black bloc/antifa comments.)

The police have been particularly aggressive towards protestors and journalists. They deliberately shoot tear gas at journalist "clusters" (presumably to prevent documentation of police actions?) They have shot multiple people with "rubber bullets" and they beat people with batons. The first people to use shields and clubs at the protests? The police.

Besides the state authorized use of violence, there is also the use of non-state assets. The authorities have encouraged the triads to assault protestors. The police stand back and allow this to happen, probably because a picture of civilians beating people is a less polarizing image than police beating protestors.

# the shooting

From the videos it is clear that there was an officer on the ground and he was being assaulted. He is wearing protective equipment. When police beat protestors with batons the protestors do not have the benefit of riot gear.

The officer who shot the 17yr kid should not have had his service weapon drawn, and should not have had his finger on the trigger. When a cop points a gun, finger on trigger, at someone the only party responsible for that shooting is the cop.

The "descent into violence" narrative adopted by the Western media is completely missing the nuance of the protests. Most of the "violence" by protestors is property damage. It is seldom violence against a person.

grugq··on Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone
Ok. I'm still unclear on your point.

You are referencing cases where exploits were in the news. What does that have to do with vulnerability markets?

Are you saying that the IC used exploits only twice? And they were misused both times? What does that have to do with vulnerability markets?

I'm sorry, but I'm utterly lost. Can you please clarify?

grugq··on Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone
> I appreciate your honesty and taking responsibility.

It is a fatal character flaw I have. When people want to know about something I try to help them.

> You mention that everyone is doing it with no citations of academic sources. I'd be interested in reading any recent research you believe is high quality

There was one by RAND which is good.

https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/research_reports/...

> represents the current market.

There is nothing that I am aware of that discusses the current market. The RAND paper is closest.

> acting in good faith.

I should not have used a blanket statement. My point is that there are people in IC who are legitimately going after terrorists and child abusers. They have a legitimate need for capabilities that enable them to do that.

I am not saying that the IC is a benign and wonderful government organ. I am saying that within IC there are people who are actually hunting terrorists and pedophiles. I didn't want to explain all of that because it is obvious that it is true. Hence, "lets take it for granted". Rather than discussing the history of the IC, I wanted to explain that there are legitimate uses for 0day and that is the issue being discussed.

The rest is not relevant to explaining how the vulnerability market operates. (Well, how it did in 2011.) When someone asks "how do shares work?" you don't start off by talking about boom and bust markets and macroeconomics. Same thing here. "How does the market work?" is not a question about the IC. It is about how the market works. If you're talking about the vulnerability market you talk about the vulnerability market. You have to assume that there are legitimate players who are acting in good faith.

This entire post is why I abridged it to "lets assume good faith."

grugq··on Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone
Yeah. They don’t exist. People don’t think about things rationally, they see phrases like “black market” and assume it is some sort of criminal transaction with armed guards and meetings at midnight and shit.

It is nothing like that. It is the same as freelance development work, except there are very few customers and the developer writes something that may or may not have any value.

grugq··on Apple Confirms $1M Reward for Anyone Who Can Hack an iPhone
I’m sorry, I don’t understand.
← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →