HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grumblenum

71 karma · joined May 26, 2021

submissionscomments
grumblenum··on Some biologists and ecologists think social media is a risk to humanity
Gopher and Gemini are attempts at this. There are a few comfortable online communities out there when you get away from the big web properties. Unless you’re into gamification of showing how orthodox and au currant you are. Then there’s Reddit.
grumblenum··on Some biologists and ecologists think social media is a risk to humanity
I like the irony of a story about the danger of social media here on HN. You know. Social media.
grumblenum··on Rally, a novel privacy-first data sharing platform
Princeton can't buy data from aggregators? Wikipedia says they have a $26.6B endowment.
grumblenum··on Rally, a novel privacy-first data sharing platform
I read it as "we're protecting your privacy by increasing the number of people who can monitor your activity on our browser." Presumably, the users will be well-endowed and tax-advantaged institutions who could have just bought the information from data-aggregators anyway. I'm starting to see a theme of papering over their technology products with a lot of modern art and hyperbolic language.

"Computer scientists, social scientists and other researchers will be able to launch groundbreaking studies about the web and invite you to participate." Wow. I'm about to make history with a browser add-on!

"Our first study is “Political and COVID-19 News” and comes from the Princeton team that helped us develop the Rally research initiative." Groundbreaking! College students can now make sure that I am adequately fact-checked if I err from the path of truth.

grumblenum··on Is education no longer the ‘great equalizer’?
Here I thought I was underachieving because I was reading HN comments instead of doing anything productive. Now I see that the world, or at least subsets of the population I’m allowed to blame for my problems, has wronged me, which appeals to my petty sense of envy and bitterness and assuages the guilt I had about not actually trying. Perhaps this inequality is actually a grand conspiracy. I wish the press, academia, and the boards of basically every major company were woke to this crisis.
grumblenum··on What is ranked-choice voting and why is New York using it?
What is the name of the voting system where the tabulators decide my vote for me and I get a sticker for showing up?
grumblenum··on What is ranked-choice voting and why is New York using it?
So voters almost got what they wanted and not what established interests thought they should be allowed to have? Frightening.
grumblenum··on Brave Search beta
Almost all of Mozilla's revenue is from Google. I don't see how bad incentives could possibly be avoided, assuming Mitchell Baker wishes to keep herself in the lifestyle to which she has become accustomed. I do believe they engage in copious moral bargaining to maintain their image as plucky underdogs sticking it to the man.
grumblenum··on Types of propaganda, propaganda techniques, and propaganda strategies (2017)
* zero-cost abstractions

* move semantics

* guaranteed memory safety

* threads without data races

* trait-based generics

* pattern matching

* type inference

* minimal runtime

* efficient C bindings

grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
That's fascinating. Can you direct me to any of their papers or public work formally verifying a rust codebase? I haven't seen that before.
grumblenum··on Google executives see cracks in their company’s success
The editorial board dictates tone and content of the paper, not just editorial pieces. They determine narratives long in advance and news articles must conform to it. You should not believe that nobody at the NYT considered the effect this story could have on GOOG shareholder value. In all likelihood, that was the only objective, given how little substance there is to the article.
grumblenum··on Google executives see cracks in their company’s success
So the NYT editorial board greenlit a hit piece against Google? Well, that's gratitude for you. I hope others learn from this. The reward for bowing to such "prestigious" institutions is getting whipped for not bowing low enough.
grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
70% of CVEs (bugs detected) being memory related does not mean that 70% of all software bugs are memory errors (bugs that exist). See survivors bias. Memory errors can be detected with the assistance of programs, so they are much easier to find than other bugs like logic errors, which require knowing what a program ought to do. I think the latter is much more insidious.
grumblenum··on Rust 1.53
Not breaking APIs is pretty considerate of your users.
grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
The stated goal of the grant program is to rewrite stable software many people use in Rust with the implied context being that C can’t be trusted, but Rust can be. I’m surprised that a language with no specified guarantees is favored over well established methods of verification. When you poopoo formal methods and verified compilers, it’s very hard to find a coherent logic behind RIIR, which offers much less in terms of security.

Unless the exercise is a pretext to rationalize the grant money (which would be the real purpose).

grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
Right, and at one point the whole team were all or mostly Mozilla employees (which, financially, is a client company of Google). So the core team is a group of Mozilla alumni and their friends. Unlike, say, C++ which is under diverse committees across multiple countries.
grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
A verified compiler is not panacea, but rust is because of unsubstantiated claims of its marketing professionals? This is total nonsense.
grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
They just employ the people who do? And, until recently, the paid language evangelists?
grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
Using a mode checker on existing software is unproductive, but rewriting existing, working software that you have to shoehorn into a shape rustc (which had a miscompilation bug until 1.52.1, has no specifications or alternative implementations, right?) will compile is productive? Rust’s type system is elegant, but Agda, OCaml F#, F* and Haskell, which are in a whole different league of sophistication, are not? Furthermore, I’m not aware of any progress in “sealed rust” or “rust belt” other than raising grant money. I don’t think a certification is coming anytime soon. There are other verified compilers that could be used now, though.

This argument sounds like rust for rust’s sake.

grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
It’s just another of many testimonials of projects that will not be named at companies that will not be disclosed with implausible circumstances or unlikely details here to convince you that you had better switch your tech stack to this brand new thing before you too become a cautionary tale.
grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
You would have to sanitize your entire dependency tree for unsafe invocations and also demonstrate that valid rust programs do, in fact, guarantee memory safety, which might be invalidated by previous or future compiler versions. That also ignores known soundness holes, compiler errors, and silliness like how rust binaries leak the file structure they were built on. I don’t see why that’s reasonable, but auto industry standards are not reasonable or a language with a garbage collector is not reasonable. The work happening in model checking is really incredible. Project Everest is focused on addressing exactly the same problems, and I don’t think the rust compilers guarantees have undergone nearly the rigor of that of F*.
grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
Well, Google probably doesn’t control all the C++ standards committees. I don’t know how much control they have over commit rights to the Rust compiler. Given Mozilla’s client-patron relationship with Google, then I’d guess it’s possible.

But, yeah, a company whose business model is tricking old people into buying junk and surveilling their users probably shouldn’t be implicitly trusted.

grumblenum··on Prossimo – Memory safety for the Internet's most critical infrastructure
I don’t understand this at all. MISRA C, model checkers and theorem provers all exist to provide some of these guarantees that are, to my knowledge, widely recognized in applications where “safety” actually entails life safety. F* is a very modern tool, I think, developed for precisely these use cases. I’m not aware that the rust compiler is proven or even specified. Avoiding its mechanisms for validating use-once memory isn’t even that uncommon, especially in low-level library code.

That Google is the man behind the curtain here also comes off as weird since they have not, to my knowledge, standardized their own critical infrastructure on Rust.

grumblenum··on I Read the Entire Cybersecurity Executive Order; Here's What You Need to Know
Since you asked, I'll make it explicit. My pile of innuendo alleges that the FBI is directly responsible or at least complicit for the Colonial Pipeline and JBM hacks, and the executive order is likely written by lobbyists who sell or intend to sell authentication services or "secure" platforms to federal contractors.

Do you remember back when there were no weapons of mass destruction and the "Intelligence Community", the media, and other agents of reputable institutions all went along with the lie so that unrelated geopolitical objectives could be satisfied and defense contractors would make insane amounts of money? It's like that.

grumblenum··on Rust 1.53
If you consider GitHub to be a reasonable metric of industry practice in general, then judging by these charts [https://madnight.github.io/githut/#/pull_requests/2021/1], I would say that going mainstream in a couple years is not very likely at all. Tiobe [https://www.tiobe.com/tiobe-index/] paints a similar picture. The number of Rust-specific jobs advertisements also don't seem to suggest a coming wave that employers are trying to get ahead of[https://www.dice.com/jobs?q=rust&countryCode=US&radius=30&ra...]. I'm not aware of any real success stories with the language, either, unlike Go and the CNCF ecosystem that's the latest fashion right now. There are rewrites of GNU coreutils (ripgrep, bat), a couple components in already commercially successful software (Dropbox, Discord), a couple side-projects within large companies (fuschia OS, FirecrackerVM) and I guess terminal emulators are a big focus. You could say the same of Haskell, which is very cool, but is not going to be an industry standard in the foreseeable future.

One way to think about it is that the big wave of new languages like Go, Rust, Elixir and Kotlin all sprang up around 2010. At that time, C99, C++03, Java 6 or C#2 were probably what you would have been using (honorable mentions to Python 2.7, PHP 5, and Ruby 1.8). The new languages were perceived solutions to the limitations of the mainstream languages; however, today, very many of the new features and the old points of frustration have already been addressed within these same 'boring' mainstream languages. Java 16, C# 8, and C++20 are vastly improved and have (or will soon have [check out Loom for Java!]) almost all the conveniences the new-wave offered without having to throw old programs in the bin and reimplement entire ecosystems. C++ and Rust are also so similar in terms of semantics and memory model, that I really don't see the value proposition of walking away from huge, mature projects like Qt for academically interesting type algebra. There have been some ambitious fresh-takes on things like ECS-based game engines in Rust, but I'm not aware of impending migration to these tools.

grumblenum··on How does one get hired by a top cybercrime gang?
https://www.fbijobs.gov/
grumblenum··on I Read the Entire Cybersecurity Executive Order; Here's What You Need to Know
That appears to be for consumers of federal government web services, which I would not expect to prevent large breaches. The service itself would be a massive single point of failure, and I'm not sure how it would prove a contractor has ZTA, or whatever an administrator thinks that means, all the way down.
grumblenum··on I Read the Entire Cybersecurity Executive Order; Here's What You Need to Know
How fortunate that an executive order was waiting in the wings, which requires federal contractors to purchase an authentication service and guarantee they use the underspecified ZTA (which will probably mean pay for AWS or Azure services to do anything at all), days after multiple highly-publicized million-dollar cybercrime heists were, quite astonishingly, thwarted by the FBI resulting in no money lost.
grumblenum··on A New Era for Mechanical CAD
OpenSCAD exists, is perfectly usable, is very cool, and stores CAD models 'as code' which is git-friendly. Professionals don't use it. I like it, but I would never standardize on it at work. I'm sure a more point-and-click front-end is certainly possible, but that nobody has tried something quite so obvious probably speaks to its incompatibility with use common use cases. I use Autodesk software daily, and merely representing 3D objects is a very small part of the utility it provides. The software is undoubtedly an unstable mess, but feature parity with Revit or just Fusion 360 is far beyond a pizza-box team of 'disruptors'. There is also a culture of professionalism and practicality in AEC that I don't see folks used to coastal VC/startup playgrounds doing well in.

I also find it pretty hard to take the contents of an article seriously when there's name-dropping of celebrity-developers whose business appears to be self-promotion. "I use vim, btw ;)" really puts the nail in the coffin for me. I'm sure CAD-but-on-electron would look great on a slide deck, though.

grumblenum··on Australian Federal Police and FBI nab underworld figures using encrypted app
>imminent mass shooting may prompt interdiction

Pulse night club comes to mind as a counterpoint. A lot of people died to keep an informant happy. I think a more cynical outlook on law enforcement is appropriate.

← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →