HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

grunder_advice

237 karma · joined August 29, 2023

submissionscomments
grunder_advice··on Germany's Merz admits nuclear exit was strategic mistake
It's the same ridiculous situation as with the Greenland saga. The transatlanticists don't want to let go of the past, but America isn't looking back.
grunder_advice··on Germany's Merz admits nuclear exit was strategic mistake
It was a populist move because a big chunk of the electorate is German moms and German grandmas who are absolutely terrified of radiation post Chernobyl.
grunder_advice··on Have Taken Up Farming
At that point it becomes an exercise in marketing more than anything else, because the whole business model depends on finding rich customers that are willing to pay a suitable markup to make the extra effort feasabile. And then you have to also be constantly trying to retain those customers....etc
grunder_advice··on I rebooted my social life
What if you have a community but it's boring and uninspiring? It's always the same shit, STEM nerds, who can only talk shop, tech, video games, sports and bitcoin/crypto/libertarianism/ancap stuff. I mean, I've moved like 3 times in the span of 7 years and every time I end up in the same kind of community. Also, no women. :(
grunder_advice··on France targets Australia-style social media ban for children next year
>hn is a social media site

Social media typically implies a website where users are sharing self-created content. If a website with comments counts a social media, than all web2.0 is social media and there's practically no distinction between the web and social media.

grunder_advice··on Who invented the transistor?
I personally detest the way we sanctify some sole individuals while forgetting the bulk of the community. I don't care who published the first patent for the transistor. He or She certainly cannot be credited for all the work that has been put into it so that I can today use a hand held device to post this comment.
grunder_advice··on Ask HN: Loneliness at 19, how to cope?
Could be a lot of things and probably a bit of everything. You might have social anxiety, even if you don't feel particularly shy. If you're too clammed up, people recognize that and keep a certain distance. It could also be that you have a very rigid personality. It might simply be a matter of lack of socialization. I don't think there is any way to diagnose this and pinpoint the problem. Learning how to be social is very much a lot like learning how to program: try lots of things, spend a lot of time doing it, and don't be afraid of breaking things. Eventually you'll develop your own methods to keep people entertained and then people will take more interest in you.

Been there, done that.

BTW, you're 19 and actually at 19 this is not all that abnormal. Lots of kids in college find themselves in your situation.

grunder_advice··on Approaching 50 Years of String Theory
I wonder what Ed Witten would have accomplished if he had gone into another field instead of choosing to dedicate his life to mathematical physics.
grunder_advice··on Venezuela explained in 10 maps and charts
> There was no 'regime', there was a democracy with corruption problems

OK.

> but that was still functional

Clearly not, because Chavez was elected despite having attempted a coup d'etat previously. Clearly not, because the coup d'etat against Chavez failed because the population was overwhelming supporting him.

> populist dismantle the state institutions and turn it into an oligarchy ran by his circle

Which was necessary because previously it was an oligarchy ran by an opposing circle, which lost favor with the people.

> It was never about classism or racism

It's classism, partly fueled by racism, which causes the ruling elite in Latin America to have such disdain for the rest of the population, that they believe they can take control of the country and govern it as if they were some kind of aristocracy, and completely ignore those beneath them, because they aren't of the right class, are not white enough, and don't have enough wealth, to be taken into consideration.

grunder_advice··on US threatens EU digital services market access
Long term, it would be good for the EU if tech market access was restricted. The reason there aren't EU tech giants is because the US and EU are basically one market, so naturally, all tech giants end up being American. So it's not in the interest of the US to restrict market access in anyway and these tech giants know it.
grunder_advice··on Venezuela explained in 10 maps and charts
The EU has consistently been anti-Chavez and anti-Maduro, probably because the corrupt Venezuelan elites who escaped with their stolen millions after Chavez was elected, have been whispering in their ears ever since.
grunder_advice··on Venezuela explained in 10 maps and charts
From what I understand the root cause is racism and classism.

Venezuela was in a deep economic crisis for a very long time before Chavez was elected. The then ruling elite were pretty happy living in a bubble, extracting oil, selling to the west, embezzling the proceeds and ignoring most of the population.

The reason I say, the root cause is racism and classism, is because they totally underestimated the power of the people to overthrow their corrupt regime.

grunder_advice··on Fight Chat Control
Europe never abandoned the elitist mindset of a ruling elite lording it over the masses.
grunder_advice··on How AI is upending the software development industry
If nobody hires juniors, then where are the seniors supposed to come from?
grunder_advice··on Denmark to raise retirement age to 70
Mormons and Amish have above replacement fertility rates. Millionaires in western countries also have above replacement fertility rates.

To me it seems rather obvious: you need both the will and the means to raise 3+ children.

grunder_advice··on Denmark to raise retirement age to 70
Getting immigrants who work is a non-issue. I never heard of immigrants from India, China, Africa or Latin America who don't work so long as they entered the country legally. The issue you are alluding to has to do with genuine refugees and illegal economic migrants, who are not filtered at the border depending on their employability within the local market. But the cultural shift is still inevitable. A foreigner is not a local, and it is neither fair nor ethical to expect a foreigner to transform themselves into a local.

I think, if you are concerned with the cultural shift, you can give immigrants temporary term VISAs and make it clear their stay is going to be strictly temporary. That was supposed to be how the Gastarbeiter system works. Thing is, when you have already on boarded a foreign worker and have had them working for you for 2 years already, you don't want to let them go and replace them with a fresh foreign worker who you have to retrain.

grunder_advice··on Reversing the fossilization of computer science conferences
In AI/ML job ads it is quite typical for the requirements to include, "must have published at top AI conferences include but not limited to NeuroIPS, ICML, ICLR, ...etc", which I find completely crazy, because it just incentivizes grad students to publish rubbish papers to have on their CV, and indeed most conference papers in AI/ML are complete rubbish, because it is trivial to take any architecture and any corresponding benchmark, tweak the architecture slightly and publish a paper. Even dud results are published as "promising". It's just a complete shitshow, and as somebody who is in the field it feels as though you cannot even complain because people get offended. You're just supposed to keep spinning the hamster wheel without posing any hard questions. Moreover, having published at top conferences does not prove that somebody is going to be a good ML Engineer. It just proves that somebody knows how to write a compelling conference paper, which is a completely different skill set altogether.
grunder_advice··on Careless People
No. You need a research lab, compute time and talent to train LLMs.
grunder_advice··on Careless People
Whenever these kind of articles pop up, I always think how sad it is that PyTorch, Llama and many widely used opens source projects are tied to Meta.
grunder_advice··on Can a single AI model advance any field of science?
I am already acquainted with them but to be honest, I am no longer in the field so I am not able to comment on latest developments. However, as of two years ago, the consistent result was that you could get models that reproduce really good physics for problems in the same physical regimes as the training data, but such models had poor generalizability, so depending on the use case, they weren't of much use. The only exception I know is FourCastNet, which is a weather model FNO from NVIDIA.
grunder_advice··on Can a single AI model advance any field of science?
Is this a recruiting attempt by Los Alamos? AI/ML for science as this broad field used to be known is interesting. Some five years ago there as a real craze where every STEM lab at my university was doing some form of ML project. I think by now people have learned what works and what doesn't. Climate models for example have been quite successful. Possibly the reason is that they learn directly from collected data, rather than trying to emulate the output of simulations. Attempts to build similiar models for fluid dynamics have been rather dismal. In general, big models and big data result in useful models, even if only because these models seem to be somehow interpolating based on similiar training data points. Trying to replace classical physics based models with ML models trained on simulation data does not seem to work. The model is only ever capable of emulating a physically plausible output when the input is close enough to the training data, and that too, only when the system isn't chaotic. For applications where you are generating a sample to be used in a downstream task, ML models trained on lots of data can be very useful. You only need a few lucky guesses, that you can verify downstream, to end up with some useful result. In short, there is no magic to it. It's a useful tool that can be regarded as both a search algorithm and an optimization algorithm.
grunder_advice··on The many ways tarrifs will hit electronics
You are not wrong, but that situation won't change if you moved to another taxation scheme. The poor are too poor to have much to take from them. So they go after those who are a rung or two above to tax. The dynamic does not change irrespective of taxation system.
grunder_advice··on Japan births fall to lowest in 125 years
I am not against immigration, neither as a stop-gap measure nor in general. I believe limited immigration can even be beneficial, even with regards to cultural aspects. I also do not believe that cultures are static but rather living and evolving. And I also believe that input from foreign cultures can also improve local cultures.

But I also do not believe that we should give up on birthrates and just resign to let our cultures fade away to be completely replaced in short order by completely foreign cultures. I also do not believe that a planet Earth with one global monoculture would be as resilient as the one we have today. I also would NOT want the whole world to share the same cultural aspects that I embrace.

grunder_advice··on Japan births fall to lowest in 125 years
I picked Germany and Australia as the example, because they are two countries with a similiar standard of living, both considered western, and culturally Christian, and yet, to anyone who is acquainted with both, they are quite culturally dissimilar. Because my point is not that some cultures are somehow inferior to an extent that they do not belong in western countries, but rather that people have a preference for living with others of the same culture, because that is literally the whole point of having a culture in the first place.

I do not understand why discussion about this topic has to be so uncharitable.

grunder_advice··on Japan births fall to lowest in 125 years
Dude, I am not talking about patriotism, nationalism, ethnowhatthefuckism or any such notions. I am simply talking about cultures. Are you going to tell that you have no preference with regards to living in Germany, France, Poland, Argentina, or Canada? That is obviously not true.

> What I care utmost about is that they are good moral people who follow rules and respect others

What counts as rules and morals is dependent on culture. I would never live in Switzerland for example. I would utterly detest living there. And I was not even talking about rules or morals or any of these big differences that might arise between wildly different cultures. I'm talking about normal everyday stuff.

Maybe some of you should take a course in cross-cultural communication, to really understand what I am talking about. People have different expectations and conventions in their everyday lives. It is not like one is better than the other, but they are different and those form a way of thinking that is at the core of what the culture of the place is.

grunder_advice··on Japan births fall to lowest in 125 years
No, I did not. My point holds just as well for any ethnicity. If I choose to live in Germany it is because I like being around Germans. Australia is not Germany. They behave and think very differently.
grunder_advice··on Japan births fall to lowest in 125 years
We are glamorizing everything else except having kids and raising a family, to the point where a DING couple with a garage full of Porsches and three yearly vacations is considered more successful than the working couple with four kids, which to me a ridiculous. I don't think the natural instinct to reproduce has gone away. It is just being overwritten by other cultural values.
grunder_advice··on Japan births fall to lowest in 125 years
To people callously saying that immigration is the solution, I want to ask: don't you care at all if within a few generations your home country loses its culture and becomes inhabited by other people of a different ethnicity? To me, what makes a country is the constitution of the local ethnicities. If I live in Germany, and nobody if having kids anymore and we compensate by importing Australians. It's not like I have something against Australians, but I did not choose to go live in Australia. I expect people to be German not Australian. Maybe people who grew up in places like New York City cannot understand this, but not everywhere is like NYC.
grunder_advice··on EU doubles down on penalising privacy-friendly and encrypted messaging services
We have neither. Look at what happened to Yanis Varoufakis.
grunder_advice··on EU doubles down on penalising privacy-friendly and encrypted messaging services
How long will it be before I won't be able to post a comment like this online without providing my government ID?
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →