http://www.economist.com/news/christmas-specials/21591793-le...
One difference, of course, is that digital type can't be dumped into the Thames.
30,328 karma · joined August 18, 2007
http://www.economist.com/news/christmas-specials/21591793-le...
One difference, of course, is that digital type can't be dumped into the Thames.
"In our ongoing studies of scientists and engineers we have found that significant arts and crafts experience is highly correlated with professional success in science and engineering as measured by outcomes such as major prizes and honors, patents, or the founding of new high tech companies."
http://seadnetwork.wordpress.com/white-paper-abstracts/final...
"Nobel laureates are at least as likely (and as much as a factor of 8 more likely) to be photographers than the average scientist; at least a factor of 2 (and as much as 18) more likely to be a practicing musician, composer, or conductor; at least a factor of 7 more likely to be a visual artist, sculptor, or printmaker; at least a factor of 7.5 more likely to be a craftsperson engaged in woodwork, mechanics, electronics, glassblowing, and so on; at least a factor of 12 more likely to write poetry, short stories, plays, essays, novels, or popular books; and at least a factor of 22 more likely to be an amateur actor, dancer, magician, or other performer. These differences are highly statistically significant [...]"
http://emilkirkegaard.dk/en/wp-content/uploads/Arts-Foster-S...
Name a book that does! The corpus of evidence in our field is quite weak and doesn't support almost any interesting claim you might make about it. For example, there's no empirical data supporting version control [1].
There are books that purport to derive software development lessons from the research literature, but they're either not very good (because they rely on crappy studies and/or go beyond what the studies support) or not very interesting (because they merely transcribe the results of very narrow studies). An anthology of the literature was published recently [2], and it falls in the latter category. I bought it to get the state of the art in empirical research and found it contained almost nothing of use to me as a practitioner. Many of the studies were shoddy (e.g. qualitative case histories--a euphemism for "anecdote") and the better ones are so careful to limit themselves to the tiny experiments they did that you can't derive anything from them. I could mention a couple of exceptions, though, if anyone's interested.
I think the root problem is that software development is complicated, so to do rigorous formal studies on it is expensive. The amount of funding available for this work is a drop in the bucket of what it would need to be. In short, the market value of empirical evidence on software development isn't high enough for anyone to pay for it.
[1] http://neverworkintheory.org/2012/12/12/empirical-evidence-f.... and http://neverworkintheory.org/2012/12/30/why-we-need-evidence.... Notice that the HN discussion of the first post completely failed to answer its question: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4931251.
[2] http://www.amazon.com/Making-Software-Really-Works-Believe/d...
Gallup asked respondents [...] to imagine a "satisfaction ladder" in which the top step represents a respondent's best possible life. Those being polled are then asked where on the ladder they stand
What the results may show is that fantasies about happiness, such as "if only I had more money", lose power as one gets more money. If you run out of fantasies about how you might be happier, it does not follow that you are happy. It could be the opposite! Perhaps the article should be titled, "Money weakens the imagination".
In any case, studies that define "happiness" very differently should not be described as "casting doubt" on one another.
Edit: looking at the paper itself, the "imaginary ladder" was one of two questions asked; the other was (paraphrased) "how satisfied are you on a scale of 1 to 10?" I don't know how the data differs between those two questions.
http://www.malling-hansen.org/friedrich-nietzsche-and-his-ty...
Objective considerations of contemporary phenomena compel the conclusion that success or failure in competitive activities exhibits no tendency to be commensurate with innate capacity, but that a considerable element of the unpredictable must invariably be taken into account.
You probably already have a laboratory running natural experiments in this area: the conversations of the people in your groups. If they lack official language for what they're doing, they have no choice but to make something up. Those can be good creative conditions. If I were you, I might try to get them to tell me what the names are, by listening closely to the words they use in conversation and to which formulations feel easiest and most alive. This often works better when people aren't consciously trying to come up with names but do it spontaneously when talking about something else.
By the way, maybe you shouldn't be down on "school" for what you're doing. It's true that people have a lot of preconceptions about school. But it's also true that your usage is historically deep. "School" didn't originally mean "child processing factory" or whatever it is now. Here's what Etymonline has for it [1]:
"place of instruction," Old English scol, from Latin schola "intermission of work, leisure for learning; learned conversation, debate; lecture; meeting place for teachers and students, place of instruction; disciples of a teacher, body of followers, sect," from Greek skhole "spare time, leisure, rest ease; idleness; that in which leisure is employed; learned discussion;"
That seems pretty close to what you're doing. Historical meanings often have resonance and sometimes make comebacks. I wouldn't relinquish this one if I were you. Imagine if you are part of a resurgence of the original meaning of schools. How cool would that be?!
[1] http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=school
p.s. You might consider "mentor" for what your web site calls "resident", and then "resident" instead of "student"...I think "resident" could go either way.
I'm not sure I like your distinction between developer enjoyment, lack of boilerplate, and state management. To me those things all have to do with good design.
Not to pick on you, but people say this all the time, as in it's probably the thing people say most often on this subject, and I wonder: do we have any evidence for it? That is, do we have any evidence that the mid-tier languages which eschew more powerful abstractions (Java and its peers) lead to either more readable or more shareable code? Or is it one of those things that everybody "knows" but ain't so?
So the point is not to get rid of status difference (which would mean replacing human nature and thus be foolish) but to find organizational forms that are better aligned with how creative work gets done.
Edit: CSS also seems to me the least webby element of the web stack, in the way that Adam Bosworth brilliantly described the web:
That software which is flexible, simple, sloppy, tolerant, and altogether forgiving of human foibles and weaknesses turns out to be actually the most steel-cored, able to survive and grow, while that software which is demanding, abstract, rich but systematized, turns out to collapse in on itself in a slow and grim implosion. [1]
HTML and Javascript, for all their messiness, have the former quality, while CSS is a case of the latter.
[1] http://adambosworth.net/2004/11/18/iscoc04-talk/ - one of the most insightful things I've read about the web and about software in general.
It's pretty funny that the knee-jerk dismissals of Lisp today are the precise opposite of what they used to be.
http://www.npr.org/2013/12/21/256114227/1979-supreme-court-r...
In fact, his classic talk "Growing a Language" is among other things a very polite and implicit, but devastating critique of the design of Java.
APL: Other languages are verbose and irregular.
Part 3: http://blog.modernmechanix.com/houdinis-master-magic-tricks-...
Their site search is actually pretty good.