HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gtani

4,434 karma · joined April 6, 2008

DM gtani @ reddit
submissionscomments
gtani··on Rust Is a Scalable Language
books for peeps contemplating the big leap:

Besides THE book (Klabnik/Nichols), the ones from O'Reilly, Pragmatic and Nostarch (for Rustaceans, Gjengset, in particular as a 2nd book) are excellent to superb. I might have missed a few, these were the ones from 3 public library systems.

Just look for 2nd eds on THE book and Oreilly's Blandy et al. Course i saw one from Wrox that was a pass.

gtani··on The new middle-class gambling addicts: how day trading is ruining lives
Good article, I'm an occasional active trader and I see a lot of pathological behaviors and pretty frequent losses of the magnitudes you read about in /r/WSB...
gtani··on Learning Synths
Over in /r/synthizers, muffwiggler and gearslutz land (there might be other forums where the pretty hardcore hang out) they usually recommend getting a knobby synth and Ableton/logic/bitwig/reaper etc on an apple that won't overheat. So micro/mini brute, DSI mopho w/keys, monologue ($200 used or so), bass station2, ms2000, the Odyssey and ms20 recreations, there's a bunch.

Recommendations for my 2 favorite books, Snoman's book is great bc it covers the whole chain of what a EDM needs, samplers, sequencers, drum machines, DAW...: https://old.reddit.com/r/synthesizers/comments/65o4r4/best_r...

https://www.reddit.com/r/synthesizers/comments/80bmj3/pickin...

https://www.reddit.com/r/synthesizers/comments/7g3uv0/best_a...

gtani··on A Programming Language (1962) [pdf]
I've been looking for a while for a copy of the original red Plivka/Pakin APL book (not the APL2 one, even tho APL2 is what i know best), and they're there now on amazon, under $10.

Now i can relive the arguments about whether Sharp, STSC or APL2 was best

gtani··on Advice on Getting Better from an Accomplished Piano Player (2011)
I've known /met a lot of serious students, some from living next door to Manhattan School of Music, and they all had different advice on practicing. Some had very structured allocations of time, recording all practices and journaling their progress, some said they put their entire being into practicing one tune at a time.

I recommend reading Kenny Werner's Effortless Mastery, which is probably in your public library if you're in a big city, and also the interviews in Wernick/Trischka's Masters of 5 String Banjo, currently going fore absurd asking prices on Amazon and hard to find unless you know a banjo player.

gtani··on Ask HN: Where can I do a self-study math degree online?
Look at UIUC and Open University, MIT's OCW, community/junior colleges can give you a big boost, there's probably a lot of other advice at /r/math, /r/LearnMath and math.stackexchange.

Some older threads:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19811715

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18939913

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19071050

gtani··on Universal Math Solutions in Dimensions 8 and 24
To bootstrap your understanding in general, pursue calculus, linear algebra and probability in tandem, then go thru texts on real analysis and abstract algebra. Also math summary books: Courant/Robbins, Ian Stewart has a couple, Stillwell "Elements of"
gtani··on Fender’s acoustic-electric hybrid is a technological wonder
Interesting, wonder if there's any DSP commonality with the Tonedexter: https://www.mandolincafe.com/forum/threads/143036-Tonedexter
gtani··on Buke and Gase built a huge indie rock career–and its own guitars, software
Good article, I'll have to see reactions on /r/synthesizers, gearslutz where people will talk their own solutions

Also how much applies to laptopless rig built around Pigtronix /EHX / Boss looper or Elektron boxes.

I did think the fan fret guitar looks a lot like Charlie Hunter's or Ormsby's but maybe he's come up with a better MIDI pickup, that wasn't discussed.

gtani··on An AI system for editing music in videos
You can google "source separation" to get background on this, Stanford has what is supposed to be a nice lib.

https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/4oewdq/rnn...

https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/4r92iq/wou...

https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/66j2i4/p_i...

gtani··on Ask HN: What do you do when you suddenly feel like not working anymore?
You need at least half day break from focused pursuits. After that channel energy into other focused pursuit

- playing guitar, piano etc

- studying math, EE, physics

- learn foreign language

- sports, yoga

gtani··on Developer wants to learn ML but don't have math background. Where to start?
Convex optimization, numerical methods books like Burden/Faires or Trefethen/Bau.

If you want to get a good fundamental grasp, intro to real analysis books. Cambridge and Oxford have good reading lists to prep for 1st year of their programs

https://www.balliol.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate-admiss...

____________________

and the math appendix/pre chapters of Goodfellow et al Deep Learning

and http://www.cs.huji.ac.il/~shais/UnderstandingMachineLearning...

gtani··on A History of APL in 50 Functions
APL and C were my first languages, but I can't read most of those, it's been too long.

Merrill Lynch's mortgage operation was an IBM APL2 shop with a few dozen programmers, along with people doing non-mortgage stuff.

http://www.thocp.net/software/languages/apl.htm

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/APL_(programming_language)#APL...

I remember that people who came from the other dialects, Sharp and STSC, had different ways of doing e.g. nested arrays and calling out to the OS which made their code hard to read.

gtani··on Magus Modular Synthesizer Toolkit
Interesting. I have a few rack mounts (mopho, ms2k) but not a modular person, I'm a little baffled by this like if i'm eventually decent at max or PureData, what's the advantage besides its cheap.

I'll have to see what they say in /r/synthesizers, muffwigglers, gearslutz etc.

gtani··on Book: Mathematics for Machine Learning
The target audience would be people that have roughly 2 years of undergrad math, the 4 semester calc sequence or high school equivalent, probability/stats, linear algebra, some computational courses using e.g. Numerical Analysis by Burden/Faires.

If you look in Goodfellow et al's Deep Learning book, Murphy's Machine Learning text and others mentioned here (Learning from Data, Shalev-Shwartz/Ben-David) the prereq's are always some variation of above and I think you could do a lot of the above at U.S. community colleges, at least the CC's around me.

Frankly, you'd have to do a bunch of self study beyond CC and there's no shortcut/royal road. So the key is self study, that's a discipline anyone that wants to do Data Science/machine learning for real needs

gtani··on Ask HN: 'Crash Courses' for Mathematics Related to DL, ML and Data Analysis
Similar quesion, aimed at math majors: https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/81px9v/what_are_some_...

Really, if you're not going to go to e.g. community college where you can do a lot of this (LA, prob/stats, calc) your best shot is to find study groups in Data science meetups, etc which are plentiful in major cities since many people have the same impulse. Truthfully, self study rarely gets far if people never went beyond Calc 2.

Here's a blog about one guy's adventure, read the part where he talks about Shores' LA text(not a bad book by the way but yes, lots of typos): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8996024

gtani··on How to Learn Piano with Technology
My sisters teacher was a Catholic nun who would get mad and slap them if they played sloppily. My teacher was a very nice lady who never raised her voice. My sisters progressed a lot faster
gtani··on How to Learn Piano with Technology
Pretty sensible self teaching approach. I thought this would be mostly about tools like synthesia, glowing LEDs built into keyboards and Ableton piano rolls.

My sense is that not many people get far with self teaching piano but some are happy to be able to e.g. comp chords out of Oscar Peterson's etudes book slowly or play a few pieces out of those Fabor Adult Piano books, which are pretty good.

I think most people that try to self teach a difficult instrument, trumpet or violin, give up. My sense of difficult is that anything I didn't learn as a kid is more or less difficult (I had 15 years lessons on 3 instruments)

gtani··on Ask HN: As a data scientist, what should be in my toolkit in 2018?
You could work thru one of the ML in R/python books e.g. Géron or Raschka/Mirjalili and then dig into the lin alg, prob, stats, calculus/analysis you see there with the books everybody recommends, LA by Axler, Strang or Proabilty by Bertsekas /Tsitsiklis, Real Analysis by Pugh, Abbott, Strichartz etc
gtani··on How to Study Mathematics (2017)
Some books on proof, theorems/axioms, set theory, epsilon/delta/continuity/limits/differentiability, natural/rationals/reals/countability etc before heading into your first proof based LA or analysis sequence:

- Kevin Houston "How to Think Like a Mathematician"

- Keith Devlin "Intro Mathematical Thinking"

- "How to Study as a Mathematics Major" Lara Alcock (for some reason, she/Oxford Press has 2 books with seemingly identical content under Math Major and Math Degree titles)

gtani··on No Causal Effect of Music Practice on Ability (2014) [pdf]
I also think this is flawed. Wind and orchestral string players (violin, cello etc) must develop a fine ear for pitch/intonation, pianists usually aren't given any choice as to tuning/voicing/regulation of the instruments they have to perform on and I think over time, many lose sensitivity to non Pythagorean intervals and ET deviations from just intonation.

So everybody's lumped together, those that play one instrument vs those than are proficient on 3 or more

gtani··on Neural Networks, Types, and Functional Programming (2015)
This covers some of same topics plus the rapidly expanding #s of frameworks, SIMD /SIMT backends etc https://julialang.org/blog/2017/12/ml&pl

20 pg tutorial on why RNN's are tricky https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.01078

gtani··on Ask HN: If I work with applied mathematics should I still study analysis?
Without knowing your background, Pugh's and Abbott's are usually good choices as are Schramm's Dover, and while not really analysis texts, don't forget the classic fundamentals/foundations books by Courant/Robbins What is Mathematics, Ian Stewart/D Tall Foundations of Math, Felix Klein etc

Here's lots of reviews: https://www.maa.org/tags/real-analysis

https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/tagged/real-analysi...

https://www.reddit.com/r/math/wiki/faq#wiki_what_are_some_go...

gtani··on Ask HN: If I work with applied mathematics should I still study analysis?
Hard to say, we don't know what your calc, diff EQ, LA, probability/stats etc classes were like. You could self study Pugh, Abbott or Spivak. At a bare minimum you can read Lara Alcock/s little red book on analysis. Or you might unfortunately be in the position that you don't quite have the support group, focus or prep for Pugh or Abbott's books.

The other question is, what are you giving up to study real analysis? If you don't have great software engineering skills, along with related skills (linux/network admin, database design/tuning) there's a good argument that you would be better off developing those skills instead.

gtani··on Open source modular synth software lets you create 70s & 80s electronic music
Yeah i'm a fun of scrounging around for cheap little used modules like Mopho, ms2k, ms20 mini, mother32, mini/monologue, the Roland and yamaha recreations jp08, bass station 2 and various novas from Novation, emu proteus 2k. Roland actually has released dozens of rackmounts, some quite decent. Also kits: Preen, audiothingies, mutable instruments etc. It's astounding what you can buy for under $300 in many cases.

I do wish for a cheap knobby controller like the maudio axiom or novation SL mk2 that has reliable faders, pots and encoders. Those are the one instrument product i would say you should buy new and get the extended warranty from Sam ash or Guitar center. When the pots start shooting out lots of spurious midi CC's, deoxit's not going to save you. Deoxit's great for making door hinges stop squeaking tho

gtani··on An Adventure in the Nth Dimension (2011) [pdf]
there was discussion also on threads about the book "Foundations of Data Science" by Hopcroft /Kannan/Blum but i can't find those threads
gtani··on Confession as an AI researcher; seeking advice
What you say is correct, but that reddit thread concerns (I think) a narrow class of devs of which there are many here: US CS majors who graduate with only a few semesters of calc and discrete and are underequipped to bootstrap themselves if they need to understand, say, topology. But they have to gain some understanding, so i put a few book lists in that reddit thread, took about ... 5 minutes.

BTW I really like what i've seen of your guidebooks, or whatever you call them (neo-textbooks?).

gtani··on A View of Mathematics (2005) [pdf]
also for all in 1 math for physics books, there's a bunch: Arfken et al., Mary Boas, Riley/Hobson /Bence etc: https://www.amazon.com/Mathematical-Methods-Physicists-Seven...

and http://www.goldbart.gatech.edu/PostScript/MS_PG_book/bookmas...

These are sort of orthogonal to the OP's link, they're not covering analysis, abstract algebra and topology, instead they're covering dif eq, spectral analysis, probability/stats, linear algebra.

gtani··on A View of Mathematics (2005) [pdf]
some other survey /panorama books for various levels: What is Mathematics, Courant and Robbins (I haven't read the 2nd ed, edited by Ian Stewart)

https://www.amazon.com/All-Mathematics-You-Missed-Graduate/d...

gtani··on Ask HN: What maths are critical to pursuing ML/AI?
For going all in, https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/mathematics/18-657-mathematics-o...

But a good number of people that are doing work haven't taken real analysis, or it's been awhile and so you should be current on multivariable and vector calculus. Calculus of variations shows up from time to time.

For math reviews, look at the following (there's others if you want more refs, ping me):

http://www.deeplearningbook.org/

https://metacademy.org/roadmaps/

http://www.cs.huji.ac.il/~shais/UnderstandingMachineLearning...

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →