HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gtsop

917 karma · joined March 26, 2020

submissionscomments
gtsop··on Grayjay Desktop App
I didn't see it as tone policing. From my point of view, I saw a very interesting application being shared and I hoped it would be good and prosperous so i can use it. When the first comment says "i hate that you do X" it is a bit discouraging towards a team of developers who have probably poured tons of free hours into making this. Words play with psychology, and it is my personal interest that these devs have good morale to make this app great, and that meand giving them feedback about obvious mistakes in a tone that does not hurt this morale. I hope that make sense
gtsop··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
Thanks for clarifying, i understand my phrasing have hit a distinction in the american government bodies which I was not aware and willing to step on.

The essence of my sentence was to be ironinc about any government institution not really doing what is best for the people but what is best for buisness and power.

gtsop··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
I would recommend you take a peak outside your window and see what the USA government is doing to it's people and the peoples all around the world.
gtsop··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
It is about freedom of speech, the freedom of China's speech within USA.
gtsop··on US lawmakers tell Apple, Google to be ready to remove TikTok from stores Jan. 19
> This was a decision made by the US Congress. It is by definition not authoritarian.

Clearly the US Congress represents the will of the majority...

gtsop··on D-Link says it won't patch 60k older modems
Ok I get it, but if anything, people pay way less attention to security than they should. So I personally don't mind. I would prefer living in a world where people spend too much time caring for security
gtsop··on D-Link says it won't patch 60k older modems
I like this. But i also assume parts of the stack are going to be reused in newer models as well, so this is probably going to be a blocker for them accepting it.
gtsop··on Keynes Predicted We Would Be Working 15-Hour Weeks. Why Was He So Wrong? (2015)
Seems, but isn't. The original argument I criticized says:

People dont work less because they will make so much more money that they just don't want to leave it on the table.

I said: it is more realistic to say that people don't work less because even if they worked for 15 hours they would still not make a living wage.

The difference: The first argument says people work more because they are greedy. My argurment says people work more because they can't survive if they work less.

> no country is even remotely close to 15hours per day.

People don't only work for what their legal framework says. Apart from working un-registered overtime that can go up to 9-10-12 hours, many people also work second jobs, participate in gig-work and such. Easily adding up to 12-14 hours a day, and factor in 6days out of 7days per week instead of your regular 5.

Yes, 15 hours may be an exaggeration, but not by a lot. And definitely closer to the reality of things than what Kayne said.

gtsop··on Keynes Predicted We Would Be Working 15-Hour Weeks. Why Was He So Wrong? (2015)
I am wondering where you got your facts from. You are saying that of the majority if people on earth got double the wage (work 8 hours and get paid the equivalent of working for 16) they would live a human life. You have new yorkers in mind maybe? Or londoners?

A source for you and the classic HN bubble living downvoters

44% Of global population lives under the line of poverty:

https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/poverty/overview

gtsop··on Keynes Predicted We Would Be Working 15-Hour Weeks. Why Was He So Wrong? (2015)
What a nice bubble world view. "People don't work less hours because they would gain so much more money if they worked more"

What is actually much closer to the reality of the majority of working people is that they work 15hours a day and STILL they can't earn what they need to live a quality life.

His prediction was wrong because his theory was wrong

gtsop··on The tech utopia fantasy is over
Not saying you are wrong, but let's not dismiss the need for good argumentation when you say something out of the norm. Dissidence with arguments does a great service to everyone involved.

Having said that, people here do downvote based on opinion allignment, which is very hurtful. I've seen perfectly legit comments (with sources) that are out of the norm being downvoted because people just don"t agree with them

gtsop··on Amazon won't accept written communication
It surelly used to exist, I have settled returns, refunds and reacheduling of deliveries through their chat in the past. Last time was 5-6 months ago
gtsop··on Ask HN: Is distributed LLM training in browsers (WebRTC and WebGPU) possible?
Possible? Yes. Practical? No

It is possible because training is already being done using distributed methods in the datacenter. It is not practical because of the sheer volume of network delay piled on top of the computation

gtsop··on Solomonic learning: Large language models and the art of induction
Dark times for science when such quotes are thrown as legitimate.

The article is extremely technical and doesn't really explain the quote other than acknowledging that there are stuff we don't understand yet.

And really, a person will never grasp machine learning and AI as long as they keep drawing unbased parallels to humans and machines.

gtsop··on Apple's mouse is so bad that Tim Cook prefers using a different brand for work
You realise this is extremely dependent on the individual's use right? I was provided such a mouse at my workplace and had to charge it every month. The first time i forgot to charge it overnight i cursed myself. The second time, I demanded another mouse.
gtsop··on Open-Source Software Is in Crisis
Open-Source is in Crisis because Open Source is the corporate spin on Free Software in order to make money, which as many have pointed out, isn't a great fit. It cpuld work, but as an exception.

On the other hand, actual Free Software as in GPL are in no crisis at all. I'll smirk everytime i see such news and it warms my heart. I know, i'm a bad person.

gtsop··on How Convenient: Every Country Needs AI Sovereignty
It is obviously convenient for nvidia, but does that mean it's false?
gtsop··on Shell wildcard expansion (un)safety
I've been always using -r for grep so it never occured to me that such a thing could happen

Looks like user error to me tbh, similar to `rm -rf /`. Should `rm` give a warning when / is the argument?

gtsop··on Refactoring Barrel Files with Codemods
Relevant: The codebase I worked on was to huge and too uncovered by tests to modify automatically. The pain point was jest tests, due to barrel files. I ended up making this plugin that is meant to do codemods only durring jest tests, skips all re-exports and thus barrel files. Performance of tests have gone 2x

Having legacy codebases in mind, I built in utilities to skip modifying code that breaks when modified

https://github.com/gtsop/babel-jest-boost

gtsop··on Git Pulse – AI Summaries of 1M+ Open Source Commits
Having extensively used chatgpt, i would never trust the accuracy of any such tool. I know it can be right 90% of the time, but it's the other 10% that will hurt the most if you trust it. The more AI generated content gets published on the net the more i seek human sources for my information.
gtsop··on Platform engineering is the industrialization of software development
The picture this article paints does not allign with what I personally observe. I would say the majority of developers do not have such a breadth of knowledge across the stack. And this is a bad thing.

I believe the industry is historically extremely young and has many decades ahead to start settling a bit. I believe platform engineering is not the reason. K8s didn't even exist 10 years ago.

gtsop··on GitHub Spark: enable anyone to create software with AI and a managed runtime
Rendering some trivial UI from scratch and adding interactivity is not impressive.

These tools will be exciting when they pass a certain thresshold. This is building a moderatly complex app, and then add a feature that requires refactoring without breaking existing features.

I highly doubt we are anywhere close.

gtsop··on HTML Form Validation is underused
Are we seriously talking of HTML by using React examples? The article doesn't even explicitly aknowledge the fact that it is written within the context of react.
gtsop··on How to Hold Developers Accountable
This article litterally talked of accountability non-stop without actually touching on accountability. It could be reduced to "be nice when people deliver on deadlines, be strict when they don't"
gtsop··on Google, Microsoft, and Perplexity promote scientific racism in AI search results
I believe "promoting' is the wrong word here. "Surfacing" is, I believe, more fitting.

LLMs are a mirror of it's data. It's data are artifacts of our society, which clearly contain a heavy dose of racism. Thus these LLMs show us the ugly truth of our societal artifacts.

Although I despise Google, Microsoft etc, I don't believe it is constructive to paint a false picture of what is happening.

gtsop··on Getting Called "Paid Actor" by Linus Torvalds
You're struggling to understand a confusion that doesn't exist. That's why you struggle. Was there any business conducted with these maintainers? In case you live under a rock, these western "sanctions" have been extended to blocking even works of art (theaters, songs, etc) that have been made by Russian artists long before Putin was born. I know that it may be hard for the enterprneurial mind to understand that not everything in life is buisness, same as it is hard for a hammer to understand that not everything is nails. But in the real world, you know, the world were actual wars are happening and people are dying, not the world of markets, there is a hard propaganda from the West to block anything Russian on all matters that is so blinding, only someone with closed eyes cannot see it (and even they can sense it)
gtsop··on Getting Called "Paid Actor" by Linus Torvalds
I guess all the people who downvoted have a based analysis on how removing russians from contribution lists damages the war capacity of Russia and is not categorised under the notion of "propaganda".
gtsop··on Getting Called "Paid Actor" by Linus Torvalds
In what way is that a compliance reason? On what earth are you putting pressure by removing kudos from a list?
gtsop··on Understanding the Limitations of Mathematical Reasoning in LLMs
LLMs are inherently emulators of digitaly imprinted artifacts of human consciousness. When people trully grasp what this means they will stop being buffled by the fact that LLMs performance deteriorate when novelty of the task increases.

EDIT: Had there been an ounce of actual true reasoning emerging in LLMs, openai would have been running this thing privatly 24/7 to produce new science and capture pattents that would give them economic dominance. Not trying to sell tokens to us all.

gtsop··on Meta is accused of "bullying" the open-source community
I don't care for the "bureaucrats in the OSI" nor the definition of open source, but your argument is complete nonsense.

The fact that llama is not open source does not make it less useful or less appreciated. Nor should anything be considered open source because it is useful or appreciated

← PreviousPage 6 of 18Next →