HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gtsop

917 karma · joined March 26, 2020

submissionscomments
gtsop··on A Paper That Says Science Should Be Impartial Was Rejected by Major Journals
Yes! I am not in academia and I do not know if such a concept would play well, but I can use a parallel in cybersecurity. It would be like having a Red and Blue team. The Blue team produces research and the Red team tries to debunk it, both are paid well to do their jobs. Also, alternating between Blue and Red can help the individual progress.
gtsop··on A Paper That Says Science Should Be Impartial Was Rejected by Major Journals
Well, you can't have impartial science when science is being funded by institutions of conflicting economic interests. Period. Identity politics is just a distorted lens through which the core problem manifests.

The author barely touches it and the paper mentions funding but not extensively. It's hypocritical not to talk about money when that's the true underlying reason they argue about. It's not about knowledge, it's not about advancement of intellect, it's about who will get funding to survive as a scientist/researcher.

If everyone had secured funding, there would be no discussion at all, because all the false science would eventually get discredited and put in the junk bin.

gtsop··on A Paper That Says Science Should Be Impartial Was Rejected by Major Journals
https://web.archive.org/web/20230504093610/https://www.nytim...
gtsop··on Walkout at global science journal over ‘unethical’ fees
Maybe I am wrong here, but shouldn't the quality metric be whether it acts as a basis for practical applications? As far as I understand, research is supposed to give theoretical answers and frameworks. X works like this. Y doesn't work like that. This knowledge should then be applied to the real world and will be prooved wrong or right. Maybe a silly thought, but I suppose pre 1800 science didn't have to pay such fees to proove the quality of their work, they just applied it.

(I understand not all papers can be immediatelly applied, but is that the majotity of the work? And if so, is that a good thing?)

gtsop··on Walkout at global science journal over ‘unethical’ fees
I like your point but let's dive another layer down the rabbithole.

Why do researchers need to buy prestige in the first place? Academic research should be done for the sake of advancement of knowledge and of course the people doing it should make a good living out of it. How does buying prestige come into play here? (just asking)

gtsop··on Ask HN: Why not permit use Linux laptop for work
As others have mentioned, security is not just about connecting to a vpn. Bare in mind that the IT department has to take care of hundrends of techologically illiterate pc users in their organization and they need as much remote control as possible and as much standardization as possible. I am not saying it's undoable to plug in a linux pc in there, I am just describing some factors

Depending on what work you do exactly and how beefy your machine is, you can spin up a virtualbox with linux to do your job. I had such a case and did my work just fine.

gtsop··on Ask HN: How to keep up with non-mainstream AI developments
Can I ask what is your purpose to keep up with it? The answer can better direct your actions.

E.g: If you don't want to miss out on groundbreaking tools, just casualy visiting HN will allow such projects to hit you in the face when they get enough momentum

if you want to dive in AI as a technology then start doing courses on ML and then neural networks and move on from there to other AI tech.

if you are just curious to obeserve what is happening in this innovative space, I would join some project's discord where tons of discussions are happening and people share tons of resources and projects with each other, eg auto-gpt discord is such a place

gtsop··on AI’s biggest risk is the corporations that control them
Their right to exclude everyone else from the decision making process. A.k.a their right to property and command over crucial infrastructure of the human society.
gtsop··on Status, Not Sex
It is 2023 and I really can't handle any more pseudo theories of why women are unequal, it's like watching a black whole sucking the IQ out of everybody.

If women were economically self sufficient then they wouldn't tolerate any injustice. Why are they not economically self-sufficient?

1) False question. Only worker-women aren't economically self sufficient and they have to tolerate injustice in their work and family environment. Why are worker-women not self sufficient? Because (drum roll) of how capitalism works, workers are not meant to be economically independent because then they wouldn't have to deal with their boss' crap. And who would work for the enterprises then?

2) Ok, but even worker-women are treated unequally among worker-men. Yes, because of marriage which propagates the economic injustice within the borders of the family.

3) Q: When were women treated equally (or even as superior to men) in the human history?

A: In classless societies

gtsop··on Get The TLDR Of Any YouTube Video
You had me until this:

> If you stop watching videos, there will be no reason to make the videos.

Nope! The correct sentence is:

If you stop watching videos, there will be no profit into making the videos.

The reason to make them still exists: sharing knowledge.

You have to ubderstand that all digital products are inherently repulsed by the market economy because of the 0 cost to reproduce. The history of the monetization problems of video, music, software and anything digital reflects the attempt to lure them back into the market. Up to one degree you can do it, but it is inevitable that in the long term you won't be able to make money out of digital products as easily as you do with classic "physical" ones.

gtsop··on The Imperative of Free Software
Thankfully, information technology is inherently repulsed by capitalism and "proprietaryness". Whether people realize this or not only affects how soon changes will occur. But it is inevitable that changes will occur and the future is gplv3.
gtsop··on A Better Argument for Working Less
This is THE argument to working less IMO.

However, if we do not take into account which forces drive long working hours then we will not get closer to achieving short working hours.

oversimplified, but, long hours, overtimes, etc are driven by the simple fact that capitalists 1) have running costs that keep running when their workers don't work 2) the technological degradation of the means of production accelerates as time goes by.

Thus, an enterprise has the economic motive to squeeze out as much value as possible, as soon as possible out of their productive means (machinery, buildings, equipment). However, the only way to do that is to get people to work.

Taylorism may had it's problems (as described in this article - I do not have any sources) but in general, higher work intensity and longer hours do produce higher yields in industry and manual jobs. in such jobs, stress and burnout are not a considerable factor to employers because of how easily replacable their workers are. Simply put, workers are being squeezed empty and thrown away when they are unable to carry on. That's why younger people are prefered due to their bilogical ability to endure more compared to older people.

Surely I see why shorter hours are more productive and that was also proven in the past durring the times when workers demanded 12 - 10 - 8 hour days. But I do not see why the majority of the global enterprises will choose employee wellness over constant use of their machinery, I think they can only be forced into such a change, not convinced

gtsop··on Make the future bright again: On building a new philosophy of progress
An ultra individualist complaining about progress of the non-individual a.k.a the common.

The problem has been solved already, there is nothing new to discover here. The capitalist economy is the driving the current state of technological progress. It used to have an accelerated pace compared to pre-capitalist economies and it has now reached it's limits.

You may like it, you may dislike it, it doesn't matter. It is what it is. It is a mode of production, a mode of progress and it produces it's artifacts.

Like every tool, when you try to do something bigger, it becomes obsolete, unusable, unsustanable. You can't build a skyscraper with a shovel.

You may disagree with what a better tool will be. You may be emotionally attached to your tool and may not want to abandon it. That's ok. Just dont helusinate over putting an addon to your shovel that will help us build a skyscraper and sell it as the solution.

This kind of philosophy is not new at all, it is 300 years old.

gtsop··on Critique of the mind/body problem
It's 2023 and we are still having this discussion because of mainstream flawed philosophy shoved in our throats every single day.

Matter, in the philosophical sence, is not to be confused whith the concept of mass in physics. The philosophical concept of matter encompases everything that exists (indepedent of individual experience). Existence != mass (eg light). Critiquing the "emergencene" of conciousness from matter as a leap of logic is like saying it's a logical leap to talk of breathing as a emergent property of the respiratory system.

Breathing is not a "thing" you can touch, but i bet you, you'll get into some very big trouble if you stop doing it.

Better to think of it as a process. We can agree that processes are real, yet don't consist of mas.

Same goes for consiousness. And the same goes for a gazillion things that are very very real, but do not fit into the mental bucket of holding some mass with your hands

gtsop··on Ask HN: What is your favorite front end state management solution?
I remember I didn't have any concerns with state management when I was using emberjs. not sure why.

Now, working with react, I have successfully avoided redux and any extra state management like yhe plague.

Good abstractions, hook factories (under-disscussed topic imho), some sparse contexts. So far it has worked out great. I recently managed to implement quite complex requirements using these disciplines on a project while some other part of the same project contains redux-hell to do some simpler things

gtsop··on Ask HN: How do you overcome feeling completely lost in life?
> But no matter which end I try to start from, I can't seem to escape the sheer meaninglessness of it all.

First of all, you are right. There isn't an once of "meaning" to anything. So don't feel "flawed" for seeing the naked truth as it is, while surrounded by a bunch of us delusionals thinking there is some sort of "meaning" to our lives. The meaning is what we put in ourselves. It's a product of our minds. Sso there is nothing to escape from.

Now, what next then?

Writting this whole post shows effort and concern. You seem concerned about your situation. This is good, this is a driving force. Use it. You are an organism, a system, that for some reason function out of the "norm". Study this system scientifically and figure out why that it. Not necesserily for the purpose of getting better. But for the shake of knowledge, for the shake of understanding yourself and putting your mind at ease.

> Making friends/maintaining close relationships doesn't come naturally to me, and the more effort I put into it, the more detached and dishonest I feel.

No reason to feel dishonest. Be straight upfront, state your selfish reasons for interacting with others and i bet you will find people who will love to hang out with you and help you, because you know why? They also need what you need, they just don't see it as clearly as you do. You know you need to interact with them to get better, they just do it instictively without knowing. As before, you've just seen the naked truth, unlike the rest.

gtsop··on Ask HN: Is it still possible to live in a terminal?
coworker #1 was literally waiting 30seconsa for his webstorm to open a subdirectory (in a really big code tree)

coworker #2 was struggling with his vscode autodeleting some imports

strange times when you are the vim developer in the house and the one with the most solid IDE...

gtsop··on Normalising Layoffs/Firing
> This industry is nothing like the factories.

You seem to ignore both the trend shifts in factory jobs and software jobs. Factory workers once had exactly the same status as you describe here:

> 99% of these people will be able to take two weeks of free time and find another job for the same (or often better) pay

Also, software engineers (at the big scale) are slowly but steadily loosing the glorious position in the workforce market they once had.

gtsop··on Ask HN: Which web browser do you use and why?
Have been happily using librewolf for over a year now. 100% suggested to friends
gtsop··on Ask HN: Getting tired of complexity in web development
A couple builders were complaining why they couldn't build houses like in the old days when you would slap 2 blocks of wood together and call it a day. now you have to use steel, heatproof it, soundproof it, check the integrity of the build, submit designs, take safety into account, what a waste...

obviously sarcastic. most of the things you are complaining about bring to mind a person who is bored of doing responsible coding.

gtsop··on A Cheap 2.5GbE PoE Unmanaged Switch
No it's not over the internet by I still need it :D I have many devices connected over Ethernet to my router, a couple of those wire up my land disks as described above. it is a legit use case and tbh, anyone buying a switch most likely has an internal networking use case that goes beyond just using the internet.
gtsop··on Is the FSF Fighting the Previous War?
Quite a rehashed discussion I think. I the essence of my question towards the fsf critics camp is: There is a non-gplv3 alternative for every single thing the fsf has made. You can literally live your life as normal without even touching their software. Why is there such a chronic pressure towards making the fsf more pragmatic? what do you wish to get out of such a move? aren't there other organizations that fight for that cause you want better than fsf? honest question.
gtsop··on A Cheap 2.5GbE PoE Unmanaged Switch
I have KVM disks sitting in network mounted drives. when I use those kvms the disk read/write happens over the network, and the 1gbps limit can be easily reached as you can imagine.
gtsop··on Kazakhstan’s president: We’re moving full speed ahead toward reform
> The top comment implies that the protestors who demanded lower gas (propane, not gasoline) prices and later political reforms were the ones responsible for violence, or involved in it.

What section are you refering to? Must have lost something

gtsop··on Kazakhstan’s president: We’re moving full speed ahead toward reform
Seems pretty clear cut to me. Rioting implies violence. The examples you noted are bound to happen durring such times.
gtsop··on The Next Chapter for Learning on YouTube
Mind to share that openwrt channel? Thanks!
gtsop··on Hammer and Tickle (2006)
Why the downvotes I wonder? Ok let me try using something the soviets didn't have: gpu shortages!
gtsop··on What’s a Fair Price? Or: You’re Not Underpaid
I admit that I didn't manage to read after my mentioned paragraph
gtsop··on What’s a Fair Price? Or: You’re Not Underpaid
Not in all sectors. There are many low wage jobs that employeers don't give a damn about constant personel rotation because they always find people and the profits are up
gtsop··on What’s a Fair Price? Or: You’re Not Underpaid
> In most cases, if you find a price unfair, you wouldn’t agree to it, so if someone does agree, that’s evidence that they find it fair, which is evidence that it is fair.

Lol, no? It makes me wonder if the author lives in the real world. Accepting a deal does not happen in a vacumn and is in no way evidence of fairness. 1) it could be there are no other people offering what you need, forcing you to accept an unfair deal 2) it could be a trade union forcing unfair deals on a sector so you really don't have a choise 3) You may find out the deal is unfair after the fact because some new information came to light, and so much more

← PreviousPage 8 of 18Next →