HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

guenthert

1,704 karma · joined August 12, 2015

submissionscomments
guenthert··on France Launches Government Linux Desktop Plan as Windows Exit Begins
> Linux still doesn't have anywhere near as nice and cohesive as Group Policy, Active Directory etc.

I take your word for it (I know of Kerberos and LDAP and Netscape and Sun trying to make such palatable, but clearly haven't followed that in the last quarter-century).

That assumes however the server to be currently MS Windows. For government agencies, I'd rather expect some Mainframe to be (and remain) in place. Surely IBM (or here rather Groupe Bull) has user authentication/authorization figured out (more than half a century ago, methinks).

guenthert··on France to ditch Windows for Linux to reduce reliance on US tech
I puzzles me to no end why the typical office clerk should care about the OS at all. I understand that secretaries will be trained on MS Word and will then have a strong preference to use such (or at least something which very closely resembles it). Same for accountants with Excel. But clerks in e.g. Revenue Service? Those I expect to interact (perhaps these days via a Web interface) with custom software. Why would those ever see a 'Start' button or somesuch?
guenthert··on RAM Has a Design Flaw from 1966. I Bypassed It [video]
And those memory arrays cannot detect access from the bus?

I'm not saying that it's easy or cheap or worthwhile (I'd rather guess it's not in most cases), but I don't see why it couldn't be done.

guenthert··on How NASA built Artemis II’s fault-tolerant computer
Multiple and dissimilar redundancy is nice and all that, but is there a manual override? Apollo could be (and at least in Apollo 11 and 13 it had to), but is this still possible and feasible? I'd guess so, as it's still manned by (former) test pilots, much like Apollo.
guenthert··on How NASA built Artemis II’s fault-tolerant computer
I think he refers to SpaceWire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceWire.
guenthert··on DRAM has a design flaw from 1966. I bypassed it [video]
No, something is funny here. In the previous submission (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47680023) the only (competently) criticizing comment (by jeffbee) was downvoted into oblivion/flagged.
guenthert··on DRAM has a design flaw from 1966. I bypassed it [video]
Indeed. And only for certain DRAM refresh strategies. I mean, it's at least conceivable that a memory management system responsible for the refresh notices that a given memory location is requested by the cache and then fills the cache during the refresh (which afaiu reads the memory) or -- simpler to implement perhaps -- delays the refresh by a μs allowing the cache-fill to race ahead.

(seems that in the earlier submission, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47680023, jeffbee hinted that IBM zEnterprise is doing something to that effect)

Said that, I'm not convinced that this is a big issue in practice. If you really care about performance, you got to avoid cache misses.

guenthert··on Top laptops to use with FreeBSD
Yeah, compare to https://ubuntu.com/certified/laptops it is.

Years ago, there was a project combining Debian with the kernel from FreeBSD. That never made sense to me and the project seems to have died meanwhile. More sensible, IMHO, might be to bolt the FreeBSD user space unto the Linux kernel. That way one would get fairly broad and current hardware support and could still enjoy a classic Unix look&feel and stable ABI.

guenthert··on Floating point from scratch: Hard Mode
" until you have proven it works, it is broken!"

immediately followed by

"Time to run some tests!"

Prompted a grin. Then however "If we wanted to test this using directed testing we would need to test for all 2^32 input combinations, which sounds like a terrible idea …

… and exactly what I am going to do "

Wait, exhaustively testing float number space ... I read about that before. Might have been https://randomascii.wordpress.com/2014/01/27/theres-only-fou... covered also here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34726919

guenthert··on DeiMOS – A Superoptimizer for the MOS 6502
Interesting project and well written. That only made me miss some links to prior art more though.

iirc, there was a superoptimizer (I belief the term was coined and motivated in that article) in the early nineties for M68k. https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/36206.36194 might have been that.

guenthert··on Decisions that eroded trust in Azure – by a former Azure Core engineer
Particularly when simultaneously "We are currently in YC Startup School as Geddy at geddy.io and we plan to launch soon."
guenthert··on Decisions that eroded trust in Azure – by a former Azure Core engineer
"While some may see this as a dick move and I wasn’t exactly proud of it, but I actually waited for Daniel’s wife, Katie, to go into labor before bringing all of this up with his management."

Holy cow! Now I've unfortunately witnessed some ugly office behavior too, but this is quite another level.

guenthert··on IBM Announces Strategic Collaboration with Arm
You don't read much about IBM here, but this is the wrong site to look for them. A big chunk of IBM's business comes from other businesses outside the IT industry. You're more likely to read about IBM in the Wall Street Journal; Google finds "IBM" at wsj.com about 48000 times (it finds "oracle" there about 30000 times).
guenthert··on Windows 95 defenses against installers that overwrite a file with an older one
Ha, you're absolutely right. The "has become a target" got me there. So glad, Zig wasn't targeted there.
guenthert··on Windows 95 defenses against installers that overwrite a file with an older one
"As Zig has evolved, it has become a target to avoid calling Win32 APIs from kernel32.dll etc., instead using lower-level ones in ntdll.dll."

If we needed an example of why we should avoid using passive voice, this is it.

guenthert··on The Cloud: The dystopian book that changed Germany (2022)
Isn't it more plausible that she mentioned there were radioactive clouds flying in from Chernobyl, because there were radioactive clouds flying in from Chernobyl? After all, it were the even further away Swedes who discovered the fall out from Chernobyl first and alarmed the world.
guenthert··on Everything old is new again: memory optimization
strtok() happily punches those holes in. Now you could argue, the resulting strings, while null-terminated, aren't true substrings (as the origin string is now corrupted), but in the context of parsing (particularly here using white-space as delimiter), that wouldn't be much an issue.
guenthert··on Whistler: Live eBPF Programming from the Common Lisp REPL
While this is an interesting project, I found following grating:

"Permissions without root

You don’t need root. Grant capabilities to SBCL:

sudo setcap cap_bpf,cap_perfmon+ep /usr/bin/sbcl

Now sbcl --load my-bpf-program.lisp works as your regular user. Tracepoint format files need chmod a+r to allow non-root compilation with deftracepoint."

That's obviously not ideal. Better might be to create a purpose-built image. Unlike perl, sbcl doesn't even pretend to care about security. Taint mode extension for sbcl, anybody?

guenthert··on What came after the 486?
Well pentiums of course! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/It%27s_All_About_the_Pentiums
guenthert··on Debunking Zswap and Zram Myths
> The LRU inversion argument is just plain from the code presented and a logical consequence of how swap priority and zram's block device architecture interact, I'm not sure numbers would add much there.

Yes, while it is all very plausible, the run times of a given workload (on a given, documented system) known to cause memory pressure to the point of swapping with vanilla Linux (default swappiness or some appropriate value), zram and zswap would be appreciated.

https://linuxblog.io/zswap-better-than-zram/ at least qualifies that zswap performs better when using a fast NVMe device as swap device and zram remains superior for devices with slow or no swap device.

guenthert··on Debunking Zswap and Zram Myths
So much polemic and no numbers? If it is a performance issue, show me the numbers!
guenthert··on BIO: The Bao I/O Coprocessor
I appreciate the intro, motivation and comparison to the PIO of the RP2040/2350. How would this compare to the (considerably older, slower, but more flexible) Parallax P8X32A ("Propeller")?
guenthert··on MAUI Is Coming to Linux
The MATE DE is fairly popular among the small (not so small in India) but growing (thanks to Windows 11 no doubt) Linux desktop market, isn't it? They strive for Wayland compatibility, but aren't quite there (such I take from their release notes; I myself use an ancient version of Ubuntu/Mate here, right now).

I'm not all that informed regarding Waylands benefits and shortcomings (just being puzzled when "performance" or "overhead" is quoted as reason to move away from X11, remembering that the latter didn't seem unbearable slow 30 years ago and that performance of computers in general and computer graphics in particular increased manifold since then). There are however some who should know, who don't seem all that excited: https://www.kicad.org/blog/2025/06/KiCad-and-Wayland-Support...

guenthert··on Alpha Micro AM-1000E and AM-1200
They didn't (not for AMOS at least, the UNIMOS capable machines had an external MMU).

"AMOS is also a strict real-memory operating system, which is to say there's no MMU, and programs were expected to be fully position-independent and run wherever the monitor ended up loading them. This makes it fast, but also makes it possible for jobs to stomp on other jobs, and it was not uncommon for busy systems to crash on a regular basis."

guenthert··on From Oscilloscope to Wireshark: A UDP Story (2022)
Even if it's the same data, the bit stream will be a variety of 0 and 1s. The period of that waveform will then be 1 frame length / data transfer rate (or rather 1/4 frame length / data transfer rate as this is a QSGMII link). I wonder how the scope triggers on that. Trigger criterium would be a bit pattern, say the Ethernet frame preamble of 7 octects (* 10/8) spread across four streams ...

Otoh, at 5Gbps, a sample rate of "just" 10GS/s would be sufficient (barely).

I rather suspect the oscilloscope is capable of 1TS/s equivalent time sampling, but that mode wasn't used.

guenthert··on CVE-2026-3888: Important Snap Flaw Enables Local Privilege Escalation to Root
> But… why?

> Performance is a frequently cited rationale for “Rewrite it in Rust” projects.

Rewrite from what? Python/Perl? If the original code is in C there _might_ be a performance gain (particularly if it was poorly written to begin with), but I wouldn't expect wonders.

guenthert··on Why I love FreeBSD
> Ok, where are the companies using FreeBSD?

Not quite twenty years ago Yahoo! was using (also, I suspect) FreeBSD.

> How do you get hired if you do happen to have proper FreeBSD skills?

By advertising your other skills?

guenthert··on Why I love FreeBSD
> For example the support for magnetic tapes and for a few other SCSI peripherals is better in FreeBSD.

Could you give us another hint?

> The Linux utility for controlling a LTO tape drive lacks some important options that the corresponding FreeBSD utility has.

That should be easy to list, no? It's been a while since I used a LTO drive, but I don't know what I missed.

> I have FreeBSD servers that I have not touched for years

Are you sure, they are still "yours"?

guenthert··on Why I love FreeBSD
>> I could read my email in mutt while compiling, something that was practically impossible on Linux

> Ok sorry, I stopped reading there.

Why? That's a treasured feature. https://xkcd.com/303/

guenthert··on An old photo of a large BBS (2022)
Telephone line modems were always slow compared to the microcomputers of their day. A 14400Baud modem will just send less than some 1.5KB/s. Even a Z80 could handle a few streams of that. I rather suspect this BBS offered fancier services than just chat and file up/download.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →