HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

guitarbill

4,311 karma · joined January 6, 2016

submissionscomments
guitarbill··on What are executive off-sites good for?
> An e.g. Developer just has to work on the backlog, there might be technical challenges but the requirement is obvious.

Ha, if only this were true.

guitarbill··on UK food price inflation hit 16.2% in October – cost of food basics surging
I'm not really sure I follow - the NI and Ireland example seems like a poor one because of the political history.

Why is a hard border unworkable in the Scottish case? I could definitely imagine this is true, e.g. if Scotland has to import much food or other goods. Or because Scotland depends on the pound. And maybe, in that way, it shares some parallels?

guitarbill··on UK food price inflation hit 16.2% in October – cost of food basics surging
Is the UK really "a major global financial centre", or is it just London?
guitarbill··on Each visit to the page deteriorates the main image
that wouldn't be scalable or cloud-native. you need to deploy the KVM VMs that run the docker containers with k8s.
guitarbill··on After price update, Amazon Prime members call Amazon Music “unusable”
Piracy's gotten harder, or maybe I just have less time to find quality sources. And curating a library isn't something everybody enjoys, either.

I would settle for being able to strip DRM simply and quickly from media I could "buy".

guitarbill··on Nobody wants touch-screen glove box latches
This old thing. Bluetooth is a technology that works fine for me and millions of others every single day. That is not to say it always works flawlessly. Seemingly every time I am forced to use Windows or Teams, it doesn't work. And if I had a car like the parent where it was my only option, I would also be annoyed.

But let's say I agreed with you, so us and what industry would declare it failed? Some Bluetooth consortium, i.e. the same people who make 99% of these devices with likely unbelievably buggy implementations hacked together in the minimum of time? Society at large? Consumers? Some union of software engineers?

I am very sympathetic to people's lives been made more annoying by technology that doesn't work, just as I am to people's lives being made worse by technology that does work. Unfortunately, I don't have a solution, either.

(Maybe right-to-repair could be a starting point for open-source efforts to change products where incentives don't align. Doesn't help much with firmware though.)

guitarbill··on GitHub Copilot, with “public code” blocked, emits my copyrighted code
The chilling effect of this decision is something everybody who uses open source software should be worried about.
guitarbill··on Ask HN: Have you used a 3D Printer?
CADQuery has completely replaced OpenSCAD for me. It's the best of both worlds - CAD as code like OpenSCAD, actual parametric CAD kernel like FreeCAD.

Their GUI is not good/stable (yet), but the Jupyter notebook integration is great and absolutely killer.

guitarbill··on Wildfire smoke is exposing millions of Americans to extreme pollution levels
A comparison would be nice. The smoke can be awful, no doubt - but is it worse for a person's health than living near a busy road or highway? That is 24x7, and cumulative over many years.
guitarbill··on Google loses EU appeal and is fined a record $4B
> Jailing executives is too hard

Do you mean "too difficult" or "too bigger punishment"? Either way, I disagree. If they reap the reward of huge salaries, they ought to take some of the risks.

guitarbill··on Amazon built a new unit to fix its engineering culture
It cuts both ways though. Some people are too invested in Brazil to embrace any improvements other "favorite language specific build tools" have made in the last 10? years. So it stagnates. Python support was bad, but bearable mainly due to the herculean efforts of one guy.
guitarbill··on Cppfront, Herb Sutter's proposal for a new C++ syntax
Some software for storage products is C. I imagine other conservative industries could be similar.

But I have also heard that although the senior devs would prefer to stick to C for technical reasons, they have started to use/embrace C++ for hiring reasons (since many grads are taught C++). So I wouldn't be surprised if finding "pure" C codebases/ones without C++ is getting harder. The eco-system around C++ (e.g. test frameworks) certainly seemed healthier. It's been a few years though, so I might not have a good picture any more.

guitarbill··on Cppfront, Herb Sutter's proposal for a new C++ syntax
It doesn't feel much different to any other language that people have been burned by (e.g. Javascript). I have some bad C++ experienced, and I know enough programmers I respect who stick to C over C++.

Of course it's difficult to equate that kind of advice/feedback to negative comments on HN. But often, there's some kernel of truth there. So while there's some merit to C++, the criticism can equally be valid. And keeping the underlying complexity of C++ (similar to how Carbon will) might not meaningfully simplify development).

guitarbill··on Jackson’s water crisis: latest updates
If that were true, they wouldn't even have to worry about the GDPR. But it's almost never a "local media outfit" in the traditional sense; they're owned by a huge media company worth billions. And they might have to care about GDPR.
guitarbill··on [dead]
It might not be any consolation now, but maybe you dodged a bullet?

Interviewing sucks. I suppose the only good thing about it is that because it's a game it can be gamed. But honestly, the best jobs come from when someone picks up the phone (metaphorically), either you or previous colleagues. Worst case is a "no, not right now", best case is a win-win. Defo keep in touch with people you enjoy working with. It takes time and effort, and I neglected it for years. But it's also a skill that can be learned/practised.

guitarbill··on .NET 6 is now in Ubuntu 22.04
This is not quite true on an M1 Mac. The VS Code C# extension only supports .NET Core, and the latest and deprecated release 3.1 has no ARM build. .NET 6 does, but is somehow unsupported.

To me, it's clear Microsoft wants to force people to use VisualStudio over VSCode. Likely not an issue for a .NET shop, but it's yet more shenanigans by Microsoft

guitarbill··on Local simulation feature to be removed from all Autodesk Fusion 360 versions
> Couldn't you equivalently use any STL/STEP/AMF viewer?

I'm not sure. A quick feedback loop is important. With OpenSCAD and CadQuery, you write code that defines the geometry. You then want to see what the geometry looks like, and possibly debug it. For this, you generally want to be able to give certain parts a different color, or opacity, wireframe, etc.

STL is out; it has to tessellate geometry turning it into triangles. AFAIK, it only supports one object. This means a sensible wireframe is out, and so are multiple parts. AMF has similar drawbacks. STEP files might work.

Generally, my understanding is many people write OpenSCAD code in their editor of choice, and then simply save the file. When you open an existing file in OpenSCAD GUI, it monitors it for changes, and refreshes. So this is great.

That said, I misspoke a bit. CQ-Editor is definitely somewhat close to OpenSCAD. It still has a - in my view - unnecessary code editor. But the last standalone release is over a year ago, and I found it to be extremely buggy on macOS. It crashes quite often. Meanwhile, Jupyer-CadQuery [0] works great.

> Seems a good choice to me that the GUI is a separate/subordinate project. I suppose it is somewhat necessary to have it at all, easier to gain popularity if you can show screenshots and have a single app 'quickstart'.

Generally, I think this is true. My personal opinion is I can be productive with something that has a minimal set of features but is rock-solid; over something that has gobs of features but is buggy. That was my main issue with FreeCAD. Ease of installation is another big one. For all it's issues, OpenSCAD gets both of these things right.

[0] https://github.com/bernhard-42/jupyter-cadquery/

guitarbill··on Local simulation feature to be removed from all Autodesk Fusion 360 versions
Maybe. But at a hobbyist level, is the problem really the kernel?

The problem is that OpenSCAD is easy to get started and the code-first approach is unbelievably useful - but too simplistic/limited. Meanwhile, FreeCAD is too complex, and often buggy.

There's also CADQuery, which is surprisingly good already. Don't get me wrong, the GUI (CQ-Editor) is unusably buggy. But the Jupyter notebook integration works amazingly well. If I were that project, I would work on a hot-reload, cross platform, standalone viewer only (in the same way people use OpenSCAD often). I would also pay for that, safe in the knowledge that the code produced can't be locked in so easily.

Is it a FreeCAD replacement? For better or worse, no. But it has let me avoid FreeCAD/Fusion360, while finally being free of OpenSCAD shortcomings.

guitarbill··on Yes, the U.S. economy is likely in recession
There is another possibility: stating something as a fact could have legal implications (especially if it isn't "true"), but stating an opinion is often fine. So, I would read this as "Our opinion is the U.S. economy is in a recession (not a fact)", despite the article trying to convince you. It even finishes off with

> "we can be highly confident that the U.S. economy entered a recession early in 2022."

which is stronger than "likely", but still shy of saying that it is so.

guitarbill··on Google Timer is gone
If this were the case, they would've used it as a PR opportunity to bash the legislation. It wouldn't have happened silently.
guitarbill··on Hg Init: A Mercurial Tutorial
I would not be surprised if there were source control management workflows involving faxing things somewhere here in Germany... sigh.

But hey, at least those workflows are probably ISO 9001 certified! /s

guitarbill··on Hg Init: A Mercurial Tutorial
You can also use `git stash apply` (which doesn't pop the stash), followed by maybe merging, and finally a `git stash drop`.
guitarbill··on How “let it fail” leads to simpler code
A warning about this; retries should only be done at boundaries. And it's important to know if e.g. the http or API library already implements retires, not to mention which errors should be retried. I have seen at least one codebase where the retries where completely out of hand.

In short, I've found retrying well is harder than it looks.

guitarbill··on Beginner's guide to error handling in Rust
I don't disagree with this... but is there anything wrong with recommending `thiserror` by default, especially for less experienced Rustaceans? It's fairly sane, encourages "good" error design. I wish there'd been something like it when I started.

And moving forwards, you could a) still write out the error type and associated code to replace `thiserror` fairly easily, or b) possibly benefit from any work being done to speed up proc macros in the future. So I feel like recommending it as a default is still the best option?

guitarbill··on How to set junior employees up for success in remote
Sure, or more likely having a CS degree or not does not strongly correlate with programming skill or software development skill.

Some people are good at programming, and do a CS degree to expand their capabilities. Some people do a CS degree solely for the career options (which to be clear is not necessarily bad). Some people didn't do CS degrees for whatever reason, but have thousands of hours in codebases, and know when to look up an algorithm or data structure.

guitarbill··on Should GitHub be sued for training Copilot on GPL code?
> In practice, you usually need to demonstrate that you were harmed by an action to bring it to court.

I think this is true for copyright infringement damages. But is a GPL violation a copyright or a contract issue? And unlike copyright, the fix isn't damages to compensate the rightsholder, but to uphold the license.

> So we would need the author of a GPL'd repository to sue, with proof that copilot copied and pasted their code.

What happens if multiple authors wait and see, and then jointly sue? At that point, removing a single repo isn't enough.

guitarbill··on FDA to order Juul e-cigarettes off U.S. market
> We know exactly what these companies are going to do

What companies would that be? They are companies like Juul. And then there were plenty of small vape shops run by individuals who mixed their own e-liquids, or who curated a selection of e-liquids from other manufacturers.

> This is basic common sense legislation.

No, it isn't. Requiring age verification? Sure, even if it wasn't the law previously, all places I used did that already. Banning USPS from shipping nicotine? Maybe, but questionable.

But the 2020 PACT Act amendment goes even further. It covers Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems, a very broad term that includes "any component, liquid, part, or accessory of a device described [above], without regard to whether the component, liquid, part, or accessory is sold separately from the device." (!)

Think about this for a second. This potentially means lithium ion batteries, coils, wire, cotton, nicotine-free/0% e-liquids, etc. How exactly does that help? I would even be fine with other solutions, e.g. banning shipping anything containing nicotine. This is how it works in some other countries; you could still buy e-liquids and components, to which you could add nicotine. The mix-in nicotine could be more controlled.

I'm quite frankly sick of these bad faith arguments. It's a ridiculously broad law, and it's awful.

guitarbill··on FDA to order Juul e-cigarettes off U.S. market
It shouldn't be. The "think of the children" rhetoric has been used many a time now around e-cigarettes/vaping, to effectively restrict the rights of everybody.

E.g. the PACT act amendment (Prevent All Cigarette Trafficking, not the other one) means USPS - and therefore effectively all other carriers - can't ship vaping products from businesses to individuals, effectively ending online sales. "Law-making" at it's worst, especially because it was bundled into a massive COVID-19 relief bill.

They literally called it the "Preventing Online Sales of E-Cigarettes to Children Act", although it's just the "Preventing Online Sales of E-Cigarettes Act".

guitarbill··on Ploopy open source thumb trackball
The page worked for me, but you can also try looking at the STLs their GitHub: https://github.com/ploopyco/thumb-trackball
guitarbill··on IPTV Pirate Must Pay £963K or 88 Month Prison Sentence Becomes 168 Months
> So then why would it be OK to jail someone for not paying the fine levied on not paying their taxes, but its not OK to jail someone for deliberately not paying their taxes?

Putting people in prison when other remedies exist is not cost-effective. Unless you run inhumane, hell-hole prisons (not saying the UK ones are great, but there's worse). Eventually, yes, prison is the last option (again, in the UK).

So is putting an IPTV pirate in prison for 14 years a good solution? Just from a tax-payer perspective, that seems dumb to me. Similarly, is putting a tax evader in prison a good solution? Not initially, no.

Separately, we can also ask whether it's just for an IPTV pirate to get a higher prison sentence than e.g. most of the perpetrators in the Rochdale child sex abuse ring. For one of these crimes, the wronged party can be made "whole" with money. For the other, not so much. I believe this is what OP is driving at.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →