HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gumby

65,359 karma · joined June 19, 2010

Currently working on removing excess methane from the atmosphere.

Previous lives:

gnu hacker (e.g. co-founder of Cygnus back in '89) Pharma developer (Talima) Distributed solar thermal systems (Terrajoule) MIT AI Lab/PARC/MCC/Rodin consumer tabletop AR (CastAR) Etc...

remove-everything-up-through-last-dash-gumby@brachiate.org

submissionscomments
gumby··on How does it feel to test a compiler?
From my years on GCC I can remember that 90% of regular users' bug reports were user error, not a compiler bug.

But as with any code, compilers have bugs too and sometimes they can be quite surprising.

gumby··on Reflection-based JSON in C++ at Gigabytes per Second
> Some programming languages have long had powerful reflection capabilities, but they are mostly a runtime feature: they do not allow the equivalent of generating code. Other programming languages allow compile-time logic generation but they do not always allow optimal performance.

Lisp casually waves from the bleachers, then goes back to high speed coding with metasyntactic macros and reflection (and so much more).

gumby··on I put a toaster in the dishwasher (2012)
I say "board" too but hear "bar" sometimes in SA.
gumby··on The Myth of the Product-Market Fit (2013)
This is why companies have product managers for different markets or solutions. Different contexts require different features.
gumby··on Show HN: If YouTube had actual channels
A physical selector dial for your faves would be nice.

I remember we had a chunky dial that required a lot of force (for me as a little kid) to turn from channel to channel. It had a bunch of channels (a dozen?) but I think there were only two channels broadcasting. (My Dad bought a B&W TV for us to watch the moon landings)

gumby··on Reading Akkadian cuneiform using natural language processing (2020)
Dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41229597
gumby··on I put a toaster in the dishwasher (2012)
It’s what we say in Australia.

If you purchase an edible “power bar” anywhere (not just America) you can be sure it has and can provide no power. It might have a little energy stored as a carbohydrate though.

gumby··on I put a toaster in the dishwasher (2012)
Why? If both your feet are in the water (or one, for that matter) there’s no current flow. But do be sure to pull the plug from the wall by grasping the plastic cord and not touching anything else dry.

The rest of the time don’t ever pull the plug out by the cord, even though NEMA requires some appliances to use a power cord with a special bar in it to defend against such mistreatment.

gumby··on I put a toaster in the dishwasher (2012)
Don’t forget the former president’s story about the electric boats and sharks.
gumby··on Why we picked AGPL
But you aren’t assigning copyright, you’re getting a license to bundle the contribution with the rest of the package.

And they don’t feel safe including a patch without a license to use it. Not an unreasonable position to take.

The wording is explicit (italics mine):

> You hereby grant to the Company and to recipients of software distributed by the Company a perpetual, worldwide, non-exclusive, no-charge, royalty-free, irrevocable copyright license to…

gumby··on Why we picked AGPL
TL;DR: my quick read is that they are trying to do the right thing.

My not super-close reading is that this is actually reasonable (but note: I wrote the original GNU blanket assignment back around 1989 or 1990 so you may consider my perspective bogus).

This agreement says that you confirm that you have the right to license your contribution (that what you wrote isn’t actually your employer’s), and that they can use it without restriction, even if there’s something patented in the submission. It doesn’t stop you from using the code for something else. But you can’t come back later and say “hey, yank out these lines of code which I sent you long ago”. It's not even an assignment -- you retain ownership.

If I were doing this, personally, I might add something to the effect of “btw if the company tries to change the license in a way incompatible with the AGPL 3.0 or later versions this license I have you becomes void” but that could implicitly be in there (if explicit, I missed it in my quick read).

gumby··on Why we picked AGPL
Their github repo just says AGPL 3.0. Can you point me to the other constraining terms are? This would be quite interesting (like the "Open Core" people). And when I say "interesting" I don't mean a positive feature.
gumby··on Emacs: Contextual Interfaces in Casual Calc
I think you misunderstood what rms said there (but if the transcript is accurate, he was unclear).

Yes, Multics Emacs was the one used by secretaries (except at AI & LCS where they used TECO EMACS on ITS). In both cases most of the extending by non-programmers was done with macros (`c-X (` which is still that command today).

Multics Emacs had an excellent design and you could in fact write some very simple functions with a copy-and-modify rote approach (nothing wrong with that!). But beyond that I never met one whom one could describe as knowing Lisp. In fact most would have been intimidated if you'd told them that they could improve the editor by "programming".

This "programming is impossibly hard for a person like me" attitude was a bad cultural property of the 1970s, thankfully now somewhat in the past. But that change depended on direct work on the problem by people like Seymour Papert and Cynthia Solomon in the LOGO lab (part of the AI lab).

Excel is a great (in volume and reach) example of this: many people write very complex and sophisticated programs in Excel and still don't believe they can program. Now Python is embedded in Excel some people can be tricked into writing real programs. And, presumably, tricked into running sophisticated malware!

gumby··on Is running a more efficient way to travel than walking?
As far as human endurance goes (more the topic of various comments than the article), humans can outrun a horse, most recently last year: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-wales-65867327

I seem to remember reading as a kid that this happened first in some Victorian bet (I would have read this in one of my dad’s kid’s books from the 1930s).

This was also a plot device in a Larry Niven short story (one of the Draco’s Tavern stories).

gumby··on Piecing together the epic of Gilgamesh with NLP
I wish I could double upvote this suggestion!
gumby··on Working from home allowed him to be a more engaged dad. Now it's over
> Seriously folks need to breed more.

People who want to are welcome to -- you be you.

People who don't want to should not be pressured to do so.

gumby··on Working from home allowed him to be a more engaged dad. Now it's over
> > inter-ethnic conflicts among White Americans

The context of the Johnson–Reed Act is more complex than you make it and significantly restricted people you would call “white”, not just other “undesirables”.

Most of the violence of the early 20th century was political (especially, but not only, during WWI, which is the example you chose) and seemingly had more to do with age demographics than racial (a similar problem arose a millennium earlier, driving the invention of crusades). The biggest period was after the Johnson-Reed act, as part of a broader increase in crime.

Yes there was an enormous amount of racial violence, but most of it was directed against black citizens, none of whom were recent immigrants.

I have followed this history because without the 1965 Immigration act I would not have been permitted to come to the US and attend school. And I come from a country with twice the immigration rate of the US, but little violence.

gumby··on Piecing together the epic of Gilgamesh with NLP
A generative model makes no sense for this application. I think they are using the machines to surface possible matches for humans to consider, similar to the use of RNNs for potential drug candidates.
gumby··on Working from home allowed him to be a more engaged dad. Now it's over
> It just moves the problem around so it hits the poorest the hardest.

Could you expand on this? I can’t think of a scenario where that is the case.

> Social security's payout formula should factor in the number offspring.

Ha, how will you track it? I have no offspring in this country (USA) bc they decided things are better elsewhere. But they were born here.

Germany just does it directly: when your kids are little you have to support them (assuming you can); when you are old and decrepit your kids have some responsibility for your wellbeing.

gumby··on Working from home allowed him to be a more engaged dad. Now it's over
> Below replacement rate in most developed countries.

So what -- are those people somehow special?

gumby··on Working from home allowed him to be a more engaged dad. Now it's over
The usual complaint is that the pyramid scheme stops working (not enough people working to pay the pensions of the old people). This is simplistic: the real problem is that there aren't enough doctors/garbos/crop-harvesters etc as a proportion of the population. Either way the fix is straightforward: bring in some people who'd like a job.

Some rethinking is required -- in the USA Social Security was put in place when the typical recipient was expected to receive a payout for...less than three years.

I have friends in the "reduce the birth rate" community, and they are at least as thoughless if not more than the "birth rate too low" crowd. In the former case their "diagnosis" is inevitably that the wrong people are having too many kids though they hate it when you point that out.

A higher birth rate in sub saharan africa is hardly a crisis: every person in the US emits 5X the CO2 of a person in Africa. Dropping population in the rich, polluting countries can be a step in the right direction.

(Personally I'm pretty indifferent to either position. As Herb Stein famously put it: "if something cannot go on forever it will stop". Sure, the latency in this case is quite high but people deal with worse all the time.)

gumby··on A worker from Berkeley's Urban Ore has opened a museum celebrating wingnuts
I clicked hoping it would be fasteners -- so glad for the link!
gumby··on How Bank of America Ignores Its Own Rules to Prevent Dangerous Workloads
WSJ of course.

The title is even ambiguous: the same title would work for a story about how BofA breaks its internal rules to prevent dangerous workloads

gumby··on The 1986 Oldsmobile Incas Dashboard (2020)
Good point!

Though perhaps you shouldn't be manipulating anything and instead concentrating on navigation while the car isn't moving straight? Hmm, perhaps those controls should be disabled when the wheel is (say) 15% from straight?

gumby··on Takeaways from the Vision Pro after 6 months
Yeah, "some people" -- my partner for one. But efficacy is low, even with all her practice. And there aren't many such people -- look at what's happening to Amazon's alexa unit.

I do mainly use voice to control my watch, which means in practice it's pretty much a read-only device (which is just fine for me).

> Think times when you can't call the person but need to send them a quick message, eg noisy festival or loud bar.

Aren't these precisely cases where speech doesn't work? Too noisy to hear you; too noisy for you to hear the message.

gumby··on Working from home allowed him to be a more engaged dad. Now it's over
FWIW it's a fertility "crisis", not the. Globally, the fertility rate exceed the replacement rate -- there are plenty of people being born.

Your points are good regardless of the fertility rate.

gumby··on Takeaways from the Vision Pro after 6 months
> To sum it all up, I think the 'killer app' here is the one that's so simple it seems kind of self-referential - having a display on your face instead of in the world.

The problem is that, at the end of the day, that's just a feature, not a benefit.

It reminds my of the ongoing push for speech interfaces. Supposedly they are "more natural" but in reality, even when you have a screen, the keyboard is still significantly better (even if it's virtual like on a phone)

gumby··on The 1986 Oldsmobile Incas Dashboard (2020)
Example of bad UX: controls where your hands already are is great (curse you, idiotic touchscreens) but gear controls for an automatic transmission aren’t used while in motion, so put them elsewhere.

Forgivable, as it’s a concept car, so just give people an idea.

gumby··on Anduril to open software-based manufacturing hub to scale production
Yeah, but after six rounds, common must be wiped out.
gumby··on Pursuits That Can't Scale
> Maybe he's more a writer's writer.

He definitely is. He was also a really nice person (I only knew him for a few years, before his stroke)

← PreviousPage 14 of 34Next →