HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gumby

65,359 karma · joined June 19, 2010

Currently working on removing excess methane from the atmosphere.

Previous lives:

gnu hacker (e.g. co-founder of Cygnus back in '89) Pharma developer (Talima) Distributed solar thermal systems (Terrajoule) MIT AI Lab/PARC/MCC/Rodin consumer tabletop AR (CastAR) Etc...

remove-everything-up-through-last-dash-gumby@brachiate.org

submissionscomments
gumby··on Anduril to open software-based manufacturing hub to scale production
Man, Series F funding...is anyone going to make any money if the company succeeds?
gumby··on What Is Rotoscope Animation? The Process Explained (2020)
The wikipedia entry on rotoscoping explains the process more compactly and succinctly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotoscoping
gumby··on Urchin Software Corp: The unlikely origin story of Google Analytics (2016)
That picture of their first computer, a sparcstation, brought back memories.

Our first computer at Cygnus was a sparcstation that was actually a “prototype” (probably PVT since it had all the housing etc) for the first sparcstation. I think Andy B had given it to John. It worked fine and lasted for years.

When the author said they’d started the company on a 10K investment I knew they were my kind of people.

gumby··on NASA says Boeing Starliner astronauts may fly home on SpaceX in 2025
That's pretty great to know, thanks.
gumby··on Intel's Immiseration
One of Intel’s strengths in roughly the 90s and 00s was the tight coupling between its strong fab technology and its strong design team. This this was the model for Motorola, IBM, TI and everybody else.

But by now both sides are suffering, and management has to try to fix them both simultaneously.

As with other industries, semiconductors evolved as an integrated industry. But now both parts are fiendishly complex, and rather than integration being a strength, it’s more like a conglomerate.

You can’t just move your design from one process to another so a spun out fab would start with mostly Intel jobs, just as AMD, IBM etc did when they sold off their fabs. But the standalone fab would possibly find it easier to hire customer-oriented people and change its culture, and the two parts could concentrate better on their needs. It would give the shareholders a better chance too.

It’s not a great solution, but the current situation is dire.

gumby··on New doctoral thesis proposes Buckminster Fuller was a 'charlatan'
As a teen I was quite taken by Fuller. Even back then I was smart enough to wonder why his ideas weren't incorporated in all the things around me (except the geodesic dome climbing structure in the schoolyard), and eventually put 2+2 together and figure that maybe his ideas weren't particularly great in practice. I think i was the "dymaxion car" that got me thinking.

It did help me develop some immunity to the conspiracy theorists who claimed that this or that invention was suppressed by "those forces" that wanted to thwart progress.

gumby··on Intel's Immiseration
The "paradox of the x86" is simply the classic Innovator's Dilemma. In fact the history of the last 20 years against ARM could be a case study right out of the book.

Worse for Intel, AMD flubbed it time and time again, but now Intel is too weak to defend against a resurgent AMD.

Meanwhile they are cutting headcount deeply yet only now suspended the dividend. Madness!

They should take a page out of AMD's book and spin off fab. That new company can then be flooded with "strategic" government aid, and maybe the rest of intel can catch up (or not) but it would at least give the shareholders a better chance. Right now the combination is acting like two anchors tied together.

gumby··on Ask HN: How did you learn Regex?
I just read the grep man page.
gumby··on NASA says Boeing Starliner astronauts may fly home on SpaceX in 2025
I can't just sit around while others are working. I don't think it would be any different in zero G.
gumby··on NASA says Boeing Starliner astronauts may fly home on SpaceX in 2025
What is the crew up to on the station? Have they been assigned work to do since they are up there already and are rated astronauts, or are they just hanging around idle as supernumeraries?

I would hate to be in the latter camp and I imagine the kinds of people who take that kind of job would be like that too.

gumby··on C++'s `noexcept` can sometimes help or hurt performance
> Why source being available makes difference?

Because the library is a spec, they don't have to be compatible at a binary level. This is obvious on a hardware architecture level (a 16-bit processor vs a 64-bit processor) but it's true even on the same hardware under the same OS (the different representations of std::string being a famous example). But they are all compatible at the API level -- which in C++ is the source level.

So this is why I mention compatibility at the source code level.

> What is so beneficial in having different implementation of same functionality? We can ignore cases of optimized per platform implementations because std was not made for that.

The point of having different implementations is that not every program has the same needs. The idea of a standard library is that it has a bunch of commonly-used functionality that you can just use so you can concentrate on your own program. You don't have to roll your own string class -- just use the standard one. You may later find you have special needs and need to roll your own, more restrictive string that does just what you want, but in most cases people won't have to. (You can argue whether the C++ standard library accomplishes this or not, but that's a separate matter).

A good example of this is std::map which was overspecified, and thus almost never what you want. If the specification had been looser than different implementations could have chosen different solutions, and even borrowed from each other.

And per-platform optimization is exactly part of std's requirements. Different implementations for the 16-bit and 64-bit cases is an easy to use example. The compilers output a lot of intrinsics to take advantage of CPU capabilities (a common example is memcpy, but there are many). Just try to read the source code for libc++ -- it's hard to read when you aren't familiar with it because it's 1 - full of corner cases so that it works with any code that uses it but also 2 - it's full of target-specific optimizations and special cases.

> None of platforms that make sense to support now were available back when current ABI was set in stone.

Well this is true, but since it's a spec it remains source-code compatible.

I don't know if your use of "ABI" was a typo for "API" or if you really meant "ABI". The APIs are set in stone because of back compatibility (like the notorious std::map example I call out above) but use of ABI, when used by the committee, refers to the de facto binary layout of code that's already been compiled. There are few platform ABI specifications for C++; they are mainly for C, with sometimes some Ada or FORTRAN calling convention stuff. Rarely do platforms say anything about C++, and when they do they don't specify much. There is also a little ABI requirement in C++ (e.g. address of a derived class must also be the address of its own most fundamental base class) but that's for something that is reflected at the source code level.

gumby··on Remembering the First 'Cold-Storage Banquet'
I remember from visiting my grandparents in the 1960s there was one cold store in the town. I believe that my grandfather (a doctor) kept some things there, like insulin. I never heard of anyone having a fridge of their own, which is the kind of thing that would have been told to a kid.

I only remember going there for ice cream which was made in a bicycle inner tube. They cut the tube into segments; the ice cream tasted of rubber of course.

In the 70s there was a huge wave of modernization in SE Asia and suddenly people had scooters and cars, girls had miniskirts, and A/C appeared in saree shops at least. I don’t remember if my GPs ever bought a fridge or not, though.

gumby··on The Soul of Maintaining a New Machine
> on a financial macro perspective, there's currently about 1.1 trillion dollars stored in bitcoin, which is a few days of global gdp

You need to compare like to like. $2T of cryptocurrencies is about 2% of all the world’s stock exchanges (after the recent fall). Or compare it to total world fungible assets: https://www.visualcapitalist.com/all-of-the-worlds-money-and...

gumby··on Bring crypto back to currency
> If Adam Smith saw NFTs he would shoot himself.

The author has clearly never read Adam Smith.

gumby··on 'Weird and Daunting': 7k Readers Told Us How It Felt to Focus
Perhaps also a good way to explore why so many kids are bored in school.
gumby··on The real "Wolf of Wall Street" sales script
The blog post is more sympathetic, but I probably should have just said that.

With most scams I can’t believe most people involved didn’t know.

gumby··on Twitter kills its San Francisco headquarters, will relocate to South Bay
The Taiwan of the countercultural Bay Area.
gumby··on The Soul of Maintaining a New Machine
Yes, cryptocurrencies not cryptography. Bad of me to use that contraction for anything but the latter.

Have they really made a significant difference? A bit of searching around resulting in a few articles with anecdotes, and if someone's life really was saved this way of course it made a huge difference to them.

But for some macro perspective the best I could find was the "Crypto Adoption Index" (https://www.chainalysis.com/blog/2023-global-crypto-adoption...), where VE, or MD don't even register (AR barely does). In fact US is listed as having one of the highest levels of adoption, and it's basically invisible here.

Countries with nonfunctional currency systems usually do better by adopting an existing stable currency like USD or EU (or even better someplace economically coupled with them).

But I'm no expert and I'd be happy to be proven wrong. On a financial macro perspective cryptocurrencies don't even exist.

gumby··on The Soul of Maintaining a New Machine
Thanks. I think I mainly developed more empathy.

I married an artist. She knew no physics, no advanced mathematics, but plenty of philosphy and languages as well as the technology and philosophy of representational art. She was a lot smarter than me and we spent a lot of time expanding each others' horizons, not deliberately or didactically but just through living.

Also so many things seem clear when you are young and I was repeatedly humbled by how complicated the real world is compared to academia or research (where I worked on very abstruse subjects, e.g. the denotational semantics of reflexive languages).

I think you see this in a lot of people: libertarianism and even Ayn Rand is more popular with young people ("hey I'm smart and responsible; why are there all these annoying and pointless rules getting in my way?"). I was never a libertarian but back then I was sympathetic to Rousseau. But you have fewer grown up libertarians because many learn to realise that sure, things are imperfect, but we live in a world that evolved (sometimes well and sometimes not) to work with fallable systems and lots of opinions, some well thought out and some...not so.

gumby··on Twitter kills its San Francisco headquarters, will relocate to South Bay
Back in the early 90s my wife and I moved to SF because it had a thriving art and music scene and more interesting culture than the 'burbs of palo alto. But as you say, the long commute to SV was a killer and we moved back down. Back then SF was a bedroom community for SV with no tech sector. Businesses up there were banking (Wells Fargo, BofA, Crocker etc), retail, the local stock exchange, and a bunch of manufacturing.

Nowadays there's a bland sameness -- barely any music or other art much less much craziness. You can't imagine anything like the psychedelic scene appearing in SF much less Palo Alto these days, and most of what's left is in Oakland. Sigh.

gumby··on Twitter kills its San Francisco headquarters, will relocate to South Bay
I have always had mixed feelings about silicon valley expanding into San Francisco -- I felt there was a strong negative impact, though to some degree SF acted as a honey pot for those just interested in money.

I wonder if this will be a harbinger of a retreat or shrinking of the size of the overall "tech" sector, or if it will remain a one-off. I guess that when the blockchain and ai bubbles really burst we'll see. They have a higher concentration up there for some reason.

gumby··on The real "Wolf of Wall Street" sales script
Cold calling is the hardest! It's probable my greatest weakness (of many!) as an entrepreneur. Not just cold sales calling but any equivalent. I don't like to get a random call so I feel I'm interrupting the person at the other end.

I am fascinated by employees I've had who love cold calling and are great at it. They are even energised by it! Most have a mirror in their cube smile on your call and the other person can hear it through the phone). One thing about all of them I've spoken with: they are certain that the person they're calling needs our product (and if not they're happy to get off the phone as quickly as possible so they can call someone else). Maybe the Stratton Oakmont sales folks thought that, though my impression was that instead they saw the callee as a sheep to be shorn.

I am astonished at people who can just make a friend or at least an interesting connection while waiting in line for the bathroom.

gumby··on C++'s `noexcept` can sometimes help or hurt performance
> Rust's standard library is not a spec, it's just code.

I consider this profound weakness, not a strength.

Don’t get me wrong: I recognize the benefits in the short term! But really long lived languages like FORTRAN, Lisp, C++ have benefited hugely from a spec-based standards approach adopted from other engineering practice. They have also benefited from cross-fertilization from different implementations which influenced later standard and thus each other.

This is why standards from building codes to electrical systems, to ships, manufacturing QC sampling, TCP/IP (and all the internet RFCs) and basically the entire corpus of ISO standards are spec based.

If you want to build long-lived engineered systems it’s worth learning from people who figured out a lot of the metaprocesses the hard way, some of them for more than a century ago.

gumby··on C++'s `noexcept` can sometimes help or hurt performance
> no std library code in portable code. FTFY.

Just want to clarify what I think you meant: no std library code in portable binaries, something I agree with 100%.

If you distribute in source, I believe almost always the opposite is true: relying on the standard library is probably a win. Not every time: some complex code bases have nonstandard requirements or can benefit from nonstandard code. Gaming is a good example of this.

gumby··on The Soul of Maintaining a New Machine
This was such important and transformational work and I remember at the time being quite dismissive of it.

I knew Orr’s and Suchman’s work (they worked in a physically adjacent area, but completely different group, though we were all under John Seely Brown and because they were nice people). Thankfully I was grown up enough to be polite, but really I was such a techno-determinist that I figured user problems came from ignorance.*

To be fair, I was not the only one: the insights described in this book draft surprised a lot of people, not just how they improved the copiers but how those two even approached the problem (starting with the sociology of the repair workers). It sure surprised Xerox management. But I’ve heard it said many times that this work led to restructuring the paper path in a way that justified (paid for) everything spent on PARC.

I did grow up of course and now do see my work (machines, chemistry, etc) as a small part of a large social system. A successful company has to base its product plans starting this way.

To choose an example of failure to appreciate the social scope (but not pick on it) the crypto folks spend their time on technology, based on a social model they want to exist rather than the one that currently does. I think it’s a big reason why it’s barely impacted the world in, what, 15 years? Xerox was the same, and it helped them sell a lot of copiers, but didn’t make them as ubiquitous as they could have been. Another example: everybody laughs at Google for launching “products” that go nowhere and are quickly forgotten. We all know it’s because of a screwed-up, internally-focused culture. But sometimes a product succeeds without marketing (e.g. gmail, at the time) because it happened to be matched to the actual, external need. It makes this kind of continuous failure even more damning.

* TBH, 40 years later I have not 100% shed this view — e.g. my attitude towards complaints about git. Maybe this means I’m still a jerk.

gumby··on C++'s `noexcept` can sometimes help or hurt performance
> Just a simple Google search would reveal that you are wrong about this and what's worse is that you place the burden on me to have to disprove your wrong assertions as opposed to providing references that justify your position:

How rude. Have you used any of those libraries or perhaps relied on Google's "AI"-generated answer?

> None of those are implementations of the C++ standard library.

HPX, EASTL specifically are, the latter being heavily used in (unsurprisingly) the gaming comunity).

libcu++ is for your target compilation.

As for Folly and Abseil, I wrote "as well as more who use Folly and Abseil which have alternate implementations to much of the standard library" (i.e. not ful drop in replacements).

So really I don't know what your point is: you made an assertion, then replied not to what I actually wrote but by simply doing a quick google search and using that as your conclusion.

I have used all of HPX, Folly and Abseil but I guess the top of a google search result is more authoritative.

gumby··on "We ran out of columns"
I am unable to do anything with Photoshop beyond starting it and exiting. I have no idea how or even what it does beyond somehow modifying photos. That’s not photoshop’s problem, it’s that I don’t know what I’m doing. So I just don’t use it.

I only hear git complaints from people who don’t have an internal model that reflects what git is doing (I’ll agree that it uses a couple — but only a couple — of terms in a way that might violate some people’s intuitive model). But if you know what you want to accomplish the command line is pretty unremarkable.

But when you don’t know how the tool works you easily get snarled. And when you blindly resort to various “cheat sheet” sites it’s a crap shoot whether you “fix” your problem (how would you know?) or make things worse. That’s like me with photoshop.

I used to see this with CVS too

gumby··on C++'s `noexcept` can sometimes help or hurt performance
See my parallel reply: there are much more than just three, and all work with the three/four most dominant compilers these days as well as less dominant ones like EDG or Intel.
gumby··on C++'s `noexcept` can sometimes help or hurt performance
> Unlike in C, in C++ it is not possible to use an independent implementation of the standard library.

It sure is, and is pretty easy to do. I know companies using EASTL, libcu++, and HPX, as well as more who use Folly and Abseil which have alternate implementations to much of the standard library.

These days many languages have a single implementation so some people whose experience is only in those environment complain that C++ is “unnecessary complicated to use”. But a lot of that flexibility and back compatibility is what allows these multiple implementations to thrive while representing different points in the design/feature space.

gumby··on C++'s `noexcept` can sometimes help or hurt performance
I consider the current tradeoff to be a feature.

It permits implementations to take advantage of target-specific affordances (your thread case is an example) as well as taking different implementation strategies (e.g. the small string optimization is different in libc++ and libstdc++). Also you may use another, independent standard library because you prefer its implementation decisions. Meanwhile they remain compatible at the source level.

← PreviousPage 15 of 34Next →