HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gumby

65,355 karma · joined June 19, 2010

Currently working on removing excess methane from the atmosphere.

Previous lives:

gnu hacker (e.g. co-founder of Cygnus back in '89) Pharma developer (Talima) Distributed solar thermal systems (Terrajoule) MIT AI Lab/PARC/MCC/Rodin consumer tabletop AR (CastAR) Etc...

remove-everything-up-through-last-dash-gumby@brachiate.org

submissionscomments
gumby··on Show HN: I built a tool to track what AI leaders say and how their views change
Joke’s on them since the carbon monoxide and nicotine (an insecticide) destroy your vascular system (definitely an even harder problem than than cancers these days).
gumby··on Apple: Switch to Safari (From Chrome)
The irony is that when the iphone was introduced, there was no way to write apps for it and jobs said the way to use third party code was to use a web app and add the link to the home screen (which you can still do, though I doubt many people even know that)
gumby··on Apple: Switch to Safari (From Chrome)
Same. Also works great for the family, kids to grandparents
gumby··on Felix Rieseberg Homepage
Certainly the user does not feel the same.
gumby··on Publishers Killed the Paperback, Then Blamed Readers
A funny thing to vote down as it’s so well known. Dime novels, TV, video games, social media…anything new is a candidate to be attacked as corrupting “kids these days”. Even Socrates (recounted in Phaedrus) said that writing would be the downfall of students.

Here’s a very brief example on the dime novel case: https://techlashed.org/panic/cheap-popular-fiction-penny-dre...

gumby··on Publishers Killed the Paperback, Then Blamed Readers
In fact dime novels weren’t just widely available but were decried as the source of truancy and corruption of youth! Sound familiar?
gumby··on Is Universal Basic Income the Answer to A.I.-Fueled Job Losses?
For paywall: https://archive.li/yYNLy
gumby··on I'm sorry, but you still have to think
Corporate code is typically terrible anyway. For many years (predating LLMs) I’ve looked askance at my bank’s app with its obvious bugs, wonder how many are not visible. It was not always so (consider SABRE back in the 60s)

But it’s the fat part of the bell curve. There’s loads of even worse crap outside corporate code…and at the right end of the bell curve is deeply thought out and the result of long-term maintenance that tends towards as bulletproof as can be possible in this universe, parts of OSes, networking stacks, clocks, and the like.

It’s only because that stuff is so robust and sufficiently general that the rest of the world’s steaming pile of code works at all.

gumby··on A plastic once thought harmless may be fueling fatty liver disease
FWIW I could not find it in the SCOGS database. I don’t know what the food packaging rules are (I only worked on the pharma side)
gumby··on Internal files add to evidence of an ExxonMobil climate deception campaign
But in your example, responsibility for the misinformation campaign is assigned to the machine (the corporation itself) not the people (the execs who mounted the misinformation campaign).

My point is that the people (the “drivers” of the car company) should bear the responsibility; it should not be absorbed by the company.

There are other liabilities that should still be assigned to companies. I’m not advocating throwing away the idea of limiting liability.

gumby··on Internal files add to evidence of an ExxonMobil climate deception campaign
That process is almost never applied to C corps except for certain financial fraud, while partnerships (like LLCs) are usually seen as proxies for their members, as in your example.
gumby··on Documents add to evidence in climate deception case against ExxonMobil
That is the lawsuit that caused these documents to be released (there’s actually a cluster of such lawsuits; the Massachusetts one released these documents which they got in discovery)
gumby··on Documents add to evidence in climate deception case against ExxonMobil
If I drive a car and run someone over, I am arrested, not the car.

A limited liability company is just a machine, as is a car. Yet somehow when you drive one you shift your responsibility to the vehicle.

This needs to be fixed.

gumby··on A plastic once thought harmless may be fueling fatty liver disease
Do you mean from the mains to the water meter or from the water meter to the house? We used copper all the way to the street.

I can’t believe the mains themselves could use PEX: if nothing else the pressure would be too high.

gumby··on A plastic once thought harmless may be fueling fatty liver disease
This is a great question to ask. If you look at the GRAS list, some molecular weights of PEG are GRAS while others are not. There’s no reason to think other polymers should be different.

GRAS is “Generally Recognized As Safe”: so for example you don’t need to do a study on its safety when using it in a drug formulation.

gumby··on A plastic once thought harmless may be fueling fatty liver disease
Good question. We built a house 25 years ago and insisted on copper throughout all the way to the street. Cost more, but was probably a good idea on multiple fronts.
gumby··on Terrence Tao does not understand cancer medicine
It’s an epistemic difference. In one case you have empirical evidence that A -> B even though the whole thing is a black box and really it only works sometimes. In the other, theory-based case, you have a model of how things work and that model has been predictive in some cases.

In medicine sometimes (more in the “old days”) someone would see that compound X caused Y and then they’d try to make a therapy that helped the patient without killing them. Other times, someone has a theory that pathway P seems to cause indication I, and so tries to develop a compound that relatively safely disrupts P in vitro, then tries it in vivo. Sometimes even after the drug works and is approved we later find the pathway P hypothesis was wrong, yet it somehow works anyway. And then people try to figure out what’s really going on.

And then, especially in psych and oncolo drugs, the meds mysteriously work on some people but not others. Teasing that out is tough.

gumby··on Satya Nadella says we should assume all AI models are 'compromised'
Otherwise suddenly MS is excluded from government contracts (even ones awarded or in progress), justice department will start attacking it etc.
gumby··on Neuroscience can make decluttering easier
Get around paywall: https://archive.li/VGOaH
gumby··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
There’s a difference between making a low-cognition effort (buying a toothbrush or holding a door open) and a complex choice like buying a car, typically a household’s largest or second-largest investment. I’m sure you know this too.
gumby··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
In this case though it appears to be a desire to promote the name as part of committing moral crime.

(Most ppl have forgotten that X was the name of one of the two failing companies forcibly merged by their respective investors to form PayPal. I remember musk being a dick back then too)

gumby··on How Protein Took over the World
The sensor she likely uses is only good in the hundreds of ppm. Fortunately the LFL for methane is roughly 50,000 ppm so there’s no need to give up smoking when a bout of methane-heavy flatulence occurs.
gumby··on How Protein Took over the World
Thanks!
gumby··on The Lightbulb Computer
Lovely. Mark Weiser would have loved this.
gumby··on How Protein Took over the World
There’s an enormous amount of data on this topic. So much I’ll just tell you to do a web search rather than pointing to some papers in is response: it’s just so pervasive and going back for decades.

Use a conventional search not an ai-generated summary as that will have influencer slop mixed in. Though oddly, I’ve never seen an anti-fibre influencer, but have seen lots of pro-fibre influencer posts!

gumby··on How Protein Took over the World
Now I have to go to the lab and check (we have a ringdown sensor tuned to CH4/CO2/H2O precise into single digit ppb).

Some humans have methanogens in their gut and these people exhale methane (gut->bloodstream->lungs) and they can emit quite a lot, at least enough to completely fuck up our lab work. Our lead scientist is such a person, and the effect is so bad that he exhales into a bin liner when setting up an experiment.

Or he did: this was so inconvenient that we automated all our instruments, valves, etc so we could run experiments from the kitchen or even at home (lots of RPis which I wouldn’t normally use for anything important). Fortunately this also automated all the data collection.

But now I have to run a trial to see if my diet modulates anal CH4 emissions. Thanks HN!

gumby··on Will We Ever Understand Dementia?
To get through paywall: https://archive.li/lIBu0
gumby··on US imposes sanctions on ICC hours after former judge wins Nobel Peace Prize
It’s hardly casual, but also hardly complex: if someone is a Nazi in both word and action, that’s pretty clear. It’s duck typing in the real world: the actual origin of the term.

But your defense of racist speech, acts, and the propagation of same sends a clear message too.

gumby··on Yandex Takes a Second Data Center Hit in 48 Hours
I’m a bit older than that: I have lived the swing from centralized remote computing (long lines and/or dial in, both to the mainframe) to distributed local computing, back to centralized computing.

I remember datacenters being close to the humans and then migrating to be close to the power supply (check out The Dallas, OR, for example) to now locating where they can and scrambling for power, which has become the bottleneck.

At this point I think there’s a diseconomy of scale with the need for all these ad hoc power systems.

I’m not suggesting a return to the captive “machine room”. I’m saying that instead of a mega-plant, smaller, distributed ones might actually be a local optimum.

(Oh, and I have had a rack full of hardware in a data center for my personal compute for more than a quarter century. So yes, I have some experience in history)

gumby··on Scam American companies are using to manipulate ingredient lists
It was several years ago. I brought it home to my wife (the soy milk drinker in the household) and though I had a laugh, she was not amused.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →