HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gwoplock

330 karma · joined March 6, 2019

McNkZHdrCn
submissionscomments
gwoplock··on Google turned me into a serial killer
>Why is this not "DuckDuckGo turned me into a serial killer", other than people hating on Google?

I think it is mostly Google using his picture with the incorrect description below. I feel that is harder to catch for someone taking a quick glance than if the correct picture was used.

gwoplock··on UK Testing Emergency Alerts
Is this similar to the technology used for the US Wireless emergency alerts?
gwoplock··on Cool URIs don't change (1998)
I swear this happens every time I visit a form. Either the 1 image I need has been purged or every post links to some other dead form. I've had pretty bad luck with archive.org for these things.
gwoplock··on Southwest Airlines grounds its entire fleet amid giant computer outage
> one recommends "don't be a jerk" and the other recommends "complain enough"

Those aren't mutually exclusive. You can complain a lot but not be a jerk. You just have to understand and acknowledge the situation the customer service rep is in but still be firm on what you want.

gwoplock··on A strong commitment to backwards compatibility means keeping your mistakes
> Right, but would that have helped? Transitioning a large codebase from Python2 to Python3 is a significant undertaking, there's no way around it.

I haven't migrated from python2->3 however I've worked on projects in both. I think a "python2+3" version would have helped. With both APIs in place new code can be written the new way and old code can be migrated as it is touched. Having the ability to incrementally change code I think encourages the transition since you won't end up with a pile of broken code.

gwoplock··on U.S. Supreme Court revives LinkedIn bid to shield personal data
> My counterpoint: companies shouldn't get to have their cake and eat it too, as in offering public content, but then preventing competitors from using that public content.

I agree this case is taking an anti-competitive action and spinning it into a pro-privacy case. However, what's the line? Personally I believe if you apply the rules equally to competitors and non-competitors alike you can restrict programmatic access to public data. Since LinkedIn isn't doing that, HiQ shouldn't be restricted.

In any case I think this is a poor use of the CFAA.

gwoplock··on Mars becomes the 2nd planet that has more computers running Linux than Windows
Alright, I'm going to be that guy. What's the other planet with more Linux than Windows?
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> Does that make the conclusions reliable?

Not totally but more then other posters on HN that were making claims without research. The NERC report will be totally reliable but that will take 6+ months. And if my conclusions are wrong, they're wrong and I'll update my blog.

> I'm not sure why you want to use layman as a measuring stick.

I made this post as a direct response to previous HN and Reddit posts where the layman were forming conclusions. I did not see a single person quoting or referencing a single standard to back up their claims. I went out looking for something to back up claims and this is what I found. I formed conclusions off this and included them.

If an expert was to tell me I'm wrong and show me what I missed I would be happy to update my blog.

I included the first paragraph just to show that the post was not an expert opinion and was what I found after some research.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
You are right that I should have been clearer about the nuclear plant. However, the reason reactor unit 1 went offline appears to be accurate.

https://atomicinsights.com/south-texas-project-unit-1-trippe...

> The trip resulted from a loss of feedwater attributed to a cold weather-related failure of a pressure sensing lines to the feedwater pumps, causing a false signal, which in turn, caused the feedwater pump to trip.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> Is the person who wrote this knowledgeable on this topic?

I am not... "I am a software developer, and this is my best interpretation of the requirements I could find"

> The way it is written it seems like they just did a bunch of searches and found some information.

That is about how that went.

> Do they know enough to be sure they're drawing the right conclusions based on what they found?

Maybe? if you have other conclusions, I'd love to hear them.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> Second there may have been frozen wells but natural gas does not go directly from the wellhead to the peaker

I agree that the natural gas does not directly go to the station. However, from what I could tell in the NERC documents they referenced it freezing at or close to the well.

> Natural gas at the burner tip is supposed to be one million cubic feet (MCF) is one million BTU (MMBTU)

I'm guessing you're referencing "14.8 Bcf of natural gas production was lost". If so, Bcf comes directly from the NERC report in reference 14.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> I'd love to see the engineering proposal to "winterize" ... a thousand miles of supply pipelines.

That isn't really what's needed. If I understand the problems with the gas supply in these events, the issue is the wellhead freezing off due to the high water vapor content in the gas.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Fair. In the documents I've found, it's not uncommon for sensors to have issues with the cold weather and force the station offline.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
From what I've seen, you cannot keep 100% of generation online. However, in a properly designed and winter weatherized system stations should be able to come online to pick up the slack. In the reports I've seen this seems to be a high rate of failure point leading to the issues seen in Texas this week.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
I really appreciate that.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> But none of the other states have giant winter blackouts like Texas had this week, and most of them have worse weather.

Not exactly true. SPP the grid operator for OK and the area immediately east of Texas did have to go to EEA3 twice and implement rolling blackouts

https://spp.org/markets-operations/current-grid-conditions/

>Feb. 15 at approximately 12:10 pm. While still under EEA Level 3 and after exhausting reserves, SPP directed member utilities to implement controlled, temporary interruptions of service.

>Feb. 16 at 6:15 a.m. SPP declared an EEA Level 3. System-wide generating capacity had dropped below current load of approximately 42 gigawatts (GW) due to extremely low temperatures, inadequate supplies of natural gas and wind generation. SPP directed member utilities to implement controlled, temporary interruptions of service.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Yes. https://spp.org/markets-operations/current-grid-conditions/

> Feb. 16 at 6:15 a.m. SPP declared an EEA Level 3. System-wide generating capacity had dropped below current load of approximately 42 gigawatts (GW) due to extremely low temperatures, inadequate supplies of natural gas and wind generation. SPP directed member utilities to implement controlled, temporary interruptions of service.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
If I'm reading http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/real_time_system_condi... right there is no power across the DC_L (Laredo VFT), DC_R (Railroad) and DC_S (Eagle Pass) HVDC ties.

for posterity:

  DC Tie Flows  
  DC_E (East)  -595  
  DC_L (Laredo VFT)  0  
  DC_N (North)  -218  
  DC_R (Railroad)  0  
  DC_S (Eagle Pass)  0
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> Texas regulators and indeed other regulators need to pursue more rigorous winterization in the southern states.

Exactly. I'm not sure that even the new NERC regulations for winter weatherization go far enough. They seem to bring NERC standards closer to Texas'.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
>Those who reported 24-48 hour outages were probably victims of this rather than the rolling blackouts.

I couldn't find specific instances of Texas load shedding devices having issues. However, there were instances of things like circuit breakers failing open in very cold weather. This was probably another cause of these very long outages.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
And the NERC report for the south east failure in 2018 talks about how many of the same issues identified in 2011 were still issues outside of ERCOT. See around page 92 in this: https://www.ferc.gov/sites/default/files/2020-04/07-18-19-fe...
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
According to ERCOT in 2019/2020 there were 80 facilities checked for the requirements. Some did fail and were rechecked in November. There were plans, however it seems that the plans weren't built for sub zero temperatures.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> So are you claiming Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana and Missouri have experience state wide blackouts similar to those found in Texas in recent days?

Yes. That grid operator did have to implement EEA3 load shedding (rolling blackouts). However, I should note that the Texas rolling blackout seemed to go wrong when they tried to bring locations back online.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> none of which were implemented by ERCOT.

The NERC recommendations are requirements in Texas. There is the requirement to plan for extreme winter weather events in Texas but not in NERC.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Yes, those are recommendations that weren't implemented. Anywhere. The issues identified in 2011 for Texas caused issues in the Eastern Interconnect in 2014 for the north and 2018 in the south. In 2018 many of the same recommendations were made and finally NERC has started the standards process however they wont be approved until November.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
> Now that statement would make sense if 'extreme cold weather' had caused problems in other parts of the USA.

In 2014 the polar vortex brought power down across the Eastern Interconnection (citation 13) and again in 2018 (citation 10).

> That suggest to me the national regulator has these extreme weather events covered.

There currently are not standards for winter weatherization. In 2013 standards were proposed for this however they were rejected (citation 15). Finally in 2020 standards started the approval process however they wont be fully approved until November.

gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Yes there is a lack of regulation around winter weatherization. However, this is not a Texas only problem, in fact the PUCT requirements for weatherization exceed the current NERC standards and are similar to the new requirements that should be approved in November. Also standards for weatherization were proposed to NERC all the way back in 2011 but they were rejected.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
It's not just Texas. it's the entire south and sometimes more. In the NERC report from the 2014 polar vortex, it looks like 20-30GW were lost due to fuel shortages even in the north east.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
The thing is, Texas winter weatherization standards exceed the NERC standards. Effectively the guidelines that NERC put out have been codified by the PUCT as requirements that are audited every year.
gwoplock··on The Texas power outage is a nation-wide problem
Maybe. Oklahoma, and other surrounding states have been dealing with rolling blackouts but on a smaller scale. I would wait for the NERC report on this.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →