HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

haffenloher

90 karma · joined November 3, 2015

submissionscomments
haffenloher··on A Formal Security Analysis of the Signal Messaging Protocol
> the Chrome desktop "app" doesn't seem to import my phone contacts for some reason

Have you tried re-importing them manually via the "Import now" button in the Desktop app's settings? Maybe that helps.

haffenloher··on A Formal Security Analysis of the Signal Messaging Protocol
Audio quality has been good enough for me, but there's definitely room for improvement as they're still using Speex (if I'm not mistaken).
haffenloher··on A Formal Security Analysis of the Signal Messaging Protocol
> Exactly why I like XMPP, it allows me to protect my metadata from leakage

I read this frequently, but I'm still not sure how this is supposed to work - would you care to explain?

haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
> You closed that issue as a wontfix

Not sure what you're talking about, because the issues in question, #127 and #1000, are open.

> you basically told them to go away on Github

Quite the opposite [1]:

"I would consider a clean, well written, and well tested PR for websocket-only support in Signal. I expect it to have high battery consumption and an unreliable user experience, but would be fine with it if it comes with a warning and only runs in the absence of play services."

[1] https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37#issueco...

haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
> I suggest that, instead of routing all messages through GCM, what if Signal could send a "wake up" message via GCM, and then let the app pull the encrypted messages directly out of Signal's servers?

Yep, that's exactly how Signal has been doing it for >1.5 years now.

haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
> OpenWhisperSystems banned them from using the service

Nobody has been banned from anything. People have been politely asked not to distribute 3rd-party builds of Signal using their name and their servers, and that's it.

haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
> 3. Showing hostility to those trying to introduce such an alternative to the project

Quite the contrary, they're actively asking people to contribute code for an alternative push mechanism [1][2]:

"I would consider a clean, well written, and well tested PR for websocket-only support in Signal. I expect it to have high battery consumption and an unreliable user experience, but would be fine with it if it comes with a warning and only runs in the absence of play services."

[1] https://github.com/LibreSignal/LibreSignal/issues/37#issueco... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12883410

haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
I think tptacek was talking about actual takeovers of Telegram accounts. AFAIK there have been documented cases of this in Iran and Russia. See e.g. https://www.fredericjacobs.com/blog/2016/01/14/sms-login/
haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
I promise that nobody is going to force you to use the GIF search. For a demo on how this feature works, check out the short video embedded into the blog post. [1]

I second the parent poster's question: "why is this dangerous?"

[1] https://whispersystems.org/blog/images/giphy.webm

haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
They're not even using it as a queue, they're queueing and delivering the messages themselves. GCM messages are empty and are only used to wake up your device.
haffenloher··on Why I won't recommend Signal anymore
From the post:

"The Google Cloud Messaging service basically handles message handling from/to the user’s devices to the Signal servers. The GCM service then handles all the aspects of queueing all messages and delivery from/to users."

This is not true. Messages are delivered via Signal's own servers only. GCM messages are empty; their only purpose is to wake up your device. [1]

"The phone component of Signal is called RedPhone. The server component of this is unfortunately not open source [...] this is also probably the reason why secure encrypted phone calls don’t work in e.g. LibreSignal"

No. The reason for that is that the signaling for RedPhone calls is currently still done via GCM and not via Signal's own message transport.

Regarding microg: I've never heard of the need to re-compile kernels for that. I think most people use it with Xposed (admittedly, a giant hack, but it works).

[1] https://whispersystems.org/blog/goodbye-encrypted-sms/

haffenloher··on Open Whisper Systems Partners with Google on End-To-end Encryption for Allo
Signal Desktop does not use GCM. You can use the extension with Chromium or any Chromium-based browser.
haffenloher··on Moxie Marlinspike Makes Encryption for Everyone
> Are you in the right thread? The discussion here is about what information Google can get from GCM messages

The parent poster of the post you initially replied to asserted that Signal was "giving NSA the only thing what they want: metadata from Google", so I guess that's where tptacek is coming from.

On a side note, Google can't actually know the message sizes because GCM is used without a payload.

haffenloher··on Moxie Marlinspike Makes Encryption for Everyone
> If he had said "the benefits of finding friends are greater than the privacy implications" or something like that there would at least been a case for a discussion

This has already been discussed at length many times. Perhaps uola hasn't seen this blog post yet:

https://whispersystems.org/blog/contact-discovery/

haffenloher··on Moxie Marlinspike Makes Encryption for Everyone
The question wasn't what metadata Signal gets, but what metadata Google gets on Signal messages. Yes, Signal servers know who communicates with whom.
haffenloher··on Moxie Marlinspike Makes Encryption for Everyone
No, that's not how it works. The GCM message is empty, it just wakes up your device which then fetches the actual message from the Signal servers.
haffenloher··on Reproducible Signal builds for Android
> For the verification, you now depend on a complex binary blob provided by the authors, that is distributed through a different channel (Docker images instead of Google Play).

Nothing stops you from building the Docker image yourself using the Dockerfile provided in the repo. https://github.com/WhisperSystems/Signal-Android/blob/master...

haffenloher··on Signal Desktop
Yep, at least that's how the official version of the chrome app works at the moment, it offers no standalone option.
haffenloher··on Signal Desktop
> am I the only one surprised

Why not ask your favorite search engine? Definitely faster than creating a HN account ;)

First Google search result: http://support.whispersystems.org/hc/en-us/articles/21253585...

haffenloher··on Signal Desktop
Yes, there is.
haffenloher··on Signal Desktop
That name would imply your phone had to be online for the desktop app to work - that's not the case.
haffenloher··on Signal Desktop
Nope, I think you misunderstood something. Your phone does not need to be online for the desktop app to work.
haffenloher··on Signal Desktop
You can! No problem with that.
haffenloher··on Signal Desktop
Using that websocket stuff instead of Play Services or GmsCore will make receiving Signal calls impossible.
haffenloher··on Signal for Android: RedPhone and TextSecure in one app
These are the client (GPLv3) and server (AGPLv3) repositories:

https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure

https://github.com/WhisperSystems/TextSecure-Server

haffenloher··on Signal for Android: RedPhone and TextSecure in one app
I wrote a little guide on how to set it up: http://o9i.de/2015/10/23/howto-gmscore.html

Has been working reasonably well for ~10 days now. Note that I'm on Android 4.2, so I might have missed something with regard to newer Android versions.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2