HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hagbardgroup

233 karma · joined April 3, 2014

Kansas City area.

Freelancer: copywriting, digital marketing strategy, web analytics, sales copy, creative testing, consulting, and ad account management for online businesses.

Read my site at www.hagbardgroup.com if you'd like to learn more.

submissionscomments
hagbardgroup··on Fare Dodging Is an Organized Rebellion in Stockholm, and It’s Winning
>We don't use accounting (fares) to plan local public transport, at least not exclusively as it's not at all a reliable, what with its inability to track routes, lots of unregistered riders with monthly tickets, etc. etc. To get reliable data, you need to count people in the vehicles and poll them regarding their route and other things -- which of course the public transport authorities do routinely. Automatically tracking people is an invasive technical improvement to this, and it's deployed in some places, but again it doesn't really require fares.

That depends on the system: many do track the routes purchased and use it to optimize scheduling (and that includes some systems with monthly riders). It's not the same as in a private sector system in which there are no public subsidies but it does make it easier to allocate the resources more efficiently.

hagbardgroup··on Fare Dodging Is an Organized Rebellion in Stockholm, and It’s Winning
Because we use accounting to measure how equipment is used and decide how to allocate resources efficiently.

Without accounting, we can't tell where to divert resources to maintain or improve the equipment. It's also not possible to limit the use of the equipment beyond its stress limits without using money. Trains in particular require additional staff to handle high passenger loads. Some passenger trains are not set up to handle high traffic loads. Charging money limits the ridership to the people who want/need to use the train more than others. It also limits ridership of likely bad actors who will do things like key the windows or spray graffiti in the tunnels or on the trains themselves.

>Why would city spend significant resources to discourage usage of public transport?

Because then they would otherwise need to rely entirely upon the political process to maintain needed funding to the system, and there would be other spill-over impacts to the quality of the rail network.

>Do they really prefer for the people to buy cars and stand in traffic for hours on overcrowded streets and subsequently be disgruntled and pressure local governments for more roads?

I'm unfamiliar with road policy in Sweden. I imagine that the fares are paid through taxes on gasoline, tickets for driving violations, licensing fees for commercial vehicles, and other fees. The two transportation methods are not completely interchangeable. You can't run heavy freight on a passenger rail line. It's a bit easier to have shared freight and passenger traffic a highway. Expanding rail coverage to other regions is much more capital intensive than expanding road coverage, and much more challenging to estimate (see: the underutilized light rail projects all over the United States).

In a magical world of infinite resources and immortal human beings and infinite time, then there would be no reason to charge fees on anything. Because we live in a finite world of finite time and resources, we use money as a measurement tool to make better decisions with how we allocate our resources.

>Why only public traffic commuters pay if all benefit from the fact that they are not on the street crawling in 1.5 tonne of steel each?

Not all benefit at all times to the same degree. Also, it is probably also partially funded by taxes. That people are rebelling probably indicates other problems with the system outside the scope of the article.

hagbardgroup··on Surface Pro 3
So take it into account in your evaluation of the product. Every magazine reviewer on the planet gets 'free' items to review.
hagbardgroup··on Surface Pro 3
Remember "I'm a Mac / I'm a PC?" The loyalty that Apple built up among creative professionals has under-girded their entire brand. If you were Microsoft, and you saw a chance to knock some of those people loose, wouldn't you work like hell to make that happen?

This would also be an example of MS improving its touch in terms of attempting to persuade people about Surface. Rather than just repeating over and over about how great [tabletX] is and how a celebrity they've paid to endorse it just loves it (see HP's disastrous TV campaigns for their tablets), they're letting an influential guy use it, review it, and criticize it publicly. The critical bits are what make it more effective as commercial messaging for MS' particular purposes at this moment.

If Gabe were shilling they would pay him directly to shill and it would be marked as an ad (which PA has done many times before for many companies). In this case, that's probably not happening.

hagbardgroup··on E-Commerce Is A Bear
Note that many of the successes were not venture funded. The extreme margins are just not there for these kinds of businesses to generate the returns needed for investors. The only hope is selling into a frothy market which is willing to ignore the financials and pay for the stock at a silly p/e.
hagbardgroup··on E-Commerce Is A Bear
E-commerce is the catalog business. It is confusing to call it 'e-commerce' because you will conceptually lose the smooth progression from the printed catalogs to the web.

The Sears stores were, in fact, add-ons that appeared after the catalogs became ubiquitous.

This assertion:

>Said differently, if your business is standalone e-commerce selling third-party brands, good luck. You can’t generate enough operating profit to scale beyond getting noticed, counter-attacked, and at best acquired. You are forced into stay right where you are.

...is basically correct for most categories. It's really hard for businesses like Macy's and JC Penny and the rest which are primarily retail businesses to compete in the catalog business. Amazon in particular is moving into apparel and is doing a capable job of it for brands that their customers are already familiar with.

Is this true for the venture funded web catalog business? Yeah, but venture economics are usually terrible for web catalogs, and there are many venture corpses built upon dumb assumptions about 'branding' to attest to this.

The linked puff piece in this article praises NastyGal, which is, again, a venture funded catalog. It is a nice catalog with excellent photography, fast load speeds, and OK copywriting. The selection is also solid with an oft-changing inventory, but I would worry about the bad demographics and limited spending power of the target market. It wasn't so long ago that a similar brand with a similar style (American Apparel) was the new hotness. AA collapsed because of the reversal in commercial real estate and the prolapse in the spending power of its target market. Escalating advertising costs, high shipping costs, and bad market demographics threaten the venture funded nuCatalog model. Why do today's young women buy stuff from Forever 21 etc.? It's because they have no money.

"I'm starting a pants catalog and putting it on the web" sounds a lot less ~web 3.6 future internets~ than something about butt algorithms and personalization. What it still amounts to is selling pants through the mail. Catalogs on the web are a fantastic opportunity for everyone except for venture capitalists, in my view, just because the economics are not venture economics, and VCs are just killing each other pointlessly by bidding up advertising and labor costs for everyone. The opportunity is there, but these are not opportunities that venture investors are really well suited to navigate.

"We sell $80 khakis that fit" is not a great USP because Banana Republic does this also.

The big problem with selling fitted clothes via catalog is that unless the customers are familiar with your fits, they will tend to shy away from fitted clothes, and will instead stick to accessories or items with well-standardized fits like shoes. They bring up all these brands that do well selling via internet catalog that do so because they have elastic waistbands. Lululemons have some wiggle on the fit in the way that men's khakis do not.

Fitted clothes now have a nightmarish sizing problem due to retailers attempting to make fat people feel better about their hyperfattitude by making the sizes on everything totally nonstandard. This has some unfortunate spillover effects online as everyone has to modify their fits.

hagbardgroup··on Panda 4.0: Why eBay lost many of its organic rankings
They're using dynamic keywords in the worst possible way. Often times the landing pages will be empty, junk, or misleading.

What that means is that they will form an ad around your query targeted to a particular page on eBay, often times insensitive to the existing inventory or improperly matched.

Compare this to Amazon's dynamic keyword campaigns, which usually only trigger when they have relevant inventory, and match to a dynamically generated page that does its best to match the inventory results to the query. This is not easy to do, but not impossible, either. eBay looks to just set up their dynamic campaigns and scream #yolo.

This is the best article written about their terribleness: http://www.wordstream.com/blog/ws/2013/03/13/dear-ebay-its-n...

hagbardgroup··on On MetaFilter Being Penalized By Google: An Explainer
For a dollar, you can get a ton of chaff social shares. All of these systems are thoroughly pwned.
hagbardgroup··on On MetaFilter Being Penalized By Google: An Explainer
This is why it happened. Mystery over. 99% of the time, "we didn't do nuffin" means that the site's moderation was not as tight as once thought.

Ignorance isn't really an excuse on this, because it takes five minutes to explain to people nofollow vs. followed links. However, when you explain it to people, 99% of the time, they will continue breaking the rules because they have time preference issues: they know that they benefit from their site passing rank in the present, and the penalty is an unknown quantity in the future.

hagbardgroup··on On MetaFilter Being Penalized By Google: An Explainer
What it's resulting in is a 'news-stand' effect in which articles from the mainstream press will rank higher than anyone else on a given query if the match is close enough. Although I'm not a huge fan of the press as it is today, it could be worse.

You can actually identify opportunities by finding valuable queries that are being squatted on by the content mills. Lots of nice things in stuff like home improvement, insurance, and finance.

hagbardgroup··on Fab Lays Off One-Third of Global Headcount, Slashing New York City Staff
This reflects what I have read elsewhere.

What they would do is bid wastefully using weak creative and little targeting as if they were actively trying to waste as much money as possible (which may have been what they were doing).

hagbardgroup··on When Helium.com closes, 1 million articles will vanish from the web
Yeah, I know, I made a little money off of it several years ago. These guys take advantage of people who don't know any better by dangling the possibility of petty cash at them and then (for the most part) paying out nothing.

That guy is basically describing spam, because that is what they were: a spam mill.

hagbardgroup··on When Helium.com closes, 1 million articles will vanish from the web
Good, because Helium was a terrible parasite.
hagbardgroup··on Google Predicts Ads in Odd Spots Like Thermostats
How exactly would I pitch this to a client?

Would they be text? If they're text, how would they click through? Text ads have negligible impact on recall without some sort of image. Whatever happened to context sensitivity?

hagbardgroup··on Making Your Writing Work Harder For You
It also helps to think about it in terms of the old print formats.

Only blogging is like handing someone a stack of leaflets with some semi-descriptive tags on the side to help you navigate through them. A good test is to ask yourself if this would be useful or compelling if someone handed you a print version of the text.

Blogs developed the way that they did, I think, because they really took off as a way to socialize about the news, usually created for print or TV first. Social networks have taken over that role. Now, web publishing is beginning to take a more leading role rather than being wagged by traditional media. It helps to hold your writing to the same standards of quality that you would in a print publication.

hagbardgroup··on Mink Is A 3D Printer For Makeup
Yup. Lush is an amazing shop. I know lots of women who buy soaps and such almost exclusively from there.
hagbardgroup··on Mink Is A 3D Printer For Makeup
Dumb question: what's the matter with the home makeup brewing methods that have been used for centuries now?

If you know women in the home-brew makeup/perfume/beauty community, it seems like they're already well served without needing a printer. The same people who would know enough to buy a printer also know enough to buy pigment from a craft shop. The market that isn't that clued in reads Seventeen or Elle and overpays for Revlon at Walgreens because they're low-information consumers. The low-information consumers are already buying Revlon because they don't know any better and don't want to know any better.

I think what'd be more interesting is a machine that serves the small manufacturers better, which can make small batch runs more profitable and reduce reliance on larger manufacturers.

hagbardgroup··on A Critique of “Don’t Fuck Up The Culture”
>I do wonder what people will use as anchor institutions now that church going has declined - not everyone can do the corporate only thing

Entertainment. Religious behavior is so ingrained and universal that, when people lose it, they immediately start organizing around the nearest banner and making mock wars against the unbelievers.

Nintendo believers (with their computerized altars, mythos, and rituals) may not actually kill the bros of the X-box, but they do get worked up about the differences and frequently engage in mock battles with those of other tribes.

It's too reductive to call all of this behavior either religious or spiritual, but if you look at it from the perspective of an anthropologist from the future or another planet, it makes a lot more sense than to say 'the enlightenment happened and each and every person separated the spiritual and the secular in their brains and we all lived rationally ever after.'

So, generally, if you're in the business of making consumer products, you're in the business of running an effective cult, or at least encouraging an existing strong cult to adopt one of your mythic ways into their own, or making use of one of your totems.

hagbardgroup··on A Critique of “Don’t Fuck Up The Culture”
You could say that the modern fashion-forward corporate culture is just the German-Protestant ethic with the family shaved off and some hedonism stapled on to replace it. Instead of the gospel, people read HBR or HBR-aping tech publications. The CEO becomes father, king/presidente/generalissimo, and priest, because it's likely that none of those things will exist in the lives of the employees to the same extent as they did in previous generations.

In California tech, something like half of the employees will not even have much stateside family, being immigrants, while another large portion come from broken families, are un-churched (but perhaps yoga-classed), and are often unmarried also. There is no 'society' there for such employees beyond the company, no rival sources of meaning. Perhaps after 'success' there is room for 'philanthropy.'

It is actually the whole culture because the alternate cultural institutions have become so weak that the corporation just fills the gaps, as the only remaining institution in the life of the individual with any confidence or capacity for initiative. Otherwise, a good article.

It's funny that a guy who has contributed to HBR, which has done so much to obliterate or subvert all competing institutions to the corporation, seems to have a little trepidation about going all the way.

hagbardgroup··on Leaked NYT innovation report is one of the key documents of this media age
In print, the production is handled by people considered to be proletarian subhumans who are paid almost nothing and disposed of at a whim. This was not always so: when printing was closer to high tech, it was also higher prestige. Manufacturing in general also used to be higher status than it has been since the 1970s.

There's been this change in US culture that provides a special aura to people who do nothing but write and speak. People who interact with physical things, and particularly machines, come to be seen as unclean.

With computers, you have to pay those people well and give them some authority so that they can do their jobs well. Socially, this does not play out well within traditional print organizations, in which the production side is invisible to the journalism side (the Times' manufacturing plant is not even close to its midtown office building), and the business side is ritualistically forbidden from contaminating the sacredness of the content side.

Stuff like labeling stories with appropriate metadata doesn't get done not because it's challenging (it's similar to slapping a Dewey Decimal code on a file folder and sticking it on there), but because writing an HTML element has the potential to make a religiously sacred 'writer' impure. A lot of print people see any sort of demand for learning technical skill as an insult, because technical knowledge is seen to be polluting.

Also you see a lot of knowledge silos in that report because it's clearly difficult for the organization to 'read' the skillsets of technical generalists.

We don't like to see it that way, but ordinary American business types see programmers as spiritually dirty people who do not deserve authority. At the Times in particular, business people are seen as particularly spiritually dirty, so much so that they must be literally segregated from the population of sacred scribes.

The change that the Times would need to make is less technological and more social: they would have to make coding not Haram anymore. That might be one reformation too many to ask for. This report is really good, but they would probably have to fire everyone over 40 to achieve its goals. Authority is zero sum, and asking the entire leadership to devolve authority is not likely to have a positive outcome.

hagbardgroup··on I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee
Yup. The right thing for him to do would be to write a technical book and sell it. He has his emacs tutorial, but his website already has a bunch of poorly placed ad units on it.

He's literally competing with his own tutorial by selling other sections of his webpage at probably less than $2 cpm. If he optimized his page to sell the tutorial he would earn more than $2 cpm per unit on that. The 'around the web' units are probably not even being managed because it looks like they are set to the defaults for general audiences, which is inappropriate.

What I would do:

1. Redesign page

2. Kill ads 3. Raise price to $30 or more

4. Aim for 2% conversion (no clue how many of those numbers are unique sessions)

5. 2% x 240,000 = 4800 sales -- 4800 * $30 = $144k before fees and taxes

That's wildly optimistic given that a lot would have to be done to the site and that the people looking for free emacs tutorials may not line up perfectly with those willing to pay for it, but if it's legitimately a good tutorial there's an opportunity there. Even a more realistic .2% conversion would still be an OK living for the guy.

He could even get started by quoting one of the other dudes in this thread who said that it was good.

The ads that he has on the page are pennies and it's hard to actually find the tutorial that he charges for. That he might be a jerk is actually totally fine. You would just have to work it into the copy as him having a maverick attitude and being a no-nonsense technical guy, which works well for selling to people who are technical.

hagbardgroup··on I'm About as Good as Dead: The End of Xah Lee
$360/mo, maybe more, with adsense, potentially much more if people clicked on the ads and the ads were high value.

Also possibly a lot more if he sold display ads directly or ran a good affiliate program for technical books and other products.

hagbardgroup··on The Economics of a Kickstarter Project
There's nothing wrong with writing down the fixed costs (which will often be estimable) and getting close on the variable costs. Revenue projections in a new company will be made-up usually, but you're correct to point that out.
hagbardgroup··on 2013 Founders’ Letter
Meh. A lot of the problem with modern search is just that a lot of topics just don't have that many people who are both web-savvy and topic-savvy. Content farmers can be slain in the rankings easily by a superior resource, but that resource has to be attached to some sort of business engine to make it worthwhile enough to create. The hobbyist auto mechanic has less of an incentive to write great articles about auto maintenance than the auto parts corporation does.

Adwords is also excellent, but the skill to use it is not well distributed. Advertisers have more obvious incentives and measurement metrics (return on total ad spent / return on investment) than hobbyists do.

hagbardgroup··on SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial
The internet is similar to mail order but faster with a lot of tricky details (in the same way that mail and print have tons of tricky details). People don't change all that much.

'Free' gets you a lot of tire-kickers automatically, whereas a guarantee pre-qualifies the customers to the people who can afford to float you some cash. If they're a tire kicker, at least they're not a totally broke / budgetless tire kicker.

There are other free sweeteners that you can offer that aren't a free trial.

hagbardgroup··on SaaS Builders: Beware The Free Trial
This is a good compromise -- certainly better than the take-your-credit-card free trial that surprises you with a charge. 'Money back guarantee' has worked for a long time, particularly in pre-internet days.
hagbardgroup··on Documents from Glenn Greenwald's new book [pdf]
They're going to, because as you suggest, the situation is fragile. It's only possible to garner enthusiastic compliance when the scheme is not properly understood. Now that it is understood, enthusiastic compliance is no longer common. People at every level drag their feet.
hagbardgroup··on Documents from Glenn Greenwald's new book [pdf]
I'll be disappointed in the NSA if they're not selling their access to hedge funds and other major corporations. This'd be great to front run mergers and other similar events. C'mon, guys -- let's not be small time with the corruption here. Go big or go home.

Now, how exactly do these companies think that this sort of collaboration will not utterly destroy the trust that non-US companies have had for American IT services? You can only lie so much until people stop listening to anything that you have to say, even if some of it is true.

I also appreciated the clear explanation of the CDN loophole. Good presentation, guys! Good job!

Also, despite increased access to 'intelligence,' the US continues to make poor strategic decisions, blunder into wars that it loses, lurch from financial crisis to crisis, and lose the trust of both its domestic citizens and important foreign allies. Tons and tons of 'data' but negligible intelligence.

hagbardgroup··on We re-built our "About" page. Feedback?
Of course.

>Is there a reason for this?

People read left to right. You want to lay out the text in a way that is comfortable for the human eye. Center alignment is great when you have short messages that can be read without shifting focus. It's not good to use when it extends beyond the breadth at which the eye can read without moving. It's just not what people are used to doing when they read blocs of text. Eye movement generates eyestrain, and people get annoyed when their eye strains to read, so they're more likely to get distracted and press 'back.'

It can still be in the center column, but it should still be left aligned.

It helps to think about it in terms of the eye's physical movements over a page.

>One of the problems I aimed to solve was to reduce the "wall of text" effect by splitting it up into tabs. How can I improve this without losing sight of that goal?

Yeah, I understand your intent. If you want more substantiation you can run a user test to see if people understand the layout and click through.

You can also read the classic 'Don't Make Me Think' by Steve Krug, which explains why this sort of design element which seems to save space tends to confuse users. While it's an older book, the advice still holds up.

You can achieve a similar result with a more modern 'long sales page' (ex. https://basecamp.com/). The walls of text can be broken up with headings, subheadings, and evocative images.

The reason why you see the signup buttons multiple times there is to give the user a chance to convert at each stage. If the user isn't ready to sign up yet, they scroll down, get a few more reasons why they should sign up, and then repeat until they either close the tab, sign up, or click through for more information about why they should sign up.

>What is the supporting copy?

The text that supports your sales pitch under the different tabs that's giving the reader a reason why they should try your product. Try to condense the sentences so that only the strongest points remain, and then build out from there.

hagbardgroup··on We re-built our "About" page. Feedback?
* Text should not be centered.

* The Unique Selling Proposition (USP) needs to be more prominent. The quote box draws in the eye. There are no faces or other images to attract the eye to where you want it to be.

* The About/Goodwill/etc. tabs break basic usability guidelines. The user is unlikely to realize that the blue means 'selected.' This non-intuitive relative to scrolling.

* USP is too heavy on features and not enough on benefits. Say what's in it for the user and less on what the thing is.

* The table with the users is OK but you would get more persuasive lift from attributed testimonials like the one you have above it from the HN guy.

* The supporting copy needs a red marker through 90% of it.

* "We make sharing stuff suck less." -- sounds cool in an affable internet cool guy kind of way, but does not actually communicate in a way that drives the reader to action.

The old version is actually a little bit better, although the animated GIF where it is will keep the visitors' eyes bouncing to it repeatedly as it loops, which impedes comprehension. The old version also uses too many h2 subheadings and would be more appropriate for an FAQ. h2 is too big for such short snippets of text.

Also, I like the GIF -> HTML5 conversion bit in the original, because it shows a benefit of your service. Seeing the video play bar on mouseover was also a pleasant surprise. I would explain why your prospective user might want to do that (make your pages load faster to make your readers happier and more loyal) without using jargon. 'Kilobyte' is jargon, as is KB.

Apart from that the navigation on the website isn't clear. The About page also doesn't drive me to sign up -- your call to action at the bottom of the first tab is to check out your subreddit, IRC channel, and twitter account. The general convention is to ask for the signup and then to provide the option to learn more if they're not sold yet.

Some more general suggestions:

1. Excise all the technical terms (yes, even references to file types -- say what the file is) from the portions not targeted to developers.

2. Weight the benefits heavier than the features (tell me what it will do for me and then explain how it will do it rather than telling me how it'll do it and expecting me to figure out why I, the selfish and lazy user, should care).

3. I would work on refining the 'Mediacrush is a fast, open-source media hosting service' tagline.

Hope this was helpful -- good luck!

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →