HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hahainternet

1,457 karma · joined May 20, 2011

submissionscomments
hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> 1 - To whom do you suggest the government should be accountable?

Other governments and ultimately the citizenry as a whole.

> if Apple cannot comply without endangering every iPhone owner, then the other owners of iPhones have a stake in the outcome

They do not. No more than owners of doors when the FBI executes a warrant.

> The government's right to investigate this crime doesn't expand to the right to endanger millions of people's privacy and security.

No plausible mechanism has ever been put forward where this would be the case.

> Libertarian philosophy doesn't suggest that you have a right to hurt other people, unless in self-defense.

Right, they attempted to coerce your staff on your premesis into acting against their own interests. This is a violation of the NAP and therefore any level of violence in self defence is justified.

This is one of the most core Libertarian beliefs.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> For example changing the WiFi or Bluetooth MAC is not locked down and effects the UDID. Because the UDID was never intended to be a way to bypass the device encryption it was not designed with anywhere near the same level of care and sophistication as handling the encryption key itself.

I never suggested the UDID. Please don't ascribe a claim to me that was never made. SHA512 the serial and macs independently. Job done.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
Therefore they have the ability to unlock the phone. I mean I knew people defended Apple here but I didn't think they'd demand logic no longer works to satisfy that.
hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> Taking the private key from Apple with a warrant, national security letter, subpoena, or other methods is much easier than creating a custom version of iOS.

Clearly it is not, otherwise they would have done this. They did not.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> Including breaking down the doors of anyone they texted or called.

But not the service provider intentionally denying access to this vital information? What a bizarre twist of logic!

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
Wouldn't these mechanisms apply to key verification? How exactly can you argue that you can modify data in realtime inside the phone's architecture, but couldn't possibly modify data in realtime inside the phone's architecture?
hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> Do you really not understand how precedent works or are you being deliberately obtuse?

Please do not insult people on HN. This false dichotomy is offensive to me.

> The criminal act being investigated is irrelevant. They want data on a device in their possession that they have permission to search. That is all that matters.

Then why are you concerned about precedent? They have met all of the requirements to search this device. Apple is impeding them for no good reason purely to advance their corporate interests.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
This comment simply makes claims like altering data in transit inside the architecture of the CPU.

Yes, if you can do that, then you can flash anything to the phone. When someone shows me that happening, then I'll believe in this technology.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> Chances are, this happened at least once over the lifetime of the terrorists ownership of the phone - thus we can at least see who they are communicating with, right?

Is that really acceptable to you? Maybe they accidentally screwed up once so it's OK to keep the private affairs of a dead terrorist secret for no good reason?

> Wouldn't that be a good starting point?

I would have thought the best starting point was unlocking the phone, given the owner is dead and committed horrific crimes.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few

No, they don't. We live in nations with individual rights. The US specifically is a nation without acceptable levels of healthcare. The needs of the many clearly do not outweigh the needs of a few.

> But of course bad people can still use extra encryption, so lack of default encryption will mostly hurt good people

This is a non sequitur driven by a false dichotomy. Nobody is suggesting the removal of encryption.

> I think it comes down to how willing you are to let bad people get away with their crimes vs lose your own right to privacy in a world where more and more of your private life and thoughts are stored digitally.

How many criminals are you willing to let get away with their crimes? Apple has currently built a system that allows child abusers and some rapists to be all but immune from conviction.

Are you happy with this? I am certainly not.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> I don't see the point you are trying to make.

Somalia is a country where the government are beholden to the citizenry.

> I'm simply suggesting that "treating the government as no better than a customer" is probably a healthy attitude

I see no evidence for that. Being able to treat a search warrant as if it's a polite request would help pretty much nobody.

> I recognize this as an idealistic attitude. I've always leaned libertarian.

By typical libertarian logic, Apple would be justified in torturing and executing the FBI agents on their property, as property is private and the Government is subordinate. The FBI agents violated the Non Aggression Principle by attempting to coerce Apple's employees to act.

Where have I mistaken your logic there?

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> The issue is the precedent that is made

That searching the effects of a dead terrorist is acceptable? I really don't find this objectionable in any way whatsoever.

> Apple could no longer argue they had to create something to fulfill the warrant, since it was already created.

Good, Apple's desires to not be subject to the laws of nations where they do business has historically hurt their customers. Even now people argue that Apple are doing this to protect their customers of which there's no evidence whatsoever.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> They could get all of the logs of outgoing requests from the cell company and then go to each service provider and demand dumps of data from any accounts that Phone logged into right?

The primary service provider being Apple, who operates a fully encrypted messaging system where the cleartext only ever exists on the device.

It's a child abuser's wet dream.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> Heck, I don't want them to be able to do it.

Why? Having talked to a lot of people who hold this position, the only underlying thought I've been able to discern is that you can't conceive of any time someone else holding encrypted data could hurt you.

If this phone instead belonged to a living rapist or paedophile instead of a terrorist, and was the only evidence proving their guilt, would you feel the same?

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
That guarantee until the latest generation was the only thing protecting the hardware. It has never been altered or hacked that I am aware of. Doing so would require modifying the physical construction of the chips on the device.

Possible? Maybe, but if it was that simple the FBI could simply change the signing key. It's not, and they can't.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> A search warrant doesn't require me to create a new capability that did not exist before.

I don't see how that's relevant. If I invent a new kind of lock you've never seen before, you'll have to come up with a way to break it.

I'm asking for why a search warrant would be oppressive, even if it involved creating new firmware for a safe.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
Apple could write code that checks the hardware ID supplied and sign only that version. It's been sufficient to prevent hacking so far and is the major protection relied upon until the latest generation, so I don't think this is an issue at all.
hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> The best way to prevent governments from oppressing their citizens is to refuse to create tools that enable oppression.

Are search warrants oppressive? Can you distinguish this request from the FBI requesting a safe manufacturer modify the firmware on a single safe?

I doubt either of these can be reliably argued.

hahainternet··on Answers to your questions about Apple and security
> I, for one, would like to live in a country where the government is a servant, not a master.

Would you? Why not Somalia?

hahainternet··on UN panel 'rules in Assange's favour'
It's extremely hard to understand how this could be the case. He has evaded prosecution for rape for years and still has people defending him. It was entirely his own choice to seek refuge inside the embassy and he did so to avoid prosecution. This makes him a gigantic hypocrite in addition to the sexual offences.

Reading the complaint against him, it's very hard to see how anyone could justify his actions. I'm sure there'll be much posted in this thread shortly though calling him a hero.

hahainternet··on Code.google.com was shut down, Go packaging is broken
"it" being "The idea they might shut down a free service with only 10 months notice".

If your company relies on Google to this extent, and does not have the staff to fix the issues inside 10 months then you need to reconsider your business plan.

hahainternet··on The benefits of static typing without static typing in Python
> Probably this will still not be enough for Python enemies though.

Because it doesn't appear to actually do anything. It's a joke to call this 'static typing'.

hahainternet··on Why Would Anyone Use Perl 6?
> So it sounds like your needs don't align exactly with perl's sigils anyway (and why should they? For different business requirements you'd categorize differently).

Indeed but I can write constraints in my function signature to permit this. Hell I can even define something as SpecialList[SpecialKey] if I truly wanted. Perl has a type system.

> Not with good language/design. Separate your concerns. Let the difference in behaviour live somewhere more appropriate - either on an object that contains the data (OO style) or in a callback you pass into the function (functional style).

Doing this in Python is an exercise in horror, frustration and hatred. Doing it in Perl is the work of a few seconds. That is my point.

hahainternet··on Why Perl 6 is Different (2010)
IMHO Project Euler is a good start. There are solutions published in Perl6 to a large number of them.
hahainternet··on Why Would Anyone Use Perl 6?
I resisted replying to Don as I didn't think he presented any actual argument. The "Write two functions" crew haven't thought this through though.

Ultimately, the scenario I came across this in was an atomic transaction decorated function. The data being provided to this function flows through a good 3 or 4 functions beforehand. I also require _single, _list and _listoflists behaviour. This would bloat a 4 function stack into something like 20 different functions. There are also issues with transaction decorators.

It just seems crazy to me that Python can't manage this (to me trivial) use case.

hahainternet··on Why Would Anyone Use Perl 6?
It's absolutely worth a try. Please see the fact that there are examples on this very page which are very succinct but hard to do in other languages.
hahainternet··on Why Would Anyone Use Perl 6?
With a language like Perl 6, you can happily use simply @clients or %clients and if you define those correctly, you can explicitly detail the key too.
hahainternet··on Why Would Anyone Use Perl 6?
Really?

my %clients vs my @clients

Do you name your variables

client_list .. client_dictionary? No? Then sigils aren't superfluous.

hahainternet··on Why Would Anyone Use Perl 6?
My apologies. I read it as sarcastically requestioning them.
hahainternet··on Why Would Anyone Use Perl 6?
If I check __iter__ I consume strings too which is what I'm trying to avoid. Both of you have taken the perspective that this distinction is irrelevant but neither of you have a good answer to this case:

    > multi sub hi($a) { say "Hello there $a" }
    > multi sub hi(@a) { hi($_) for @a }

    > hi("lmm")
    Hello there lmm
    > hi(<lmm DonHopkins>)
    Hello there lmm
    Hello there DonHopkins
Surely this is not so exceptional a use case?
← PreviousPage 2 of 29Next →