HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hairytrog

884 karma · joined January 18, 2019

submissionscomments
hairytrog··on 1MW Molten-Salt Test Reactor by Copenhagen Atomic for €88k [video]
You mean crazy dangerous. At that power density, everything has to work for this thing to not meltdown.
hairytrog··on I made 24 high-quality Covid illustrations. Free for commercial and personal use
truly infantile.
hairytrog··on Mushrooms Can Eat Plastic, Petroleum and CO2 (2018)
Just nuclear waste?
hairytrog··on Mushrooms Can Eat Plastic, Petroleum and CO2 (2018)
The ham itself will protect it, wrapped in Aluminum foil or even a hemp bag for shipping. The packaging is simply an artifact of people not wanting to buy a whole ham and wanting it presliced, which is perhaps an artifact of the fact that most people in the US will heat the majority of their meals by themselves and do not like to prepare meals. Sad.
hairytrog··on Scientists grow bigger monkey brains using human genes, replicating evolution
The fetus would probably not have3 survived. You can't just make the brain bigger and expect everything else to work out. Example problems: skull too small, eyes and everything around the brain would have to be reconfigured, heart/blood supply would have to be reconfigured, etc etc. Some examples of how this goes wrong in humans (graphic): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anencephaly
hairytrog··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
90% protection... Let's see what this really means - because I'm pretty sure we already have something on order of 80+% protection without a vaccine. I'd like to see % protection vs age.
hairytrog··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
Developing countries have youth immunity. When you convolve covid hospitalization / IFR as function of age with age distribution, developing countries have no risk whatsoever from COVID. that's why Brazil and India are nearing herd immunity with basically no serious medical infrastructure saturation. Median age in Africa is 19... No fks given. Covid vaccine is just for old people/developing countries.
hairytrog··on New nuclear engine concept could help realize 3-month trips to Mars
This is the same company doing the Micro Modular Reactor ? amazing
hairytrog··on We Need a Nuclear New Deal, Not a Green New Deal
Author has good intentions, but absolutist and dangerous thoughts here. For example: "In order for this to work in the United States, the federal government could consolidate the nuclear arms of General Atomics, General Electric, Westinghouse, and others into a single public corporation. This federal entity would be mandated to decarbonize the American electricity grid."

They suggest making a monopoly for nuclear? Are you kidding me? That is a recipe for bad technology choices and taking advantage of customers. Let the market figure it out, with dozens of designs and vendors and demonstrations. It's already an oligopoly with maybe 2 or 3 incumbents in the US. And it's been that way since the 60s when the government created that market power for military and international nuclear export reasons. Essentially they picked water cooled technologies because they made sense for the Navy, and picked just two companies to export them internationally, subsidized, etc for civilian use. We need more companies not less. And we need the government to stay out of it. The only thing federal government should do is help lower licensing costs and timelines and establish locations for rapid and responsible demonstration of advanced nuclear projects. The only way to do this is smaller reactors that take less money and time to demonstrate and verify. Think small not big. The DOE might be doing this with the Advanced Reactor Demonstration, but it seems they may be in the business of monopoly creation with just two companies out of 20 or more selected to demonstrate billion dollar mega projects.

Whatever we do, we should not deploy more water cooled technologies just to decarbonize. Yes, they work; yes they have not caused damage human life the US. But the GE designed Fukushima reactors and the RMBK water reactors are astonishingly close to catastrophe. People don't understand how much effort goes into avoiding meltdowns. We need new meltdown proof designs that don't need active cooling to keep the reactor at safe temperatures.

TO THE FEDS: prevent monopolies - make demonstrating new nuclear technologies easier

hairytrog··on Ultra Safe Nuclear
also they used a strange control system. No control rods. Instead they moved the whole core up and down to change reactivity. wtf?
hairytrog··on Ultra Safe Nuclear
Seems like they used a sodium coolant - great thermal properties as it allows for atmospheric pressure loop. But sodium introduces the chemical hazard and all the associated maintenance and materials woes and accident scenarios. Also, the power density on the 4S was relatively high.
hairytrog··on Ultra Safe Nuclear
I don't think they're necessarily chasing grid power at first anyway. They seem positioned to tackle mass market electricity last, after addressing smaller higher price markets.
hairytrog··on Ultra Safe Nuclear
I highly recommend HBO's Chernobyl. Explains a lot this stuff. Basically, as a nuclear reactor operates, it is turning the Uranium into lots of other stuff. One component of this other stuff is Xenon-135, which absorbs neutrons and basically gets in the way of nuclear reactions. This is not an issue if you keep the reactor on because there are enough neutrons to keep things going and overcome the Xenon absorption. But if you turn the reactor off, you now have no neutrons from the fission reactions and lots of neutron absorbers. There is so much absorption that it's impossible to start up the reactor for a couple of days. That's why nuclear reactors operate at constant power and only turn off to refuel. This MMR also operates at constant power, which would also have benefits for cycling issues, and uses the molten salt loop to store heat and then use it when it's needed.
hairytrog··on Ultra Safe Nuclear
Seems like their claim to "Ultra Safe" is actually merited based on a first principles look at the power density. They claim 1.24 W/cm^3 versus 20-40 W/cm^3 in normal reactors. The high power densities mean you have to be able to cool the reactor, even when you shut down the reactor because reactors take a long time to actually turn off. With such low power density, it should be no problem to cool down the reactor. It'll just cool down naturally, like a hot pot. In fact the metric to look at would be power per core surface area.
hairytrog··on Ultra Safe Nuclear
Two interesting things to see here, of many. They are really planning the sites to be temporary compared to the solar/wind/ and other industrial power plants that have little or no plan for returning their sites to the original virgin soil. And two, they seem to use a molten salt loop like in concentrated solar to meet variable demand without changing the power level of the reactor, which you can't really do because of Xenon poisoning. So it's like a natural gas plant in its ability to deliver power, but clean and holds 20 years of fuel inside the reactor.
hairytrog··on Study: Cheap gas, not renewables, caused nuclear woes (2018)
100 kW may make sense but as part of a large facility with maybe a few hundred of them. Distributing nuclear material so widely would be imprudent. The materials themselves are dangerous, there's no getting around that and there's real value in a minimum of centralization and control of the reactors in one place. A turbine generating half a gigawatt is also much more efficient (orders of magnitude) than 5000 turbines generating 100kw.
hairytrog··on Study: Cheap gas, not renewables, caused nuclear woes (2018)
If renewables growth continues and expands (as in the multi Trillion Green Deal lol), different nuclear thrusts will probably not require any government assistance or support. The money making potential will completely outweigh any other concerns like high capital costs and risk. It's getting there. A carbon tax would be the cherry on top.
hairytrog··on Study: Cheap gas, not renewables, caused nuclear woes (2018)
The battery/solar/storage costs are near material costs already. And the material costs are artificially low. If you wanted to scale up production to match demand, prices will have to increase so that mines can extract worse ores in harder to reach places.
hairytrog··on Study: Cheap gas, not renewables, caused nuclear woes (2018)
Let's not get stuck into one solution. Need to pursue several. Floating power plants are very promising as there is lots of shipbuilding capability and the worldwide commercial cargo fleet numbers in the tens of thousands of ships. This could scale pretty fast. I do dislike the idea of a power plant surrounded by salt water - it just doesn't help with the chemical/corrosion safety even if you can use as coolant for an extreme accident. Obviously, no earthquakes and less population in the area. But once the accident happens, you don't get to do mitigation like collecting the dust or pieces.

Another strong approach gaining traction is production in the 5-50MW range, with 100s/1000s/yr in the same way Boeing and Airbus build ~2000 wide body aircraft each year. Smaller reactors with lower power density can claim inherent safety with respect to various hazards - ie cannot meltdown through system failures.

Must move away from absolutist mind set with single solution and try lots of strategies. Many will be effective.

hairytrog··on Germany plans to dim lights at night to save insects
The machine never slows down to protect weaker species. Such plan may be an attempt to lower power demand at night and make the demand curve more closely match Germany's wind/solar supply curve. It's an effort to lower costs and lower demand for power they'd have to buy from coal/natural gas.
hairytrog··on The Truth Is Paywalled but the Lies Are Free
There are drawbacks to such a universal search system as described. The search is often crucial to the development of ideas. Like going to a library looking for a book, and finding a bunch of books on the same shelf or two shelfs over. You lose that with a universal search. The time and energy involved in finding things is crucial to the development and ideation process.
hairytrog··on FCC approves Amazon’s internet-from-space constellation of 3,236 satellites
Solution: 10% tax on all satellite internet revenues to fund space based telescopes. Could really improve astronomy.
hairytrog··on SEC issues $3.8M whistleblower award
I wonder what goes through the whistleblowers head in terms of timing and how much they should help the crime. If you wait a little longer or help the crime, the payout increases. Maybe there are already people designing schemes in which they can do the crime, whistleblow, and get a legal payday.
hairytrog··on Facebook announces policy changes ahead of 2020 elections
Who's paying for HN?
hairytrog··on Why venture capital doesn’t build the things we really need
Curing disease is not likely to make more money.

Carbon-free energy: nuclear, storage??

Self-driving cars: just keep throwing money at it, eventually something will cross the threshold of good enough

hairytrog··on The US military is getting serious about nuclear thermal propulsion
NASA is developing its own system: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/201700.... It's expected to follow a similar industry bidding process as the commercial crew launch etc. It's too bad the military had to get involved.

Let's hope nuclear rockets become a commercial reality before they become a military tool. There's a company in Seattle called Ultra Safe Nuclear Corp that develops the fuel and core for the NASA mission: https://www.usnc-tech.com/products/. They also do a terrestrial reactor for off-grid remote regions that is set to be demonstrated in Canada in the next few years: https://www.usnc.com.

hairytrog··on The US military is getting serious about nuclear thermal propulsion
It's not a dirty bomb! The nuclear thermal rocket has not operated yet which means the fuel is not radioactive and contains no fission products. The surface to space chemical rocket could explore and there would be no fall out.
hairytrog··on Why people hate contemporary architecture (2017)
The winnowing theory only makes sense to people today, because we have such a massive demolition industry. But when things were built with old construction techniques, taking a lot more time and effort, using stone and brick - you built once and it remained long term. The rate of demolition was probably much lower in the past.
hairytrog··on The US can reach 90% clean electricity by 2035 without increasing consumer bills
I think I came out a little strong and biased here. My apologies. Some more thoughts on this article.

- They group nukes in the clean %, so today we're at 37% clean already. not bad. Going to higher clean % with mix of wind/solar expansion + new storage + dispatchable nukes is very possible and the political momentum to throw a lot of money at this is there.

- I think it's unlikely costs can be reduced much in most parts of the US if we still want 100% dispatch capability.

- It's not just about cost. We should consider paying a bit more for carbon considerations, within reason and without forgetting who gets punished by higher prices in the short term, and without compromising the 100% dispatchable standard.

- Wind/solar LCOE is approaching very low numbers, so it should be used as much as possible, but we shouldn't throw a trillion dollars from the government, as the article suggests, to shove wind/solar down the grid's throat. It's likely to break the grid and waste a load of money. Government should just ensure the markets can properly deal with higher renewables without compromising the grid. They can do this via establishing capacity markets, resiliency markets, R&D for storage tech, etc. They might also do a carbon tax to try to set the higher cost we are willing to pay from above.

- There are significant resilience, material, and regulation challenges. It's not just the energy storage for a few hours, but longer term for days and weeks. If we are a responsible society and expect smooth operations and we want to do an extreme renewables expansion, we need to pay the price to keep an idle fleet of fully dispatchable gas/nukes in addition to the renewables fleet or establish multi month storage.

hairytrog··on The US can reach 90% clean electricity by 2035 without increasing consumer bills
Short answer: anything above 20% is unproven and will cost significantly more if you expect to have 100% uptime/reliability. If you're okay with 95% uptime, wind/solar can get the job done, and I believe cheaper based on https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S25424...

____

The flaw with renewables is they are so dam cheap and so dam finicky. Basically, renewables force nukes and nat gas to sell power at a loss or sit idly by for most of the time. This becomes worse and worse as the renewable's market share increases and they eat away at the profitability of the dispatchable sources. The limit is something like 20% at which point nukes and nat gas just can't make any money and so a free market system would just get rid of them. But yet, they need to be there, just in case, because they are dispatchable and you want shit to work at all times. Unfortunately, prices for consumers don't go down because you need the super dispatchable power sources which just sit there for a lot of the time and cost just about the same if you have em on or off, and you also just built a bunch of renewables which are cheap and make money for the guys who built them, but hurt the rest of the grid because you have a bunch of idle equipment (gas/nukes during the day and most of the year, panels at night). Lower cost storage is a way to address that, but has to be really low cost, especially when you increase wind/solar market share. Keep in mind, there's not yet a good solution for long term storage (days or weeks or months).

To go beyond 20% renewables you need a power market that rewards dispatchable sources, essentially preventing solar and wind from taking all the money and bidding everyone into oblivion. If the market is fair, there will be little incentive to push renewables because they just make things more expensive. There's a bunch of ideas on how to do this like capacity payments. Might work, but it's gonna cost more because of all the unused equipment. Everything is possible, you just need to be willing to pay for it.

In an 80% renewables grid, most of the time, renewables will be meeting 100% of demand and producing much more than needed. 20% of the power is delivered by nat gas. But they will mostly be called to do that only on the bad days where they will have to be able to match closer to 100% of the demand. So you've basically got two nearly complete fleets. Who's gonna pay for the idle equipment? The solar power producers should right?

One data point: Germany is 30% renewables and pays 50% higher than EU average. That's old prices in a country not ideal for renewables. It's no Arizona or Washington.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →