HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hairytrog

884 karma · joined January 18, 2019

submissionscomments
hairytrog··on Filthy surgical instruments: a threat in America's operating rooms (2014)
Considering the amount of antibiotics used, doctors could probably use tools fished out a dumpster.
hairytrog··on When the Public Feared That Library Books Could Spread Deadly Diseases
Preventative measures: quarantined society, minimized travel and human contact, private or limited use facilities, increased isolation, enhanced and more frequent sanitation at point of use, and enhanced air treatment.

Sanitation is currently done by chemical (Clorox), heat (autoclave or flame), light (UV, X-Ray, gamma), filtration, or pressure treatment. These are highly functional, especially when used in tandem.

hairytrog··on When the Public Feared That Library Books Could Spread Deadly Diseases
Spread of disease is unavoidable in a society of public restrooms and shared infrastructure. Sick people contaminate their environment at points of contact like handles, toilet seats, keyboards, the air around them, etc. The damages caused by sick people at work are poorly estimated at $150B (https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/11323-cost-of-coming-to-wo...).

I could imagine micro terrorists or psychos who actively try to spread disease. Sick people who go to work do the same thing, just without evil intentions. It would be relatively easy to cultivate bacteria or viruses and spread them across the human environment.

Examples:

- Go to the airport and mist some Norovirus around

- Enter a couple stalls and drip some E-Coli on the seats or contaminate a whole role of toilet paper or drying paper

- Contaminate a few ketchup bottles at a restaurant or mist the silverware bucket

It would be extremely difficult to pinpoint these people as the damage is anonymous, random, and highly distributed. Damages could dwarf any previous terrorist attack or serial killer. It's likely that such people exist.

hairytrog··on Dog ownership is associated with better cardiovascular health
I mean the owner.
hairytrog··on Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution
Maybe tech companies would contribute based on the extra money they can make. If Google can earn $5 for each additional user, they should be willing to pay 4.99 to create new users.
hairytrog··on Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution
No. I'm addicted.
hairytrog··on Dog ownership is associated with better cardiovascular health
I wonder if dog ownership also correlates with lower reproduction rates.
hairytrog··on The $18B Electric-Car Bubble at Risk of Bursting in China
There's tons of performance bike manufacturers with minimal variation. Reason is its easy - not that many parts, parts easily configured and modular, easy to build, low maintenance.

Maybe EVs are similar. lower complexity than fossil engines (fewer parts and complexity moves down the supply chain). Perhaps such a large number of vehicle producers is sustainable. The real ev companies are the companies making batteries, motors, and ev base tech.

hairytrog··on Show HN: 2.5B people can’t afford internet – need your opinion on our solution
You might be starting with the wrong question. You are assuming internet access is a good thing and that extending its supply will be best for everyone. Consider the following:

- the internet makes people dumber (low attention spans, group think, advertising driven content, addictive behaviors promoted, etc)

- the internet makes us consumers instead of creators

- the internet makes people depressed and anxious

- the internet causes around 5% of global GHG emissions

- internet enhances ability for total monitoring and censoring of speech

- internet creates centralized global tech monopolies on information flow and data

- extensive global networks put society at increased risk of total collapse

What are the benefits and do they really outweigh the negatives? Can the benefits be accomplished through other means? Just make sure you're comfortable with possibly making people's lives worse.

hairytrog··on A Chunk of Trinitite Reminds Us of the Power of the Atomic Bomb
Similar story but of a failed physics project is "Project Prometheus" by George Dyson, Richard Dyson's son. It's about the project to use atomic explosions for extremely efficient propulsion. With proper implementation, such atomic bomb thrusters would have allowed for 100,000 ton payloads and a truly space faring society.
hairytrog··on Preindustrial workers worked fewer hours than today's (2009)
Sure, many spend 8 hours at the office. But do they do 8 hours of work? Probably not. There are diminishing returns on time spent working, and it probably starts around the third hour.

https://www.oxfordscholarship.com/view/10.1093/oso/978019087...

Many industries would probably suffer negligible losses (and maybe gains) by transitioning to 20 hour work weeks.

hairytrog··on Removing One Maine Dam 20 Years Ago Changed Everything
I wonder if rehabilitation is always possible. The Italian region of Südtirol, in the alps, is completely hydro powered with large exports. And there are basically no fish. What happens if they undam it all today? What if they undam it in 500 years? Does it just take a decade or two for a pretty complete rehab?
hairytrog··on Tourism Is Overwhelming the World's Top Destinations
I agree. They do pay for things while they are here. But they are not paying for everything they are getting. For example, have they paid for all the infrastructure they are using? Or for the 100 years of parks conservation? Or the US system of law and order? They are not paying the full price.
hairytrog··on Tourism Is Overwhelming the World's Top Destinations
We need to start pricing tourism. For example, why should a Chinese citizen visiting Yosemite only pay the same as an American citizen who is paying a lifetime of taxes to run and protect the park? The tourists use the entire infrastructure and economy to their benefit without paying the historical price that citizens have paid. They simply tap into the current prices.

We can charge for tourism in a few ways:

1. price discrimination at individual locations based on passport. This would be difficult to implement and unpopular.

2. Charge really high prices for tourist visas that represent the true value of the what the tourists is gaining access to.

3. UBI for citizens

hairytrog··on U.S. Officials Suspect New Nuclear Missile in Explosion That Killed 7 Russians
These missiles take a long a time to reach destination, and the time can be extended by a prolonged voyage (circle the globe a few times). The only people who can disarm the warhead are the enemies. You're not going to blow up your enemies while the missile is in the air. It's a great political tool. Launch a missile and everyone starts talking and giving in to your demands.
hairytrog··on Nuclear Reactor for Mars Outpost Could Be Ready to Fly by 2022
Cost estimate: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14701774
hairytrog··on Russia Says Small Nuclear Reactor Blew Up in Deadly Accident
Cruise missiles are generally short range. The main advantage of a nuclear cruise missile is its added long range and maintained ability to stay mostly undetectable and unstoppable to missile defense since they can travel at low altitude.

The other advantage is political. These missiles take a long a time to reach destination, and the time can be extended by a prolonged voyage (circle the globe a few times). The only people who can disarm the warhead are the enemies. You're not going to blow up your enemies while the missile is in the air. It's a great apolitical tool. Launch a missile and everyone starts talking and giving in to your demands.

Better article: https://www.wsj.com/articles/russian-nuclear-agency-confirms...

hairytrog··on Nuclear Reactor for Mars Outpost Could Be Ready to Fly by 2022
Making things small is actually not that big a challenge in nuclear. The challenge are safety, cost, and proliferation. There are a lot of reasons this shouldn't be produced at scale.

- at 10 kW, it produces power for about 5 American homes. You'd need 60 M of these for the US.

- Proliferation. Kilopower uses high enriched fuel (92%). This is bomb material from the get go. They could probably build a lower enrichment core. But they haven't. shame. In any case, if there were lots of these cores around, it would lower the barrier to access and process spent nuclear fuel.

- This is for space and NASA. Not the right type of innovation for terrestrial and mass produced. They went small, high performance. We need safe and low cost.

- It's a heat pipe cooled reactor and heat pipes have the worst heat transfer characteristics (compared to water, gas, molten salts) and will have a new set of accident scenarios like what happens if a heat pipe bursts and you get a sodium fire.

- You don't really want nuclear systems to be too small or mobile mobile devices or to travel much. You want to build em and know they're not going to move. You don't want to give the reactor more kinetic energy that it can use to break itself apart and release fission products. During a launch to space, this isn't so big a problem because the reactor has not yet been turned on and contains no fission products, so failed launch is not so bad.

hairytrog··on A Commercial Path to Fusion
Overheard a wailing researcher at a bar in Boston. Sorry.
hairytrog··on A Commercial Path to Fusion
Let's just toss out all physics pre 2000 because it's old. lol. Truth doesn't age. Just using ITER as an example. I can update that link with a Commonwealth one in a few years I suppose.

Manufacturability is a function of a lot of things like parts, systems, interactions, size, mass, supply chain, transportability, etc. Generally speaking, more complex things are less manufacturable and they become manufacturable by simplification and reduction. As a kind of measure of manufacturability, look at the cost. Think about the most expensive piece of technology that is mass manufactured today. It's probably the 777 or 737 - so price tag on order <$100M. Big ships are on order $10Ms. Maybe military procurement goes into the $500M, but those are low quantity and generally failed programs.

So if it's more than $100M and much more complicated than a wide body aircraft, today's economy and technology level is probably not going to be able to mass manufacture it.

The size and complexity of these fusion systems is physically constrained by various factors many of which are physics limited. And even with the innovations they propose but have yet to prove out, the size and complexity is still too large to manufacture.

Regarding fusion's proliferation risk: "One of the best ways to produce material for atomic weapons would be to put common, natural uranium or thorium in the blanket of a D-T reactor, where the fusion neu- trons would soon transform it to weapons- grade material. And tritium, an unavoidable product of the reactor; is used in some hydro- gen bombs. In the early years, research on D-T fusion was classified precisely because it would provide a ready source of material for weapons."

hairytrog··on A Commercial Path to Fusion
it's a she.
hairytrog··on A Commercial Path to Fusion
You're missing the point. We know there are asteroids with price changing amounts of precious metals - we aren't mining them.

Commercialization involves so much more than proving it can be done physically. And it also involves more than meeting a price in a padded environment. There are hurdles to jump that are totally disconnected from the price.

hairytrog··on A Commercial Path to Fusion
This is R&D - not a commercial path.

These types of fusion projects are trying to prove the most basic piece of the puzzle: net energy generation. And it is a big problem, even for Commonwealth. I've heard that the magnets are underperforming by about a factor of 2 - and that's 4 years into the project.

But commercialization is a lot more than just proving that the concept is physically possible. It was proven possible that man could walk on the moon, but it's not a commercial activity 50 years in. Commercialization for nuclear energy systems means global deployment, mass manufacturing, lack of proliferation risk, extreme safety, etc. Fusion systems like Commonwealth's do not meet any of these criteria. They are constantly generating radioactive waste because they have to breed their fuel and reprocess it on site.

To commercialize, you have to be able to deploy the technology in a significantly better way than traditional fission. These large fusion prototypes ($65B for ITER and $5B for Commonwealth based on their 2015 white paper, so probably 2-4x larger now) exacerbate traditional nuclear's cost problems because they are construction projects that will last decades. Viable nuclear solutions will be factory manufactured rather than constructed.

For comments from MIT dissenter in 80s that stand true today: http://orcutt.net/weblog/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/The-Trou...

For a review of fusion problems: https://thebulletin.org/2018/02/iter-is-a-showcase-for-the-d...

hairytrog··on Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy
Using renewable electricity to make Hydrogen is bonkers today.

Using high temperature nuclear heat is not. You just need gas-cooled reactors that can make 900 to 1000 °C steam.

This company is making gas-cooled reactor in Canada and claim they can make competitive Hydrogen: https://usnc.com/FCM.html

The processes are different from electrolysis. From https://art.inl.gov/NGNP/NEAC%202010/INL_NGNP%20References/R...

"1. SI Process: A thermochemical process that incorporates: (1) endothermic decomposition of hydrogen iodide (HI) at about 450°C in the presence of a carbon catalyst to yield hydrogen and I2, (2) recycle of the iodine to a concurrent or countercurrent column reactor where it reacts exothermically at about 120°C with sulfur dioxide (SO2) via the Bunsen reaction to form hydriodic acid (HI) and sulfuric acid (H2SO4), (3) gravimetric separation of the HI and H2SO4, and (4) thermal/catalytic decomposition of sulfuric acid (H2SO4) to oxygen and SO2 at high temperature, up to 900°C, with the SO2 recycled back to the Bunsen reaction section. In the SI process, H2SO4 acts as oxygen carrier and HI as a hydrogen carrier.

2. HTSE Process: A ceramic electrolyte and electrode electrolysis process operating at up to 950°C. Water is the only reactant, and high temperatures allow for some of the energy required to split the steam (water) to be supplied as heat as opposed to electricity alone, as in LTE cells.

3. HyS Process: A hybrid process that produces hydrogen and oxygen in a polymer membrane based electrolysis cell operating at temperatures below 125°C. In the HyS process, SO2 is used to depolarize the cell and allow it to operate at lower voltages and hence higher efficiencies and current densities as compared to higher temperature electrolysis cells. Sulfuric acid is produced along with hydrogen in the cells, with the SO2 recycled from a sulfuric acid decomposer similar to that used in the SI process."

hairytrog··on LightSail 2 Spacecraft Successfully Demonstrates Flight by Light
If a photon hits the sail and is reflected, it must transfer two photon momentums to the sail. The energy should be less than before it the sail. Is it redshifted?
hairytrog··on America’s packaged food supply is ultra-processed
Would be interesting to see the fractions by mass rather than number of products. The latter could just be that we have many many varieties of chips and soda and only a few varieties of flour.
hairytrog··on In the US, wells being drilled ever deeper as groundwater vanishes
This is poor reporting and possibly poor science. It's not enough to say that it will vanish. We need to know on what timescale it will vanish. I suspect that it will last at least several centuries at current extraction rates. Several hundred years from now, the climate may be completely different, energy might extremely cheap, new continental water distribution might be constructed, etc.
hairytrog··on Launch HN: Wren (YC S19) – Offset Your Carbon Footprint
This is pretty unfair. People who put money into these projects should be able to make money from them as well. Why should climate-conscious people have to donate money to offset the carbon footprint while investors get to earn?
hairytrog··on House orders Pentagon to say if it weaponized ticks and released them
How do you defend against weaponized ticks or mosquitoes?
hairytrog··on Notes from Peter Thiel’s Speech at the National Conservatism Conference
"China is an unusually dirty country dirtying up the planet. Trump’s 25% tariffs on China should be reframed as a carbon tax."
← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →