HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hannob

16,731 karma · joined March 7, 2014

See https://hboeck.de/ and https://industrydecarbonization.com/
submissionscomments
hannob··on Show HN: Nxtscape – an open-source agentic browser
Okay, maybe this is a stupid question, but: what is an agentic browser? You seem to assume that everyone knows what that means.

Is this a common and well-defined term that people use? I've never heard it.

It would appear to me from the context that it means something like "web browser with AI stuff tackled on".

hannob··on DNS4EU for Public Is Available
It's a company selling this "enhanced protection". You need it, because otherwise, they wouldn't make money.

The whole thing looks like a PR stunt for an Infosec product. Just that they somehow convinced the EU to fund it.

hannob··on AI Responses May Include Mistakes
"AI Responses May Include Mistakes" is really the one, single most important thing I want to shout into the whole AI debate.

It also should be the central issue - together with the energy/climate impacts - in every debate about AI ethics or AI safety. It's those two things that will harm us most if this hype continues unchecked.

hannob··on There Is No Diffie-Hellman but Elliptic Curve Diffie-Hellman
This is a justification that was made up after Git came under increasing criticism for its poor choise of a hash function after the shattered attack. It was already known that SHA-1 is weak before Git was invented.

The problem is... it doesn't line up with the facts.

Git has been using SHA-1 hashes for signatures since very early on. It also has claims in its documentation about "cryptographic security". It does not rigorously define what "cryptographic security" means, but plausibly, it should mean using a secure hash function without known weaknesses.

hannob··on BGP handling bug causes widespread internet routing instability
> The standard approach is be liberal in what you accept and be specific in what you emit.

What you're paraphrasing here is the so-called "robustness principle", also known as "Poestel's law". It is an idea from the ancient history of the 1980s and 09s Internet. Today, it's widely understood that it is a misguided idea that has led to protocol ossification and countless security issues.

hannob··on Why I no longer have an old-school cert on my HTTPS site
> Some people don't want to be forced to run a bunch of stuff they > don't understand on the server, and I agree with them.

Honest question:

* Do you understand OS syscalls in detail?

* Do you understand how your BIOS initializes your hardware?

* Do you understand how modern filesystems work?

* Do you understand the finer details of HTTP or TCP?

Because... I don't. But I know enough about them that I'm quite convinced each of them is a lot more difficult to understand than ACME. And all of them and a lot more stuff are required if you want to run a web server.

hannob··on Updated rate limits for unauthenticated requests
> Several people in the comments seem to be blaming Github for taking this step for no apparent reason.

I mean...

* Github is owned by Microsoft.

* The reason for this are AI crawlers.

* The reason AI crawlers exist in masses is an absurd hype around LLM+AI technology.

* The reason for that is... ChatGPT?

* The main investor of ChatGPT happens to be...?

hannob··on Google to back three new nuclear projects
> the only power generation that has a completely closed fuel life cycle

What exactly are you talking about? It does not sound like it describes the way nuclear power, uranium mining, and nuclear waste storage works.

hannob··on Office is too slow, so Microsoft is making it load at Windows startup
I mean, it's not as if Libreoffice was created yesterday. Its predecessor OpenOffice is now 25 years old. Your question becomes: Why did you choose the expensive version where you never know what it will cost next year in the first place?
hannob··on Data centers contain 90% crap data
I have seen takes about the environmental footprint of unused data before, and I have severe doubts this is a relevant issue.

I mean, sure, there is some impact. Storage media has to be produced. But there's a reason storage is cheap, it's not a whole lot of resources going into it. And hard drives that are idle in some data center without being accessed don't consume a lot of electricity.

There are very real and concerning problems with the environmental impact of IT. But they are primarily found in other areas. Energy consumption is mostly a function of "how much you compute with data", not "how much data you have".

In other words: be concerned about so-called "AI", be concerned about Bitcoin. Don't worry about unused data too much.

hannob··on Atop 2.11 heap problems
> HN post detailing how we got it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43519522

I don't see any details there. Is there some link missing here, or is it the wrong link?

I'd be interested to read how your tool found it.

hannob··on Entropy Attacks
> The advantage of a quantum-based entropy sources are that they are often much > faster than other hardware based entropy source.

What kind of problem is solved by a fast, hardware-based entropy source? You only need a couple of bytes of entropy to initialize your RNG.

hannob··on Entropy Attacks
No, a Quantum RNG does not solve the issue that people use an API for insecure random numbers when they should use one for secure random numbers.

Every OS already has a secure RNG API. That's a solved problem.

hannob··on Entropy Attacks
Technically correct, but the RNGs you're mentioning are essentially RNGs build on public key cryptography. And I don't think they're widely used, simply because they're slow and have no advantage over faster ones (the Dual EC stuff was, as far as I know, the only thing that was somewhat widely used, and, very obviously, nobody should be using that).
hannob··on Entropy Attacks
His point was that he was working on a product that solves no actual problem.

Quantum RNGs are gimmicks that are sold as a solution to a security problem. But they don't solve any security problem. There are real security problems with RNGs, but none of them is solved by a Quantum RNG. They usually come down to implementation errors or not using a secure RNG.

hannob··on Entropy Attacks
> Forgive my ignorance on this but does his assertion that a CSPRNG is all you need after an initial truly random seed, hold up against theoretical quantum attacks?

Yes, if you mean by "theoretical quantum attacks" the stuff we could run if we had a scalable quantum computer. Those impact public key crypto. They do nothing to impact the security of RNGs.

hannob··on LibreOffice downloads on the rise as users look to avoid subscription costs
I don't want to start any wars either, but I think people should make informed choices.

By choosing OpenOffice, you should be aware that you are at an increased risk for attacks. One of the consistent problems with OpenOffice over the past years has been that they have often not published security fixes for many months, sometimes critical ones, for vulnerabilities that were publicly known.

(Due to the shared codebase, obviously, many security issues affect both LO/OO, yet, with the difference that LO usually fixes them in a timely manner.)

hannob··on Spammers are better at SPF, DKIM, and DMARC than everyone else
This is missing the point.

To be clear, I'm not necessarily a fan of DMARC, particularly how it was introduced. But it is very obvious that spammers will eventually do everything to not be flagged as spammers.

What DMARC gives you is that it makes it less likely that your phishing mail will come from contact@yourbank.com. It will rather come from contact@y0urbank.com or some other domain.

How much of an improvement that is and how many people will notice is certainly debatable. But that's what DMARC can give you. Nothing more, nothing less.

hannob··on Deregulated energy markets accelerate solar adoption
They would have released less CO2 if they had regulated CO2 emissions.
hannob··on Deregulated energy markets accelerate solar adoption
As a counterpoint, I recommend this article: https://ketanjoshi.co/2024/08/12/texas-builds-clean-power-bu...

It looks into the numbers for the Texas renewable buildout, and there's a very important caveat: the amount of renewables you build is not the relevant metric. Emission reduction is. And Texas does not succeed there.

hannob··on The SeL4 Microkernel: An Introduction [pdf]
Ok, admittedly, that's more than I expected. And hey, if they found some use cases in the embedded world, fine.

Nevertheless, it's not exactly how it was pitched. This Microkernel thing always had a "Linux is doing it wrong, we're doing it better" story behind it. They wanted to be a replacement for a general-purpose OS. That cetainly hasn't happened.

hannob··on The SeL4 Microkernel: An Introduction [pdf]
L4 was popular at my university (Karlsruhe). While I never really looked into it in any detail, it always appeared to me like a project that is primarily interested in testing some theoretical ideas, but not in building anything that would be practically useful.

That was 20 years ago. As far as I can tell, this has not changed. (Quick googling tells me there appear to be some efforts to build an OS on it, but they all look more like proof of concepts, not like something with real-world use.)

hannob··on Quantum Speedup Found for Class of Hard Problems
I think it's clear that factoring works if you can build a scalable quantum computer. But:

1. It's a very lonely example.

2. It's not clear how big the market is for "you can break encryption from the past, but not current encryption, because once QCs arrive, everyone will obviously move away from QC-breakable encryption". And I'm not aware of any other reasons why factoring large numbers would be useful beyond breaking encryptions.

hannob··on Why do transit agencies keep falling for the hydrogen bus myth?
Within one technology, that'd be true. But not if you have the option to choose another technology that produces a lot less waste heat.
hannob··on The 2008 coal ash disaster in Kingston, Tennessee
Oh, I remember that one.

At the time, the construction of new coal-fired power plants was a controversial topic in many locations in Germany. (Around 30 new coal power plants were planned at times. Some were stopped, but 10 of them were actually build, which is bad enough.) I also tried to raise awareness about this incident in Tennessee, trying to have a look at the environmental issues of coal on a more international level. But it didn't generate much interest.

hannob··on Recursion kills: The story behind CVE-2024-8176 in libexpat
Here's the relevant pull request: https://github.com/libexpat/libexpat/pull/973
hannob··on First ammonia-fueled ship hits a snag
> What am I missing here?

Climate change. Maybe you've heard of it?

(And it turns out things with LNG ships are much worse than previously believed. They not only emit CO2 - a bit less than traditional bunker fuel, but not much - they also emit methane, and in no small quantities. The LNG industry likes to pretend that these emissions are small and neglegible, but whenever someone goes out and actually measures them, they are substantial.)

hannob··on Tether and Circle are battling to win the US stablecoin market
I couldn't care less about Bitcoin's use of SHA-256, but based on experience:

First of all, it's quite unlikely that this is going to happen at all. There are no signs of significant weaknesses in SHA-256.

But if it's going to happen, in all likelyhood, you'll get preliminary results long before any actual breakage. (For both MD5 and SHA1, you had around a decade of warnings between "this looks insecure / broken in theory" and "we now have an actual collission".) Anyone paying attention and moving away from algorithms already known to be broken was unaffected by the MD5/SHA1 weaknesses.

Of course, there will be those who will wait until an actual breakage, and a few years more, before they act. (As we've seen particularly with MD5.)

hannob··on Harvest the sun twice: Agrivoltaics promises sustainable food, energy and water
Agriphotovoltaics is largely a solution for a non-existing problem.

It is always brought forward as an argument when the perceived landuse issue of solar is brought forward. But if you do any serious analysis, the landuse impact of even utility scale solar is so neglegible that it's not an issue to worry about.

If you want to talk about landuse impacts of renewable energy, there's really only one issue to focus on: bioenergy crops. It can be as bad as 30 times less space efficient than generating the same energy with solar photovoltaics.

Talk about using the same space to make food and bioenergy. Use agricultural land for food, and utilize the residuals as good as possible. Stop making biofuels out of food. And treat the space needed for utility-scale solar as what it is: tiny.

(P.S.: If people can make agriphotovoltaics work, I have no issue with that. Great. Even tiny impacts should be reduced if possible. But I have an issue with the way this is discussed, because it makes up a problem with photovoltaics that largely doesn't exist.)

hannob··on A whirlwind tutorial on creating teensy ELF executables for Linux (1999)
Didn't know about that, will have to take a look.

I think I am the "inventor" of the first 64 and 32 byte intro competitions. (Just checked, we ran a 64 byte competition at the 0a000h 2002 and added 32 byte in 2003.) See https://0a000h.de/2002/ and https://0a000h.de/2003/ - releases are on scene.org

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →