4,440 karma · joined November 4, 2019
And to the larger question, which I hear all the time, what does “starting from scratch” even mean when it comes to ongoing health care?
You can’t seriously argue that we should risk medication interruptions so your friend loses her dad to his heart condition so we can somehow “start over?”
We need a smooth transition to a more sustainable system with incentives aligned to customers and not investors in one scenario, single payer in another, or some other working idea to continue to provide care while reducing the insane profits and aligning health and well being of patients, as well as the health and well being of the people providing it, with the actual service delivery again.
Burning everything down could kill a lot of people. I think this position is actually not particularly compassionate.
Jobs would have had a wallop of a joke for this one.
What the author is ultimately complaining about is something they touched upon, which is that the creative market is saturated and in order to survive you need to have another job.
You can call it “diversification of revenue sources,” but what it actually is is getting a job as a waiter or a waitress while you audition for your Hollywood dreams.
And it happens when there are too many people wanting to sing and dance and be in movies and not enough people ready to pay them to do that.
So there’s an oversupply of creative talent, which is about to get even more squeezed as artificial intelligence pushes in on human capital.
There are, at the end of the day, only so many eyeballs, and not everyone can be the radio star.
Whenever there is a financialization of creative markets, there are artists screaming about the legitimacy of the art, and the connection with the receiver of that art, is being tainted by the commercialization.
But it doesn’t matter. The commercialization is inevitable because artist need to eat, and unless they have patrons, they have customers, and that’s just how the thing has worked throughout history.
Really at core it’s just another industry being eaten by software.
This is a trend that has been going on for a very long time, as tokenization and monetization and incremental digital transformation comes in and gradually disassembles ways of human existence into component parts and creates a business model around them. Let’s remember that painters screamed about photography being sacrilege and not even qualifying as an art form as the process involved no expression but mere capture. I met a few in my younger years who regaled me with my camera about the wrong I was committing.
It’s been the thing that’s been going on here for 30 years (and I’ve been lucky to watch the juice being squeezed). But from a digital perspective this is the way that it works in the modern economy. There’s a gold rush, then a reckoning, and from ashes emerge winners and losers, eventually leading to another stabilized period. That stability then transforms by new technology (the next breakthrough) and another rapid change of social behavior and income opportunity happens. It just goes on and on as digital technology progresses.
> The content should be meaningful, insightful, written, recorded or filmed for your audience. The people who give a shit. The people who care.
That’s the price of digital. It exacts emotional taxes to make change and people find it difficult and objectionable to watch their values erode as it gets eaten by disruption. But can anyone really get off the bus? Maybe if there’s a large scale EMP attack, the internet is shut down from a massive cybersecurity event, or solar flare, but I see almost no other way to stop the disruption otherwise as the snake that eats it tail pays the bills.
Goodness. Instead of building a digital twin to be of service and partnership with society, it seems abundantly clear that Google seems more aimed at reshaping society to their specifications and with no input or oversight from the public that receives them.
This would be a “wrong use” of this technology.
We do not want to create subservient “receiving classes” of people and controlling information people who run the thinking machines and decide how society should be.
I think Google is getting kickback because their AI is presciently invoking the plot of Gattaca.
Google feels like they are getting caught running an agenda with the technology, not having a technical problem.
Now obviously everyone on here is going to be commenting about how hard it is to get these systems right, but this version was shipped after it was reviewed internally. How can these kinds of issues go unnoticed by an entire testing staff of some of the smartest people on the planet prior to their most important product release? Does that make sense? Is there something I’m missing with that?
For larger providers, bandwidth cost drops tremendously, especially if you’re well connected as transit is much cheaper and if you are really large or a network provider you may even be routing between your own facilities or in some cases from one customer to another and every large scale isp is going to want a “direct link” to your facility (a peering relationship). Those costs are astronomically small at scale for bandwidth.
The ISP or similar then turns around and sells a sustained network throughout as GB transferred, which isn’t how wholesale bandwidth is sold at all. So the get to charge for the data the pipe moves while they only pay for the connection itself — the markup added to this process is considerable.
For someone operated a global CDN, which is basically what they do, they have racks of storage and computer collocated all over the world and optimize the living crap out of their network to reduce their costs and make it run on as many peering relationships as possible. It’s an expensive and complex business to set up, but once it’s set up you get a fairly good and consistent return out of it.
The reason for this article is related to the nature of that business: it’s the issue of liability.
When you have policies where you protect your clients from downsides and excessive use on the network, you suddenly have to assume the role of paying attention to what’s on the network and policing it’s contents. That’s not possible with a massive system like this generally, so they push the liability down to the customer and discount the mistakes that come up. That’s why things are set up like this… this kind of stuff isn’t their business at all really. They are looking for the customers that convert and pay, which is very profitable, and the free tier is often thought of as a sustainable cost if you are large enough scale, as it substitutes for the rather massive expense of marketing and sales which is one of the largest expenses in a bandwidth focused business. CAC is the free tier.
There also competitors, but the benefits of scale are tremendous in terms of cost efficiency. A large provider might be paying just a very small fraction of a penny or less (even “free”) compared to what a small provider is paying. So that’s why you end up with fewer competitors because it truly is a business that benefits from economies of scale.
There are other smarter people on here who can correct any mistakes I’ve made or provide better pricing or whatever, but that’s the more in depth answer.
It’s a reminder of what can be done when billionaires give back and pass it through to society instead of passing it along to their heirs.
This kindness is going to change the world and provide doctors that will treat and help hundreds of thousands.
Laundry, cooking, dishes, sweeping, vacuuming, and other constantly recurring tasks are what I would love to see automated not just a “robot that sweeps” like the market has been trying to sell me.
Ever since I read the second shift book about the unpaid extra 40 hour week women work doing domestic tasks I’ve dreamed of robots replacing that for humanity. It’s a massive cost to people individually and humanity overall, and kind of a silent epidemic.
It’s crazy but freeing up half of humanity from the drudge work of daily chores is one of the most obvious disruptive technology plays. I rarely hear people put the robot revolution in this context, but I very much think we should start doing so.
Here’s a good overview for the uninitiated:
https://www.americanprogress.org/article/unequal-division-la...
I really am stoked to see more and more space companies setting new milestones. It’s going to be a bright future for humanity if we can continue to expand space exploration and eventually become multiplanetary. It’s awesome to be alive to witness it.
This is a day to celebrate. This is a momentous achievement and I can’t wait to see private space scale to its potential — which is ginormous.
Edit: Why would this get downvoted? Do people really find value in shorts?
Be well and thank you.
Let me double down…
https://ideas.lego.com/projects/40434532-eaa1-4926-8621-3629...
We can find any metaphor we want, cite one or two example companies like GE (and it was bad company management not the fact that they were in finance that sank them IMO — I was a customer of theirs and they were so poorly run), but it won’t make up for more than a century of the practice working across most major industries without problems. I’ve read several books about the GE failure and am widely aware of the problems, but disagree with the mainstream analysis. Nobody wants to pin it on the management but they deserve the criticism. Read * Lights Out: Pride, Delusion, and the Fall of General Electric* if you haven’t — it’s worth the time.
Don’t you agree that narrowing down the argument that financing your own product is bad because GE took themselves out with a finance division becoming too critical to their business and then blowing up their business with poor management choices to be overly specific as an example?
Broadly, private financing works, and works well.
My first thought was that you could stay on Postgres and save that $100 by using the secret power of Open Source.
Well said.
Tons of companies offer financing for products they manufacture just like car companies have done so since the 1920s — more than *100 years! — and in many cases longer than that. It’s not new. It’s not unusual. What’s different about this? The subject matter? The cloud-as-a-service component? How is it really different from support contracts? It’s really not.
Sitting around trying to make it sound like a manufacturer offering financing is some deep conspiracy is crazy talk, no matter how many times I get downvoted for saying it.
(Downvoting on hacker news is supposed to be used for deemphasizing poor comments not downvoting people you don’t agree with btw. This isn’t Reddit. The idea is to encourage high quality discussions not win popularity contests and we should endeavor to keep this community differentiated.)
I would love to see a coherent argument as to what’s so massively unique about providers financing their own equipment to their channels. I just don’t see it as being anything different from standard. Neither is investing in the most promising companies in your ecosystem unusual for Norge companies. These aren’t unusual things: they are well trodden paths used by many kinds of companies.
Sam’s massive fab for AI chips alone is huge news. Japan is pouring it on.
I know people comment about the growth and bust cycle in chips, but it does create profound societal transformation in the process and I’m really starting to wonder just how profound the change that’s coming is going to be — if history guides us it looks pretty big.
The challenge all these AI vendors are trying to solve and why national priorities are turning towards supplementing this industry is to try to capture market share to solve critical shortage of computing power specifically (in microchips or GPUs) that are necessary to advance AI technologies.
And like I mentioned Nvidia has been the hot AI chip with the H100 (and it’s lead to a rather high market valuation — a trillion dollars). But their success is getting noticed and we are seeing Microsoft, Meta, OpenAI, Amazon, and Google all throw in to create their own AI processors. And that’s why you see this massive spending by nation states, because they don’t want to be left behind in this conversion and what is presumed to be ground floor opportunity for the “next big wave” of technology.
Different companies are doing different things but almost all of them are going all in on in-house design and many on FAB itself:
Microsoft is in-housing the Maia 100 for cloud.
Google is doing the TPUs and a bunch of other stuff not public yet.
Amazon won’t be left out with the hilariously named Trainium for machine learning and a bunch of chips under development for AWS.
META is doing the MTIA and Artemis in house.
SoftBank has realized that real estate isn’t it and now has their Izanagi project.
Huawei has their 910B.
Nvidia is all-in on GPUs like the H100 (and developing the H200) and making huge piles of money helping other create custom AI chips.
And of course I already mentioned it by Sam Altman is seeking trillions for some unnamed chipset.
What other major efforts do people know about? Seems like a massive shift and if this is as big as it looks, like I said, this is going to change society incredibly.
There I fixed it.
The question should also be, “how much of the general Internet is similarly faked?” How could anyone ever tell if it wasn’t badly done?
I am asking if anyone is becoming aware of the machine that seems to be shaping public opinion and how difficult it is to even talk about the idea of an opinion shaping machine?
Seems like we should be able to have a civil converation on HN in 2024 about media shaping public opinion and whether it seems like there is a pattern to negative news stories around public figures that are out of fashion without it becoming a “conspiracy conversation” at this point.
I mean all of media seems increasingly coordinated to the halls of power, investigative journalism is almost dead, and billionaires or the large companies they control own almost all media at this point. Does asking whether there appears to be a coordinated system trying to shape public opinion across social media now automatically generate “conspiracy” tags? That seems naive at this point.
I’m concerned because what I’m seeing in my life from people I know personally VS what I see online have diverged greatly. The conversations I have with people who work in technology and are “plugged in” are very similar and seem propelled by the same talking points and opinions, especially when I interact with people who aren’t technologists or more Internet connected. It’s really interesting how profoundly “shaped” a lot of people are in why they think.
But what’s even more interesting is how profoundly hostile people become whenever you ask whether their opinions are being shaped or whether they are seeing that the system is feeding a steady diet of “what to think about who” that seems to be working really profoundly well on public opinions.
It kind of concerns me because the population seems kind of unaware and unprepared for the Internet to become largely machine generated which is inevitable at this point. People aren’t questioning things at all. That’s kinda concerning to me.
But how would we ever be able to tell if there was a deliberate campaign or not? The man has himself tried to assemble a social media network and his own information machine. Shouldn’t that imply that he is trying to counter another existing system? How would we ever know besides questioning the narrative like I’m trying to do whether we were in a narrative generation system?
I’m aware of the post hoc, ergo propter hoc nature of the question, but as we enter the AI era I see precious little discussion of this stuff and its effects and it’s notable to me that just raising question greets massive downvoted and negative attention on social media platforms.