HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hardwaresofton

12,857 karma · joined January 16, 2013

writing at vadosware.io
submissionscomments
hardwaresofton··on Microsoft to Cut 9k Workers in Second Wave of Major Layoffs
> Union may save job for few who have job but people who don't (and they are lot more and increasing) are not gonna get helped by any union.

Note that in some countries, unions extend to cover workers who are not even part of the union. Heard about this from some french friends:

> Collective bargaining agreements (conventions collectives) may be negotiated between employers and labour unions covering a company or group of companies (accords d’entreprise), or between employers’ associations and labour unions covering an industry as a whole; in the latter case, the government may decide that the collective agreement covers even those employers who are not members of the employers’ association and is therefore mandatory throughout the industry.

https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en/knowledge/publication...

Not saying it's the right solution for $COUNTRY, but I was certainly surprised when I heard of this

hardwaresofton··on Sam Altman Slams Meta’s AI Talent Poaching: 'Missionaries Will Beat Mercenaries'
I read through and I think that the analysis suffers from the fact that in the case when the modifier is the user it's fine.

Free software refers to user freedoms, not developer freedoms.

I don't think the below is right:

> > Notwithstanding any other provision of this License, if you modify the Program, your modified version must prominently offer all users interacting with it remotely through a computer network (if your version supports such interaction) an opportunity to receive the Corresponding Source of your version by providing access to the Corresponding Source from a network server at no charge, through some standard or customary means of facilitating copying of software.

>

> Let's break it down:

>

> > If you modify the Program

>

> That is if you are a developer making changes to the source code (or binary, but let's ignore that option)

>

> > your modified version

>

> The modified source code you have created

>

> > must prominently offer all users interacting with it remotely through a computer network

>

> Must include the mandatory feature of offering all users interacting with it through a computer network (computer network is left undefined and subject to wide interpretation)

I read the AGPL to mean if you modify the program then the users of the program (remotely, through a computer network) must be able to access the source code.

It has yet to be tested, but that seems like the common sense reading for me (which matters, because judges do apply judgement). It just seems like they are trying too hard to do a legal gotcha. I'm not a lawyer so I can't speak to that, but I certainly don't read it the same way.

I don't agree with this interpretation of every-change-is-a-violation either:

> Step 1: Clone the GitHub repo

>

> Step 2: Make a change to the code - oops, license violation! Clause 13! I need to change the source code offer first!

>

> Step 1.5: Change the source code offer to point to your repo

This example seems incorrect -- modifying the code does not automatically make people interact with the program over a network...

"free software" was defined by the GNU/FSF... so I generally default to their definitions. I don't think the license falls afoul of their stated definitions.

That said, they're certainly anti-capitalist zealots, that's kind of their thing. I don't agree with that, but that's besides the point.

hardwaresofton··on Sam Altman Slams Meta’s AI Talent Poaching: 'Missionaries Will Beat Mercenaries'
Yeah if it's a problem of definition, then I definitely agree that it could not match there, it certainly isn't a do anything you want license.
hardwaresofton··on Sam Altman Slams Meta’s AI Talent Poaching: 'Missionaries Will Beat Mercenaries'
This is a strong claim, given it is listed as a free, copyleft license:

https://www.gnu.org/licenses/agpl-3.0.en.html

Could you expand on why you think it's nonfree? Also, it's not that hard to comply with either...

hardwaresofton··on Sam Altman Slams Meta’s AI Talent Poaching: 'Missionaries Will Beat Mercenaries'
It wouldn't -- AGPL code that is picked up would also just get "fair used" into new software.

That said, AGPL as a trend was a huge closing of the spigot of free F/OSS code for companies to use and not contribute back to.

hardwaresofton··on Sam Altman Slams Meta’s AI Talent Poaching: 'Missionaries Will Beat Mercenaries'
This was immediately my reaction as well, but I'm not a judge so what do I know. In my own mind I mark it as a "spice must flow" moment -- it will seem inevitable in retrospect but my simple (almost surely incorrect) take is that there just wasn't a way this was going to stop AI's progress. AI as a trend has incredible plot armor at this point in time.

Is the hinge that the tools can recall a huge portion (not perfectly of course) but usually don't? What seems even more straight forward is the substitute good idea, it seems reasonable to assume people will buy less copies of book X when they start generating books heavily inspired by book X.

But, this is probably just a case of a layman wandering into a complex topic, maybe it's the case that AI has just nestled into the absolute perfect spot in current copyright law, just like other things that seem like they should be illegal now but aren't.

hardwaresofton··on Sam Altman Slams Meta’s AI Talent Poaching: 'Missionaries Will Beat Mercenaries'
Another funny possibly sad coincidence is that the licenses that made open source what it is will probably be absolutely useless going forward, because as recent precedent has shown, companies can train on what they have legally gained access to.

On the other hand, AGPL continues to be the future of F/OSS.

hardwaresofton··on Lossless LLM 3x Throughput Increase by LMCache
> Then I start replying to you...but then I throw away the comment, because I'm inviting drive-by downvotes. I.e. the minefield describe up top, and if you look like you're being mean, you'll eat downvotes, especially on a weekend.

Don't self-censor for this reason -- "downvotes aren't real" in that they don't actually matter. Being afraid of getting downvoted is a silly way to live, and I also fall into the trap but try to avoid it.

If you're worries as coming off as mean, probably worth rephrasing!

hardwaresofton··on bootc-image-builder: Build your entire OS from a Containerfile
yeah you're probably right -- going forward the usage is likely going to be a lot higher, at the very least.

I thought of the underlying tech for those other distros being ostree more than anything but this is the better interpretation.

hardwaresofton··on bootc-image-builder: Build your entire OS from a Containerfile
I wonder which gets more actual usage, this project or linuxkit.

Does anyone have experience worth sharing with both?

hardwaresofton··on CareerBuilder and Monster job boards, file for bankruptcy
Don't forget Indeed -- they seem to be absolutely crushing it and have been for... over a decade? Even though they've been purchased, I think their operating team is mostly still the same.
hardwaresofton··on Asterinas: A new Linux-compatible kernel project
> This IPC often has a performance impact, which is a big part of why microkernels have remained relatively unpopular.

Somewhat comforting to see deeply technical people still misconstruing why approaches/projects don't get adopted.

hardwaresofton··on Show HN: Canine – A Heroku alternative built on Kubernetes
Congrats on the launch Chris! Product has come a long way
hardwaresofton··on Show HN: Canine – A Heroku alternative built on Kubernetes
Hey, if you’re going to offer constructive feedback to a competitor, maybe don’t lead with a plug.
hardwaresofton··on Google Cloud Incident Report – 2025-06-13
Has there been any confirmation it was golang?
hardwaresofton··on UK unis to cough up to £10M on Java to keep Oracle off their backs
Thank you! This is a great example -- interesting that a SAN would be a cause for this kind of requirement, but I can understand that.
hardwaresofton··on UK unis to cough up to £10M on Java to keep Oracle off their backs
Thanks for the explanation -- back when I wrote Java, it was a choice between "Oracle Java" (i.e. Oracle JDK) and the OpenJDK -- where you downloaded was different and what you agreed to download was different.

> If you use Oracle OpenJDK in production to the best of my knowledge you are probably still on the hook for the licensing fees.

I'd be surprised by this but I guess that is par for the course.

> At my company we use RedHat OpenJDK on RedHat VMs and Eclipse Temurin OpenJDK in docker containers.

Thanks for clarifying -- do you find any differences that were important? Or is it more you've never needed the Oracle distribution so you never had reason to find out?

I'm just wondering why anyone would choose Oracle's distribution in this day and age. Who are their main customers that are happy to be customers?

hardwaresofton··on UK unis to cough up to £10M on Java to keep Oracle off their backs
Can anyone who still uses Java opine a bit on where it's better to use Oracle versus OpenJDK?
hardwaresofton··on Seedance 1.0
> The difference is that the jury is still out if these things are truly generating something novel. Or are we just making it pick from the spaces in between an average of all the images on the internet.

Novel in what sense? Most creative endeavor is not completely novel -- it's usually a combination of pre-existing styles, taste, patterns, and other inputs.

> The latter would mean everything quickly looks and feels the same.

I think human preferences will be a good guard rail against this. The reward will be greatly reduced for creating mostly the same things, just like real artists in real life.

> I also believe some barrier to entry is needed for good art, people are inherently lazy and AI lets us get away with "just good enough" - see llm assisted coding as an example

That's a pretty deep philosophical question -- "good art" is also a hell of a rabbit hole to go down!

Guess we'll find out :)

hardwaresofton··on Seedance 1.0
Like the hot take but it is needlessly negative because it doesn’t go far enough.

You could make the same argument about musical instruments, or being able to record and playback music, dj tools, etc.

I think what you get is the power law distribution for tons of content. Some of the stuff is still mega valuable, but distribution just gets more and more important and it’s harder and harder to break through. This is what the “democratization” of any previously difficulty-gated endeavor does.

More niches will be created, more fragmentation in tastes, stuff like that. Not just completely valueless content.

Incumbents and platform providers get to win through it all though, because humans still want to fill their time.

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
If only, but we know that the vast majority of people don't want to self-host, as the majority of people don't even want to make their own coffee.

In the right form (on devices they already own, with internet connections they already own, etc) self-hosting could work though...

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
I think we may be discussing different things. When I talk about the DMCA machine, I mean the cottage industry of firms that make it their job to check the internet for infringement and file the appropriate claims. I'm not referring to Google's AI.

My point was that those firms currently cater to large creators/the cost only makes sense for firms with lots of IP. BUT, if it was cheaper/more accessible (and profitable to litigate in this area) then more small creators can do it, and the problem becomes more acute for large content hosters.

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
> i meant anonymous as in "a user can receive a link to a video and watch it without having to log in" as well as "there's a list of content on the homepage to watch" - the same way youtube works if you go via private browsing.

Oh yeah this is my fault, I understood your meaning but wanted to make a separate point about the average user and their very specific.

IMO the vast majority of open source projects will use that word because it is a legitimate benefit, but it's anathema to the average consumer. It just signals "this is for criminals", even if it shouldn't.

Agree it's clearly a valuable feature -- it's hard to even demonstrate the value these days. "no algorithms" or "no tracking" might work, but it's so hard to verbalize.

With regards to the F/OSS solutions like peertube and the difficulty of marketing all this stuff (filecoin with/without crypto)... There just aren't the right incentives or the right insane person hasn't come along yet.

> That's not out of reach for the likes of someone like Louis Rossman, who really ought be moving off youtube

Maybe this is a bit weird but IMO Louis has been incredibly effective in his fight for right to repair, and I would hate to sacrifice his reach for a more user-friendly platform. I agree with the idea of at least simulcasting. Maybe it's another difficulty problem.

I haven't kept up with the stuff he's doing with FUTO these days as closely, but you have to fight on the battleground you're given. Winning and moral purity are often at odds, and IMO this isn't a place where moral purity is paramount.

IMO one of the hidden lynchpins here is the default license that youtube broadcasts with. I think there's a really clear legal path to downloading a LOT of youtube if only more things were CC licensed on there (not the default YouTube license) and accessible without logging in (similar to the LinkedIn scraping case).

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
Ah, but IMO not for smaller creators -- and at some point, if the DMCA claims are legitimate and not being heeded in a timely manner, more litigation aimed at YouTube should be started.

This likely has bad effects for the internet as a whole (more efficient legal action can make those who abuse the system more powerful), but if it's something that needs to happen, then it should happen.

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
That's fine IMO! Content creation is a really top heavy thing anyway -- it seems like anyone can just be replaced with anyone else, but if that were true we wouldn't have such outsized discrepancies between successful creators who are able to monetize and those that can't.

It's a power law distribution. In fact, companies know this so they do sneaky stuff to keep high value creators on their platforms, have heard some stories (try to find some stuff on the Twitch vs Mixer saga).

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
> this isn't to argue! just some clarification because i really don't copyedit/proofread well enough on HN.

No worries! Arguments are great if I can learn something.

> Peertube is this, if you want anonymous viewing of videos. I'm not sure about ease of setting up, i don't remember having any issues, which means i can package it for others, but IIRC turnkey linux has peertube as a container, which means any hosting provider that offers TKL it's essentially 4 clicks to launch a peertube server. Fediverse is a little rougher, but i imagine a content creator would be the one that would self-host (or have their own homeserver, but host it with a hosting provider for $50 a month or whatever), and everyone else can go to https://fediverse.party/ or whatever and find a homeserver. You don't need to run your own to participate. I was careful to suggest that more people should run their own instances, because i worry that the larger instances will get tired of adding 16TB drive sleds every year. I can't imagine what mastodon.social costs to run! this also ties in with your final point; the acquaintance is part of the value4value movement, so they may get donations to offset costs, but i think they have a server room on their property with a couple of racks. maybe they have solar and a sweetheart deal with their ISP - i did at one point, so i also had a server shed. still do, but i used to, too.

OK so my thing is that all of this is just too hard. Give me ONE program to run that does everything. I don't think that's impossible either (and no one). If the average user has to hear the word "container" or "linux", it's over. If they have to pay, it's over (probably, unless it's a TINY amount that basically just deters bots or something).

Also, most good widely-adopted consumer products NEVER mention anonymity. Maybe security or privacy, but never anonymity.

Always love me a little mitch in the comments :) HN hasn't lost it.

I guess what we really want here is PopcornTime for PeerTube. Maybe PeerTube is already this and I just don't know about it... the tech would be hard to make work seamlessly but a way to just get the ease of PopcornTime and the interface/product mindedness of YouTube.

> oh that technology that made buying a used HDD/SSD risky business for a few years? Now, afaik filecoin didn't serve any useful purpose, it was just another "proof of X" where X was "i'm wasting a ton of storage space for this". ipfs et al are the ones that do distributed storage.

But IMO this is a human problem -- it did what it was supposed to do, it made storage valuable. The problem is that when things get valuable, bad actors do things to try and steal that value. That's like thinking computers are bad because people try to steal them once they realize how valuable they are now that people can make money on the internet.

I'm not really the right person to defend Filecoin (there were also a few others, I wonder if I'm referring to the right one), but the idea of distributed payment-for-spare-disk-storage (does this fit the value4value movement?) makes a ton of sense to me.

IPFS is a technical solution IMO, it stops short of solving the other bits - i.e. motivating the actual money-for-storage exchange that makes the idea sustainable.

> One thing i would add - unless you absolutely need to, and i mean really need to, never upload high-def to these sort of services. Upload your FHD/QHD/8K videos to the large hosts "for backup", mark them as unlisted, and then link to them for people to archive if they wish.

TIL, thanks!

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
> The big problem is that someone will download your video and upload it to YouTube if you do not. Often while monetizing it until you stomp on them.

Let's automate the stomping then. If people are bothered by this and it keeps happening, then that should create demand for someone who is able to scour YouTube and sue the appropriate parties/do the appropriate reporting.

At some point, it will become enough of a problem for YouTube that they will change/have to hurt their business model that currently benefits from it.

> The only things that will break YouTube hegemony (spelled that hegemoney originally ... talk about a typo) are either an anti-trust action or a successful copyright infringement lawsuit from someone other than a BigCorp.

Really disappointed in lawyers of this age. I'm a layperson but it looks like they should have been eating out in the age of AI and with all the copyright infringement that goes on (whether you agree with copyright infringement or not). Why are there not 100 suits against these AI companies right now? Probably because it's too expensive and courts are already packed, but why let reality get in the way of a possibly really profitable venture?

I'm certainly not a great proponent of IP/copyright and all the associated moral stances, but IMO the tech is useful without that gray area -- having that stuff get properly legislated is only going to prompt retraining on safe/permissioned content, and maybe that's what SHOULD happen.

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
> There's peertube and Pixelfed and someone was working on an activitypub version of Instagram, but really it's like Pixelfed but more ergonomic for video.

> it's like Pixelfed but more ergonomic for video.

This is a huge problem IMO. Just like Mastodon/Bluesky (which seems to be working recently) and all these other things, the tech and experience need to be SUPER easy. I mean as-easy-or-easier than YouTube, etc for people to switch en masse.

> So the next stage, ideally, would be everyone kinda sharing hosting responsibilities, and if you like a creator, you just follow them. This has the benefit of possibly caching/mirroring all the videos, too. My Fediverse server was chewing through disk, one of the reasons I shut it down - but I was following 1400 news and journalist accounts, plus my ~100 or so gang of idiots. I was nearing 1TB on disk after about 16 months on my essentially single user instance.

Yeah the problem is people won't do this/can't be expected to do this, unless it's drop dead easy.

Really appreciate hearing about your point on the scaling curve for this tech though, clearly the tech has come really far, that sounds like much more than the average person and "only" 1TB and a single server is quite nice.

The best ever approach I have seen to this is PopcornTime. It took the world by storm (and IIRC people still use it/ it still exists in some form, they're just lower profile now), and it worked better the more people used it, because torrents (aka, the technology being a mature, perfect match for the usecase).

> I exported my follows and moved to an acquaintance's server and imported, the owner doesn't even blink. Who knows what they've got going for storage. > > Anyhow if you don't need to follow 1500 people, this becomes tractable. If it gets popular, someone will post how to cron the multimedia stuff to compress it as it ages, moving it to cold storage, whatever.

I could see this working if that acquaintance got paid for this. Tying money as an incentive to things is sometimes bad/not what you want, but having people think of computers and compute as an asset/tool for them to use is a step in the right direction IMO.

I'm not a crypto person (kind of wish I was, 10 years ago), but Filecoin was really interesting originally to me because it just made sense. The marketplace of data storage seems like something that could be easily democratized in this way (no need for the crypto bits, but the ease of payment was a legitimate use IMO).

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
> Based on my observations over the past decade of similar stories on HN, nothing will change, the squeeze will simply continue.

I do agree here, but sometimes (let's say 10% of the time? less?) the squeeze does not continue -- see Apple. Perplexity/ChatGPT vs Google search right now.

> The rest of us, the unwashed users of the platform, do not hear about it or act upon it en masse. We'll occasionally see a post like this on HN or Reddit, shake our heads and call it a shame, there need to be alternatives and so on, then go right back into those platforms and forget that something happened but a few months later

Yup, wish I could add "- posted from Chrome browser" to my own response here but I use Firefox. I'm still going to watch YouTube.

I think the thing that might bring hope is that Google/YouTube doesn't actualy own the new paradigm of AI -- I can very much imagine a world where people just ask for videos/scroll through them, and YouTube isn't the site they do it on (in fact they don't do it on a "site", per say).

But then again, that's really calling for the death/dramatic reduction of the open/surfable internet. Is that what it takes?

hardwaresofton··on Self-hosting your own media considered harmful according to YouTube
If LLMs are already doing this, engineers are cooked.

I don't think this is a job that requires an LLM but if an LLM took the order, made the plan to go through the relevant data(bases|lakes|platforms) and triggered the warnings, etc. I'd be very impressed.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →