HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

harpiaharpyja

867 karma · joined September 13, 2016

Mechatronics Engineer
submissionscomments
harpiaharpyja··on I Hate Anthropic and You Should Too
The article was essentially, "you should hate Anthropic" followed by a poorly explained timeline and some insubstantial arguments.

If there was a point there the article did not make it easy to find.

harpiaharpyja··on Centuries of selective breeding turned wild cabbage into different vegetables
I knew it couldn't be coincidence that a green cabbage looks exactly like a giant brussel sprout.
harpiaharpyja··on Grief and the AI split
Thank you for articulating that.
harpiaharpyja··on My “grand vision” for Rust
I mean, you're asking for a fundamentally different directing for the language with different tradeoffs? Why are you commenting on an article about Rust? Not everyone wants the same tradeoffs that you do.
harpiaharpyja··on My “grand vision” for Rust
Look, included in the concepts the article discusses are features that people have been wanting for a very long time.

Like, the ability to have multiple mut references to a struct as long as you access disjoint fields? That's amazing!!! A redo of Pin that actually composes with the rest of the language? That's pretty awesome too.

I think you're getting tied up because the the author is describing these features in a very formal way. But someone has to think about these things, especially if they are going to implement them.

Ultimately, these are features that will make Rust's safety features (which really, are Rust's reason for existing) more ergonomic and easier to use. That's the opposite of what you fear.

harpiaharpyja··on How did Joann Fabrics die while Best Buy survived? It wasn't Amazon
TFA makes a strong argument that that isn't the case.

I would say it's even the thesis of the article. Joann Fabrics was a healthy company with customer demand and zero debt and was basically assassinated by a leveraged buyout.

harpiaharpyja··on What it means that Ubuntu is using Rust
The author refers to a few things that he thinks will appeal to the "early majority," but I feel like that's a weakness of the article. Is the author part of the "early majority?" (doesn't seem like it). Does he have the same problems that they have? How does he know?
harpiaharpyja··on List animals until failure
Kicking myself because I ran out of time yet forgot to mention any vultures, elephants, or large cats. I guess that's for trying this first thing on a Sunday.
harpiaharpyja··on Ford kills the All-Electric F-150
I'm one of those people. What is a work truck used for?
harpiaharpyja··on Perl's decline was cultural
Seems like the essential criteria is not whether you can write opaque code in it, but rather whether the language enables you to accomplish most tasks using clear, readable code. They aren't mutually exclusive.

Hopefully I am paraphrasing you correctly.

harpiaharpyja··on Physicists prove the Universe isn't a simulation after all
At that point the whole idea becomes quite removed from what most people would think of when asked to consider if the universe is a simulation.

To clarify: without being able to simulate the universe from within the universe itself (i.e. needing to resort to some "outside" higher-fidelity universe), then the word "simulation" becomes meaningless.

We could just as easily refer to the whole thing (the inner "simulation" and the outer "simulation") as just being different "layers of abstraction" of the same universe, and drop the word "simulation" altogether. It would have the same ontology with less baggage.

harpiaharpyja··on NTSB Preliminary Report – UPS Boeing MD-11F Crash [pdf]
A design that was once useful but no longer has a use is not the same thing as a failed design. Which is what the disagreement seems to be about.
harpiaharpyja··on Solving a million-step LLM task with zero errors
If air was highly conductive that analogy would totally hold.

"If there’s a cut in my wire’s insulation, the device won’t get enough voltage" doesn't follow from: "voltage is like water pressure in pipes"

So I don't really get your point.

harpiaharpyja··on Nano Banana can be prompt engineered for nuanced AI image generation
Not all models can actually do that if your prompt is particular
harpiaharpyja··on AI Broke Interviews
It's an indictment of how bad coding interviews are/were
harpiaharpyja··on AI Broke Interviews
It's funny how this article seems to repeat itself halfway through, like it was written by AI
harpiaharpyja··on Minnesota Cop Who Fabricated a Sex-Trafficking Ring Won't Be Held Accountable
That is a criminal level of fraud. If as a society, we continue to tolerate this, it will get worse. If there is no corrective mechanism, other bad actors that might engage in similar conduct are only going to accumulate over time.

It doesn't matter how personally upset you might be at this.

harpiaharpyja··on Claude Sonnet 4.5
Maybe just take a weekend and build something by writing the code yourself. It's the feeling of pure creative power, it sounds like you've just forgotten what it was like.
harpiaharpyja··on California needs to learn from Houston and Dallas about homelessness
It's another public health issue that could also be receiving attention which causes harm to people.
harpiaharpyja··on Themis (European Reusable Rocket) is assembled on launch pad
I'm not sure if "economies of scale" is the thing here. I think calling it that may confuse people.

Really what produces an advantage is an environment of trust. Having that reduces a lot of friction when it comes to economic activity.

harpiaharpyja··on Bertrand Russell to Oswald Mosley (1962)
> The structure of British democracy kept fascists away, not British people.

That sentence was particularly hard to parse. It read like you were saying that the structure of British democracy kept fascists away, but did not keep the British people away (???).

I did manage to figure it out eventually though. I think you meant to write:

It was the structure of British democracy that kept fascists away, not the British people.

harpiaharpyja··on A clickable visual guide to the Rust type system
The other replies do a good job of explaining what 2s complement is.

I find the best way to understand why 2s complement is so desirable is to write down the entire number line for e.g. 3-bit integers.

Using 1s complement, the negative numbers are backwards. 2s complement fixes this, so that arithmetic works and you can do addition and subtraction without any extra steps.

(Remember that negative numbers are less than positive numbers, so the correct way to count them is:

-8 -7 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 +1 +2 +3 +4 +5 +6 +7

Where -1 is the largest possible negative number)

harpiaharpyja··on Python has had async for 10 years – why isn't it more popular?
I've been working quite heavily with async Python for five and a half years now. I've been the principal developer of a control system framework for laboratory automation, written pretty much entirely in async Python. I say framework because it's a reusable engine that has gone on to become the foundation for three projects so far. Our organization is primarily involved in materials research.

At it's heart it's kind of like an asynchronous task execution engine that sits on top of an I/O layer which allows the high-level code to coordinate the activities of various equipment. Stuff like robot arms, furnace PID controllers, gantry systems, an automatic hydraulic press/spot welder (in one case), various kinds of pneumatic or stepper actuated mechanisms, and of course, measurement instruments. Often there might be a microcontroller intermediary, but the vast majority of the work is handled by Python.

My experience with async Python has been pretty positive, and I'm very happy with our choice to lean heavily into async. Contrary to some of the comments here I don't find the language's async facilities to be rough at all. Having cancellation work smoothly is also pretty important to us and I can't say I've experienced any pain points with exception-based cancellation. Maybe we've been lucky, but injecting an exception into a task to cancel it actually does work pretty reliably. Integrating dependencies that expose blocking APIs has never been a big deal either. Usually you want to have an interface layer for every third party dependency anyways, and it's no big to deal to just write an async wrapper that uses a threads or a thread pool to keep the blocking stuff off of the main thread.

I personally think that a lot of people's negative experiences here might have more to do with asyncio than the language's async features. Prior to stepping into my current role, I also had some rough experiences with asyncio, which is why we chose to build all of our async code on top of curio. There was some uncertainty at first about how well supported it would be compared to a package in the standard library, but honestly curio is a really well put together package that just works really smoothly.

harpiaharpyja··on Counter-Strike: A billion-dollar game built in a dorm room
I'm sure that's how companies these days justify their choices, but I don't see those problems as being inevitable on self-hosted infrastructure
harpiaharpyja··on The Timmy Trap
A lot of negative comments in this thread, but I think the article makes one really good point, that has had far-reaching consequences for for society before and beyond AI: humans are pretty bad at assessing intelligence.
harpiaharpyja··on A month using XMPP (using Snikket) for every call and chat (2023)
Yeah, "commodification" is the wrong word here. I'm not sure what the best word would be, but it would be more along the lines of "extraction" or "exploitation".

As in: The last 15 years has been just relentless attempts to bend and twist everything the previous generation has built to extract value instead of creating it.

Something like that.

harpiaharpyja··on Unexpected inconsistency in records
Ehh, I think the real footgun here is using a property with backing storage to store what is clearly a derived value. Using a computed property is what we really should be doing here, if we think our code should line up with our intentions.

I feel like what's happened here is that the author actually needed a system to cache their derived values, but didn't think to build that out explicitly.

harpiaharpyja··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
Probably more than you might think.

As a teen I used to play around with Core Wars, and my high school taught 8086 assembly. I think I got a decent grasp of it, enough to implement quicksort in 8086 while sitting through a very boring class, and test it in the simulator later.

I mean, probably few people ever need to use it for something serious, but that doesn't mean they don't understand it.

harpiaharpyja··on Simpler Backoff
Generating tables is the way to go in that case. The flexibility you need, with the advantages of being data driven.
harpiaharpyja··on Simpler Backoff
So, this is just about declarative programming style?

I thought based on the title it would have been about different approaches to backoff.

← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →