HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hartpuff

120 karma · joined January 25, 2016

submissionscomments
hartpuff··on 85 percent of Facebook video is watched without sound
> Not sure why you're being downvoted.

Is it really about "mind control"?

(I wouldn't downvote it (and can't anyway), but that might be why others did.)

hartpuff··on Jane Fawcett, British Decoder Who Helped Doom the Bismarck, Dies at 95
AFAIK, BBC Radio is not blocked outside the UK, perhaps because a TV Licence is not required for radio, and/or possibly because the BBC may control more distribution rights for the content of its radio productions than its TV output.

The link you posted is not blocked though, FWIW.

hartpuff··on StackOverflow – a missed opportunity
It's kind of an in-joke/meme for some people to write it like that.
hartpuff··on I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning
> the word 'fasces' does not exist in Italian.

The word "fascism" does not exist in Italian either. We're using English and anglicised words.

The "Fasces" is a group of rods tied together with an axe, dating back to ancient Italian/Roman times, and comes from the Latin fascis ("bundle").

The word fascism no more derives from a political party (which simply pulled the word out of nowhere, did it?) than the words "democrat", "republican" or "communist" do.

hartpuff··on You can’t replace your face, says face recognition
Heathrow and maybe other UK airports, but not all, whether you're entering or exiting, will take (two) photos, AIUI, in order to verify the correct person is boarding the aircraft.

Don't worry, they only keep your data for "as long as is necessary".

http://www.heathrow.com/departures/security-and-baggage/flyi...

hartpuff··on An Unconventional Look at the European Map
Which is why it shouldn't say "its (Mankind's) flag".

The USA (to its credit) dedicated the Apollo mission to Mankind (which Soviet cosmonauts were pleasantly surprised by) but the flag was planted as a symbol of the USA. (Other considered options, such as the flags of all countries, were rejected.)

The flags, if they still exist, are likely to be blank now anyway.

hartpuff··on An Unconventional Look at the European Map
> mankind did even get to the Moon with its flag

The US flag is the flag of Mankind? Interesting.

hartpuff··on I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning
> If you're going to call me a Nazi, I think all I can do is stick out my tongue, call you a commie, and close the tab.

Call me a commie if you like, I'm not ashamed to admit I sympathise with Communist principles (class and race/gender equality, for example) - unlike you, quacking like a fascist but too embarrassed to openly admit it.

The only people I see online making the effort to argue Nazism was not as bad as "X" are Nazi sympathisers/fascists. I mean who else would bother?

If you want to 'take down' a stupid and ridiculous caricature of what a Communist is ("Che wearing millennial" or whatever) you can do it without mentioning Nazis at all.

Instead you chose to take the 'at least the Nazis weren't as bad as the Communists' route. Your other posts here defending fascism don't exactly scream "Not a Nazi-sympathiser" either, so I don't know who you think you're trying to kid.

What happened after the Russian, Chinese or Cuban Revolutions doesn't negate the beliefs behind and reasons for the revolutions themselves (equality and 'the people'), any more than what happened after the American Revolution - almost 100 years of slavery, aggression and "Manifest Destiny" (cf. Lebensraum), followed by another century of racial persecution and overseas aggression/imperialism - negates the ideas and beliefs behind that revolution (equality and 'the people').

What happened in Germany after 1933, however, went exactly according to the Nazi playbook. What happened in Italy and every other fascist country, likewise, went exactly according to fascist principles.

Nobody becomes a Communist because they believe in purges or gulags; and nobody becomes a Nazi or a fascist because they believe in good roads, advanced rocketry or trains running on time.

That's why Nazis and fascists have a stigma attached to them - because the principles behind both are reprehensible to most people.

hartpuff··on I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning
> It just gives an out for idiots to call as soon as the word Nazi comes out

Something even worse happens on Reddit. Whenever anyone mentions Nazis or Hitler, someone is absolutely, certifiably guaranteed to fall over themselves trying to be the first (in the thread; the 876458430854th overall) to post: "Hitler killed Hitler".

Followed inevitably by: "But he also killed the man who killed Hitler".

hartpuff··on I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning
> "Fascism" etimology is from "Fasci di combattimento" the political party founded by Mussolini.

No it's not. It derives from the word "fasces".

hartpuff··on I created Godwin's Law in 1990 as a warning
>>>I find it strange that people proudly identify as "communists" without much stigma

Do you also find it strange that white people proudly identify as "Americans" without much stigma, even after centuries of racial atrocities by white Americans?

> That's my point.

Your point - as is the point of everyone who trots out the "Communism" is worse than Nazism old chestnut - is to minimise what the Nazis did. And there's only one reason people do that.

The only surprise here, compared to every other Nazi sympathiser online making the same hackneyed "point", is you didn't claim Stalin killed 50/60/100 million people (any number higher than Hitler will do).

hartpuff··on Global Citizenship a Growing Sentiment Among Citizens of Emerging Economies
It would not surprise me if the latter is a primarily American interpretation. (The US being the spiritual home of "NWO"/anti-Government sentiment.)
hartpuff··on Global Citizenship a Growing Sentiment Among Citizens of Emerging Economies
What makes you think this is about economic betterment?
hartpuff··on Global Citizenship a Growing Sentiment Among Citizens of Emerging Economies
I'm surprised by the remarks (in both posts) about China.

People in China cannot be unaware of the country's shortcomings (as a repressive totalitarian state) while also having a strong awareness of, and often direct family or business connections to the rest of the world, which China has influenced and been influenced by for centuries.

Traditionally, Chinese people have had no objection to emigrating, working and settling in other countries, in Asia and beyond - exemplified by how many cities in the world have a Chinatown - and have never struck me as being particularly racist, nationalistic or xenophobic.

hartpuff··on Global Citizenship a Growing Sentiment Among Citizens of Emerging Economies
It isn't about money or tying finances together, it's about how people self-identify.
hartpuff··on Global Citizenship a Growing Sentiment Among Citizens of Emerging Economies
Or correlate it with the level or sophistication of nationalistic/xenophobic propaganda in each country.

Or with the level of real-life experience and awareness a population has with other countries.

hartpuff··on We discovered our parents were Russian spies
> Not at all.

Then, as I said, the most distinguishing fact about these two is obviously not that their parents pretended to be Canadian.

There really is no point in arguing this since you believe the circumstances of someone born in Canada, raised to some extent in Canada, and having an affinity with Canada are analogous to someone who doesn't even know Canada exists, like a large proportion of that 7 billion you talk about.

BTW, did you edit your other post? Not that it changes anything, but I don't remember it saying "victims of not being born Canadian citizens" when I replied.

hartpuff··on We discovered our parents were Russian spies
Interesting that I've suddenly, just now, received no less than two downvotes on the above (otherwise popular) post and my post above it (4 simultaneous downvotes on just two posts), despite this currently sliding down Page 5 of HN.

To be legit, that's at least two separate people coincidentally downvoting the same day old posts at the same time, on a Page 5 submission.

hartpuff··on World's Obese Population Hits 641M
^ (Not looking for an argument though, just saying.)
hartpuff··on We discovered our parents were Russian spies
Who is saying anything remotely like "if parents lie to their kids for long enough then we have a duty to make those lies come true"?

Unless you're claiming 7 billion people in the world were born in Canada, the most distinguishing fact about these two is obviously not that their parents pretended to be Canadian.

hartpuff··on We discovered our parents were Russian spies
The law is not necessarily stupid, but an exception, if possible, probably should be made in this case, on moral grounds, since the kids seem to be victims of a situation they played no part in creating.
hartpuff··on We discovered our parents were Russian spies
I agree. The only way such a casual reaction is plausible is if they are also KGB agents.

The problem I'm having is that it doesn't really invoke any Cold War aspect any more.

They basically just are Americans, meeting with other "Americans", watching American movies or David Copperfield, visiting EPCOT or EST, alongside some rather tedious non-political espionage. They (very suddenly) don't seem to have any solid association with the Soviet Union or "the cause" any more.

The now sadly all too rare Rezidentura scenes (with some of the most interesting aspects and characters of the show IMO) and Reagan clips just seem like tacked-on lip-service to the original concept.

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
Thanks. I had vaguely heard of Voat before, but for some reason thought it was a script for self-hosted Reddit style sites.

dang, I assume you meant stop bickering, but if you absolutely mean no more posts, sorry for this. It will probably be the last anyway.

I'm just curious, since you (ferrari) and anyone else still reading this have more knowledge or experience about this, has any site, or even HN, ever tried making the usernames people who upvote and downvote publicly visible?

I think people would put more thought into what they up or (especially) downvote if they could not 'hide', and their usernames were attached to it. Likewise, if voting had a 'cost', say, 1 karma to upvote and 1 or 2 karma to downvote.

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
Someone/people really proving the points being made about downvoting and the seriousness of this forum. FWIW, I upvoted because I think the downvotes are abusive (particularly the one you object to here). Did not seem to make any difference though.
hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
> I've re-read it several times and I have no idea why you thought it was relevant or what point you were trying to make.

So people downvoted because you personally can't understand the following two laughably easy to understand sentences?

    Let's say someone here posts "fuck off"
    or "you're an idiot". Please explain how
    that can be interpreted as constructive
    to a discussion here.
Made - completely relevantly - in response to someone claiming "non-constructive" is always subjective.

> Comments like that will usually get you downvotes.

Why? Her post made no sense to me. If I can't tell if someone is being serious how am I supposed to find out?

If only I had 500+ karma, I guess I could have just mindlessly downvoted her instead, since according to you if someone can't understand a post, the poster should suffer for it.

> You might disagree with (I do too), but pointing it out by calling people childish is going to get downvoted.

> It's also childish to keep whining^W complaining about downvotes using the same language that got you downvotes.

Yet somehow okay for you to use the same language?

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
Where's my so-called "attack" or "insult" in this entirely reasonable post then (aside from the edit, which was obviously made after I was downvoted), with a lower score than the one you cited?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11645104

Or this one (also with a lower score):

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11645505

> is obviously going to get downvoted.

For the baby language, maybe, but downvoting something you don't personally like is pathetic and childish.

That's not an "attack" or an "insult", it's a fact.

And it's, if anything, even more pathetic and childish to petulantly downvote a poster (perhaps across different posts) because they point out that fact.

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
It should also be fucking obvious that downvotes are not being made for something as yet unknown that I do in the future and only in response to the downvoting (ie: criticising it as childish).

And downvoting someone because they call specific downvoting childish? That seems like the epitome of childishness to me, and simply validates my point.

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
Every post I made has been downvoted, and the edits that mention downvoting obviously came after I was downvoted. Some downvoted posts don't mention downvoting at all.

Two are downvoted for asking someone to clarify their argument and for rebutting someone else's incorrect point. Or they're downvoted because some people simply downvoted every post I made, because I made it.

I'm mostly being downvoted by people who downvote opinions they don't agree with, or people they don't like, just as other people are in this thread, and which happens in other threads all the time.

> https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

   > Avoid gratuitous negativity. 
How is using what is literally a negative arrow on posts or posters you don't like/agree with anything but gratuitous negativity?

   > When disagreeing, please reply to the argument
How is lazily pressing a down arrow replying to the argument?

   > it makes boring reading.
It makes boring reading to see posts all over the place whited out (yet no actual written refutation of the post content) because some people can't tolerate or be bothered to discuss or argue with things they disagree with.

If HN is against negativity, then maybe it should not have a button that expresses pure negativity.

And if something is being complained about so often there have to be two rules against it, maybe it's time to get rid of the (non-constructive) thing so many people are complaining about.

If people want to reward discussions or comments, or have them rise to the top, they can achieve such by pressing the up button (which AFAIK is how it works on the submissions - no downvote).

The only reason a downvote is necessary is to provide childish, fragile people a way to 'hide' or 'punish' opinions or people they don't like but are too incapable/lazy to refute.

Since I doubt I'm the first person to make these points, and suspect nothing will change after this post, I guess it's deliberate HN policy to pander to such people.

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
I agree; I hate the concept of downvoting. It's purely negative, which this site claims to discourage, it's completely mindless - why bother forming a cogent rebuttal to something you disagree with when you can lazily (and cowardly, without any risk of having your fragile beliefs challenged back) click a down arrow instead - and it disfavours minority (potentially interesting or controversial) points of view.
hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
I just checked the first page of your comments and there seems to be some strange examples of inane/non-constructive downvoting.

(I've seen threads where some of the wackiest, most inexplicable downvoting is going on, I almost wonder if it's the site deliberately trying to stir up activity/controversy.)

In this thread it's becoming quite pathetic and ridiculous that people are unable to explain or back up the point they have made when I ask, and yet I get downvoted. On every post. This one will be no exception. (Edit: and it wasn't.)

I assumed this was a serious place, and liked the idea of rules to keep a civil and theoretically high quality discussion, but the abuse of downvoting by infantile people just destroys it.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →