HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hartpuff

120 karma · joined January 25, 2016

submissionscomments
hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
I honestly can't tell if this is meant to be serious or not.

It's not proper discourse on HN, or it insults people's intelligence, to have a minority opinion? What?

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
(as in posts that don't make any argument, whether you agree with it or not, or add anything to a discussion)

Let's say someone here posts "fuck off" or "you're an idiot". Please explain how that can be interpreted as constructive to a discussion here.

Edit: Wow, people who childishly downvote certainly don't like to be called out about their childish downvoting. :)

hartpuff··on 'Boaty McBoatface' polar ship named after David Attenborough
> he's being downvoted both because HN users disagree

Which is probably the usual reason people downvote. And it's a shit reason.

Downvoting (ie, trying to bury or hide a post) because someone says sumfing u don't wike is pathetic and childish; if you disagree either argue against it or move on.

Downvotes (if they have to exist) should be reserved for posts that are objectively non-constructive (as in posts that don't make any argument, whether you agree with it or not, or add anything to a discussion).

hartpuff··on AdBlock Plus teams up with Flattr to help readers pay publishers
Is ABP being paid by the advertisers whose ads they're allowing? I honestly don't know. But it's unlikely they're blocking ads they're being paid to show.

> Since you apparently hate capitalism, I'm curious how you're paid.

Is advertising a synonym of capitalism?

hartpuff··on Italian court rules food theft 'not a crime' if hungry
Well it's about as "logical" as saying it's okay to kill people while in the army, so it must be okay to kill people in any other situation too.
hartpuff··on Italian court rules food theft 'not a crime' if hungry
> What if a hungry person decided to smash up a $5,000 vending machine to get a sandwich or a coffee?

Did they legalize smashing up $5000 vending machines if you're hungry too?

> Does the Italian government pay for the repairs?

Do Governments usually pay for repairs to private property?

hartpuff··on Italian court rules food theft 'not a crime' if hungry
I'm not seeing the same logic you are. If someone is hungry (or pretending to be), why would they want to break into your home and sleep in your bed, rather than steal food?
hartpuff··on What cold showers and exercise have in common (2014)
I assume you mean AJRF. Just because those two examples are unacceptable doesn't mean "wow, get real" is acceptable. If you disagree or don't understand why someone said something, then either forget about it, or reply to it for clarification or discussion.

I mean why don't we all just post "get real" to everything or everyone we disagree with? Apparently a surprising number of people here can't think of a reason why not, since they think "get real" a fine response.

Edit: Actually, I think you mean if the "motherfucker" guy had said those things, in which case, I agree. People defending the use of "crazy motherfucker" may indeed be offended by the examples you gave, or feel they are inappropriate here, but can't seem to understand that terms they think are fine may be considered inappropriate to other people.

hartpuff··on What cold showers and exercise have in common (2014)
Who said the default reaction should be offence then? Who even said rituch was personally offended by it?

If someone doesn't recognize it as relatively harmless banter (which may be a matter of opinion anyway), then why would they not think it's inappropriate here, when this forum is known for being more civil than most, partly for the reason rituch gave?

The "default" should be to recognize that misunderstandings happen online, and to definitely not post a rude, redundant comment like "get real" to an already heavily downvoted post that two other people have already addressed.

Edit: Well, judging by the down and upvoting, it seems I'm in a minority, or a lot of 'free speech' warriors here don't understand the concept of private forums with rules, and think posts simply telling people to "get real" add to a discussion.

hartpuff··on What cold showers and exercise have in common (2014)
You "get real". Not everyone is from an English speaking country or can differentiate 'earthy banter' from sincerely offensive epithets online.
hartpuff··on Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases
> And that's why it's a bit silly to have ideological positions about currencies

Indeed. I think Bitcoin would be given the time of day by a lot more people if there was a lot less political whackjobbery surrounding it, and more sane, informed discussion from people such as yourself.

hartpuff··on Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases
The point is, unlike with Bitcoin, people with Euros do not have any significant ideological opposition towards dollars, or acquire Euros because they believe it is superior to or will one day replace dollars.

> That's still good for the viability of the euro as a currency, because it can be easily exchanged for goods and services, even with a middleman.

So it's good for Bitcoin in exactly the same way that it's good for Dogecoin, and other popular alts.

hartpuff··on Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases
Then why does it only happen using bitcoin?

Actually, scratch that, because it doesn't even matter. Wherever you want to lay the blame (anywhere but bitcoin) it's a problem for anyone using bitcoin, making it more useless than (not "immensely superior" to, as claimed) using a credit card or Paypal, which makes it a problem for bitcoin.

hartpuff··on Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases
> It doesn't matter. I can pay with bitcoin on Steam.

I can pay with Dogecoin with one additional step.

>It makes bitcoin more fungible and thus viable as a currency.

Isn't using Bitpay just a way of exchanging bitcoin for dollars, while kidding yourself that's not what you're doing?

> And for what it's worth, I find the bitcoin payment process immensely superior to credit cards: Just pull out the phone and scan the QR code on the screen. Screen updates to show payment was made.

All that's left is to wait countless tedious hours for the funds to appear in the, for example, Namesilo account. It is easy (so is using a credit card), but it's almost uselessly slow (unlike credit cards).

Edit: maybe this explains anti-Bitcoin sentiment. The fundamentalists can't handle any factual comments that aren't entirely about how game changing it is.

hartpuff··on Traffic to Wikipedia terrorism entries plunged after Snowden revelations
> If you read slightly further you will see:

Good point. Because I mentioned two words that appear at the top of the page, that means I obviously didn't read any further.

If you read the article you'll know that nowhere does it say false, as the other poster claimed.

Why don't they say it's false, if it's false? What's stopping them?

The fact that someone eventually removes something from their site does not mean it was false.

Someone using the contrived sentence "the odds that the report is accurate hover near zero" - rather than just saying "it's false" - also does not make it false.

I don't believe it happened either - sorry if you used your 500+ karma because I didn't issue a disclaimer to that effect - but that also doesn't mean it's false.

My point was about someone whining about getting facts right, by linking to an aticle that bends over backwards to not say what they think it says.

hartpuff··on Traffic to Wikipedia terrorism entries plunged after Snowden revelations
While we're all busy checking our facts, the site you linked to does not state the quote is "false", it says it is "extremely unlikely".
hartpuff··on Facial recognition service becomes a weapon against Russian porn actresses
Thanks for your reply. That's an argument about 'sex sells' though. Like car exhibitions or Microsoft Xbox conventions using scantily clad women.

What I meant (and I think the parent of my post was talking about, though I could be wrong) is the old chestnut that the sex/adult industry innovated or popularized all kinds of technologies.

hartpuff··on Facial recognition service becomes a weapon against Russian porn actresses
> It is funny how many technologies are introduced the mass market by relating to sex.

This kind of claim is often made (often by smut mongers), but I don't remember (though may have forgotten) ever seeing any examples that really back up the claim. Can you list some?

hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
> Your claim was that innocent simply meant not found guilty, which is incorrect.

What I said is: "by definition, the people being tortured, not having been found guilty of any crime, are innocent". Which is not incorrect.

I'm going to assume you know the principle of innocent until proven guilty, since it was in my last reply, quoted from Cornell's Law site.

> the law assumes they're in that state until proven otherwise. That doesn't mean everyone presumed innocent is innocent.

Okay, point me to a legal principle akin to innocent until proven guilty that instead states might not be innocent even if they have not been found guilty.

> The word innocent is problematic for reasons I've explained.

That it's problematic for you does not make it problematic.

hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
> That word does not mean what you think it means.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/presumption_of_innocence

    One of the most sacred principles
    in the American criminal justice
    system, holding that a defendant
    is *innocent* until proven guilty. 
> Plenty of uncharged and unconvicted people have broken the law.

I can't believe anyone would bother making such a fatuous point, to which the obvious response is simply: plenty of uncharged and unconvicted (and even convicted for that matter) people have not broken the law.

Now can you answer the question you evaded in my last post:

If stating that black sites are set up specifically to detain people without charge and torture them is "misleading", according to you, please explain what you believe the purpose of black sites is.

hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
> I was just pointing out that "specifically to torture innocent people" was misleading and wrong.

What are so-called 'black sites' set up for then, if not to torture people who have not been charged with let alone convicted of anything (ie, are innocent)?

hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
No, I will not come up with another word or phrase just because you will not accept innocent.
hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
Why I should use "unconvicted", which implies possible guilt, for people who have not even been charged with anything, but are simply imprisoned and/or tortured indefinitely?
hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
I was thinking more generally, about the fact that these sites are set up and used specifically to avoid due process. I mean by definition, the people being tortured, not having been found guilty of any crime, are innocent.
hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
AIUI the CIA is not supposed to operate domestically, so the comparison between the two is not exact (I don't believe the CIA would operate domestically the same way as the KGB did anyway, though, but the KGB was basically just helping to prop up an openly tyrannical state), but even if the KGB has the CIA beat on home turf, I think the CIA 'wins' abroad.

Even just taking the example in this thread, a monstrous program of 'black sites' set up around the world specifically to torture innocent people indefinitely, where is the KGB version?

Leaving aside any comparisons, if they're a distraction, why is an organization that does the terrible things the CIA has done throughout its history not only tolerated in a civilized democracy, but actually still viewed generally positively?

hartpuff··on The Al-Qaeda Leader Who Wasn’t: The Shameful Ordeal of Abu Zubaydah
> The CIA is a sickening and surprisingly amateurish organisation. Their actions over the past decades have ruined the United States' international moral authority.

I'm not even sure that's true. I think the perception of the CIA (perhaps due to generally positive portrayals of it on TV and in movies) is completely different to, say, the perception people have of the Stasi or KGB.

And yet did those organizations, which people rightly consider to be bad, actually do anything worse than the CIA has been doing in the last 70 years?

hartpuff··on Getting shit done. A guide for lazypreneurs
Well you lose marks (metaphorically, I don't mean downvotes) for talking about copying another site and doing it better, and then not naming your own site, perhaps because you don't want someone to copy it and do it better. (Unless it's just so Adsense violating that you can't say what it is.)

I think a better article might be one which went through the process and lessons learned in creating and building up your Adsense site. Even if you weren't following your own guide posted here, and it was about how you weren't 100% sure what you were doing, but you learned that this thing worked, and this thing didn't.

I suspect that's going to be more interesting to people than an article giving advice and suggestions that there's no real evidence you've actually (successfully) employed yourself.

Anyway, you win points (a literal upvote) for being good enough to tolerate and respond to criticism here.

hartpuff··on Getting shit done. A guide for lazypreneurs
Pretty lazy site. Four posts total, about the same number of affiliate links to Fiverr and Digital Ocean, and no examples of how he put this guide into practice in his other (unnamed) "successful site", referred to on his About page.

In fact the article that mentions his other site (the Adsense post) says nothing of thinking about it in the shower, getting feedback or scoping ideas; simply of copying an existing site, knocking out 4 posts of barely 300 words, posting about it on Reddit, and by accident creating something people like.

Still, #3 on HN, so I guess someone likes it.

hartpuff··on Do not talk about pricing
It's not just you, and probably not even just an American thing. I personally think of the The Times when I see "The Times", but I'm British, like the author of this Medium article.

I know why it happens, but it's somewhat ironic that The Times is given a made-up regional-sounding name (The London Times or Times of London) to differentiate it from shorthand versions of region-specific titles that are, directly or indirectly, inspired by The Times.

hartpuff··on I returned home from Silicon Valley and built a failed startup
If you're living in an area where having a fridge and TV is rare or unusual, if I understand you correctly, then I'd say you're living in a very poor area, not a 'typical' or even average place.
← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →