HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hcknwscommenter

1,715 karma · joined November 7, 2017

submissionscomments
hcknwscommenter··on It took two days to develop Moderna’s vaccine
Yes. The question is not whether bad health outcomes exist, only the truly ignorant believe COVID is a total hoax. The question is whether COVID is significantly worse than the influenza, rhino, and corona viruses we generally get year-round. The answer, is resoundingly yes. COVID is much worse in terms of the short-term and long-term sequelae both in terms of the range of "bad health outcome[s]" and in terms of the likelihood that an infected person will have one of these "bad health outcome[s]".
hcknwscommenter··on It took two days to develop Moderna’s vaccine
> I don’t think any European country has completely lifted their lockdown restrictions.

True

>All of it is a “limited re-opening.”

Yes, but the issue is how limited was the limited re-opening. I live in the U.S., but ALL of my colleagues are in Europe. It's anecdotal, but my understanding is that the re-openings throughout EU were quite closer to the "unlimited" side than the "total lockdown" side of the spectrum.

>Perhaps respiratory viruses spread much more effectively in the winter versus the summer

The presence of an additional explanatory factor does not prove the absence of an alternative explanatory factor. They could both be true, and almost certainly are true. That is: lockdowns work; without lockdowns, you have Bergamo in Jan-Mar 2020 (mass death); COVID spreads better in winter.

hcknwscommenter··on It took two days to develop Moderna’s vaccine
The lockdowns in Europe worked. Full stop. Case rates dropped dramatically.

Some of those countries are "not sitting pretty right now" because they ended their lockdowns.

The answer is not "lockdowns don't really do any good." The answer is "don't prematurely end your lockdowns." Now that can be burdensome. You can do a middle ground (limited re-opening). That works too, but you have to be very careful and keep a close eye on case numbers and shut down totally as soon as cases ramp up. California tried to do that in the latest surge, but was a little late in implementing the newly stringent measures and even further So. Cal. "resisted" the newly stringent measures and are now suffering mightily.

hcknwscommenter··on It took two days to develop Moderna’s vaccine
Wrong. First, you have no uncontrolled covid spread to compare to. You are actually comparing tightly locked down COVID spread to a normal flu season. And COVID is still killing a lot more people. The closest example for an "uncontrolled covid spread" would be Bergamo in Jan-Mar 2020. Is that what you want repeated world-wide? The death rate there was astronomical.
hcknwscommenter··on It took two days to develop Moderna’s vaccine
You seem so confident, but cite nothing (just like the comment you are referring to). However, I do note that all the symptoms noted in the comment above are actual symptoms found in survivors of severe COVID. I'm not sure about the proportions though, but is it a stretch to believe that patients who are hospitalized (by definition, severely impacted by COVID) very often have long-term damage?
hcknwscommenter··on Emails show Navy's 'UFO' patents went through significant internal review
This whole thing is beyond bizarre to me. The posted article references another article about the appeals process. https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/28729/docs-show-navy-g... . In that one, it is clear that in response to the non-enablement argument by the patent office, the Navy simply agreed that the technology is not possible today but they are doing experiments that they hope will work, and any way you better grant the patent because the Chinese are working on this. That was apparently enough to get a patent. That is not how it works for any normal inventor/applicant.
hcknwscommenter··on Emails show Navy's 'UFO' patents went through significant internal review
Sort of. If the Pais effect is described in enough detail, such that an "ordinary" person of "skill in the [technical field relevant to the making or using of the invention]" can use the teachings of the patent in combination with what is already commonly known to practice the invention without "undue experimentation", then the patent is considered enabled. If the patent does not teach enough to meet this criteria, then it is invalid for non-enablement. One subset of non-enablement is that the "invention" is simply not possible (e.g., perpetual motion machine).
hcknwscommenter··on Age-specific mortality and immunity patterns of SARS-CoV-2
You are correct. OP is spreading conspiracy theories.
hcknwscommenter··on South Dakota nurse says many dying patients still insist Covid-19 'not real'
Clearly it is a solution. The problem is that places like Spain stopped their lockdowns. What we really need is a flexible and informed approach, where the stringency of lockdowns is implemented on a sliding scale determined by actual real-time case numbers. Masks and other basic measures should be everywhere and always required and more stringent steps applied proactively as hot spots emerge. This coupled with rapid testing and contact tracing works. It has been proven multiple times in multipel places.
hcknwscommenter··on South Dakota nurse says many dying patients still insist Covid-19 'not real'
>5+ antiviral or immunomodulatory drugs with published successful RCTs

I don't think that number is at all accurate. Dexamethasone is really the only thing that fits your description. People think of remdesivir, but the data on that are still quite ambiguous.

hcknwscommenter··on South Dakota nurse says many dying patients still insist Covid-19 'not real'
Your view of "mainstream" news does not fit at all with what I have seen.
hcknwscommenter··on South Dakota nurse says many dying patients still insist Covid-19 'not real'
>It’s regurgitated daily by right wing American politicians and media.

Who are themselves (purposefully or unwittingly) part of a foreign intelligence operation.

hcknwscommenter··on South Dakota nurse says many dying patients still insist Covid-19 'not real'
Spain did do real lockdowns and it worked. And then they stopped doing real lockdowns. So it is in fact supported by the evidence.
hcknwscommenter··on South Dakota nurse says many dying patients still insist Covid-19 'not real'
>we have made a very big mistake by turning this issue into political one. For example, by criticizing Trump on his COVID-19 plan

Huh? "We" have made a very big mistake by turning this issue into a political one. However, the mistake was in failing to criticize Trump from the very beginning. Twitter should have canceled his account when he put out that tweet calling COVID a hoax (in March?). Corporate America should have stood up in a united fashion and put out a pro-mask/anti-Trump message. Every health care administer should have put out PR immediately debunking Trump's nonsense. The idea that we should have avoided criticizing the guy who stupidly made this thing political in the first place is just crazy to me.

hcknwscommenter··on Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, trials show
Your IJME link does not support in any way your assertion about the "danger" of the HPV vaccine. From the link, 30,000 were vaccinated. Three girls died for reasons that are never stated. The article provides that "there is no conclusive evidence of a causal link between the vaccine and the deaths."
hcknwscommenter··on Moderna Covid vaccine candidate almost 95% effective, trials show
It is also not definitive that the 532 cases of Guillan-Barré were actually caused by the vaccine. In any large scale vaccination effort people die/get sick just because that is what happens in any large population.
hcknwscommenter··on RCEP, the world’s biggest trade agreement
You do have a say, after the negotiations are complete. If you don't like it, call your representatives, vote, etc. If they have to go back and renegotiate, then that is what it is.
hcknwscommenter··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
I am truly unworried about an "underground/blackmarket" of maskless events. It's just a mask. Wear it.
hcknwscommenter··on Measles surging as Covid-19 curbs disrupt vaccinations
It is an hypothesis, but the data suggests that the effect will be weak to non-existence. Data shows that the seasonal influenza pattern existed before modern era levels of international travel.
hcknwscommenter··on RCEP, the world’s biggest trade agreement
> it weakened our IP laws to that so they're comparable with the USA.

This statement literally makes no sense to me. Care to elaborate? As it stands, I have to admit that your statement suggests to me that you haven't the vaguest idea about U.S. versus NZ IP laws and perhaps have also gotten the idea of strong vs. weak IP laws entirely backwards. Enlighten me, please.

hcknwscommenter··on Measles surging as Covid-19 curbs disrupt vaccinations
> with significantly reduced travel and social restrictions in the southern hemisphere, the data's going to be bad, so this year's flu shot won't be as effective

This does not seem correct. The data on this does not require travel or social interaction. The CDC (and other gov't agencies throughout the world) literally has cooperation with sites around the world to monitor the rise of new flu strains. These sites use technology like: the telephone, the internet, and the fax machine, to transmit the information the world uses to develop the current generation flu vaccine.

hcknwscommenter··on A few kilograms weight loss nearly halves the risk of diabetes?
30kgs! Good on you ( assuming that is a healthy amount to lose). From my own point of view, I have grown to like a quality salad, and they are very easy to make quickly. Some fresh variety of greens from the store, half an avocado sliced, cubes of roasted golden beet, add roasted/salted pistachio nuts or sunflower seeds, layer a few chunks of roasted chicken on top, add olive oil and your choice of tasty vinegar (e.g., balsamic), and a dash of salt and mix. 5 minutes to prep if you have all the ingredients. Divine!
hcknwscommenter··on A few kilograms weight loss nearly halves the risk of diabetes?
From my point of view (currently mid 40s and undergoing my very first attempt at losing weight in my life), losing weight of course means consuming fewer calories than you burn. However, eating healthy foods is what makes that a less miserable experience. Eating foods that take a while to digest and sit in your stomach for a while making you feel full like whole grains, nuts, fresh fruit and vegetables, and enough protein to keep your muscle mass, will make it a lot more likely to lead to success than simply "eating less."
hcknwscommenter··on Dan's online motorcycle repair course (1999-2020)
"a rear radar" On a road bicycle? What is this device?
hcknwscommenter··on Voyager 2 is back online after eight months of radio silence
I was responding to a comment about a story that was specifically about the unjamming by heating/cooling; a phenomenon which everyone above the age of six knows about. My comment was not a genital measuring context, nor did it have anything to do with the innovation and creativity displayed by the deployment of the Voyager space craft.
hcknwscommenter··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
It's just a mask. The "power" the government is applying to "coerce" you into wearing a mask must be weighed against the burden being imposed (extremely low, less than asking you to at least wear underwear in public/near schools) and the benefits (extremely high, masks work).
hcknwscommenter··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
Check out Figure 1 of your cite [3]. Of course mutation rate is high compared to a prokaryote. The point is that coronaviruses (as proven by Fig. 1 of [3]) do not have a high mutation rate for an RNA virus. Indeed, the mutation rate is much lower than influenza.
hcknwscommenter··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
>vaccines which are made to flood the body with fake ACE2 proteins

There is no such thing as a vaccine that floods the body with fake ACE2 proteins.

hcknwscommenter··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
The comment you respond to states "more readily." This is undoubtedly true. Influenza virus is designed to recombine at every single replication cycle. Coronaviruses as a whole do not do that. We have a lot of data on coronavirus mutation rates and they are dramatically lower (1000x) than influenza. The point is not that mutation/recombination can't happen (it can and will happen), it is just that this mutation/recombination is relatively rare and we will not get the standard twice-yearly seasonal flu effect where we have to tweak the vaccine every year.
hcknwscommenter··on Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% protection
"Covid19 would also be over if people with symptoms would just stay home."

That is unlikely to be true. There are asymptomatic super spreaders. The fact that R0 is currently hovering around 1 is that society has greatly reduced contacts. Even in areas where social distancing is a mere suggestion, most people are not behaving completely normally (a good thing). Flights are super low, movie theater visits are super low, hotel occupancy is super low. Social distancing and contact tracing work. Better social distancing and contact tracing work better.

← PreviousPage 8 of 26Next →