HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hdctambien

692 karma · joined July 12, 2010

Computer Science Teacher
submissionscomments
hdctambien··on Java 16
> C++ is more portable because it doesn't require the JVM to run

Java is portable BECAUSE of the JVM. If a new computer architecture hits the scene, once someone writes a JVM for it your .class files will run on it (probably).

Your C++ program, however, will definitely not run and you'll need to recompile it with a compiler that targets that new architecture.

The same compiled Java code will(should) run on a Mac or a PC or any Linux box, but you need a different executable for each target with a C++ program.

The JVM isn't portable. That needs to be recompiled for each new target, but your Java .class files are portable.

hdctambien··on Students Left Behind by Remote Learning
I think we agree.

It has become clear to me that my job is to babysit first, and educate second.

If all you really want are babysitters, then you can get away with paying babysitter wages. And you'll be supplied with babysitters.

Babysitting at scale is actually pretty cheap. I get about $1.33 per student per hour, if you only count the time I am in the room with kids.

hdctambien··on Students Left Behind by Remote Learning
The chemistry, history, or anything teachers wouldn't get the 2500 stipend or the industry experience bump (even if they were a professional chemist for 20 years!), so would only make $60,000 after 30 years of teaching (at which point they would max out the ladder)

0 years experience, 45,000. 30 years experience, 60,000 (in my district) Do you have a phd? You get +$2000 a year.

The head football coach makes $100,000+. The band director makes $100,000+.

hdctambien··on Students Left Behind by Remote Learning
Teachers are not paid based on supply and demand. We all get paid the same amount (by district) based purely on years of teaching experience. With little perks for masters degrees ($1000 per year on my district) or teaching a CTE class like computer science ($2500 per year but 5 extra work days), and I even got a few extra steps on the ladder for industry experience (9 years experience for me, about $5000 up the ladder)

Some districts are doing a Pay For Performance situation, where "good teachers" can earn lots more... But I have a feeling the average teacher wage is lower in those districts and is highly dependent on what classes and mix of students your administrators give you (the AP calc teacher is going to have higher achieving students than the class full of seniors that are just taking algebra 1) it all depends on how "performance" is measured..

hdctambien··on Students Left Behind by Remote Learning
> is close to impossible to evaluate (and fire bad) teachers in public schools

It is harder to hire new (good) teachers than it is to fire bad teachers.

My first teaching job paid $29,000 a year in 2004 and I had a CS degree. My classmate who I went to high school with, same college, same major, same minor, and moved back to the same town.. his starting salary was $80,000 and they paid for him to get his mba. He works at Google now.

16 years later and I make $60,000 teaching (because I moved to a much wealthier district). Next week I start a new job programming for $80,000.

Who is going to teach cs in my place? Who is going to turn down $80,000 - $100,000 for a $50,000 teaching job... In a school with 3000+ students, during a pandemic?

hdctambien··on Show HN: A Firefox add-on to strip Google search results of 'blacklisted' URLs
Or because too many people were using it!
hdctambien··on Students are failing AP tests because the College Board can’t handle HEIC images
I have to teach an entire lesson about downloading a file, finding it in the downloads folder, and unzipping it.

Apple did a good job abstracting away the file system.

hdctambien··on I graduated into the dot com bust as a programmer and made it – you will too
If unions were the cause of "mediocrity" then there should be better teaching in states that don't have teacher unions right?

Ranking of states without unions (2011) https://www.businessinsider.com/states-where-teachers-unions...

Wisconsin after unions were removed (2017) https://money.cnn.com/2017/11/17/news/economy/wisconsin-act-...

hdctambien··on Gaggle monitors the work and communications of almost 5M students in the US
The students at my school used to joke and say KMS and KYS all the time, too... until one of those kids actually did. And then they stopped saying that to each other almost over night.

Sometimes you are joking, but the person you are joking with isn't. Think about that next time you jokingly tell someone to KYS because they got a 65 on a quiz.

hdctambien··on Strengthening Congressional Independence from Corporate Lobbyists
I believe he is refering to this[1]. Each party publishes one each election year.

[1] https://prod-cdn-static.gop.com/media/documents/DRAFT_12_FIN...

hdctambien··on When homework is busywork (2009)
I write my tests specifically so previous test questions do not answer future test questions on the same test. It's interesting how many "A students" get B's and C's on the first few tests I give...
hdctambien··on When homework is busywork (2009)
I teach computer science, and you need to know long division in order to understand the % operator.

This is actually an issue I run up against because my 15 and 16 year olds ask to use a calculator for things like 23 - 7 ... And then I want them to do crazy math like 23 % 7.

hdctambien··on Joel Spolsky and Clive Thompson discuss the past, present, and future of coding
The reality is that we are teaching as much math as we can.

My school teaches Algebra 1, Geometry, Calc, and Stats. We sometimes are able to offer Multivariate Calculus if there are enough Juniors in the BC Calc class.

It would be nice if we could offer an Abstract Algebra or Complex Numbers course occasionally, but there just aren't enough students that get to senior year ready to take those kinds of courses. Keep in mind that there are 2 AP Calculus tests, so no student that could take Abstract Algebra would choose to not take AP Calculus due to getting college credit for it.

Since there is an AP Stats class, students will often take both AP Calc and AP Stats. Which means they are lined up to take all the fun math classes when they get to college!

Of course, these aren't the average students. These are the students that are taking full boats of AP classes and coming out of high school with 15 - 30 college credits.

hdctambien··on Joel Spolsky and Clive Thompson discuss the past, present, and future of coding
Geometry is really used to introduce proofs. Turns out its easier to get teenagers to understand a proof if you can actually see its results.

I think that's a pretty good foundational skill, but I admit that it isn't obvious from the students point of view why that would be or that that is what they are even learning.

In Texas the Geometry class is designed to "strengthen their mathematical reasoning skills in geometric contexts. Within the course, students will begin to focus on more precise terminology, symbolic representations, and the development of proofs" [1]

In Texas Trig is taught in Precalc, which makes sense if you are going to take Calc which makes sense if you are going to go on to study engineering or physics or mathematics. But neither of those classes are required in Texas. You could just as well take Algebra 1, Geometry, and AP Stats.

[1] http://ritter.tea.state.tx.us/rules/tac/chapter111/ch111c.ht...

hdctambien··on Joel Spolsky and Clive Thompson discuss the past, present, and future of coding
For the average person a basic understanding of arithmetic would be nice.

People are always complaining that schools don't teach them how to do their taxes, but for most people doing taxes is a combination of addition, subtraction, and following a page of instructions about which numbers to copy from one piece of paper to another.

Imagine trying to teach 16 and 17 year olds that are going to grow into adults that struggle to copy numbers from Box A to Line 3 and then add them correctly the difference between t-value and a t-value.

(I also believe the average person should have a better understanding of probability and statistics ... but we're still working on getting the average high schooler an understanding of why 1/2 + 1/3 is not 1/6 and why you don't need a calculator to calculate 7 * 0)

hdctambien··on Joel Spolsky and Clive Thompson discuss the past, present, and future of coding
Both the school I went to 20 years ago and the school I teach at now offer Probability&Statistics and AP Prob&Stats and at neither school is Calculus a required course. In fact, you can take any of our 4 Computer Science courses as your 4th year math credit, but usually students choose between Stats or Calculus (or just take both)

I'd wager it's been a while since Joel was in a school and the course offerings across the board are likely quite different than he remembers.

hdctambien··on Reasons not to use Netflix
Spinning disks, I suppose
hdctambien··on YouTube Stars Being Paid to Sell Academic Cheating
Cheating can take from others.

Merit scholarships are given based on class rank. If the #11 student cheats to get to #10, then they took scholarship money that someone else actually earned. This is a very real problem in my school district.

Additionally, if you cheated to get good grades and got into a good university because of them, then you probably took the seat of someone that didn't cheat and was not accepted but would have been.

Also, (some?) universities internally rank high schools by the performance of the students they accept. So, if School A sends a bunch of 4.0 students that all flunk out, then future students from that school get their 4.0 weighted lower than a 4.0 from School B where students regularly graduate from the university with honors.

So, if you are cheating to get a good grade and you get into a good school (taking the seat of a student that didn't cheat) and then you get caught cheating, or just end up doing poorly because you were never that good of a student, then future students from your high school will be penalized because of the poor choices you made (and because the school was unwilling or unable to deal with those choices).

hdctambien··on An employee whose job was to be sacked (2010)
The company kept the "last check" of the employees who quit (probably by no-showing which is why they didn't pick up their last check) so the company got a few hours of free labor from each employee.

"They did this" means they had the actor convince the applicants to take the job. The more employees they hire, the more free hours they get (since the quitters don't pick up their last check)

hdctambien··on I’m the Wife of a Former N.F.L. Player. Football Destroyed His Mind
Here's an article from 6 months ago about new helmet technology.

http://www.foxnews.com/tech/2017/08/08/revolutionary-new-zer...

hdctambien··on Company gives non-smokers six days holiday to compensate for cigarette breaks
Sitting is chairs has not been shown to cause cancer.
hdctambien··on Request for Education Startups
I completely understand. I teach AP Computer Science to about 100 students a year and I assign many Open Response questions which are solved by writing code by hand on paper. I grade these using the same rubric as the College Board which takes into account much more than "would it compile". For every hour of homework I assign my students, I assign myself double digit hours of grading.

Some AI + a pool of previously graded assignments could probably automatically pre-grade essays (or my open response questions) with comments and notations which would allow a teacher to skip the 100% correct papers, and focus on the hot-spots of the others. Automatically identifying plagiarism (via the internet and other students) would be a nice side effect, too.

Those kinds of solutions seem way more useful than Yet Another Gradebook/Attendance System or a Teacher->Parent Chat Room or even Distributed Tutoring Systems.

hdctambien··on Request for Education Startups
Honestly, fixing the education of educators would be the best long term solution.

Alternatively, creating a complete, ready-to-go curriculum package for every course (as defined in every state) that could be handed to anyone might be a startup-able solution to that problem.

Although, that might also just be a patch that leads to a local maximum of not-very-good teachers teaching from better-than-before curriculum. Where making better teachers would lead to better teaching (eventually).

hdctambien··on Request for Education Startups
You have to imagine a school full of children like a room full of hackers that will work harder to break your system than they will to follow it.

On this forum people say "all you need is a library card" to learn Computer Science, but you also need to read those library books.

How does your system deal with students that just refuse to do anything?

hdctambien··on Request for Education Startups
> a teacher "trained" in coding is not a programmer

And if the "trained teacher" is a programmer, what is stopping them from taking a $100,000 programming job over their $40,000 teaching job (That caps out at $70,000 after 20 years)?

hdctambien··on Kids Praised for Being Smart Are More Likely to Cheat
The idea is that if you are told "you got the answer, you must be smart", then your success and failure is innate to who you are. You don't have agency over it.

If you are told "you got the answer, you must have worked hard", then you get to own your success and you learn that if you work hard, you can earn success.

hdctambien··on Virginia has decertified its most hackable voting machines
Hanging Chads. See: the year 2000.
hdctambien··on Ask HN: 50 job applications, 15 interviews, 7 onsites, and no offer – what next?
An up vote on a throwaway doesn't earn your main account any internet points, so it's be a thrown away up vote.
hdctambien··on Snap values itself at nearly $24B with its IPO pricing
Every single student in the high school I teach at uses Snapchat. All day. Every day.
hdctambien··on Computer Science Education
> I have yet to see a woman studying a STEM subject who is very skilled at it and made such complaint.

Seriously, you should actually talk to some of these women about their experiences.

← PreviousPage 3 of 8Next →