Ultimately, it boils down to: 'do the people want a deflationary or inflationary currency?' Stability is subjective but purchasing power isn't. What's a fair function of money for society? Not a clue.
868 karma · joined April 25, 2015
Pro-tip to HackerNews (emailed when commented on; not mine): http://www.hnreplies.com
Current past-time: Certifications (electrical and cad tools) and Masters program (at my leisure).
Previous hobbies: DIY car repair, Handyman work
BTC: 17z2QWMByv5NHnMMg4VFwspJeL63Hn3Dm2
Ultimately, it boils down to: 'do the people want a deflationary or inflationary currency?' Stability is subjective but purchasing power isn't. What's a fair function of money for society? Not a clue.
Umm. It's not that old, testnet maybe but not the public blockchain.
"At that stage, most users should start running client-only software and only the specialist server farms keep running full network nodes, kind of like how the usenet network has consolidated." [1, emphasis added]
"The current system where every user is a network node is not the intended configuration for large scale. That would be like every Usenet user runs their own NNTP server. The design supports letting users just be users. The more burden it is to run a node, the fewer nodes there will be. Those few nodes will be big server farms." [2, emphasis added]
To clarify, these are excerpts of satoshi's comment that were in a thread. They've been kept through the Nakamoto Institute website (i.e. my source is a secondary source). I chose this and not the bitcointalk threads because it's Satoshi's writings only.
A few points to note, 'full network nodes' are nodes that do both mining and validating of wallets; not just validating like the Lightning Network or SPV clients. First quote talks about 'like how usenet network has consolidated' which hints at knowing about centralized farming. Second quote is more direct to rebuff the above opinion, fairly directly.
> the biggest thing Satoshi didn't know (or didn't foresee) was that the idea of "one CPU, one vote" was flawed, a victim of its own success, because of mining ASICS.
He knew. In the beginning, it wasn't truly one CPU, one vote. If you had a higher-end single cpu, you definitely got more than one vote since most people don't have the average CPU (it's high-end for a reason). Satoshi clearly had this in mind. Early adopters were awarded more bitcoins with their average CPUs then, than high-end ASICs today. This was all thought out in the economic sense and security sense, attempting to balance both.
>A consequence of that is that bitcoin and related cryptocurrencies really aren't as decentralized as claimed.
I feel this opinion is based on the crypto-twitter opinions. Or based on many 'bitcoin maximalists'. Basically, a narrow-minded group that isn't really seeking to inform the public, they just want to 'moon' and meme.
But looking at this critique from a different perspective, it's extremely decentralized in it's mining function. How many people have mined bitcoins? Throughout time? Has it always been one central authority (Satoshi, Gavin, etc)? Or have people from all stripes been able to? Yes. Many regular working people could buy an ASIC and mine today. That's fairly decentralized, no FED needed to inject a new QE.
Will you make a profit? That's not the question. Decentralization mining exists but at what cost?
I could also unpack the idea that buying coins in 2009 would be considered a decentralization of the currency, since there would be more people (not less/centralized) holding the currency, therefore more dispersed.
But let's return back to Satoshi to conclude. Satoshi thought about CPUs, FPGAs, GPUs, and ASICs. Look at his writings. Look at the OG code. Look at the whitepaper. He created an architecture that creates cryptographic trust through a proof of work function. He knew about Moore's Law and incorporated it. The specifics were quoted above but this conclusion is to bring everything together that bitcoin was thoroughly designed in such a way that thought through ten, twenty years in the future, based on the best science available then. My final thought is that Satoshi 'didn't think about______' is an opinion based on ignorance or it's something outside of the scope of Satoshi's intent with bitcoin. He has many posts that explain enough to settle most debates. Please read more, do less criticizing and when you're informed, let's have a mature discussion.
[1] - https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/posts/bitcointalk/105/...
[2] - https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/posts/bitcointalk/287/...
P.S. I'm not a Satoshi worshipper. I've done extensive research and came to my own conclusions. You can debate my auxiliary points but without reading Satoshi's writings, you're missing the context of the actual debate.
>> I said this: I'm not sure how you quantify (facts/evidence) your statement that "That is the exact opposite of Aristocratic". As this would be considered historic revisionism. Aristocratic might not be the most precise word (elitism goes too extreme) but it gets close enough to the vein of truth to understand my point. Selected few men, rule over the masses, by design. [1]
I'm not sure why you went on multiple different tangents but my main point is above and hasn't been refuted. It's almost as if you don't understand the definition of aristocratic (addressed later).
>You said: You can credibly say that it sure smells like an aristocracy nowadays, and I won't argue. Back then though? Absolutely not.
No. It was aristocratic then. It wasn't British aristocratic then but it was aristocratic, nonetheless. Yes, it was by design or else there wouldn't be a Republic. I'm not deeply a scholar of the time period therefore I can't say whether it was malevolent or not.
> Wiki says: Aristocracy (Greek ἀριστοκρατία aristokratía, from ἄριστος aristos 'excellent', and κράτος, kratos 'rule') is a form of government that places strength in the hands of a small, privileged ruling class, the aristocrats. The term derives from the Greek aristokratia, meaning 'rule of the best'. [2]
The founders didn't merit their land ownership nor the ability to read/write nor merit being white nor merit being male nor merit many other factors. It was circumstantial, largely through no agency of their own, which is privileged. They did use that privilege to attempt something new which was more Democratic than most forms of govts. Regardless, they were aristocrats. /end for me.
[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24361561
[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristocracy
(edited for formatting)
You never answered my question, "How would you define the ability to vote, as only going to select white men?"
My point still stands as historically sound. The founders/govt were upper-middle class by England's standards and they recreated a very similar aristocratic structure here in the 13 colonies but with the founders at the top.
My point can also be supported by how State Legistatures would pick Senators, the electoral college, lifetime appointments to SCOTUS, lack of term limits on Congress and POTUS. These are all putting power in a select few. The select few aren't as wealthy as England's elites but the founders were very rich (the elite of American society).
It seems you don't understand the difference between how the people directly elected US Senators since 1913 versus a State Republic that was voted on.
These are two very different things. I say very because one is more Democratic and the other is more Republic. A Republic is an indirect mechanism whereas Democratic is a direct mechanism.
How would you define the ability to vote, as only going to select white men? Land owners of a certain acreage, looks like only 6% of the population fit that bill [1].
These people were a bit contradicting. 'All men' didn't mean all men. It meant all, white land owners. Also, to be clear, the founders and early civil servants were upper-middle-class British that moved to America to...have their stab at trying to become upper-class.
I'm not sure how you quantify (facts/evidence) your statement that "That is the exact opposite of Aristocratic". As this would be considered historic revisionism. Aristocratic might not be the most precise word (elitism goes too extreme) but it gets close enough to the vein of truth to understand my point. Selected few men, rule over the masses, by design.
> The founders actually culturally understood this believe it or not.
I wholeheartedly agree with this entire point you made here. I would go even further that the founders rigorously debated my point of govt officials accountability and they settled with the three branches as sufficient. But they intentionally left the door open for later terms to legislate/adjudicate which is again what I'm advocating for.
Great response by the way.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_voting_rights_in_t...
Freedom isn't free.
> The framers themselves recognized that, since the Constitution isn't full of threats of criminal penalties. Even impeachment is deliberately just a removal from office.
I separated the quotes to add emphasis.
The founders leaned very much in the direction of aristocratic, not all but it was the prevailing thought hence Republic instead of direct democracy.
As for the 'disastrous consequences', 'Constitution isn't full of threats', and 'impeachment is deliberately just a removal from office'.
I understand your points and they are historically accurate. One can see through the 'norm' that was created by President Ford pardoning President Nixon, that this understanding persists even in more recent history.
My words are a desire to see an amendment/law/ruling to go further in holding these leaders of our government accountable. As it's toxic to maintaining the social contract within our society, IMHO. If we are lenient on political corruption, even the foundations will crumble, IMHO.
>> xxpor said: Not the same thing IMO.
It actually is. This country is not a direct democracy. You are trying to reinterpret the structure of this Republic. The people through their votes uphold the structure every time they vote. It's a collective decision (social contract) to have our vote to have representation and we 'trust' (for lack of a better term) said Rep. to perpetuate the ability of governing.
[edited: accidental pasted something additionally]
Let's totally 'nitpick' because the structure that our entire government is built upon the Constitution. "The first, The Articles of Confederation, was in effect from March 1, 1781, when Maryland ratified it. The second, The Constitution, replaced the Articles when it was ratified by New Hampshire on June 21, 1788." [1]
If this 7 year gap is something that's causing you issues, just know that today that we aren't judged by 1900 laws. We're judged by the living document called the Constitution, as it 'replaced the Articles when it was ratified', and auxiliary laws via State/Local govts. But the backbone is the Constitution.
>Congress isn't the final authority of if laws are constitutional or not. The courts are.
In theory, sure. But Dred Scott said one thing (no Black person is free, even in the North) and the people in the North said something else with their 2nd amendment rights.
>What you're proposing is essentially a oligarchy lead by the Supreme Court.
Actually I'm not. A law can (and in many cases, already does) include what appropriate punishments should be for a law that is broken.
> There is no social contract based on the constitution. It's just that enough people agree that it has value, so it does. That's not a social contract. No regular people voted on the Constitution. You don't have the ability to reject it if you don't agree with it.
These statements are entirely false.
1) Your first sentence and your second sentence are contradicting each other. ~'no social contract' vs ~'what a social contract is'.
2) As for the latter two sentences. We vote everyday with our citizenship. You either agree to that living document or you don't by your allegiance. No one is forcing you to be a US citizen ruled by Constitution, namely after an adult legal age. Constitution is just American's structure, it can be changed but within it's already given framework. The country could become a Communist rule of law, if it got ratified, whether an individual liked it or not.
Actually, it's nonsense to think anything to the contrary. Either our founding document matters as the backbone of our Laws or it doesn't. Your outlandish logic nullifies any power that the government may have over it's people. It nullifies the social contract.
> The Constitution, for the most part, just states norms and procedures that the the country and government have decided to follow voluntarily, not because some authority will punish it if it doesn't.
It's not a document of 'norms' and 'procedures'. It's a structure of how our Republic is built. Either we have a structure or we undermine it. That's really it, full stop. Amendments are apart of that structure to build or take away for what that structure is to be. Not 'ought to be' not 'suggested' not 'maybe if you'd like to follow', it's a mutually agreed upon Law.
[edited: minor edits for added clarity]
So, when the planet is on the brink of going in flames, you choose division instead of commonality. You're choosing to focus on where you disagree than where you have agreement.
> to wait for someone else from sky to fix them up for us.
This is a false perception. Because lcall just said he's trying to "do his part" [1]. They are hoping for a solution, even if you disagree with it being possible.
Again, I want to reiterate this. We have one planet. One. We have one shot at fixing our problems. Are you trying to compound the problems by arguing about someone you believe is a "superstition"? That's effectively what you're doing.
I say this not entirely to you. Many people in the tech community think the way you do. And I'm making a public comment, in hope, that others learn from the clear destructive mob mentality that people engage with. Are you trying to be "right" or are you trying to get more people to solve this very difficult problem that affects everyone?
[1] - "I wholly agree that we should do our best to be clean, care for this wonderful planet, and I try to do my part (conserving, recycling, avoiding pollution, etc)." -lcall
To them it's very related. "Signs of the times" giving people a 'sign of His coming'. 'The sun will darken' (most of Cali the sun is a bit more dim due to all the smoke). Among many other 'signs'. But to throw some water on the fire, depending on your POV every generation since Christ could. say. this. [1]
At the same time. As someone of a similar faith to OC (original comment), I have to mention that I'm gravely concerned that the religious people of the USA are being worked up into a frenzy. It's bizarre to me how common the attitude of the OC is. This has been going on the past year but I'm not sure if it's the pandemic is taxing people's sanity or what but there is an interesting shift happening within the religious community that is actually concerning to me. The UAE/Israel deal seems to whip up more fervor. Almost like a brainwashing/weaponization of Christianity, albeit this is par the course for American Christianity. My disdain for it remains.
My last point is that the OC is concerned about the future. That is a good thing. Start from there. Don't debate that 'Jesus isn't real' or some other else that's a non-starter. Instead, find the common ground. They are concerned about the changes. THEY SHOULD BE! And encourage them to be apart of the solution. We have one planet. Whether Jesus comes back or not, we aren't treating this planet well and it's obvious to all of us. Let's work on a solution together.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_dates_predicted_for_ap...
Yeah. I think that would be apt to say.
If you're able to do some napkin math about the sheer amount of R&D to get to the other 99%, start a company ASAP because that is the billion (maybe trillion) dollar question.
Getting there is different, yes, which was entirely my original point. I'd rather not shoot an idea down before we've even started. Let's stop with the nitpicking and actually build. Incremental is probably the only way that we will get there. Think like a builder, not a complainer.
Will getting the other 99% look like how we got 1%? Of course not and if it does...then we're actually very close to a major breakthrough because we have a lot of the auxiliary technology already fleshed out.
Every journey begins with one step and we already have made a few steps. Now onto making many more.
I've changed my career path because of these problems. I was a Math Major and now EE. These are the problems we need to be focusing on. Instead of using outdated and faulty technology from the 1960s.
IMHO, humanity is an inflationary species (for lack of a better term). We want to grow, spread and thrive. We aren't using a horse and a buggy. We (mostly) aren't shipping big chunks of ice around the world. We've made massive innovations happen and we should continue. It's nice that VASIMR is trying to push the envelop. Hopefully more of us can join together and tackle these big problems together.
We are not facing overpopulation. Population is contracting currently and will continue for at least a few decades.
IMHO since removing the gold standard (1970s), this problem came up. I'm glad you have been able to but that possibility was shrinking every year. Less and less people were able to do what you did, starting in the 70s. Financial college administrators kept up with inflation whereas jobs didn't. Income didn't. Expenses took a little time to catch up with inflation as well. So, that might've been why for your situation. It wasn't extremely prohibitive but the issue compounds every year.
So, given the rising costs of Health Care and College both situations are good examples of this. The rising 'costs' are more people in administration. This could be blamed on regulation among other issues (greed).
As for voting in their self interests, I live in California now. University of California is the #1 employer in this State. This doesn't happen by chance. It happens due to stakeholders. Many people in this States want an 'easy' and 'stable' job. The easiest way to do this is require more red tape (regulation/'initiatives'/etc), in the name of 'progress' and then now you just created a 'stable and easy' job to make sure certain quotas are reach.
Professors and students lose out due to admin workers are more aggressive on making the government enrich their interests.
Actually this has been true for many decades, not just the last 10-20 years. The issue is exasperated due to massive unemployment because of the mismanagement of covid19.
There will be no 're-examining' because there is so much bloat that votes. Countless administrators that actually vote for their interests, at the expense of the students. It's systemic and just like police reform, it's not going to be an easy and fast change. When renovating the system, there are losers and those losers will fight you tooth and nail to prevent progress.
It's partly why I like creative models like Lambda School. There is a massive opportunities for business(es) to help fix this gap but...again, incentives are not static.
A business helping you get a high skilled job, might want cheaper labor, so they flood the market with more workers, which reduces the collective in that field.
In conclusion, these issues are massive/systemic. It's entrenched to society and protected by stakeholders. Effectively making change happen won't be easy and we may be creating a 'wake-a-mole' type environment where we solve today's problems and gain two problems tomorrow.
On one hand Epic (and any developer) is building their business on Apple's property/ecosystem. On the other hand, Apple has demonstrated anti-competitive behavior in numerous instances.
Due to all the political turmoil in the USA with the technology industry, I don't think Apple has enough political capital to prevent a massive/historic prohibitive ruling against Apple.
> The filter technology is essentially the same as in the N95
So, due to the very small size of this virus, in microns. Most air filters on the market are still not good enough. HEPA isn't good enough, is it better than nothing? Yes but not much. A MERV 14 isn't good enough. I've seen some promising UV light tech but...AC units are pretty ill equipped for this virus.
I'm even curious if studies have been done in hospitals have the equipped AC filtering system to stop this virus. Air flow and filtration is a tradeoff currently. Try to blow out a candle with an N95 mask. It's extremely difficult. The filter technology is not the same.
> orders of magnitude more effective than cloth masks
Cloth masks help about 40% reduction, surgical masks 80%, and N95...95%. I find it very annoying that governments are encouraging cloth masks because they could be use their size and buy surgical masks for everyone at a very cheap cost (economies of scale).
Also, the creator of N95 masks got out of retirement and found that if hospital workers had 7 masks, one for each day. Just rotating them in the storage closet is very effective to reusing them without contamination.