HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hermannj314

3,808 karma · joined June 25, 2009

Software developer and statistician.

Residence: Iowa. Luxembourg. Pennsylvania (currently).

The opinions I express are my own, but I accept the possibility I might be a Manchurian candidate sent by the algorithm.

submissionscomments
hermannj314··on Cali's AG Tells AI Companies Almost Everything They're Doing Might Be Illegal
Your argument makes it sound like the statement says "adverse and disproportionate". I'm seeing that it says OR, meaning you don't have to do anything adverse.

I don't like when laws are worded such that we told we shouldn't care what the words say, we all know what we meant, this is a law for getting the bad guys, so don't worry about the actual words we use. You shouldn't need a law degree to know what OR means.

hermannj314··on Cali's AG Tells AI Companies Almost Everything They're Doing Might Be Illegal
What kind of standard is disproportionate impact?

Do not build an AI system that discovers the best way to target men to get a prostate exam, or the elderly to enroll in a program that may benefit them?

I understand "adverse", but disproportionate implies don't even try to help classes of people. AT ALL!

hermannj314··on Cleveland police used AI to justify a search warrant. It derailed a murder case
Are anonymous tips admissible?

Can the police launder AI results through an anonymous tip line?

"Here is a picture of a guy, do you know who he is, please don't use AI (wink wink), but if you call this number apparently we can then use whatever you tell us. Wink wink."

I am clearly not a lawyer but if anonymous tips exist in police work why can't wacky flailing AI guessing machine also exist?

[Another post clarifies it is not wrong to use AI or anonymous tips, it just can't be used to establish probable cause, so the police skipped some important steps]

hermannj314··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
Big banks role in 2008 financial crisis. Facebook fines from FTC regarding user privacy.

But your point shows the asymmetry in the system. Most thieves don't get to argue costs of goods stolen vs. sticker price of goods stolen and then get to reach a cushy settlement because the government is scared of losing a protracted battle.

hermannj314··on It's not a crime if we do it with an app
This is the way our world works.

If you steal a potato, you will be arrested immediately and the case will be resolved in a few weeks or months.

If you illegally fix the price of potatoes and steal billions from the market, you will be allowed to operate for years in the open while a lengthy civil procedure eventually may ask you to give 1 or 2% of what you stole back in fines.

Don't blame the potato theives or potato cartels, blame the politicians that built the system to work this way.

hermannj314··on How shut-down Bay Area tech companies ditch their fancy gear
I would need more data on how many businesses failed based on ownership of the chair.

If you told me that chair had been used by n successive failed businesses, there is a value of n where I would reject the null hypothesis that the chair has no association with the business failing.

I don't think n=1 is sufficiently large.

hermannj314··on Nobody cares
The world is what it is today because 1% of people do care. Or more probably, 5% of people care for about 20% of their life.

Whatever you do today, through action or inaction, it will ripple through eternity with both intended and unintended consequence.

hermannj314··on TikTok preparing for U.S. shut-off on Sunday
The "War on Drugs" ensured that when an American dies from a drug overdose it is an American company, like Purdue Pharma, that made money killing them.

And when an American is brainwashed into believing a lie, it better damn well be an American company that sold them that lie.

That is the dream this country was built on.

hermannj314··on Bill requiring US agencies to share source code with each other becomes law
I have read section four. How does it connect with my comment? I'm not sure what an automatic exemption is?

I speculated this bill may feel good, but like all things in the government, was only passed because wealthy cronies have determined it is a net good for them in the long run.

What connection am I missing?

hermannj314··on Bill requiring US agencies to share source code with each other becomes law
What's the cynical scam angle for this bill?

If agencies share code, there will be a need for coordination of changes, someone makes extra money in the process? i.e. a small contractor doesn't get the change request because only some big player can handle the complexity of a mutli-agency contract?

The government is full of cronies, this bill was passed because someone has plans to use it to screw us all over.

hermannj314··on Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit
One year ago I gave openAi $100 to have credits for small hobby projects that use their API.

They expired and disappeared and then openAi charged me $100 to reload my lost money.

I am sure this is what I agreed to, but I personally thought I was hacked or something because I didnt expect this behavior from them.

They lost me as an API user and monthly chatgpt plus user. I hope it was worth it. They want enterprise, business, and pro users anyway and not my small potatoes.

hermannj314··on Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit
Nope they aren't lying, but they lost me as a customer. My Arby's gift card lasted longer than my OpenAI credits, it's a horrible business model and I wish them luck, but I won't be a part of supporting bad models.
hermannj314··on Elon Musk wanted an OpenAI for-profit
A few weeks ago my OpenAI credits expired and I was billed to replace them. I had no idea this was the business model, fine you got me with your auto-renew scam because you decided my tokens were spoiled.

At some point, OpenAI became who they said they werent. You can't even get chatgpt to do anything fun anymore as the lawyers have hobbled its creative expression.

And now they want to fight with Elon over what they supposedly used to believe about money back in 2017.

Who actually deserves our support going forward?

hermannj314··on 418 I’m a teapot
We just had a work party and they invited the whole staff. I was outraged they didn't do a proper controlled A/B test. Management will never know if having fun together was a good use of their money. Idiots.
hermannj314··on How 'Factorio' seduced Silicon Valley and me
My train network ran about as good as any multi-threaded code I can write. Perfectly smooth and then a massive deadlock because my mutex locks (rail signals) have a bug.
hermannj314··on Ask HN: What happens to ".io" TLD after UK gives back the Chagos Islands?
I feel like some of you are going to run for politics in a few decades and owning a .io domain with no residence or operation in that part of the world, while technically not wrong at the time, will be the seen with the same disdain as blackface, cultural appropriation, or wearing a Nazi uniform to a Halloween party.

It seems in poor taste to use your privileges to perform digital colonization, revise the intention that .IO was never about Indian Ocean territory, and justify it all simply because it was a convenient way at the time for you to get attention and make money.

hermannj314··on GitHub's Copilot lies about its documentation. Why would I trust it with my code
Does it predict the next most likely word or sample proportionally from the space of possible next words? I don't get consistent results, so I assumed it generated a sequence by sampling. I guess I also don't understand how these things work.
hermannj314··on Gorhill pulls uBlock Origin Lite from Firefox store
"But the bias-variance tradeoff doesn't really apply to us" - every bureaucracy ever.
hermannj314··on Pro bettors disguising themselves as gambling addicts
I worked at a biotechnology company, we had thousands of clients but five of them were 80% of our revenue. In your world, should that business not exist as well?

I don't understand the princple that revenue should be uniformly distributed as a condition for existing. How would you enforce this?

hermannj314··on Europe's deadly floods are glimpse of future climate
"X% of the variability in flooding explained by climate change, regressions show" probably failed the A/B testing for engagement.
hermannj314··on CISA boss: Makers of insecure software are the real cyber villains
No member of the US government proposed locking up mechanics that build KIAs for the crime of theft of motor vehicles. (And if I am wrong, and they did, then I would be against that as well)

An official of the US government is saying they want software developers to be treated as criminals if their software can be exploited. That is an insane proposal.

hermannj314··on CISA boss: Makers of insecure software are the real cyber villains
I strongly disagree.

If someone puts cyanide in the coffee pot, we don't blame the engineer that designed the coffee pot for not making it cyanide proof.

Criminals are the criminals, not a developer that didn't code defensively enough. The fact that a government official is blaming developers for crimes they don't commit is fascist level rhetoric.

hermannj314··on FTC: Vast Surveillance of Users by Social Media and Video Streaming Companies
There are pretending to take this topic seriously because there is an election coming up. Your government is in bed with big tech, no one is coming to save you, everyone is on their own, expect no quarter.
hermannj314··on Hezbollah pager explosions kill several people in Lebanon
I am curious how would you conceal an explosive in an electronic device (like a pager) to make sure that it minimizes collateral damage when it goes off. That is a political question since you ultimately are making a human life vs military objective trade-off.

The international law standard seems to be proportionality to the military objective desired, so maybe no one (generally) cares how many civilians die if you know the targets will be high ranking.

hermannj314··on Indiana police are seizing FedEx packages containing cash
Could an America where cash and it's movement was as sacred as speech be viable? My naive take is that people can carry large amounts of cash, mail it, burn it, who cares?

I use cash to do things I don't want traced to me, that's the point. Many communities live at the fringe or beyond of what society deems acceptable and cash is a great tool for those communities to do their thing.

Civil asset forfeiture is an attack on marginalized people.

hermannj314··on An NFC movie library for my kids
I discovered how cheap NFC tags and readers were a few years ago and now I have completed several hobby projects based on that concept.

When we buy books for our younger nieces and nephews we buy companion stuffed animals and then sew an NFC tag (the small quarter size ones) into them with the YouTube read-along url encoded on it.

hermannj314··on AirPods Pro 2 adds 'clinical grade' hearing aid feature
I'm just concerned people won't like the feature where IRL merchants are muted if they don't agree to give Apple a 30% cut of revenue the airpods helped to facilitate.
hermannj314··on FTC Pushed to Crack Down on Companies That Ruin Hardware via Software Updates
Electronic waste is an externality that I am ok with the government regulating.

My VCR still plays cassettes 30 years after it was made, but my 1st Gen iPad stopped playing YouTube videos 5 years after it was made.

hermannj314··on FTC Pushed to Crack Down on Companies That Ruin Hardware via Software Updates
Someone wrote a letter to the FTC?

Is this like some obscure government rule where the FTC can't do something until they receive a letter in the mail? What is this world we live in? Are they not aware of what is happening in the world? Do all government agencies enforce their mandates by mail order?

hermannj314··on Have ‘hobby’ apps become the new social networks?
If your goal is to meet a human person, it is probably best to go to a social media site that is largely made of humans.
← PreviousPage 8 of 25Next →