HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

heymijo

2,927 karma · joined August 1, 2016

heymijo.hn at gmail
submissionscomments
heymijo··on Why ranking employees by performance backfires
It's a shallow article on well worn territory. This is the closest it gets to touching your assertion

> A number of line managers told me they gamed the system. They would put people who had just joined the team in the bottom bracket, because they were easier to sacrifice. Or, perversely, they tried to hang on to poor performers so they could put them at the bottom and protect everyone else.

You are correct though, we have no way to accurately measure knowledge work. I'm a broken record on this, all performance management is subjectivity masquerading as objectivity.

It's making work about work that doesn't make the org more effective and in fact is toxic. There are too many examples from the past 40 years across industries for anyone to claim ignorance.

heymijo··on The Daily Standup Is a Waste of Time
closeparen, you're majoring in the minors.

I watch a group of twenty kindergarten students (5 and 6 year olds) every day who have figured out how to have effective remote meetings (turn taking, mute by default, etc) and most don't use headphones.

Bring up the issue with your team. Pick some norms to try, and iterate until it works. You got this.

heymijo··on The Daily Standup Is a Waste of Time
The author circles back on himself though and notes that even though the 15 minute stand up itself is "a waste of time" the conversation it catalyzes amongst employees afterwards is of value.
heymijo··on Google will stop using Oracle’s finance software and adopt SAP instead
Does SAP use its own system?
heymijo··on Google is accelerating reopening of offices and putting limits on remote work
This past year wasn't WFH. This was WFH during a pandemic. Thinking they are the same is a mistake.
heymijo··on FAA safety engineer goes public to slam agency’s oversight of Boeing’s 737 Max
The great tragedy to me is the regulatory capture of the FAA and the erosion of trust in commercial flight.
heymijo··on FAA safety engineer goes public to slam agency’s oversight of Boeing’s 737 Max
"In his letter, Jacobsen recommends that Boeing upgrade the MAX’s autothrottle logic to either disconnect or give the pilots a warning when the computer registers invalid data.

In the upgrade to the MAX that allowed it to return to service, the FAA did not require any such change but did add an explicit instruction that pilots in this kind of emergency should “disengage the autothrottle.”"

In the many articles about the MAX that have shown up on HN the underlying concern seems to be that this is still not a safe plane. This excerpt is scary.

Anyone with aviation experience want to weigh in?

heymijo··on FAA safety engineer goes public to slam agency’s oversight of Boeing’s 737 Max
The article shows that safety engineers at the FAA would have had the requisite knowledge to see the problems with the MCAS system, but as OP said above, there was no "issue paper" from Boeing to regulators about the system.
heymijo··on The U.S. Air Force just admitted the F-35 stealth fighter has failed
Next Generation Air Dominance (NGAD) [0]. You might have missed this news.

It’s a modern remix to the Kelly Johnson and Ben Rich days of developing legendary aircraft at Lockheed’s Skunkworks that you lamented the loss of.

People in the know confirm it’s legit and shocking, in a good way. Especially compared to the failures of the F-35 and even the F-22’s development.

[0] https://www.airforcemag.com/article/ropers-ngad-bombshell/

heymijo··on How my school gamed the stats
What you noticed is what is well known in education--school ratings are merely a proxy for the socioeconomic status of its students/families [0].

What can be teased out from that regarding cause/effect/deterministic is still mostly unknown.

I don't have a canonical source for this, but this nature paper gets the point across. This link [1] also has a useful chart on p. 6 to visualize the point.

[0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41539-018-0022-0

[1] https://cepa.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/reardon%20dist...

heymijo··on How my school gamed the stats
"...I think makes this untenable, at least in the US"

Some information that may be new to you:

Widespread cheating is common in the US. Atlanta, El Paso, Columbus. Google "big city name + cheating" and you'll likely get a result.

"A state investigation of Columbus, Ohio, public schools found a "top-down culture of data manipulation and employee intimidation" in connection with changes to test scores and student grades" [0]

"An investigation by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation (GBI) released in July 2011 indicated that 44 out of 56 schools cheated on the 2009 CRCT.[2] One hundred and seventy-eight educators were implicated in correcting answers entered by students" [1]

[0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303277704579349...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlanta_Public_Schools_cheatin...

heymijo··on YouTubers have to declare ads. Why doesn't anyone else? [video]
When was the last time you saw a cigarette ad on TV?

Commercial speech in the United States has limitations. Historically commercial speech was not protected by the 1st amendment. Protections and limitations have largely been established over the past 50 years in Supreme Court rulings [0].

[0] https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/939/corporate-speec...

heymijo··on Ford, Google form 'strategic partnership' on cloud services, Android
Yes!

I've been in late model Porsche's, BMW's, GMC's, Honda's, and Ford's.* It's weird being in an $80k Porsche and thinking "this is garbage" because the infotainment system is so poorly designed.

Just get me into Carplay and let me go cough Toyota [0].

*I don't own any of these

[0] https://9to5mac.com/2019/04/29/carplay-toyota-2018-cars/

heymijo··on Businesses should try to be the best, not the biggest
“There are no environmental restrictions here.”

Cloud is still computing. Computers with a finite life that need to be produced, from natural resources.

Computing that needs to be powered and cooled.

Those have environmental impacts and very much align with OPs quote.

heymijo··on DOJ fines Boeing over $2.5B, charges it with fraud conspiracy
The CEO for starters.

Post-Enron accounting rules via Sarbanes-Oxley made it so that the CEO had to sign off on and certify the financial statements. The buck stopped there. [0]

Why not here as well?

Unless you are thinking about putting the system that incentivizes a CEO and company to do this on trial.

[0] https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2014-152

heymijo··on U.S. Capitol Locked Down Amid Escalating Protests
I think these three books offer a solid framework for providing an answer to your question:

1) The System: Who Rigged It, How We Fix It by Robert Reich [0]

- Reich drops the buzzword neoliberalism in favor of the word power. I like that as neoliberalism is a terrible phrase for the concept it describes, but make no mistake, it's the insidious, invisible nature of neoliberalism that put our country in a position where neither party served the people well. That is what Reich describes here.

2) The Loudest Voice in the Room: How the Brilliant, Bombastic Roger Ailes Built Fox News-and Divided a Country by Gabriel Sherman [1]

- There is also a Showtime miniseries based on the book you could watch. Pair with the movie Bombshell

3) Dark Money: The Hidden History of the Billionaires Behind the Rise of the Radical Right by Jane Mayer [2]

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/52118381-the-system

[1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/15981705-the-loudest-voi...

[2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/27833494-dark-money

heymijo··on Talking out loud to yourself is a technology for thinking
I see how that could be confusing. I am unfortunately past my edit window but thanks for the feedback.
heymijo··on Talking out loud to yourself is a technology for thinking
In your head > out loud > on paper > to someone else.

"First you communicate with yourself." - Peter Drucker

I remember Drucker laying out this hierarchy for communication in his tome on management. Each step is progressively harder. Something that made sense in your head, you might not be able to articulate on paper. Something you just wrote may not communicate to someone else.

IME, it is spot on.

heymijo··on John Urschel tackles his lifelong balance of math and football in new memoir
I'm curious what ideas people here have to best address our world's collective quantitative illiteracy.
heymijo··on Texas astronomers revive idea for 'Ultimately Large Telescope' on the moon
Biosphere 2 was originally meant to demonstrate the viability of closed ecological systems to support and maintain human life in outer space[0]

>including humans seem to have caused most of the problems

I chuckled a bit at your reply hvd.

The hardest, seemingly intractable problems in the world aren't engineering problems, they are human ones. If we want to level up as a species those are the ones we will need to figure out how to solve.

heymijo··on The True Size Of Countries: Mercator projection
I taught this in 6th grade social studies in Ohio (a state in the USA) two years ago.

A reasonable interpretation of the standards should see this being taught in all 6th grade social studies classes across Ohio.

SPATIAL THINKING AND SKILLS

Content Statements:

3. Geographic tools can be used to gather, process and report information about people, places and environments. Cartographers decide which information to include and how it is displayed[0]

There were a number of videos explaining this concept. I remember this one from Vox [1] in particular resonating with the students.

So while we might have been short changed (I grew up in Ohio), the curriculum is improving.

[0] http://education.ohio.gov/getattachment/Topics/Learning-in-O...

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kIID5FDi2JQ

heymijo··on Why to Start a Startup in a Bad Economy (2008)
I think there's such an interest in seeing the genius behind a work which actually involves the collaboration of a group to actually succeed

Walter Isaacson recognized this when he went to write his book The Innovators [0]. He intended it to be a more narrow autobiographical book like he is known for but quickly realized the technological revolution was brought about through an collaborative effort across time and space.

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/21856367-the-innovators

heymijo··on Sacklers–who made $11B off opioid crisis–to pay $225M in damages
Prosecutors have been going after Purdue and the Sackler's for over a decade now. Forty seven states have sued Purdue pharma over the opioid crisis with twenty nine of those states specifically naming members of the Sackler family in the suits. So if you want primary documents, you have more than you can read.

Here's an excerpt from a recent New Yorker article:

The 2007 case was not supposed to end the way it did. For four years, prosecutors in the Western District of Virginia gathered evidence on Purdue, subpoenaing millions of documents. They found a widespread pattern of illegal misconduct in which Purdue systematically misled doctors (and the general public) about the risks associated with OxyContin. In September, 2006, the prosecutors detailed their damning evidence in a hundred-and-twenty-page memo, suggesting that the wrongdoing at Purdue was so pervasive, and so consistent, that it could have been authorized only by the company’s leaders. This memo, an internal government document, was not made public until August, 2019, when the Times published excerpts of it showing that the prosecutors had intended to bring felony charges against three top Purdue executives: Michael Friedman, Howard Udell, and Paul Goldenheim. The full memo, which I have reviewed, describes the Sacklers as “The Family” and notes that the company was owned and controlled by the brothers Mortimer and Raymond Sackler and their heirs. (The heirs of a third Sackler brother, Arthur, sold their interest in the company prior to the introduction of OxyContin.) The company “trained its sales representatives” to use “false and fraudulent” claims about OxyContin, the memo states. The prosecutors noted that the three executives they intended to charge “reported directly to The Family.”

https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/the-sackler-familys...

heymijo··on Sacklers–who made $11B off opioid crisis–to pay $225M in damages
I think that maybe then you too should be mad at the Sacklers.

They intentionally and knowingly deceived the market that opioids were safe. Had they not done that maybe the opioid epidemic would not have happened and you could still have access to the medicine that you are grateful for.

Please do read up on how horrible they are.

heymijo··on Ask HN: What did you do to improve your company?
Sure. This was a school/school district. We thought big, and started small. Our initial initiative was for K-6 only. In the following years, this spread to both the middle school, and then the high school. Driven by demand from the teachers themselves.

The modern era of education reform goes back to the Soviets launching Sputnik, so 60 years. It has been omnipresent reform efforts in K-12 education since then. Lots of change, little improvement.

We created not only a durable change, but a positive one that is still pointed in the same direction five years after we got this off the ground.

There's more detail about what we did in a reply below you.

heymijo··on Ask HN: What did you do to improve your company?
This was a school/school district.

The common concern was lack of direction and changing direction with new change initiative one/two/three/four times per year.

We created an initiative for teacher created and led professional development. We used students for live class recreations where teachers could analyze in real time. It was coordinated, structured, and sequenced in a way no teacher's in our district had experienced.

At the same time we took all of the feedback we got from every teacher we interviewed (and we interviewed all of them) and created a vision statement for both teachers and students. We took it back to the teachers and showed how each person's feedback was reflected in the vision. We got the district to adopt the vision. Then we held leadership's feet to the fire and didn't let them do anything that didn't align with the vision. We put the onus on them to explain how any decisions did align.

We used the vision to design professional development, adopt curriculum, craft special education services, and more.

This started as a K-6 initiative, which was wildly ambitious at the time. In the following years the middle school got on board, and then the high school followed suit, led not by administrators but by the teachers themselves. Something we never in our wildest dreams thought would happen.

Five years on the direction is the same and positive change continues.

heymijo··on Ask HN: What did you do to improve your company?
Listened to people.

The organization I worked at had no direction. Low morale. Lots of complaining. No leadership from people in management positions.

A colleague and myself tried some of the things mentioned by others below to build camaraderie, etc. Minimally effective.

Then, we started talking to colleagues.

"What's going well?" "What challenges are you facing?"

Listening alone, letting these people know their voices were heard by anyone, went a long way in building relationships, alignment, and getting things done.

Then we took what we were hearing, developed an initiative, pitched it to leadership. They rubber stamped it without really paying attention or asking questions.

We executed.

People were shocked. Their voices had been heard, and something had been done to address common concerns they had. I don't know how to measure or describe this impact, but it's the most significant thing I have ever accomplished.

heymijo··on Ask HN: What does performance management look like at your company?
In theory performance management should be about helping people improve. In practice performance management is about four things:

1) Pay

2) Promotions

3) Accountability (e.g. firing)

4) To satisfy legal requirements (perceived and real)

Performance management falls under the umbrella of HR. HR's historical roots are in compliance. In the 90's when cost vs. profit center was the rage, the HRBP model emerged to prove HR could provide business value beyond compliance. HRBP is the dominant model now but it hasn't had the impact its creator intended. Inertia is a powerful thing.

Combine HR's roots in compliance, with the above four reasons performance management exists in practice and that will give you a good way to understand why performance management works the way it does.

If you're learning about these things in an effort to improve your own organization's practices then you can also use the above to evaluate any proposed changes and think about what they would have to contend with. History is replete with failures. Unless you are in a small organization, with total control over incentives and the culture then I will leave you with a quote from Blade:

"Some motherfuckers are always trying to ice skate uphill."

heymijo··on Ask HN: What does performance management look like at your company?
Performance management is subjectivity masquerading as objectivity.

I'm a broken record about this.

heymijo··on How to Learn Everything: The MasterClass Diaries
Unfortunately the educational system I work in prioritizes conformity.

I feel that in my bones.

If you see this I'd be curious to hear more about your education experience. Drop me a line at heymijo.hn at google mail if you'd like to continue the discussion :)

← PreviousPage 5 of 18Next →