This article doesn't say what the six organizations were, which is the main contention of settlement (the fact that it was going to them, not what they are). But in case you were curious: AARP, World Privacy Forum, Carnegie Mellon University, Chicago-Kent College of Law, Harvard University and Stanford Law School.
It has nothing to do with AMP. There's a lot of reasons why, but one reason is for example, two different sites can technically be hosted on www. and the non-www version, if the site isn't set up to redirect the www to the non-www, for example. So this could, in certain scenarios, pose a security risk in that if you pretend that www and the non www are the same sites -- when they're not -- it can make it easier for those that hijack one or the other to get away with it. Now, that's fairly extreme and esoteric. But there are actually times in development when you use subdomains, which this makes more difficult, and there's other subdomains they're considering trivial which, in fact, aren't. This is really good discussion on the topic and why this change just simply ignores so many technical issues, best practices and simply realities: https://bugs.chromium.org/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=881410
The exception in this standard is for "likely" and "imminent" violence. There are also exceptions for the commission of a crime, but then the crime has to be committed, and thus the intent.
Episode 8 of the "Make No Law" First Amendment podcast has an excellent explanation of the difference between the two. That episode is a Q&A and covers other great topics as well. The entire podcast is excellent if you want a good, baseline understand on the exceptions to US first amendment law and why/how they are so narrowly defined.
It could. If you read deep-down in the article you can also see that the NYT and WSJ are making massive efforts to keep new subscribers, but the LA Times doesn't appear to be investing much at all. It's possible that could be the biggest factor.
It 100 percent is still this way. But generally your queued list can be set up 1-2 days beforehand, so that's why it's often 48-72 hours, because you're already in that list that's been cleaned at the provider for drop.
Giving over your list to a third-party provider like Mailchimp can be a risk. One thing most publishers is more protective over than anything else is the database. Also, Mailchimp just isn't ideal for high volume mailings/companies who do this as a revenue generator. It's designed more for the mom-and-pop operations.
It's because of permissions there's different databases, plus most importantly the drop lists are usually keyed up 48 hours in advance (you have to do in advance because of all the checks you have to do, etc.). They can take you out of the main but you're probably in some drop lists that have already been send to the provider -- that's why they say a few days/72 hours.
Definitely! We actually dropped one vendor because it was all ex-Oracle salespeople, and their negotiation tactics were outrageous. They tried to hold us over a barrel and instead we made a major platform change in six weeks just so we could tell them to f-off.
THIS. I don't understand how so many people don't actually get how Google and AMP work. You don't need AMP for organic search results. It's used by Google, yes, but only for certain things AND there's ways to turn it off/point to non-AMP pages. We choose not to use it, other publishers do use it, but everyone looks at the pros and cons and then just decides. It's like any other business decision, but you have to understand how it actually works first and not just go "Oh, AMP's bad" or "Oh, without AMP my site is dead.) I don't believe either of those is true.
I do this for a living. As head of digital and editorial for a major publisher It's absolutely not suicide as we are extremely successful with our Google traffic without AMP. In fact MANY publishers don't use AMP -- I would say most don't (at least that I talk to). Most of us don't like the trade-offs And I talk to a lot of people who do exactly what I do (conferences, private mailing lists, etc.). And its absolutely not true that Google serves almost exclusively in AMP, as we get 80-90 percent of our site traffic from Google and, again, we don't implement AMP. Remember that page load as a factor is looked at completely independently from AMP (Google has verified this -- one of the few factors they've verified how it works), so it can help you with load but if you build your pages correctly and don't use it it's not a punishment. Even within Google news you can turn off Google pointing to AMP versions of your story -- it's an option right there you can click. So yes, I would disagree with you that not using AMP hurts you, and I've talked to publishers who have gone back and forth and that's how I know it's minor boost. But I'm just some strange on the internet so no need to listen to me -- you can believe what you want.
It's still 90-95 percent Google, surprisingly. You'd think it would be less with mobile but no. We are seeing more duck duck go, but bing and yahoo have stayed steady for years. Social is a rise, and that's a lot of mobile. Also then just pickups (links from sites like this). But yeah, still very much google dominated.
Yes, a lot of people agree on that. But you don't need to block Google from your site to stop AMP.The way this article is written it makes it seem like the only way to have AMP not affect your site is by blocking Google entirely, and that's simply not the case. I think that's why those of us who understand how AMP is used are commenting here -- and you can see that people are confused because other people are posting questions about blocking amp, when you don't have to block amp, you don't use it in the first place.
The author should clarify that they're taking extreme measures, but that this isn't required to not use AMP.
Exactly! I am so confused as well. It's like this person doesn't understand that AMP is optional. And even then there's ways to instruct Google NOT to point to your AMP page. (And no, you don't need AMP for SEO -- it's only a slight boost)
I'm very confused by this article -- AMP is an optional framework: https://amp.dev/ and even if you use it you can opt out of having Google load/point to it: https://support.google.com/news/producer/answer/7281462?hl=e...
You don't need to no_index your site. What can you do about it? Just don't implement AMP. Yes, sites who do AMP get preferential treatment in search engines, but you can still get excellent results without it; it's a very small boost.
38 page process to get something done. That's insanity. Most places the editors have pre-prepped art that you slap on. There's no time or staff for careful crafting.There's not even editors to look at writers pieces before they go up anymore in most cases. Writers do their own production! MAYBE, if you have a special project, you might have ONE meeting, if not two. No one has these kinds resources to have the staff to have these kinds of meeting and these kinds of processes, not even at the big guys. You'd have to be flush with staff to even allow your staff to have enough time to entertain something like this. And again, that's so much time to spend on something -- look at all these meetings, these discussions, and then look at those results. I don't see the payoff here.
Online publishing, technical and editorial side. 20 years. This is an incredible level of staffing. I don't know that the payoff is worth what it takes with this 38 page process.
I cannot imagine the staff it takes to pull this off. Most publications are not staffed nearly to levels that would make them able to even try to follow what's outlined here. This is pipe dream, and as someone in the industry it makes me question their staffing and funding levels, actually.
This is how all other major rental stores work. BUT THEN they wouldn't have a business. That's really the issue -- they care about their business, NOT their customers. And they don't have to because they don't own the equipment like any other rental store would.
This is a great question -- I'd love to know this too. I watch this space from the enterprise perspective and I see a lot of big data talk/prep but not so much execution, if that makes sense.
Where there's plenty of cases out there but I'd ask you why you think that opposing counsel attempting to violate attorney/client privilege is ethical?
There's no question, really. It's not ethical by any means. If it wasn't a military court the judge would spank them, hard. But the defense could still report the prosecuting attorneys to the state bar.
Any action by the government that can be seen to be chilling toward a free press can be interpreted as a violation of the first amendment. It's not as black and white as you make it out to be, and remember new precedents are being set all the time. They're also in the ninth circuit which is historically hugely favorable to these kinds of cases. You get a strong enough case, a lot of money and a creative lawyer, you might be able to make some caselaw here. There's at least a baseline argument for it.
That said, target is not irrelevant for illegality. There's also an issue of ethics in targeting other lawyers; if I was the defense lawyer this is the issue I'd be pushing like crazy with the judge, ethics panels, etc. Right or wrong, they can do something with that, esp. if they can get some discovery that proves there was actually an attempt to target -- that would be huge. (And they're not allowed to delete any documents to that effect since they are the government).