HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

himaraya

1,081 karma · joined December 21, 2018

submissionscomments
himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
Harming investors in order to uphold the nonprofit charter sounds more reasonable than you suggest. Take it from Matt Levine. I don't think investors would win this line of argument.

https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-11-21/openai...

himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
The nonprofit board holds no fiduciary duty to for-profit investors, big or small. In theory, I suppose you could sue the board over undermining the charter but that seems tricky itself, this case aside.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
I really don't think investors have the case you think they do. They may ultimately pin the board on some technicality but the case looks far from straightforward. Anyways, it looks like Sam has finally started talking with the board again.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-11-21/altman-op...

himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
They can iterate off ChatGPT but don't own the underlying IP?
himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
OpenAI isn't Big Tech? Adam could reasonably argue his interest in Poe doesn't conflict with the nonprofit charter. Sam & Greg saw fit to leave him in place. Uncommunicative boards remain less unusual than you think, unfortunately.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
Why? The nonprofit will certainly continue existing in name, if nothing else.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
He doesn't cite any sources either. The contract details remain murky.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
OpenAI's lawyers? Big tech passes everything through legal anyways.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella: "We have all the rights and all the capability."
The cited source indicates otherwise, that the license comes with restrictions. Ben didn't read the article.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/microsoft-and-openai-forge-awkw...

himaraya··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
Shareholders check the power of corporate boards, unlike nonprofit ones, so not a surprise.
himaraya··on OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns
To reassure investors? He just made the rounds on TV yesterday for this explicit reason. He told Kara Swisher Microsoft has the rights to innovate, not just serve the product, which sounds somewhat close.
himaraya··on OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns
The nature of those rights to OpenAI's IP remains the sticking point. That paragraph largely seems to concern commercializing existing tech, which lines up with existing disclosures. I suspect Satya would come out and say Microsoft owns OpenAI's IP in perpetuity if they did.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
The fact that Sam and the employees have waged this PR campaign suggests the board still sits on something of value. I guess we'll see who flinches first.

OpenAI gave up 49% equity because they thought Microsoft gave a fair valuation and terms, among other possible reasons. OpenAI wanted to scale up their LLM research so they signed the agreement. I don't think OpenAI negotiated from a position of weakness.

himaraya··on OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns
Timestamp for "improve upon the existing tech"? I only heard him say they have rights up and down the stack, which sounds different.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
First, I meant people would've already jumped ship to Microsoft en masse without bothering with the OpenAI board fiasco if Microsoft truly held all the cards. I suspect they do not.

Second, I meant the OpenAI that signed the initial agreement with Microsoft years ago already had ample resources and funding. In those negotiations, OpenAI would have had little incentive to hand over all their IP regardless of the offer on hand.

himaraya··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
Hence the need for strict governance. I can't think of another board with so many board seats empty, to say nothing about conflicts of interest.
himaraya··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
The board likely thinks the IP gives them leverage to attract talent after the drama subsides. Otherwise, they may very well go for broke.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
Not Microsoft? Otherwise people would've jumped ship long ago. None of this letter writing and PR campaign.

The smaller OpenAI that signed the Microsoft agreement had plenty of sustenance. Compute remains fungible unlike LLMs.

himaraya··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
It shows nonprofit boards wield outsize power and need strict governance, e.g., conflicts of interest, empty board seats.
himaraya··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
Why would the board endorse the sale?
himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
They've hired a bunch. Tech giants pass everything through legal—too big not to. IP & patents remain a PITA regardless of market cap.

Licensing ChatGPT versions developed by OpenAI seems favorable enough to me. The question boils down to what happens if OpenAI stops development. I highly doubt the bright minds at OpenAI gave away their IP for widely available compute credits.

himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
Let's assume Microsoft can freely use present-day ChatGPT in its products. If Microsoft wanted to further develop ChatGPT in-house, I imagine the effort would resemble Apple's in-house modem struggles due to tiptoeing around Qualcomm's patents.

You can't compare a hostile OpenAI with a cooperative ARM. Even with a cooperative OpenAI, Microsoft restricts internal researcher access to the source code, so the license appears less favorable than you think.

himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
Don't like the WSJ? The blog post only indicates some kind of exclusive license to GPT-3, not the all-encompassing claim to OpenAI IP you suggest. Microsoft has never indicated such to my knowledge.
himaraya··on 95% of OpenAI Employees (738/770) Threaten to Follow Sam Altman Out the Door
I agree but Sam made the deliberate choice to leave him in place after forcing out Reid Hoffman over Inflection AI.

https://www.semafor.com/article/11/19/2023/reid-hoffman-was-...

himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
I don't see how that makes your case. The license comes with restrictions per the WSJ.
himaraya··on 95% of OpenAI Employees (738/770) Threaten to Follow Sam Altman Out the Door
Given the board sees winding down the company within its mandate, they may just keep playing this game of chicken.
himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
They don't have such a license...Stratechery didn't read his own source.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/microsoft-and-openai-forge-awkw...

himaraya··on Satya Nadella says OpenAI governance needs to change
In theory, no. In practice, Microsoft wields influence through OpenAI's employees, who the board answers to in addition to the charter.
himaraya··on OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns
I assume their personal relationship played more of a role, given Sam led Quora's Series D round.
himaraya··on OpenAI staff threaten to quit unless board resigns
I think there's more to the Poe story. Sam forced out Reid Hoffman over Inflection AI, [1] so he clearly gave Adam a pass for whatever reason. Maybe Sam credited Adam for inspiring OpenAI's agents?

[1] https://www.semafor.com/article/11/19/2023/reid-hoffman-was-...

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →